Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

The Atheist's "god" (a civilized discussion)

who's talking here?

Justwatching72 1
Going off air 21
Donkey Hodie 1
Shana 1
Laurabeth 1
POTUS 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
oneyedman 3
Warren Peace 9
voice of reason 2
JohnLynch 6
allday 3
SighFiGurl 2
Work in Progress 1
Puss In Boots 1
PiratePersona 1
Panties 2
Ares 11

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

Before u all start with me

let's get it right

This is not a fight nor baiting nor an attack

it is an intellectually honest 100% curiosity that i have and i am seeking answers for my own good

I hope to find answers or at least hear some opinions

For the sake of our discussion the term God shall refer to Supreme Ruler

Here are the Facts:
In christianity the Laws of Life are set forth by God the one true and living God

we either obey or not

Here is my theory:
In Atheism, since there is no God nor any of his rules, then each person is fully able to rightly declare that he can do whatever is right in his own eyes

Here is my Question:

For the sake of r discussion we shall pretend that there are only Atheist's

that way we are not distracted from all the other stuff

Here we go... If there is no God nor any rules of life

How does the Atheist decide who makes the rules?

Why should one listen to man (even though he be a scientist) and go by his rules?

is not each one a god in their own right?

And how can one man despise another because he likes to strip the skins off of children and wear them as coats?

If you think its deplorable yet he thinks its ok

Who has the final say so? And who is right? Who sets forth moral order?

And if we pick one man to decide which is actuality right or wrong, then are we not denigrating r own selves and in fact have become puppets on a string?

In summary and in brevity i would genuinely like to know how Atheististic

"Rule and Order" is set forth

For me to know this would be of great help to me 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

I'm not getting involved. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Dude, paragraphs are a thing of beauty....

And I'm also not getting involved. :) 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

I'm not getting involved.


lolx 6

copycat

I love it!!! 

Ares --- 16 years ago -

In Atheism, since there is no God nor any of his rules, then each person is fully able to rightly declare that he can do whatever is right in his own eyes

I'm not an atheist now, but I have been. And I know many.

This statement is inherently wrong.

Atheists I've known have typically been far more moral and ethical than bible types because their morality is thought out and often internal, rather than coming from an external source.

Reasoned ideas of ethics and morality are often going to be far stronger in a persons mind than those that come from others.

They also do not have the "but Jesus will forgive me" mentality I've seen so often... which in some peoples view gives them carte blanche to act in the most horrid of ways.


"Jesus will forgive me", versus GUILT that an atheist would feel. Hmmmm...

Even when I was an atheist I still found abortion to be wrong since it ended the life of a human (separate DNA, separate entity and just as deserving of life as anyone else...) Religion had no bearing on my view of the wrongness of it.

As for the concept of what is moral or not, most follow the constructs of the culture in addition to their own conscience. First came the cultural norms THEN the religion. The religion only codifies what the cultural norms were at the time. Atheists are still part of the culture. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

The central illogic of the Athiest is that he belives man to be moral by nature, but is unwilling to devise from whence that "natural" morality derives. 

allday --- 16 years ago -

Atheists I've known have typically been far more moral and ethical than bible types because their morality is thought out and often internal, rather than coming from an external source.

Reasoned ideas of ethics and morality are often going to be far stronger in a persons mind than those that come from others.

They also do not have the "but Jesus will forgive me" mentality I've seen so often... which in some peoples view gives them carte blanche to act in the most horrid of ways.


"Jesus will forgive me", versus GUILT that an atheist would feel. Hmmmm...

Even when I was an atheist I still found abortion to be wrong since it ended the life a human (separate DNA, separate entity and just as deserving of life as anyone else...) Religion had no bearing on my view of the wrongness of it.


That's about how I feel. What the heck you gonna go to church for and pray for forgiveness and salvation for if you don't act up the week before?

I believe we are inherently good with obvious deviations mostly occurring from those that feel they are called by God to do their damage. 

Ares --- 16 years ago -

The central illogic of the Athiest is that he belives man to be moral by nature, but is unwilling to devise from whence that "natural" morality derives.

Survival of the species. In order to prosper as a species we need to have social constructs that depend on proper behavior.

I do believe that many people do have an internal, built in, sense of right and wrong. I also believe that many do not (and perhaps those folks are the ones that need religeon....) 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

Survival of the species. In order to prosper as a species we need to have social constructs that depend on proper behavior

Weak argument and not supportable

do believe that many people do have an internal, built in, sense of right and wrong.

Ok, but from where does this derive? Nature? genetics? something else? If a natural construct of evolution, then it would manifest in the genome, correct? 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

I don't need a fake Book and a Sky Daddy to tell me that treating other people with respect and refraining from evil is in MY best interest. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

This statement is inherently wrong.

Atheists I've known have typically been far more moral and ethical than bible types because their morality is thought out and often internal, rather than coming from an external source.

Reasoned ideas of ethics and morality are often going to be far stronger in a persons mind than those that come from others.


OK, that was a step in the right direction for the answers which i seek

The inherent problem i have with that is that if you look at cultural norms

most poeple are inherently evil

this is why our prisons are so overcrowded

The moral Atheist to which you refer, and i believe there are some

are so few and inbetween

i must ask

Do THEY make the difference for the vast majority of others who are

well to put it kindly

are not quite so moral? 

allday --- 16 years ago -

most poeple are inherently evil

this is why our prisons are so overcrowded


Our prisons are overcrowded because they are a profit center.

If you believe people are evil, that sucks for you. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Without preachings about morality, we would have reasoning about mutually accommodating exchanges.

In the beginning, people trade with each other because they expect to get something in return that is more valuable than what they give up. Even with charitable giving, we're receiving self esteem that is worth more to us than the money or labor we give up.

Killing or harming people is unproductive - you have fewer customers

Forcing people to do things they don't want to do is unproductive - you'll get lower quality work

Even preachings on sexual morality are based on productivity and notions of net gain.

None of the productive decisions we make in a society require a belief in God. But spirituality is a good thing. I wouldn't want it banned. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

The central illogic of the Athiest is that he belives man to be moral by nature, but is unwilling to devise from whence that "natural" morality derives.



it is called the ability to reason. having that, i am flagging you all. 

Ares --- 16 years ago -

Weak argument and not supportable

Easily supportable. Groups of humans that have had issues with inherent morality tend to self destruct... Incas for example...

Ok, but from where does this derive? Nature? genetics? something else? If a natural construct of evolution, then it would manifest in the genome, correct?

Combination of many things, genetics being one of them.... instinct. Many animals also have behaviors that could be considered to be "self sacrifice" for the benefit of others in their gene pool.

I do not deny the possibility that this inherent sense of right and wrong in humans comes from God as well. But many atheists still have this sense as well... no matter the source. 

allday --- 16 years ago -

Do THEY make the difference for the vast majority of others who are

well to put it kindly

are not quite so moral?


Do some research on atheists in prison, atheist divorce rates, athiest's children's success in life, atheist household income. Atheists are very well off and quite well adjusted...thank you very much for playing.

If you want to succeed in life the research says you'd be better off with a new brain as an atheist. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

treating other people with respect and refraining from evil is in MY best interest.

Potus that was an excellent point for my ponderance


But!

what about the vast majority of others whose idea of what treating people with respect and refraining from evil even means?

Not everyone might see things as you do

And even that indicated i was right in my theory

That which is right in your own eyes... is to treat with respect and not do evil

but what about those whose "Right in their own eyes" is to kill maim and hurt others?

WHat i truly want to know is...

Who decides what is right or wrong?

is it right just because you see it that way?

There must be a governing policy somewhere in the equation 

Ares --- 16 years ago -


are not quite so moral?


What are you basing this on? Most of the atheists I know are more moral than I am. Good family people that will always lend a helping hand. Seriously, they are some of the nicest most caring people I know...far more than some of the fakey religious types I also know.

Example, a coworker was having an issue at home. Another coworker (an atheist) worked to actually help that person. The bible type, says "I'll pray for you" and did nothing else. What do you think was more helpful???

I've also been stunned when I've been told that medical problems are a result of "sin". Oh, really? Like kids that get cancer? They sinned?

Lots of loony people out there. My point being that the bible and religion don't make people moral or good either... it is the PERSON not the religion or lack of one. Thus my contention that morality comes from inside oneself. 

Panties --- 16 years ago -

This thread

is really

hard to read

with all

breaks in

the writing.

It's a pain

in the butt.

thanks.

That's all. 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

There must be a governing policy somewhere in the equation

? So atheists are anarchists now too? 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

it is called the ability to reason

This ability by no means assures a moral outlook... in fact the opposite is true.

"reason" would seem to imply an ability to see advantage for self and exploit it. This, history teaches, is the true nature of Man. Morality is easy for the economically comfortable and food secure, but in reality these sweeping notions of the Atheist of inherent morality are shown to be far too easy to abandon when faced with a conflict between morality and survival or other advantage over others. 

Donkey Hodie --- 16 years ago -

Who decides what is right or wrong?

is it right just because you see it that way?

There must be a governing policy somewhere in the equation


For me, what is right is the action that creates the best outcome for the most people, without sacrificing individual rights, and while following the rule of law and due process. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

Without preachings about morality, we would have reasoning about mutually accommodating exchanges.

In the beginning, people trade with each other because they expect to get something in return that is more valuable than what they give up. Even with charitable giving, we're receiving self esteem that is worth more to us than the money or labor we give up.

Killing or harming people is unproductive - you have fewer customers

Forcing people to do things they don't want to do is unproductive - you'll get lower quality work

Even preachings on sexual morality are based on productivity and notions of net gain.

None of the productive decisions we make in a society require a belief in God.


That was helpful

If you believe people are evil, that sucks for you.

Wake up and smell the coffee

The facts are proof within themselves

Man if left to his own devices usually makes unproductive choices and winds up hurting others 

Ares --- 16 years ago -

Man if left to his own devices usually makes unproductive choices and winds up hurting others

No, only some do that. And when they go too far, others with a higher sense of right and wrong work together to solve the issue.

Example: The American Revolution...

You do know that most of the founding fathers were mostly atheists or deists right? 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

This thread

is really

hard to read

with all

breaks in

the writing.

It's a pain

in the butt.

thanks.

That's all.



For u panties i will try to make a complete sentence

however it should be noted that i think everyone fully understood what i was a askin

but i will try and make longer more complete and grammatically correct statement's it's just so much work that i must ask my self is it really worth it? 

Panties --- 16 years ago -

I didn't say I didn't understand it, I said it was hard to read. There's a difference. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

Man if left to his own devices usually makes unproductive choices and winds up hurting others

No, only some do that. And when they go too far, others with a higher sense of right and wrong work together to solve the issue.

Example: The American Revolution...



Lancealot u r heading me in the right direction for you said those with a higher sense of right and wrong

But who is the final decider?
Where does the buck stop?

The more rich? The more powerful?

What is the bottom line and where does it come from?

Who makes the final decision on what is right or wrong

That's all i need to know 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Man if left to his own devices usually makes unproductive choices and winds up hurting others

I strongly disagree. The nations who provide the most economic freedom to their people tend to be among the most prosperous and productive. Even China is learning this.

Unproductive choices that hurt others are usually a result of failing to grasp consequences. The most severe unproductive choices that hurt people tend to be criminal offenses. We've decided to punish those people for their unproductive choices and to keep those folks out of our society for a period of time so that we can be more productive in their absence....until we give them another chance to learn from their mistake. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

I didn't say I didn't understand it, I said it was hard to read. There's a difference.

My bad and you are correct

but it is truly easier for me to read

but i dunno why

simple minded i guess

statistics tell me that the average reader reads on the 6th grade level so i pattern myself after that statistic 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

Man if left to his own devices usually makes unproductive choices and winds up hurting others

I strongly disagree. The nations who provide the most economic freedom to their people tend to be among the most prosperous and productive. Even China is learning this.

Unproductive choices that hurt others are usually a result of failing to grasp consequences. The most severe unproductive choices that hurt people tend to be criminal offenses. We've decided to punish those people for their unproductive choices and to keep those folks out of our society for a period of time so that we can be more productive in their absence....until we give them another chance to learn from their mistake.


Excellent Warren... great input and nicely put 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

Who makes the final decision on what is right or wrong

In the absence of religion? The society people live in make that decision. In a free society, that usually comes in the form of a democracy. The best economic system to promote continued freedom is capitalism. 

Ares --- 16 years ago -

Who makes the final decision on what is right or wrong

For the simple things, the law of the land guides us. For more complex situations, WE are the final arbitrators of that. Laws, and even the bible, don't make the final call on what WE do individually. So, the final decision... is us.

The brain is very complex, the genetic code as well. There are instincts that are built into us that we often don't recognize as such.

But, I was born with knowing right from wrong. I don't remember a time when I didn't know. Now, knowing and following that sense, is of course not the same thing.

I also believe that there are indeed many people that lack that understanding. And for those people, religion is essential, laws are essential... they must have external controls on them because they have none of their own. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

The society people live in make that decision. In a free society, that usually comes in the form of a democracy.

But that once again takes us right back to...

"Each man doing that which is right in his own eyes"

At this point i have learned that it is a societal issue, that is somewhat helpful to me

But i still see the bottom line as having no bottom line

In this scenario we are making up the rules as we go, and can only hope we are allowing those with some common sense to make our decisions for us 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

I believe we are inherently good with obvious deviations

I am not getting that when i watch the news

Man IS NOT inherently good

He was in the beginning

now he is marred by sin

But that is the point of my question

What is sin?

Who makes the final decision and why does he (whoever he is) get to be the final decider?

The buck must stop somewhere 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

As far a societal norms

there have beeen savage societies, brutal societies, and soceities unthinkable-Hitler's

If a societal noem is to be used then count these folks out

So who is right
and why are they? 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

I am not getting that when i watch the news



what the heck do you expect? they always report the blood and gore not the unicorns and rainbows. come on with the common sense! 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

"Each man doing that which is right in his own eyes"
Yes, each person pursues that goal. But to be productive within a system that promotes voluntary transactions, there has to be mutually accommodating benefits.


But i still see the bottom line as having no bottom line
In this scenario we are making up the rules as we go, and can only hope we are allowing those with some common sense to make our decisions for usĀ 


I'm not sure I understand what you're looking for and why it needs to be framed as a bottom line.

We do refine rules as we go. If we do it wisely, we will not take away freedoms in the process. But with each incremental decision of rule-making, we need to consider whether freedoms lost are worth it. With the purest freedoms, no one will be making decisions for us until we become physically or mentally impaired.

But in our society, we have politicians making spending decisions for us - with taxpayer money composed of mostly the earnings of the most economically productive among us. Politicians have no incentive to make productive decisions as long as corporate money can be given to them.

We need to fix our system by cutting all corporate giving toward political campaigns. Technology has now made it easier for information about how money is spent to be available for scrutiny by the public. We are now better equipped to hold them accountable than ever before....if only we can cut out the cancer that causes them to act against this nation's best interest. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

Who makes the final decision on what is right or wrong

For the simple things, the law of the land guides us. For more complex situations, WE are the final arbitrators of that. Laws, and even the bible, don't make the final call on what WE do individually. So, the final decision... is us.


Bingo!!!

Now wee r getting somewhere

Is anyone aware that the laws of the land which lance referred to

Most everyone of them come straight from the Bible?

i can prove it= they are all found in the Bible

its true! Our current laws of the land came straight out of the Bible's teachings

But back to r discussion

God and Bible aside

How do we construct our system of law and moral order

Warren just said

US

But there are many US's

so where do we boil it down to?

Who is most capable of telling us all what we should or shouldnt do? 

Ares --- 16 years ago -

Most everyone of them come straight from the Bible?

True, but those laws are found in almost all societies, Christian or not.

There are also may parts of the bible that we have not chosen to be made into law. Thankfully... WE have decided what to use and what not to.

So again, its not the bible that directs our moral code or even laws... it is we the people, individually and collectively. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

What is sin?

Sin is an effective preaching point for those who consider a Creator and are weighing the likelihood of "getting away with it". If someone is considering a selfish act that risks harming another and believes they are likely to get away with it and do not fear the consequences if caught, the only possible deterrent is the notion of sin - and only if they believe in a Creator who can provide negative consequences to sin. Those consequences must be sufficiently high to deter the action. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground