Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Is a DNR the same thing as an assisted sucide?

who's talking here?

outermaga 1
Fallon 1
JDaddy 3
wayward1 1
Deltadawn 1
Eliza2 1
Lillabeth 7
Jpgirl 1
Shana 1
2boys4me 1
Laurabeth 2
quiettype 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
K.T. 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 1
rightwingmom 1
Work in Progress 2
~ MARY C ~ 1
a3097062uu 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Is a DNR the same thing as an assisted sucide?

I'm a little torn on this. My grandfather has been very sick this past month and half and has had to be resuscitated 3 times. Twice just this last Saturday. He has since signed a DNR~Do Not Resuscitate. My grandmother, who is very religious, told me that she believes he will be going to hell as to her, it's the same as a sucide or an assisted sucide. I really didn't know what to say, so I responded with, "Well grams, if it was his time to go it wouldn't matter how much they tried to resuscitate him, it wouldn't work. The same goes for if it wasn't his time to go just yet he would come back." I keep praying that he will make it through this next Summer, but I'm being selfish as I have plans to take the kids up to Colorado to see him. I did get to go up there last month and say my goodbyes in the event he did pass. Where he went from death's door to asking "when that pretty blonde lady was going to be back to give him another bath"? How do you guys feel?

Yes, I believe it is. Vote
 
 1.4% (1)
No, not at all. Vote
 
 97.1% (67)
Depends~please explain. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
Wow, I never really thought about it. Vote
 
 1.4% (1)
Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

I'm a little torn on this. My grandfather has been very sick this past month and half and has had to be resuscitated 3 times. Twice just this last Saturday.

He has since signed a DNR~Do Not Resuscitate.

My grandmother, who is very religious, told me that she believes he will be going to hell as to her, it's the same as a sucide or an assisted sucide. I really didn't know what to say, so I responded with, "Well grams, if it was his time to go it wouldn't matter how much they tried to resuscitate him, it wouldn't work. The same goes for if it wasn't his time to go just yet he would come back."

I keep praying that he will make it through this next Summer, but I'm being selfish as I have plans to take the kids up to Colorado to see him.

I did get to go up there last month and say my goodbyes in the event he did pass. Where he went from death's door to asking "when that pretty blonde lady was going to be back to give him another bath"?

How do you guys feel? 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Here is a picture of my grandfather and myself.

0 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

DNR's are tough, but they do have a place. It's not suicide, it's not as if they are doing something to harm themselves, but they are choosing not to be mechanically or medically prevented from dying.

Sorry Elizabeth, we went through a similar circumstance with my Gramps. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

I don't think it is the same.

Wonderful that you had the opportunity to visit with him recently. 

JDaddy --- 16 years ago -

For goodness sake... even if he commits a sin, which I doubt a DNR is, that does not mean he's going to hell! Has he accepted Jesus as his savior? Jesus forgave ALL sins for those that accept him. He doesn't have to keep dying on the cross over and over every time you commit a new one. I blame the catholic church for this misguided interpretation of the Bible that makes people think that suicide = a straight trip to hell. Its just ridiculous. 

K.T. --- 16 years ago -

Elizabeth:

I would say no......not suicide.....it is God's will. You could look at it this way also, medical professionals are interfering with the God's will/nature by extraordinary measures. It is in a way, maybe selfish of us to keep them here on earth with us. Tough situation. Stay strong...hugs 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Sorry Elizabeth, we went through a similar circumstance with my Gramps.


It's really hard for me. This man flew on D-day, freed a lot of Jews from concentration camps, was there on the day Pearl Harbor was bombed, as well as being shot. He was just honored this year in Washington which was just awesome.

It will very hard on me when he passes. He is my gramps. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

I blame the catholic church for

These grandparents are not Catholic.

I am Catholic and not all Catholics have that viewpoint. As God does not punish those who are ill. ie: mental illness. But that is a whole different thread. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

Recently lost my grandmother, she had signed a DNR - it is not a sin or suicide. Just think, your grandfather has given so much already, and he is tired and wants to go home to be with the Lord if that is His will. The DNR just lets the doctors know to not interfere and to make your grandfather as comfortable as possible for his remaining time here. Your faith tells you that you will see him again. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

A DNR is by NO means a suicide! They are left to die a natural death, they are not taking their own life.

I'm sure that you grandmother is distraught at the thought of losing him, so she's grasping at straws. But it is nowhere close to suicide. 

JDaddy --- 16 years ago -

I am Catholic and not all Catholics have that viewpoint. As God does not punish those who are ill. ie: mental illness. But that is a whole different thread.

From my perspective it's not a viewpoint... It's just not Biblical. Its from a bunch of rules the Vatican made up. Once we are dead, God does not punish us. He judges us. We go to be with Him if we have chosen to be with Him. If we rejected salvation while we were alive then we don't. That's why Christianity is different than any other religion. It is not about what meritorious acts you perform or following a bunch of rules. It is about acceptance, grace and forgiveness. Jesus didn't die for all of your sins except the one you might commit just before you die. He died for all of them. You are worrying about something that doesn't matter. Has your grandfather accepted Christ's forgiveness and given his life to Jesus or not? That's it - nothing more to worry about. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Okay, who said "Yes"? I really want to know why? Is it your faith or are just picking yes to pick yes? 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Has your grandfather accepted Christ's forgiveness and given his life to Jesus or not?

Yes, he has. They're the elders of their church. In fact they're leaving their house and money to the church. Up until last month my grandfather spoke every Sunday at the church. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Fantastic answer JDaddy! 

Shana --- 16 years ago -

You're an old soul Elizabeth. 

rightwingmom --- 16 years ago -

Deltadawn ~ Beautiful answer.

No, it's not suicide! He sounds like a wonderful man. You have TRULY been blessed to have him in your life! Praying that you, your grandmother, and family are comforted. 

JDaddy --- 16 years ago -

Yes, he has. They're the elders of their church. In fact they're leaving their house and money to the church. Up until last month my grandfather spoke every Sunday at the church.

Yes he has is sufficient. The part about being elders and leaving money to the church, etc. has nothing to do with salvation. We don't do good works to get into Heaven. We can't be good enough. Its just the acceptance of Jesus' forgiveness that matters. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

Honey, he just doesn't want the doctors forcing him to suffer with artificial means to keep him alive-doctors get carried away with life at any cost, and forget about the person-he just wants to keep the dignity he's obviously had all his life-he sounds like a wonderful person, and i hope you all can be with him at the end-please don't worry-just concentrate on his wonderful, selfless life ,and know how fortunate you are to have had such a wonderful grandfather- 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 16 years ago -

My father had a DNR and it is not suicide by any means.. my father was ready to go but by some error with the paperwork he was resuscitated 2 diffent times and each time it tore a hole in this throat which made it hard to breathe and eat/drink.. he said his goodbyes to us and had his last rites given he was ready to go.. when he died it was peaceful with no more pain.. and i am thankfull for that everyday 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

No way it is suicide. My mom is 81 and that is her wish so I made sure she had the proper paperwork in place. It is not my place to tell her no rather as a dutiful and loving daughter I respect her choice and will miss her dearly when her time comes. 

outermaga --- 16 years ago -

I think your grandmother is grasping at threads maybe because she knows how much she will miss him. Just guessing here?????? 

wayward1 --- 16 years ago -

A DNR isn't suicide, as no one is assinting with anything.
But for your Grandfather's actions, how was it possible for him to have been in Hawaii for Pearl Harbor (Navy), flying on D-Day (Air-Core) and freeing concentration camps (infantry) all within a few year's time? That's both amazing and nearly impossible. 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Exactly wayward. Which is why we has honored this year. He has a wall full of metals.

He is a true hero and I'm very proud to have him as my grandfather. 

Jpgirl --- 16 years ago -

Not suicide- I lost my Dad 2 months ago (WWII vet too :)- he had a DNR for a long time. I don't think it's suicide and without going into gory details- sometimes it's a blessing. Ive heard some horror stories from 1st responders about having to do CPR on dying people. I never want that to be me!
I am sorry- it's a tough time and very hard to let go- many prayers. Remember to talk to him as often as you can- even if he seems unresponsive- he can hear you 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

Ive heard some horror stories from 1st responders about having to do CPR on dying people. I never want that to be me!


It's sad for the EMS people, the family, and the patient. Elizabeth, please help to ensure he has the correct state required documentation with him at all times. I had a 911 call before where the man was dying, and the wife could not find his DNR paperwork and by law, we had to act. I remember telling the man that I was sorry just before I intubated him. :( 

2boys4me --- 16 years ago -

My grandmother had a DNR and no it's not assisted suicide. When she passed away she was at home with my parents there. She got up and collapsed in my moms arms. As my dad dialed 911 my mom did perform CPR till EMS arrived. Once they arrived they took over with general CPR but did nothing more to revive her. When that didn't work they stopped and she was gone. A DNR just means that the person doesn't want to be kept alive by a machine and truly if that's the only thing keeping them here them they are already gone so what's the point.
Your family will be in my prayers. 

a3097062uu --- 16 years ago -

Oh my honey, it IS NOT suicide nor has it anything to do with assisting a suicide. If he is needing resucitatation, then God has already called him. He is being held on Earth only by artificial means. Sometimes our need to have a person here on Earth leads us to make decisions that do not agree with God's plans for our loved ones. We have to let them go when it is time and like I stated at the beginning of my comment..... if they are having to keep him alive by artificial means 3 times....then God has called him 3 times. I know it's hard to think of not having our loved ones here but it's harder to know they are suffering. My prayers are with you and your family. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

My Granny had to have a DNR. She had osteoporosis. And if they had tried to resuscitate her, that most likely would have killed her.

There are a ton of reasons you have to have a DNR.

And it is not assisted suicide. You may just need to take a bit of time to explain this to her. 

Eliza2 --- 16 years ago -

My FIL had a DNR. Doctors still must do the basics but none of the extreme stuff like paddles and needles in the heart. It is NOT suicide. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground