Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Was an innocent man executed????

who's talking here?

JDB2 4
DrowningFish 1
randyjet 2
Deltadawn 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
ExLady In Blue 1
drbruce 1
Perfection 3
Nightstorm 1
Hiro Protagonist 6
zapper007 2
Warren Peace 6
JohnLynch 1
evolved 2
Tipsyhic 3
A Simple Equation 10
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
The Livable Forest Gump 14
Clock 1
a174862uu 2
Panties 1
Scotties Hottie 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

DALLAS – A DNA test on a single hair has cast doubt on the guilt of a Texas man who was put to death 10 years ago for a liquor-store murder — an execution that went forward after then-Gov. George W. Bush's staff failed to tell him the condemned man was asking for genetic analysis of the strand.
Execution Story... 

DrowningFish --- 16 years ago -

A strand of hair, in most cases, is circumstantial. It could have been a contaminate. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

the article quotes Barry Scheck as clearly stating that the evidence warranted a review and that it wasn't enough, not that the guy was innocent....read your article zapper 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

It wouldn't be the first time and it won't be the last.

Our nation has executed or had the hand in over a million innocent Iraqi civilians deaths since 1991.

Government is the problem. Not the solution to what ails this world. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

So no government now? Free reign for criminals? What does Iraq have to do with this topic? 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

This guy was exercising his "rights" too ase...he was pursuing his happiness...your idea says, whatever he wants is ok, no rules!

Exercising his rights too...where is the line? 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

Our nation has executed or had the hand in over a million innocent Iraqi civilians deaths since 1991.

what nonsense 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

what nonsense

Air raids, economic sanctions and DU poisoning. It all adds up. It's not nonsense.

Sanctions in Iraq hurt the innocent


Iraq Body Count

0

The estimate that over a million Iraqis have died received independent confirmation from a prestigious British polling agency in September 2007. Opinion Research Business estimated that 1.2 million Iraqis have been killed violently since the US-led invasion.

But, hey. When you have a nation that will murder over 50 million babies, what's the difference when one man gets executed.

After all, it was Stalin that said, "one death is a tragedy. A million deaths is a statistic." (paraphrased) 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

I thought this article was going to be about the murder the other day in Houston where the man killed his wife before killing himself.

She didn't deserve to be beaten to death just for wanting a divorce. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

I guess this article could have been about the man in Houston who was trying to help a woman being robbed and then he was needlessly killed by the robber.

So now purse thieves think it is ok to kill too? 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure the genetic analysis of the strand was too much to ask. After all it was election season.

Who in Texas running for office will stop a killin' when the mob is chanting? 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

The only innocent man executed was the small business owner that Jones and Dixon conspired to kill on that day. In my mind, the question of which one pulled the trigger is irrelevant. They both had prior murder convictions before they were caught for this act of murder. Neither were even permitted to possess (or constructively possess) a firearm, yet they chose to use a firearm that day to risk killing an innocent man for a few bucks.

It's not a shame that Jones was executed, it's a shame he and Dixon were not executed sooner. If they had been, an innocent man would still be alive today. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure the genetic analysis of the strand was too much to ask. After all it was election season.

I think every decade, a criminal should ask for a new test...they could get the death penalty and stay alive for 80 years if I just did that 8 times...brilliant evolved...you sure are evolving. 

evolved --- 16 years ago -

jdb...you in the investment business? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

I guess the more evolved thing to do would have been to stone them to death.

Oh wait only women get stoned to death in this day and age. 

ExLady In Blue --- 16 years ago -

It's not a shame that Jones was executed, it's a shame he and Dixon were not executed sooner. If they had been, an innocent man would still be alive today.

Best post of the day! 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

That article seems more like a dig on Bush than an article on a man who was executed. 

The Livable Forest Gump --- 16 years ago -

The other primary evidence against Jones came from one of two alleged accomplices: Timothy Jordan, who did not enter the liquor store but was believed to have planned the robbery and provided the gun. Jordan testified that Jones told him he was the triggerman.

Scumbag goes to rob liquor store, someone dies, now scumbag wants to be innocent?

Forget it. Even if he was not guilty he needed to be put down. He was a bad person. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

The innocence project alone has used DNA to prove the innocence of 17 death row inmates. Over 100 death row inmates have been found innocent after conviction and been released from prison. These men served an avg. of over 9 years on death row for crimes they didn't commit. To think that NO innocent person has been executed when this many people have been proven innocent after conviction, is the height of arrogance. No system is 100% accurate, and to me the cost of 1 innocent man being executed for a practice that has shown zero social benefit is wrong. Agree or disagree with that statement if you will, but only a blind man couldn't see that the liklihood is that innocent people have been executed in this country.


My numbers are readily available from places like innocenceproject.org if you would like to check yourself. 

The Livable Forest Gump --- 16 years ago -

These men served an avg. of over 9 years on death row for crimes they didn't commit.

Were they not guilty of those crimes, or innocent as in having committed no crimes?

For you to get convicted of murder, you have to be the most likely suspect around. Usually this involves a criminal record or other criminal activity.

Forgive me if I don't cry a river. Our society is awash in criminals and predators and I'm not going to cry when one gets offed. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

To think that NO innocent person has been executed when this many people have been proven innocent after conviction, is the height of arrogance. No system is 100% accurate, and to me the cost of 1 innocent man being executed for a practice that has shown zero social benefit is wrong. Agree or disagree with that statement if you will, but only a blind man couldn't see that the liklihood is that innocent people have been executed in this country.

This appears to be the type of case that can be used by death penalty opponents to remove it as a tool of regulating the economics of behavior. Many articles and headlines have already been written holding up the talking point that the wrong guy was killed.

But we know from evidence that the facts do not support the conclusion that the wrong guy was killed. What we are witnessing is the fallacy of mistaking decisiveness for exactness.

The State of Texas decisively killed a murderer.

An error of executing the wrong person should be dreadful to anyone. But the killing of innocent people by released or escaped murderers is no less dreadful, and certainly no less common. Just as we can't expect the recidivism rate among murderers to ever be zero, nor can we expect that human judgement in death penalty cases will ever be so precise that we reduce the probability for error to zero. Innocent people will die either way.

Trying to escape these inherent trade-offs of our justice system is futile when decisiveness based on notions such as "Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent" is valued more than the preciseness of the determination of which repeat murderer pulled the trigger when both shared in guilt.

Valuing precision to the nth degree at the cost of acting decisively when guilt is a near certainty has a negative impact to the economics of justice. It ain't for the squeamish. 

The Livable Forest Gump --- 16 years ago -

But the killing of innocent people by released or escaped murderers is no less dreadful, and certainly no less common. Just as we can't expect the recidivism rate among murderers to ever be zero, nor can we expect that human judgement in death penalty cases will ever be so precise that we reduce the probability for error to zero. Innocent people will die either way.

Trying to escape these inherent trade-offs of our justice system is futile when decisiveness based on notions such as "Mercy to the guilty is cruelty to the innocent" is valued more than the preciseness of the determination of which repeat murderer pulled the trigger when both shared in guilt.

Valuing precision to the nth degree at the cost of acting decisively when guilt is a near certainty has a negative impact to the economics of justice.


I thought this was a really insightful comment.

It's better to take a hard line on crime, and punish zealously, than it is to weaken the system and let people off the hook.

If you do that, you ruin the deterrent factor.

Complicating this is that a small minority of the population are truly nuts and cannot be deterred, so you just have to catch them and put them away. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

The State of Texas decisively killed a murderer


In this single case. How many have been executed that haven't killed anyone?

An error of executing the wrong person should be dreadful to anyone. But the killing of innocent people by released or escaped murderers is no less dreadful, and certainly no less common. Just as we can't expect the recidivism rate among murderers to ever be zero, nor can we expect that human judgement in death penalty cases will ever be so precise that we reduce the probability for error to zero. Innocent people will die either way.


If you institute true sentencing for murder, life in prison would mean life in prison. This would make a lot more sense than risking the execution of innocent people and would eliminate recidivism.

I thought this was a really insightful comment.

It's better to take a hard line on crime, and punish zealously, than it is to weaken the system and let people off the hook.

If you do that, you ruin the deterrent factor



Capitol punishment has never shown to have any impact as a deterrent. Those who would commit murder would do it whether they're in TX or MA. Life in prison is no less, or no more a deterrent than capitol punishment. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

The innocence project alone has used DNA to prove the innocence of 17 death row inmates. Over 100 death row inmates have been found innocent after conviction and been released from prison. These men served an avg. of over 9 years on death row for crimes they didn't commit. To think that NO innocent person has been executed when this many people have been proven innocent after conviction, is the height of arrogance. No system is 100% accurate, and to me the cost of 1 innocent man being executed for a practice that has shown zero social benefit is wrong. Agree or disagree with that statement if you will, but only a blind man couldn't see that the liklihood is that innocent people have been executed in this country.

Actually, Ex-Lady, this is the post of the day. Common sense trumps violence and a holier than thou attitude.

George Ryan commuted the death sentences of ALL death row inmates in Illinois as his final act as governor before leaving office because so many of those on death row had been found not guilty and some put to death for crimes they never committed.

Sounds like you want to be judge, jury and executioner along with Warren "Peace". That's not what is supposed to happen in a Constitutional Republic, but our police, DAs and court system have become so absolutely corrupted, that very few people get a fair trial anymore. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

In this single case. How many have been executed that haven't killed anyone?


This thread is about this single case. In other cases, I'll rightly criticize prosecutorial negligence that risked convicting an innocent when warranted.


If you institute true sentencing for murder, life in prison would mean life in prison.

If, if, if. Unfortunately, the life sentences we actually have trigger a number of additional other things that are unnecessary and costly.

Charles Manson for example received a death sentence. But it was commuted to life in 1972. Now we have to endure a costly charade of parole every 5 years, triggering a series of entitlements, media events, celebrity status, and multiple victims whose families probably have varying levels of forgiveness toward him grieving about the injustice of such entitlements getting any consideration.

Would we better off with the Charles Mansons of the world dead, or serving life sentences? I guess that's what we may disagree about.

I see such softer views of what appropriate punishment for an act of murder is as naive thinking that forgiveness as a form of higher moral existence will benefit society. Even some victims indeed relish an opportunity to portray themselves as noble. No doubt those of us with opposing views aren't immune from false nobility.


Sounds like you want to be judge, jury and executioner along with Warren "Peace".
Did you misunderstand that this is an opinion forum? We don't get to be any of those things on this forum. It's obvious to most of us, but I didn't want to assume it was obvious to you as well.

You've got some hair-trigger sensitivities ASE. Take a laxative or have a drink. But the solution seems to lie with one of your orifices. Pick one. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

Did you misunderstand that this is an opinion forum?

So, you're telling me that I'm not entitled to mine? What a hypocrite...

Take a laxative or have a drink. But the solution seems to lie with one of your orifices. Pick one. 

Sorry, Warren. I don't drink and I don't take pharmaceuticals. My mind is clear, my body is clean and I like to keep it that way. Perhaps that is YOUR problem...

For the record, I would lose no sleep knowing Manson has been eliminated from this earth. His case is undeniable. He is truly a nutjob. However, the fact remains that our criminal "justice" system railroads thousands of people through the system and steals their freedom when they have done nothing wrong.

We have 4% of the population on this planet, yet 25% of the incarcerated population of this planet. Over 2.3 MILLION people and 85% of them non-violent drug offenders. There are more people in prison in Amerika than in Communist China.

Nope, we don't live in a completely corrupt police state that operates above the law on a daily basis. Go back to sleep...

But the solution seems to lie with one of your orifices. Pick one. 

The solution to our problems lies not in how we can medicate ourselves to avoid facing the real problems in this world, but in educating ourselves to the true reality of how things really work and facing it with courage and the will to change things for the better. You will never understand that concept, though. That's too bad for you. I really do pity you, Warren. 

Panties --- 16 years ago -

This should have been a poll. 

zapper007 --- 16 years ago -

Hear u go, sum of you-ins need ta git yerself edukated on this stuff...

about the Hanging Judge of Texas!!!
Judge Roy Bean 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

So, you're telling me that I'm not entitled to mine? What a hypocrite...

This is typical from the "Truther" mindset. You know damn well I didn't say that. Yet in the absence of it, you decided to say that I said it. What's next? Are you going to make up some bs about me planting thermite too? I noticed you and the other two abandoned that last Truther thread when this lie of the Truther movement got exposed.


We have 4% of the population on this planet, yet 25% of the incarcerated population of this planet. Over 2.3 MILLION people and 85% of them non-violent drug offenders. There are more people in prison in Amerika than in Communist China.

When you're ready to start a thread about drug legalization to more efficiently operate our criminal justice system, we may find some common ground. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

This should have been a poll. 

How about a poll to see which of me or ASE are more deserving of pity? 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

I noticed you and the other two abandoned that last Truther thread when this lie of the Truther movement got exposed.

Nothing got "exposed" Warren. You just will never be convinced that you are wrong. Even in the face of mountains of evidence proving you so. We just decided to let it go. Even if the government came out and admitted it tomorrow, you still wouldn't believe that you are wrong.

I came across a great article the other day which explains the psychology of you and the rest of the deniers out there:

The Fuzzy Logic of Useful Idiots

Read the article and then read the comments. We are not alone and we will not be deterred in our efforts to awaken the masses. It is our only hope against the parasitical/cancerous government which is feeding on and slowly killing its host. That being our once great Republic and the Constitution which supposedly protects our inalienable and God given rights.

When you're ready to start a thread about drug legalization to more efficiently operate our criminal justice system, we may find some common ground. 

We're gonna have to slightly disagree on this point as well. I am for complete DECRIMINALIZATION of all drugs. Legalizing them only gives the government more power and control over our choices and our lives. And leaves more room for corruption within our already corrupt system.

Do I want drunk and mind-altered people out there behind the wheel of a car? No. But if we got to a point where the government quits stealing more than half of our income, I think people would be more willing to pay for a cab home and make better choices for themselves.

Look at Amsterdam. Druggies there are looked down upon by society and there are clinics offering help to those looking to clean up their act. As for those who wish to destroy their lives, well, that's just natural selection at work. It is not the job of the government to protect everybody and dictate how they live their lives.

There is a fine balance in a minarchist type of society. Our government has FAR overstepped its bounds and the people are too dumbed down to do anything about it. That, or they just don't care. Either way, we're screwed until the awakening reaches critical mass... People like you are not helping the cause for a truly free humanity by denying the obvious. Sorry, but that is the cold, hard truth. 

The Livable Forest Gump --- 16 years ago -

Capitol punishment has never shown to have any impact as a deterrent. Those who would commit murder would do it whether they're in TX or MA. Life in prison is no less, or no more a deterrent than capitol punishment.

I doubt that very much. The deciding factor is not just punishment, but likelihood of getting convicted. The more appeals and loopholes, the more people are likely to commit murder.

This excludes the insane, who would murder even if being held in the arms of a police officer. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Alright ARSE, if you want to revisit the useful idiot thingy, I'll start another post so we don't hijack this thread. 

The Livable Forest Gump --- 16 years ago -

As for those who wish to destroy their lives, well, that's just natural selection at work. It is not the job of the government to protect everybody and dictate how they live their lives.

While this is true, their actions have consequences on other people, and the cleanup diverts funds/energies that could go to productive people.

I don't think there's anything wrong with a society saying "we're not going to allow drug-taking here." 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

I doubt that very much. The deciding factor is not just punishment, but likelihood of getting convicted. The more appeals and loopholes, the more people are likely to commit murder.


People aren't thinking of "loopholes" when committing a murder.

According to Death Penalty information center, murder rates in non-death penalty states are consistently lower than in death penalty states. Where's the deterrent? 

Scotties Hottie --- 16 years ago -

Can you imagine actually sitting on death row for a crime you didn't commit? I can't even fathom what that has to be like.

I always wonder if the ones that have been later found innocent had lengthy criminal records? 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

I don't think there's anything wrong with a society saying "we're not going to allow drug-taking here." 

I don't either. And those communities will not be the destination of those who wish to partake in their habit. Ostracization works very well and has in the past. Control of the masses by an "elite" oligarchy doesn't. That is what this country has turned into... 

The Livable Forest Gump --- 16 years ago -

I always wonder if the ones that have been later found innocent had lengthy criminal records?

Usually, and/or were accomplices in the commission of a crime where someone died. "Not guilty" is not the same as "innocent."

Control of the masses by an "elite" oligarchy doesn't.

I agree, but what I'd add here is that the masses by their irresponsible behavior tend to select these oligarchies.

I'm not sure I want the average Houston driver picking our future as a country. The average business owner, professor or law enforcement officer? Maybe. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

I always wonder if the ones that have been later found innocent had lengthy criminal records? 


Does that really matter if they didn't commit the crime they are there for? It's thinking like that which gets innocent people convicted in the first place. The person is already a criminal so they must be guilty. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

I always wonder if the ones that have been later found innocent had lengthy criminal records? 

There have been some with NO criminal record at all. I was following a case with Amnesty International 2 years ago. Troy Davis was convicted and sentenced to death on circumstantial evidence of killing a cop. He was completely railroaded through the system by a corrupt DA. He has been on death row for over 19 years and his sentence was stayed 2 years ago, but his latest appeal was just denied again 6 days ago. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
book club
charity
children


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground