Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Real Estate Commission Question -

who's talking here?

Carla 3
MoveIt 4
ladybeachbum 1
Meme2my5 2
Squareduck 7
evolved 1
needrnr 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 5
Puss In Boots 1
Panties 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Squareduck --- 15 years ago -

This is a question for currently licensed real estate agents. But open to hear what others think :)

Your immediate (blood) parents are selling a apartment complex. They have enlisted your assistance as their real estate agent because this is your area of expertise.

Would you expect to be paid a normal commission, a reduced rate commission or no commission since they are your parents?


**This is a situation we are dealing with in regards to my DH's parents and his brother is their agent. 

MoveIt --- 15 years ago -

If I had a good relationship with the parents, I would be inclined to reduce the
listing side of the commission to 1.5- while leaving the buyers agent commission in tact. If I managed to wrangle the sale myself, I would ask for 3%, which is 1/2 of what is customarily d...(depending on what is negotiated up front) 

Meme2my5 --- 15 years ago -

Moveit, that sounds very fair. The brother is doing the work, and does deserve to be paid for his time. Good luck. 

Squareduck --- 15 years ago -

If I had a good relationship with the parents, I would be inclined to reduce the
listing side of the commission to 1.5- while leaving the buyers agent commission in tact. If I managed to wrangle the sale myself, I would ask for 3%, which is 1/2 of what is customarily d...(depending on what is negotiated up front)


This is what we figured. But DH's bro is asking for 6% and stands to make about $25 grand off the sale. Which we think is pretty $hitty on his part! 

Meme2my5 --- 15 years ago -

figured. But DH's bro is asking for 6% and stands to make about $25 grand off the sale.

Wow. That is just not right, speaking from a parent's view. My dd is also realtor, and I would expect a discount too like moveit said. Maybe he will change his mind. 

MoveIt --- 15 years ago -

Wow...I would agree. But then, I have made the concession I mentioned for family before. I would think he would rather have 1/2 of something than all of nothing if they were to decide it isn't wise to do business with family - which could cause a rift, if they can't come to terms. It isn't worth it. 

Squareduck --- 15 years ago -

figured. But DH's bro is asking for 6% and stands to make about $25 grand off the sale.

Wow. That is just not right, speaking from a parent's view. My dd is also realtor, and I would expect a discount too like moveit said. Maybe he will change his mind.


Nope. Deals done. It's what he has insisted on and expects. DH is quite mad about it... 

Squareduck --- 15 years ago -

I thank you both for your info, advice and opinions. I'm trying to get my DH to understand that his bro is a just a idiot and to leave it alone. It's his parents business and DH doesn't need to get involved in the drama. 

Panties --- 15 years ago -

I have my own business. It's not real estate, though. But I charge everyone the same. Friends, family, everyone. Business is business. I'd be offended if someone, especially my family, expected me to do my job to the best of my ability for less than my worth. 

needrnr --- 15 years ago -

I thank you both for your info, advice and opinions. I'm trying to get my DH to understand that his bro is a just a idiot and to leave it alone. It's his parents business and DH doesn't need to get involved in the drama

I have several family in the biz. I would only use my sis for a purchase but not for a sale. MY BIL AND SIL been there done that and if I told you all their BS I will have to start to drink.

What is the old saying..." Don't do business with family".

If my family was not such Jack Wagons I would not mind paying a 6% commission as long as they look out for my best interest and go up and beyond in service. Sometimes if the agent is not the broker they don't have too much of a choice on what the commission can be cut down to. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I have negotiated a rate of 3% with no blood relationship at all to the realtor. They were both the buying and selling agent of said home.

Tell your DH parents to see what commission rate they can get with a total stranger and then decide. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

and BTW I may someone more than willing to negotiate the commission with them if they need a new agent. LOL 

MoveIt --- 15 years ago -

I thank you both for your info, advice and opinions. I'm trying to get my DH to understand that his bro is a just a idiot and to leave it alone. It's his parents business and DH doesn't need to get involved in the drama.

You're welcome...and you are correct. What's done is done and completely the biz of the parents now.

I have my own business. It's not real estate, though. But I charge everyone the same. Friends, family, everyone. Business is business. I'd be offended if someone, especially my family, expected me to do my job to the best of my ability for less than my worth.

I respect that. It's just not what I do. And no matter what I charge, I give it my all. I believe we get back when we give. 

Panties --- 15 years ago -

It's just been my experience that when you cut people breaks in business transactions, word spreads. And then more and more people want to take advantage of your generosity. So I simply don't go there. I give in plenty of other ways, so I'm not too worried about bad karmic energy. 

MoveIt --- 15 years ago -

I'm not too worried about bad karmic energy.

I hope you know I didn't mean it towards you like that..speaking only for what I do. =) 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

It's just been my experience that when you cut people breaks in business transactions, word spreads.

Exactly, and typically the better the "deal" you give someone, the bigger the PITA they are. Family is no exception.

That six percent commission doesn't all go towards your brother. He won't be "making 25 grand" off of them.

That commission will be split between the listing and selling office.

From there, it will be split between the office and the agent.

And then everyone gets to pay their expenses and see what they end up with.

There are hard costs that are involved in selling a property, it's not just a few walk throughs. And typically, the higher the price, the longer marketing times and more aggressive tactics are needed . . . which equates to more money.

If there is this level of pissiness about your brother getting paid for what he does, then it sounds like he would have come out ahead just to have referred them to another agent and received a referral fee. 

Panties --- 15 years ago -

I hope you know I didn't mean it towards you like that..speaking only for what I do. =)

Of course! No worries. I've just been burned too many times by people EXPECTING to get what I do for cheap because we're related or been friends forever or whatever other excuse they give me. The bottom line for me is that I've got talent, skill, experience and most of all expenses to cover. You either pay for it or move on. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

If there is this level of pissiness about your brother getting paid for what he does, then it sounds like he would have come out ahead just to have referred them to another agent and received a referral fee. 


Like I said before talk to a few other agents many will lower their commission without the pissiness, without being related especially in this market. Real estate commissions are out of hand. 

ladybeachbum --- 15 years ago -

Carla, is right. First, there is the fee split to his broker which is normally, at least 50%, then if the selling agent is not him, they get 50% of the total 6%. So brother might get only 50% of 3% which goes to the listing company. 

Squareduck --- 15 years ago -

If there is this level of pissiness about your brother getting paid for what he does, then it sounds like he would have come out ahead just to have referred them to another agent and received a referral fee.

No pissiness. The issue is that my DH and his sister feel that their brother is taking ADVANTAGE of their parents. They expect their brother to be paid but the amount should be fair and reasonable. And what irks them more is that he stands to make even more money off of them because he is pushing them towards reinvesting their money into more properties, which of course he will be their agent for the transactions.
Tell your DH parents to see what commission rate they can get with a total stranger and then decide.

They refused because BIL is the be all end all of everything. He hung the moon and the stars. They believe anything and everything he says...

and BTW I may someone more than willing to negotiate the commission with them if they need a new agent

The property is not in Texas.

That six percent commission doesn't all go towards your brother. He won't be "making 25 grand" off of them.

That commission will be split between the listing and selling office.

From there, it will be split between the office and the agent.


BIL is the listing agent for the complex and the buyer is another agent. There is nothing to be split, what I said he will be making on the deal is the correct figure. He is a jack of all trades who has his real estate license. Yes, it is his area of expertise and at one point in time he was in the business of commerical real estate. 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

If the buyer is another agent, that agent will be taking their portion of the commission and so will the office. He will still get his same split regardless.

No one else cares if someone is someone's relative, they still want to get paid for their time.

I sold real estate for 10 years and one of the biggest PITA transactions I had was for a home where I was the listing agent and the buyers used a hobby Realtor that was a family friend that donated his commission so they could get into the house.

That would have been fine, except for that other than walking them through the house once and writing the offer, he did absolutely NOTHING. Anything about the transaction, they called me. I was not their agent.

Then there was an issue that came up after the transaction. The sellers did some minor damage during moving and the buyers wanted it repaired in a certain way.

I told the other Realtor that he needed to be there during the walk through and he told me, "I'm not getting paid for this so I can't spend any time on it.". I told him that had been his choice.

THEN he told his buyers to file a complaint against me with the Board of Realtors (which is in itself an ethics violation) when the sellers wouldn't agree to everything they wanted. Yes, the buyers actually told me that when they called me threatening me. I told them they could go ahead if they wanted, but it would make no difference to the sellers and it was their decision what they would pay.

*I* worked it all out in the end, but I also had to manage both sides of the transaction while I only got paid for one. And that jackass that "was doing it for free" actually caused me more work. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

However it was your seller that did the damage. 

Panties --- 15 years ago -

The issue is that my DH and his sister feel that their brother is taking ADVANTAGE of their parents.

But it's okay if they take advantage of him? He has a job, he gets paid for that job, asking him to do the same job for less money than he'd make from anyone else....is taking advantage of him. 

Panties --- 15 years ago -

What a presumptuous world we live in. If they thought they could find a better deal, they should have sought it out.

Like I said, Business is business. I have friends who own their own businesses. I can choose to use them at their going rate because they're my friends and I like the quality of their work. If I'm in the market for a better, faster, cheaper deal, I'll look. But I'd never assume that because we're friends, they OWE me some sort of deal. Same goes for family. 

Puss In Boots --- 15 years ago -

Seems as if the parents had a problem with the commission terms that all of this would have been worked out in advance. If they went ahead with the deal, we have to assume that they were accepting of the terms.

Seems from your posts that there is a bigger family issue here, and that is the (presumed) bad feelings between your DH and his brother. I may be assuming too much here, but from your posts....there seems to be bad blood.

His parents signed the deal....I would stay out of it. BTW, it would have seemd generous and entirely appropriate for your BIL to have offered his parents a discount.. 

Carla --- 15 years ago -

The sellers did do the damage and they did fix it, just not in the way the buyers were wanting at first.

It is an AGENCY relationship. The selling agent had the agency relationship with the buyers, I did not. Sometimes there are issues after the sale, that is just part of real estate. The other agent and I should have been discussing it, not me and the buyers. Instead he shoved them off on me and then inflamed the situation even more.

After the buyers threatened me, I went into my broker to give him a heads up. I had a print out of the conversation journal for the transaction.

He said, "You've done all this AFTER closing?". He told me not to even talk to them anymore. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

I understand what you are saying but I am one of those people who would have been calling you too. lol

A little bit of a control freak I am so I would want to deal as directly as I could with who was gonna fix it. Not the third person removed from the situation. 

Panties --- 15 years ago -

There's a hierarchy, or food chain, to things. They had someone representing them, THAT is who they should have called, regardless of his donation of commission. However, that proves my point. He didn't expect to have to put in as much work, because he wasn't physically going to receive any money. What a douche. 

Squareduck --- 15 years ago -

His parents signed the deal....I would stay out of it. BTW, it would have seemd generous and entirely appropriate for your BIL to have offered his parents a discount..

This is exactly what I have told DH and his sister. As far as bad blood, there is none that I know of, I think they feel he is being 'greedy'. Both my DH and his sister have expertise in certain fields that their parents use on a regular basis. They have never charged them a fee. I guess their feeling is that it's their parents and there is no need. Shame on them I guess. I also think it's a case of my inlaws being lazy and rushing the deal. Hopefully for their sake they don't get screwed. I've told DH and his sister to keep their mouths shut about it all and see how it plays out.
Business is business. I totally agree. But when it comes to your mom and dad it seems that they deserve some sort of consideration, at least make an attempt not to accept the full fee. If they choose to give it to you, then so be it.

Thanks for the imput everyone. I wanted to be sure I was giving the best advice. And everyone has voiced what I was thinking or had previously told my DH and sister. 

Panties --- 15 years ago -

But when it comes to your mom and dad it seems that they deserve some sort of consideration,

Personally, I think those should be the LAST people who should be expecting any "deal," I'm raising their grandkids and trying to stay afloat. This is my livelihood we're talking about. No one gets to dip into my bowl of sugar, not even my parents. :D 

Squareduck --- 15 years ago -

This isn't BIL job. He has a full time career that is very lucrative. The real estate career had been put on hold for many years. He saw an opportunity to make a boat load of cash and he is doing it, can't fault him for that. He is a jack of all trades and always has the iron in the fire so to speak, he is ready for the next come up. It's been his downfall in life for sure. Heck he bought a fire truck cuz it was a "good deal". Its sitting in his driveway because it costs $1000 to fill up the tank. Such a great deal! :) 

evolved --- 15 years ago -

My mom handles all of mine for 1.5% and it is a lot of volume. All agents are negotiable.

If you don't negotiate you're silly. There are agents I know offering less than that. They are STARVING. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground