Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is yelling child abuse?

who's talking here?

likeke 1
planemom 2
Tylers Journey 1
Laurabeth 1
Frio 1
RedMulch 1
freebyrd 1
SighFiGurl 5
It is I WhyWhyWhy 2
Puss In Boots 3
Mabs 6
fabforty 2
Bornanraisedkw 1
Ares 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ares --- 15 years ago -

I've seen a lot of parents scream bloody murder at their kids for almost anything.

Some of them get so skittish it is scary.

Is yelling at your kids considered child abuse?

I know one kid whose mother screams at him so much, that if he even accidentally spills a drink he freaks out and starts crying immediately. 

Laurabeth --- 15 years ago -

I know one kid whose mother screams at him so much, that if he even accidentally spills a drink he freaks out and starts crying immediately.

That's sad....and yes abuse can come in many forms. Emotional, verbal, physical.....etc. 

freebyrd --- 15 years ago -

Our dog is totally traumatized by a raised voice...., 

likeke --- 15 years ago -

depends what you yell' 

RedMulch --- 15 years ago -

Yelling is the only language my cats understand....and they often yell back.. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

depends what you yell'

In the cases I'm thinking of its not that the words used are all that bad, it's the level of intensity, the frequency, and over minor issues. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Oh I've had to reach deep and touch my inner devil. No, I don't like yelling but I'm five feet tall surrounded by dumb-a$$ guys. Yes...I yell. It's actually one thing I do perfectly. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I know one kid whose mother screams at him so much, that if he even accidentally spills a drink he freaks out and starts crying immediately.

This kind of stuff shows there is a problem. The kid has obviously been traumatized at this point. Most parents don't take it this far.

I'm a calm person and not a screamer. When I did yell at them for something, they knew they crossed a line and Mom was justifiably upset. But the truth is yelling is an indicator that YOU have lost control and at that point one one must ask themselves what the benefit is? If your yelling is causing your own child to fear you for no good reason, that is abusive in my book. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

And how about if it's directed at a spouse? 

fabforty --- 15 years ago -

I'm a calm person and not a screamer. When I did yell at them for something, they knew they crossed a line and Mom was justifiably upset. But the truth is yelling is an indicator that YOU have lost control and at that point one one must ask themselves what the benefit is? If your yelling is causing your own child to fear you for no good reason, that is abusive in my book.
Pretty much my thoughts to a T. If I've lost all dignity and resort to yelling or screaming, it scares my kids and makes me feel like an idiot. 

Tylers Journey --- 15 years ago -

I don't think it matters if you yell, scream, or talk it is what comes out of you mouth that can be abuse. She may not want to hit her children so she yells instead. Some times yelling works better in our house then hitting, time out, or taking things away. 

Frio --- 15 years ago -

If yelling is abuse. I am screwed. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

And how about if it's directed at a spouse?

You mean this person yells at both the child and the spouse, or the parents are fighting in front of the child and scaring him?

If one spouse is yelling at the other in front of the kid and scaring him, that's just very poor judgment and any counselor will tell you it's very unhealthy. It also means there is anger management issue causing all the other issues. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

I should clarify;

Is screaming bloody murder at a child for an accident, child abuse?

It's obvious to me that yelling when the kid's safety is at risk, or they are being intentionally difficult, is understandable. But for an accident? 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

If one spouse is yelling at the other in front of the kid and scaring him,

That's what I'm talking about. Some people have serious issues and can't control themselves. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 15 years ago -

Its not abuse if they have selective hearing....lol 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

I think screaming at a kid for an accident is totally inappropriate. It might be abusive if it's habitual and is obviously causing issues with the child. I mean that is basic parenting 101.


Yelling at the spouse in front of the kid is demeaning the other parent, also probably very confusing and upsetting to the kid.Everyone knows fighting in front of the kids is bad, but it happens to everyone sometimes. I think the key control issue is the child's behavior. If "issues" are developing, that's a sure sign lines are being crossed. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Is screaming bloody murder at a child for an accident, child abuse?

Well, if this was an isolated incident, I don't think that would be abuse, unless the words used were particularly hurtful and demeaning.

However, verbal abuse when used fairly consistently and meant to degrade, shame, frighten and belittle a person, as a means of control.....then yes, this is definitely a form of abuse.

Yelling can also be a precursor or a warning to a physical escalation....I experienced yelling as a child that literally made me sick to my stomach. To this day, in certain situations when I hear this voice, I get goose bumps. So, it can be damaging in the long run. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

Yelling can also be a precursor or a warning to a physical escalation....I experienced yelling as a child that literally made me sick to my stomach. To this day, in certain situations when I hear this voice, I get goose bumps. So, it can be damaging in the long run.

My mother was a non stop screamer, so I can't stand yelling. Even a little yelling wigs me out. Makes me physically ill now... even as an adult.

I can't stand to see children screamed at as a result. Maybe it's just my issue.

But damn, going bonkers on a kid for spilling a drink just isn't right.

Perhaps the answer is that for some kids, screaming is abuse, for others... it doesn't bother them. Depends on the tolerance level of the child. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

I can't stand to see children screamed at as a result. Maybe it's just my issue.

Me too. I feel bad for any child that has to endure this. I feel their pain. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

But damn, going bonkers on a kid for spilling a drink just isn't right.

True. But in playing the devil's advocate as I so frequently do :D, the child could've spilled his 286th drink limit for the day. I'd go bonkers too. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I'm a calm person and not a screamer. When I did yell at them for something, they knew they crossed a line and Mom was justifiably upset. But the truth is yelling is an indicator that YOU have lost control and at that point one one must ask themselves what the benefit is? If your yelling is causing your own child to fear you for no good reason, that is abusive in my book.


yep! 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

the child could've spilled his 286th drink limit for the day.


Then there is a much bigger issue that screaming won't fix and may actually be the cause of. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

going bonkers on a kid for spilling a drink just isn't right.

It might depend on the circumstances. How many times was the child told to stop playing around? In the past, how many times has the child spilled their drink? If the child has been told a dozen times to behave or has been told to move their cup and doesn't do it then I can totally see being upset when they spill. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

Then there is a much bigger issue that screaming won't fix and may actually be the cause of. 

Definitely. Time to purchase different cups. :/ 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

Spilling was an example. I'm talking about screaming about every little damn thing.

I find that I can get great behavior out of my kid just by calmly talking to him, ... and threatening to take away toys or tv if that doesn't work.

I never have to yell at him.

But my wife? She can't seem to do anything but yell when confronted with issues, even minor ones. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Was your wife a product of a "yelling" home? I would bet one or the other of her parents did this.... 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

We never had to yell at middle ds either. Disciplinary tactics were minimal because he was just such a great kid. Scratch that, we don't HAVE to yell, we choose to let the little monster get to us.

Yelling at every damn thing does absolutely nothing but undermine anything you're trying to accomplish. And as far as Insano, the only time I can truly make some kind of impression is to get irate. Like when he just darts out into the parking lots. He doesn't do it anymore because I was one of the parents you probably saw freak the hell out, put him back in the car and whip his A$$ for it. But yay, that lesson was learned. Haha. 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

Was your wife a product of a "yelling" home? I would bet one or the other of her parents did this....

That can go either way. My dad didn't yell all the time, but when he did, watch out, it scared the devil out of me. So, I'm the calm type and I TOTALLY agree it works way better than modeling hysterics in front of your kid. But some grow up to do the same yelling and hysterics. Same with abusive physical behavior. Some men beat their wives because their father did it.

At any rate, it's wrong and it's hard on the kids. 

Ares --- 15 years ago -

Was your wife a product of a "yelling" home? I would bet one or the other of her parents did this....

No, her mother used the guilt trip method.

But I'm tired of it. No more non stop screeching at me or the kid.

The next time, I'll be posting from a local hotel. Bag is already packed. 

fabforty --- 15 years ago -

I have a highly emotional kid (AKA a drama queen) if she see me lose control, cue the drama 50 fold. I think the yelling/screaming begets the same behavior in some instances and makes you absolutely not want to repeat it in others. It all boils down to this for me, if I yell or scream, it shows that I have no control over myself and that's the last thing I want my kids to see.


And screaming and yelling gives me a migraine LOL 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

if she see me lose control, cue the drama 50 fold.

This is also a huge problem having so many years between the boys. I now have extra 'parents' around to 'school' me on handling Insano. And so goes Mabs, "REALLY? How 'bout you two stfu and go make some good grades?" 

SighFiGurl --- 15 years ago -

if she see me lose control, cue the drama 50 fold. I think the yelling/screaming begets the same behavior in some instances and makes you absolutely not want to repeat it in others. It all boils down to this for me,

Yep. Especially with girls. If you collapse like a two-dollar suitcase, they do too. A hefty reminder that the behavior we model in front of them really does matter. 

Mabs --- 15 years ago -

I'm so glad I don't have girls. I can look at them and say SHAKE IT OFF. LOL.

Although those that know me know better. I'm all bark. 

planemom --- 15 years ago -

Somedays, selective hearing requires me to yell. Once I have their attention the volume usually returns to normal. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground