Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

should families be required to pay for needs before government?

who's talking here?

GCan 1
Sandyr9111 1
Deltadawn 1
HsMommy 2
Perfection 6
Yosamitesa 2
Warren Peace 2
voice of reason 1
SighFiGurl 2
~ MARY C ~ 1
Bornanraisedkw 2
MsGoatlady 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Family defined as parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, siblings, step parents/siblings. Aunts, uncles and cousins.

Basically anyone you consider family should they be responsible before strangers 

Yosamitesa --- 16 years ago -

I actually agree with this!!! Now, convince government of that... 

MsGoatlady --- 16 years ago -

Um no. Why should I be made to pay for my screwed up family? Helping should be my choice and would depend on the situation. 

SighFiGurl --- 16 years ago -

Yes, it's just logical. But it opens a huge can of worms. And as you know, our gov't is entrenched with inefficiency issues. To try and administer or follow up on whether one has exhausted all "familial" responsibilities in order to qualify for aid would be a nightmare.

These programs are out of hand and if the gov't wants to save some dollars they should enforce REAL limits on the program and cut down on fraud and abuse. That said in my assuming these programs will never be abolished now because they would cause a political fire storm and conservatives probably wouldn't touch it with a ten foot pole. 

Yosamitesa --- 16 years ago -

I take it more as you take care of your family needs before paying for the government "necessaties" that they feel are necessary. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Why shouldn't families help without government intervention?


If government stopped paying wouldn't the families step up to do the responsible thing? 

MsGoatlady --- 16 years ago -

If government stopped paying wouldn't the families step up to do the responsible thing? 

This depends on the situation. Is it a need because of something that life has thrown at them such as job loss or illness or is it stupidity and laziness? There are so many factors that could come into this. 

SighFiGurl --- 16 years ago -

Why shouldn't families help without government intervention?


If government stopped paying wouldn't the families step up to do the responsible thing?


They should but the situations in family dynamics would be so varied as Humpty pointed out. If you were unlucky enough to be linked up with a dead beat, you wouldn't want to be the responsible party. BUT it seems family would be higher on the list than the gov't. Just too hard to administer. But I always believed that's what charities and churches should do, and they DO, but the vast numbers who are on aid and stay consistently on are a real problem. Instead of getting a leg up to move on to taking care of themselves, it becomes a way of life and that's what drains the system. 

MsGoatlady --- 16 years ago -

I guess if you were being made to pay because of laziness or stupidity, family members would be more likely to take them around the corner and smarten them up! 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

If government stopped paying wouldn't the families step up to do the responsible thing?

This depends on the situation. Is it a need because of something that life has thrown at them such as job loss or illness or is it stupidity and laziness? There are so many factors that could come into this.


I agree....we tried to help my sister for years. Sorry but bad choices in men is not a factor to keep helping someone. 

MsGoatlady --- 16 years ago -

I agree....we tried to help my sister for years. Sorry but bad choices in men is not a factor to keep helping someone. 
Exactly! 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

I believe family should take care of family. I would never let a real "need" not be taken care of for our immediate family or my DH's family if I had the ability to take care of it.

I also realize there are circumstances where family members are struggling themselves and cannot help other members of the family. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 16 years ago -

This reminds me of the saying I recently learned. Charity starts in the home. More people should practice that. Take care of our families, extended families before giving to others. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

So if the family feels the person is beyond helping why should the government help them? 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

So if the family feels the person is beyond helping why should the government help them?


throw them under the bus. after it passes kick them to the side of the road and leave them to die. so what if they have no food water and shelter. if their family won't help they must be worthless and deserve it. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Good thought Steve.

The families are the best judges not the government. 

Bornanraisedkw --- 16 years ago -

[i]if their family won't help they must be worthless and deserve it. [/i]

not true! 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

If a family doesn't want to help, charity is available. Potential sources of aid should be in order:

Self
Family
Charity
Government 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

[i]if their family won't help they must be worthless and deserve it.

not true! [/i]

Check your sarcasm meter Housewife. I think it's on the fritz. 

HsMommy --- 16 years ago -

a lot of times the people that need help are those that have family that do not have the means to help (the whole generational thing). i dont think that those that are working citizens who have lost a job thus need help should be frowned upon either for using the gov't help as long as they are trying to get back on their feet either. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

But shouldn't the family resources be tapped before government?

Isn't that more fair?

Then the government aid can be used on those who truly have no other resource 

HsMommy --- 16 years ago -

But shouldn't the family resources be tapped before government?

Isn't that more fair?

Then the government aid can be used on those who truly have no other resource


Government aid needs to stop for those that are not trying to better themselves period. If you don't have anything and your sitting at home and living off the system....cut them off.

Do I think that their resources (savings) should be completely tapped, no I don't, as long as they are trying to find other employment. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

Then the government aid can be used on those who truly have no other resource

In a perfect world it makes sense for families to step up to the plate but there are too many variables. My SIL likes to call and tell me that our MIL is going through tough times, etc. I suspect that she believes that since my DH is working (and the only son to be doing so), then it's his responsibility to help out. However (big however), DH's non working brothers are not disabled. One of them is unmarried and does not have children. He lives with the parents. He can find time to play in a band and hang out. If he is able-bodied enough to do these things, then he should get a job. The other brother is also "between jobs". He lives just down the street. Of the three kids they have, only one lives at home. He and my SIL enable this child while openly acknowledging that he's hanging with gangs, smoking dope, driving drunk, etc. If my BIL has the time and energy to deal with his wayward stepson, then he needs to get a job too. But supposedly he is prone to migraines and can't work.

Meanwhile, I'm here with the best of the brothers, my DH. Who busts his backside to make sure that we are taken care of. There's no job that's beneath him and that he's unwilling to do so long as his children and I are kept comfortable. I feel that helping out his parents when they have two sons with far fewer responsiblities is a detriment to my family. I would have a different outlook if these two were helping out in some manner...I'm not heartless. But I refuse to be an enabler either. If the govt. wasn't so overly generous, maybe these two would be forced into some responsiblity. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

There was a time when that was the norm and folks were ashamed to take "aid."
I have a friend and most of her cousins are actually half siblings - she had an Auntie who couldn't keep in in her panties. After each relationship one of the siblings would adopt the child. After a time they told her that she had to have her tubes tied or they would not help her any more. In some of the cases the adopted kids were not treated the same as the biological ones. The kids it seems are always the ones who suffer the most. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

So what's the answer? Who is responsible for those who choose not to help themselves? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground