Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Cookie Cake

who's talking here?

la guerita 1
Fallon 8
Sandyr9111 1
NellieGurl 9
ilovemydog 1
doglady 2
~ MARY C ~ 1
nicknic 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

NellieGurl --- 16 years ago -

Can anyone suggest good place to purchase a cookie cake other than the Great American Cookie Company? The cookie was not fresh the last time I purchased one from them. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Girl save yourself some major money.

Go by the already make Tollhouse Chocolate Chip cooke dough in the large roll.

Put it in a pizza pan and bake. Viola, you have a cookie cake for under $5.00. Even if you buy the icing with the decorator tips you are still under 6. And it is fresh, and better than anything at Great American Cookie. 

NellieGurl --- 16 years ago -

Great idea Fallon....thanks for the suggestion!!!! 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

I just did this for my youngest son.

I have the pizza stone from Pampered Chef, and it was a great fit. It does spread out a good bit, so you have to be careful if you put it on a stone, that it does not run over.

But the one I made was 100% better than GAC company. And it was darn near free compared to paying $30 for the same thing. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I love GACs small cookies but the big ones r yucky!

I agree with making ur own....krogers stink too. 

NellieGurl --- 16 years ago -

I've not tried Krogers but if you say they are bad I will stay away from them too. I love their small cookies too but I think their large ones are not fresh baked. I think I'm going to take Fallons suggestion and bake and decorate my own. 

la guerita --- 16 years ago -

nestle's are good, but fallon's idea is probably the best 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

Be sure to let it cool a bit before you decorate it, I learned this one the hard way:)

I bought the tubes of Wilton Decorating Icing. It tastes great, and you know I usually make my own everything. lol But this stuff really is good, and it only takes one tube to decorate the edges and write happy birthday.

We were all so happy with ours, it tasted great, looked really nice, and was unreal cheap. 

NellieGurl --- 15 years ago -

Fallon do I purchase the Wilton Icing at the grocery store? I think I've seen it there....hanging up? I can't believe he wants a cookie instead of a cake! The first thing I thought was 'oh yulk' because I remember the dried out cookie cake I had bought for him when he got his drivers license (it was square and decorated like a license.)That was 13 years ago. 

doglady --- 15 years ago -

I personally have never had a problem with GAC, but if you did, maybe try Fallon's idea. I do know for a fact that the ones at the grocery store bakeries are YUCK!!! Have gotten one at HEB and Kroger - bad news! My boys still get cookie cakes to this day, and they will be 23 & 26 :) 

NellieGurl --- 15 years ago -

Doglady son will be 29. The last year of his 20's....wow....has really gone by fast. 

doglady --- 15 years ago -

isn't it funny how they still want those cookie cakes??? :) 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

Yep Nellie, I got the Wiltons at the grocery store.

I could not believe how nice the cookie looked, and you can't beat the taste. We had no left overs. lol 

NellieGurl --- 15 years ago -

Well Fallon I purchased the cookie dough while at I was at Walmart. It was a large size roll. Walmart doesn't carry Wilton ... just Betty Crocker brand. I bought can icing (hope it works) and a bag with tips. I plan to roll this out on a round pizza pan and decorate once it's cool. This will be on Friday, I can't wait to try it! 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

You will love it, and be so darn glad you saved yourself so much money:) 

NellieGurl --- 15 years ago -

Fallon....I know you think I'm nuts but today is the day I make the cookie cake! I have the jumbo roll of dough sitting in the middle of my cookie sheet....do I roll it out or will it spread to the edges as it cooks? I have a normal size round cookie sheet and I also have a large 16" pizza pan without edges (the edges are curved up a little)....which do you feel would be best? 

nicknic --- 15 years ago -

nellie,in my experience you would need to spread/roll it out and the pan with edge imo would work better 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

spread it out, to the very edge if you have an edged cookie sheet.

If your cookie sheet does not have an edge, then do not spread it all the way out, or it will heat up and spread right over the edge and onto the bottom of the oven. Yeah I figured this one out the hard way:) 

~ MARY C ~ --- 15 years ago -

Y'all are going to force me to put some cookies on to bake. 

NellieGurl --- 15 years ago -

Well Fallon I learned the hard way too...LOL... I stuck it in the oven and when I checked I realize I had to spread it. It's baked, cooled, decorated and looks yummy. I can't wait to try it. Thanks a million for your suggestion and your help. 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

Glad things went well:)

I tell you it is way better than what you buy at the mall.

You know where I live Mary so just bring them right over when you get those cookies baked. 

ilovemydog --- 15 years ago -

Just think of all the money you saved AND a trip to the mall ... even more money saved when you factor in time, gas. and the "I might spend more money at the mall when I get there" factor. You also have the satisfaction of learning something new ,... 

NellieGurl --- 15 years ago -

You are so right and with the mall at 90% capacity yesterday I'm really glad I didn't have to go there.... The one I made was much much better. He loved it too. Plus I had the fun of decorating it! I hope he asks for it again next year! 

Fallon --- 15 years ago -

YEAH!

I was doubtful when I made my sons in Nov. But wow, it was so much better than the ones at the mall. And like you, it was fun to decorate it myself. Everyone loved it, we had no leftovers - lol 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground