Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Texas Considers Medicaid & CHIP Withdrawal

who's talking here?

marthas attic 1
smartypants 9
random 1
Randi 5
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 19
Betty 4
Hiro Protagonist 3
ladyjane 1
OH SNAP 1
johnregalman517 1
Butterfly Kisses 1
poolgal 1
Clovis 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Clovis --- 16 years ago -

Some Republican lawmakers — still reveling in Tuesday’s statewide election sweep — are proposing an unprecedented solution to the state’s estimated $25 billion budget shortfall: dropping out of the federal Medicaid program.

Far-right conservatives are offering that possibility in impassioned news conferences. Moderate Republicans are studying it behind closed doors. And the party’s advisers on health care policy say it is being discussed more seriously than ever, though they admit it may be as much a huge in-your-face to Washington as anything else.

“With Obamacare mandates coming down, we have a situation where we cannot reduce benefits or change eligibility” to cut costs, said State Representative Warren Chisum, Republican of Pampa, the veteran conservative lawmaker who recently entered the race for speaker of the House. “This system is bankrupting our state,” he said. “We need to get out of it. And with the budget shortfall we’re anticipating, we may have to act this year.”

The Heritage Foundation, a conservative research organization, estimates Texas could save $60 billion from 2013 to 2019 by opting out of Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program, dropping coverage for acute care but continuing to finance long-term care services. The Texas Health and Human Services Commission, which has 3.6 million children, people with disabilities and impoverished Texans enrolled in Medicaid and CHIP, will release its own study on the effect of ending the state’s participation in the federal match program at some point between now and January.

State Representative John M. Zerwas, Republican of Simonton, an anesthesiologist who wrote the bill authorizing the health commission’s Medicaid study, said early indications were that dropping out of the program would have a tremendous financial ripple effect. Mr. Zerwas said that he was not ready to discount the idea, but that he worried about who would carry the burden of care without Medicaid’s “financial mechanism.”

“Because of the substantial amount of matching money that comes from the federal government,” Mr. Zerwas said, “there’s an economic impact that comes from that. If we start to look at what that impact is, we have to consider whether it’s feasible to not participate.”

State Senator Jane Nelson, Republican of Flower Mound, who heads the Senate Public Health Committee, said dropping out of Medicaid was worth considering — but only if it made fiscal sense without jeopardizing care.

Currently, the Texas program costs $40 billion for a period of two years, with the federal government paying 60 percent of the bill. As a result of federal health care changes, Ms. Nelson said, millions of additional Texans will be eligible for Medicaid.

“I want to know whether our current Medicaid enrollees, and there certainly could be millions more by 2014, could be served more cost efficiently and see better outcomes in a state run program,” she said.


link


And by the way, Perry wants to "opt out" of Social Security too:

link

Is this what Texans want? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Texas already chooses to only partially cover CHIP. But I'm sure you knew that in your research. 

poolgal --- 16 years ago -

that's pretty stupid,to get rid of chips and Medicaid .. i do think any adult who needs to be on medicaid should have to take a drug test..but there are a hell of a lot of kids who needs one of these services ..for example my daughter has been on chips since she was 5 and is now 15..she has had 2 surgery's and a broken arm..and numerous tests done on her head..but of course they would think these were acute care not life threatening..but none of this could have been done if she hadn't had chips... 

OH SNAP --- 16 years ago -

What a cruel and heartless way of looking at things. This is the kind of stuff that makes people see Republicans as cold and uncaring for their fellow man. 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

CH, enlighten us. Are there strings attached to the federal monies associated with these programs that we're trying to avoid? Is it that there are other alternatives on the horizon (ie, Obamacare) that they're battening the hatches for?

And while I'm fired up, are there any serious plans underway to eliminate fraud and wasteful spending in these programs? Of means of ensuring that recipients make some kind of contributions to their care? For example, I hear some hospitals are replacing those programs with their own insurance plans, very low cost, but so they can at least buffer the financial pummeling they're currently taking? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

ladyjane, yes on the strings, the federal money only covers a portion of the program with the State paying for the rest. The State then determines how much they can afford to cover which is why Texas only covers up to 200% of FPL (federal poverty level) and not 300% as the fed allows.

Also the State of Texas recently (within the past couple of years) settled two lawsuits brought on by Medicaid recipients - these settlements require additional resources be spent on Medicaid services and that took the money originally allocated to the CHIP program so the State can spend even less on CHIP.

The two lawsuits were good for Medicaid recipients, in the first it dealt with preventative care visits and making them more available - the downside to this is that there is no punitive action on the parents who do not take their children in for the visits. If the State does not meet certain standards (and the settlement was 100%) then the State is fined huge dollars. This has forced the State to focus only on that service.

The other lawsuit dealt with special needs children (physically challenged) and removed any benefit limitations from them. So the parents can request and must receive any home health service they say they need. This is HUGE dollars that the State (and therefore the insurance companies) are paying.

So since the money is legally required now to go to Medicaid, it can't go to cover CHIP. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

As for fraud and wasteful spending - help identify it. If you get a bill from a provider for services not rendered tell your insurance company. Every one of them as a fraud/abuse unit that investigates these.

Call the Texas Medical Board and file a claim against the provider - while these are typically not made public they do reprimand their physicians frequently.

Some hospitals are creating their own insurances - they have to find a way to cover their losses and still keep their doors open.

I know Memorial Hermann, Texas Children's and Harris County Hospital District have their own insurance companies - and I'm sure there are others around here too. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

Why don't they just round up all the kids and disabled people and start euthanizing them? That would be cheaper! Go Texas! :P 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

smartypants, nice response.

So if everyone should get everything they want, who pays for it?

What happens when the money runs out?

The State only has so much money. They are now mandated to pay for whatever home health services children with special needs want (note that I did not say clinically NEED). 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

smartypants, nice response.

Well, that's how I feel about the idea of the state dropping Medicaid. Nice idea. WTF. Let's go after the poorest, most medically challenged people, and cut their health care. It's a death sentence to a lot of them. But, so what. Gov. Good Hair needs to pay his rent. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Texas is NOT dropping Medicaid. 

Randi --- 16 years ago -

There are too many people that are abusing the system. I think there should be random home visits to make sure the number of people actually live there. Maybe if we could help only those that really qualify then there would be enough money. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

What should be paid for and what shouldn't? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Randi how do you prove someone lives somewhere?

The applications were filled out months before and could have been correct then. 

ExLady In Blue --- 16 years ago -

In the words of the left (and directed at the left), how do you propose to have the money to cover everything? 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

They are now mandated to pay for whatever home health services children with special needs want

And guess what, they still don't get services. What they do is put eligible people on a waiting list for these "mandated programs" for years. After a decade or so, they MAY get off the waiting list. Guess what the state does then? Nothing. Because the state doesn't fully fund the "mandates". And, if the state doesn't release the funding, no provider will perform the service, because they don't get paid. Isn't that special? :P 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Smartypants I don't know where you learned that from but it is wrong.

If a Medicaid HMO denies benefits they are fined a ton.

Now finding a home health agency willing to accept how much the government pays that's another story.

Home health agencies want more for their services than the government wants to pay. So whose fault is that? 

johnregalman517 --- 16 years ago -

This state has never been a hand out state. For social Security you pay the federal government they write the check not the State of Texas. I will be blunt if your a newbie to Texas may I suggest you look into California, New York, and Northern Illinois for state driven handouts. To all of those living here for years this should be no surprise. CHIP wasn't even talked about not even 20 years ago one thing or the other has happened with this gimme generation. You do not want to take responsibility or you love OPM other peoples money. Its your mess you pick it up. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

You also realize Smartypants that insurance companies must pay claims in 30 days or they have to pay penalty and interest that basically doubles the payment for every day the claim is not paid.

You also realize all late claims have to be reported to the State who also then fines the insurance company. 

Randi --- 16 years ago -

CH - They are supposed to report any changes, address, money situation. I knew someone who lived with the father of 2 of her kids, but they weren't married so she said they lived apart. She also had two other kids that she claimed, but they lived with their father. I was too afraid to turn them in, but if they had gone out to the house then they would have known that there was a man living there and only two children. And I think it should be unannounced so that they don't have time to get rid of the baby daddy clothes. 

Randi --- 16 years ago -

I am not saying that medicaide is a bad thing. I have been on it before when I was pregnant. I just think if there is less abuse then the people who need it won't have such a hard time. Thats all. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Randi if you know that then turn them in.

One of the verifications is checking with tax returns. They also can check bank accounts, car and boat licensing, court records, and any legally registered item to validate the application

Not everyone is a cheat. The low number who are hurt everyone. 

Randi --- 16 years ago -

As far as I know she is not doing that anymore and I lost all contact with her. But I do know how she did it. She didn't work, but he did. So she said he gave her like $200 a month. She didn't have a bank account no car or boat in her name. There are sooo many ways to get around that. If someone showed up at the door and says I want to see the children and look to see if someone else is living there then maybe it wouldn't be so easy.
I am not saying everyone is a cheat, or that most everyone is a cheat. I am saying that the cheaters hurt everyone. For every dollar spent on someone who is cheating the system that is one dollar that isn't spent on someone who deserves it. I don't see how anyone could argue with that. 

Randi --- 16 years ago -

And you are right. I should have turned her in. I just didn't want her to find out it was me. Stupid I know, but that was my reasoning. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

I don't know where you learned that from but it is wrong

Some needed services come from Medicaid (doctors, durable medical equipment, home health aides for example). Other services are provided from the same funding and are called Medicaid waiver programs. CLASS, MDCP, DBMB, and HCS are some of the programs in Texas. They are for Medicaid eligible people only. These programs are not fully funded even though the people who they are supposed to serve have already been determined to meet all medical eligibility requirements, and the care has been determined to be necessary by the state because of medical conditions.

So if the state is looking at dropping Medicaid, those programs which are already underfunded, will be further impacted.

edit to add: The waiver programs allow more flexibility in the way the money is used; mostly it is to provide services in the home and/or community which is WAY LESS EXPENSIVE AND MANY TIMES BETTER FOR THE PATIENT than institutional or nursing home care.

(not shouting with the caps, just emphasizing) 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

They don't have the FUNDING because they are mandated to pay for items in the Alberto N and Frew settlements.

What can they cut to fund those programs?

State Parks?

Highways?

State Police?

Education?

Food Safety?

What?

There is greater demand than there is funds to pay for it. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

The cost of those two lawsuits in money diverted from caring for MANY to caring for a FEW is in the hundreds of millions of dollars. 

Butterfly Kisses --- 16 years ago -

Chunk...i agree with you! There is so much abuse of the system. There has got to be a better way to verify the info people turn in. I don't want anyone who it TRULY down on their luck to suffer, especially children, but things can't go on this way any longer. THERE HAS GOT TO BE A BETTER WAY! When my husband was layed-off several years ago...we refused to go on any type of aid. I was a stay at home mom at the time so i went out and found a job to help out. It was an extremely difficult time for our family...but we just could not bring ourselves to go on unemployment. (Pride I guess, i don't know) We did apply for chips for the kids because we have a type 1 diabetic child who has to have insulin, syringes, test strips, etc.....and I don't know what we would have done without that. We only had them on it for 3 months and then back on my husbands when he got another job. So, I can relate to both sides. I just really believe that a lot of the people do abuse the system. Instead of getting out there and getting a job, any job, its just easier to stay at home and get paid! 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

Its your mess you pick it up.



Frew vs State of Texas

The petitioners alleged that the Texas program did not satisfy the requirements of federal law. They asserted that the Texas program did not ensure eligible children would receive health, dental, vision, and hearing screens; failed to meet annual participation goals; and gave eligible recipients inadequate notice of available services. The petitioners also claimed the program lacked proper case management and corrective procedures and did not provide uniform services throughout Texas.

The State of Texas made a mess by not following the law. At least that's what the courts decided. Now they are having to clean up their mess. Guess they should have made more of an effort to follow the law in the first place. It would have been more cost effective. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

smartypants, how can you FORCE parents to take their kids in for appointments for well child visits?

Physician offices send reminders, they phone the parents, Medicaid will pay for transportation to take them there and they still do not show up.

There are some cultural issues at play as well as some cultures do not see a value in preventative care, they go only when sick.

But if they are on Medicaid the State now has to find a way to get them to the visit.

If you have some ideas I would love to hear them and I know the State would too.

Ask some of the nurses on here - ask them how many missed appointments there are, how hard it is to get people in to see the doctor unless they are sick.

If the parents don't value the well child visit, the parents won't go to it.


And the State is held responsible.


So, let's take this one step further.........

If the State is held responsible for the child NOT getting the well child visit, and the root cause is the PARENT, should the PARENT lose custody? 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

if they are on Medicaid the State now has to find a way to get them to the visit.

If you have some ideas I would love to hear them and I know the State would too.


Yes, poor people often have transportation issues. There are often legitimate reasons why people miss doctor's appointments, and I agree some cultural issues may be in play. Mobile units rather than fixed clinics could be a way to try and improve service. Professionals in Public Health would be the ones to go to for the best ideas. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

There are mobile clinics and school based clinics all over the place. The problem is that they can't see the child without the parent.


It all comes back to the parental responsibility issue not Medicaid. 

Betty --- 16 years ago -

fraud in the system hurts everybody on it.Sooner or later it has to stop the abuse. The drs offices loves it they are always packed with midicade patients. They all go for everthing like the common cold that they can take care of themselves. I have heard of people say they make money on it they get paid they go for people that does't have insurance just to get them medicine 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

Gosh, Betty, you just completely contradicted what Chunky Heifer is saying. She's saying people AREN'T taking their children in for proper care, and you're saying they go in for the common cold.

So, which is it?

I cannot believe anyone would be behind getting rid of medicaid/chips. Isn't there a better way to save a dollar? 

random --- 16 years ago -

B******t!

so our conservative elite believes in "survival of the fittest"?? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

No one is supporting getting rid of it.

And we are saying the same thing.

I said they do not go in for well child checks they only go in when sick.

Preventative care visits are not valued by the parents 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

So what should be cut to pay for more services Marcellus Wallace? 

Betty --- 16 years ago -

They should only be able to go so many times a yr unless they have a castrastrophe disease are illness.People go to the drs way to much Drs are not a fix all for every medical problem they just want to give you medicine. People take way to much medicine I think. Time heals drs can't heal. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

And we are saying the same thing.

I said they do not go in for well child checks they only go in when sick.


and Betty said:

They all go for everthing like the common cold that they can take care of themselves.


So, like I said before, which is it?

What type of preventive visit is there for the common cold, Chunky? You seem so well versed in all things medical, please, enlighten us. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

Time heals drs can't heal.


Brilliant.


So what should be cut to pay for more services Marcellus Wallace?

Certainly not medicaid and chips. Kicking people who are already down doesn't seem like a good solution to me. Not too mention, how will the hospitals handle even more cases of uninsured patients needing medical care? 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

news


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground