Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

FOR AYN RAND FANS

who's talking here?

randyjet 9
Justwatching72 1
Going off air 1
ShookUpRamen 2
quiettype 4
oneyedman 1
jtcitrus 1
ladyjane 1
rightwingmom 1
Work in Progress 2
iIivVv 1
HipsterHunter 1
AandEphotography 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I was wondering how any Rand fan can be religious since part of the bedrock of her philosophy is based an atheism. Indeed that was one of the more attractive things I found in her writings.

So I am wondering how can you like Ayn Rand since she is a GODLESS CAPITALIST? It is like a person saying I am a Marxist, but I love Jesus amd believe in God. Just a bit of a major contradiction it seems. 

iIivVv --- 16 years ago -

Ayn RandAyn Rand - Wiki


ANOTHER CRAPPY POST BROUGHT TO YOU BY _____ ___ 

HipsterHunter --- 16 years ago -

i am not very religious at all, if anything i am Agnostic.

I enjoy Ayn Rand because while i do not agree with a lot of her philosophies i find them interesting. Her novels are very well written, you don't have to agree with a book to enjoy reading it. 

AandEphotography --- 16 years ago -

You can enjoy someone's writings without embracing their ideas. I love Chaim Potok's books which detail the struggles among the Jewish community, though I am not Jewish. I enjoy the writing style and get an insight into other people's lives. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

. Her novels are very well written,

I think that the Fountainhead was well written, but Atlas Shrugged was not as good from a literary point of view. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

Thanks for the link iIivVv. I want to read the whole thing when I have more time.

Randyjet, I no more have to agree with everything the writer believes or does not believe to enjoy their work any more than I have to agree with everything any other entertainer believes or does not believe to enjoy their work (thinking Barbara Streisand here.) 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

I agree that Atlas Shrugged was lacking from a literary point of view. She beat the reader over the head with her philosophy too much. I kept thinking, "ok Ayn, I get it, alright?"

I am absolutely a Christian, not an objectivist. I do not believe in egoism as she describes it, because I wholeheartedly believe in charity. However, her description of what liberalism and welfare does to the human psyche was spot on.

We are smart enough to discern the arguments, and take from them what we perceive to be true, and discard the rest. It's necessary for every thinker! 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

Great post Alli. Also she did not totally discount the idea of charity but rather clearly stated that if someone decided to do something for or give something to another person it was because they had decided to do it of their own reasoning not because some government took it from them and gave it to someone else that the person did not reason was deserving. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

. However, her description of what liberalism and welfare does to the human psyche was spot on.

At the time I read it I was a Republican conservative and it was relatively recently published. All she did was to raise strawmen and knock them down. The collectivists were not real and did not acurrately portray those views or philosophy. If one wishes to debunk or discredit a philosophy or political movement, one has to honestly state their positions and understand it first. It is similar to calling the Tea Party a Nazi movement which is inaccurate and false. There are elements of that there, but that does NOT make it a fascist movement. So calling liberals a communist/socialist movement is just as inaccurate and it unfair.

For those who like simple things and cannot understand much, I can see why she is very popular with them. 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

For those who like simple things and cannot understand much, I can see why she is very popular with them.

So, people like you then...

Indeed that was one of the more attractive things I found in her writings.

I think that the Fountainhead was well written
 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

Great post Alli. Also she did not totally discount the idea of charity but rather clearly stated that if someone decided to do something for or give something to another person it was because they had decided to do it of their own reasoning not because some government took it from them and gave it to someone else that the person did not reason was deserving. 


And great post, quiettype! I find that philosophy fits nicely with Christian teachings, although for different reasons. I loved Atlas Shrugged and was intrigued to find how closely the capitalist point of view fits with what the Bible teaches - God loves a cheerful giver, those who do not work shall not eat, etc. So clearly it defines helping those who truly need help, but not making victims out of those who can help themselves.

I admire her thinking and find it useful, even though it doesn't fit exactly with my point of view. I like to think of that as tolerance. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I saw that Allen Greenspan has finally understood that she was full of it. The latest crash blew his and her philosophy out of the water. Too bad it took him so long to see that and in the meantime he did great damage to our country. It should serve as a cautionary tale to avoid simple ideologues and allowing them to have any kind of power. NOW we are paying the price.

In my chosen profession he and she did great damage to aviation. He was the architect of airline deregulation and now we are going into the inevitable concentration of capital that comes with that. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I admire her thinking and find it useful, even though it doesn't fit exactly with my point of view. I like to think of that as tolerance

So you would like Mein Kampf too, except you don't like the part about the Jews and hating them. You would like the part about hating communists and forcing unions to be subservient to the state. That was indeed the position of most conservatives before WWII. They took the parts of Mein Kampf that they liked and ignored the rest of his philosophy. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

If one wishes to debunk or discredit a philosophy or political movement, one has to honestly state their positions and understand it first.

She lived what she wrote against and I don't think it gets any more real than that for someone. I'm not saying I agree with all of her views but for her personally how much more can you want from someone that disagrees than the fact that they lived through it? It makes what she wrote valid to her, it is up to the rest of us to decide if we agree or disagree with all or some of her beliefs. Oh, and don't forget 95% of her widely read writings ARE fiction. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

I saw that Allen Greenspan has finally understood that she was full of it. The latest crash blew his and her philosophy out of the water.

Are you living in reality?

And I'd LOVE to hear how the Tea Party has elements of Nazism. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

And I'd LOVE to hear how the Tea Party has elements of Nazism.

Just a few things such as David Duke endorsing it and urging his folks to join in. The extreme right wing which is basically fascist is flocking to it. The actions of Miller and others who refuse to answer questions unless they are screened and deemed "friendly" in seeking to control the press for their ends. The fact that it is primarily financed by wealthy capitalists is anti-union and wants to get rid of them. All of those things are part of fascism, but it is not full blown fascism at this point. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Are you living in reality?

I guess you missed Greenspan's testimony before Congress. I suggest you read his remarks. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

All of those things are part of fascism, but it is not full blown fascism at this point.

lol.. ignorance is funny :) 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Rand also ignores US history in which we already tried her prescriptions and it did NOT work. THAT is why we passed the Sherman anti-Trust Act, established the SEC, FERC, the FDIC, and a host of other agencies needed to regulate capitalism and prevent the abuses that were so prevelant. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

lol.. ignorance is funny :)

Why don't you try answering the points instead of being like a child calling names? 

rightwingmom --- 16 years ago -

refuse to answer questions unless they are screened and deemed "friendly" in seeking to control the press for their ends.

Don't forget Anita Dunn (O's WH Communitcation Dir.)said "We controlled the media."

Minute 2:20 is the BEST!

 

ShookUpRamen --- 16 years ago -

So I am wondering how can you like Ayn Rand since she is a GODLESS CAPITALIST?

You are absolutely right. One need not be a fan of Ayn Rand to be a conservative capitalist. Her philosophy is rather weak, and certainly lowers the bar for Christians. The Christian Research Journal ran an excellent article on Rand several months ago. It should be "must reading" for Christians who think that Rand's philosophies provide any salve for our nation's woes. 

ShookUpRamen --- 16 years ago -

randy, as far as your other ramblings on this thread go, I don't even know what you're talking about. I don't really know what the Tea Party is. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

Rand also ignores US history in which we already tried her prescriptions and it did NOT work. THAT is why we passed the Sherman anti-Trust Act, established the SEC, FERC, the FDIC, and a host of other agencies needed to regulate capitalism and prevent the abuses that were so prevelant.

And we all know how well that government regulation works. I'm thinking the Bell System that went on for a long time before someone decided it was anti-trust, the FDIC was really great in preventing several banking crises that is why we don't have a savings and loan industry any more, and the SEC was soooo good at regulating wall street...thinking not only present time but the 80's/90's. Yup, more government regulation is always good for what ails us. 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

Just a bit of a major contradiction it seems.

I, being the epitomy of contradiction, have no problem understanding

However i consider her writings junk 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

I was wondering how any Rand fan can be religious

I'm a fan of Thomas Jefferson, but he owned slaves.... and he's a might bit more significant.

LaRouche believes we should invest in infrastructure... but he's an idiot... even idiots can have good ideas now and then.

you don't have to agree with someone 100% to acknowledge they might have some good ideas. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground