Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Former State Trooper seeks workman's comp after injuries...

who's talking here?

randyjet 3
txsweetpotato 1
Going off air 2
Mabbers 2
txdaddy 1
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 3
JusticeForAll 4
allday 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

he sustained in an accident he caused due to reckless driving. He hit and killed two young sisters, pled guilty in the criminal case, but not guilty in the civil case. The story was aired on the TODAY show this morning. I was curious as to what others think about this case.

Link to story...

From the story:


Mitchell was driving 126 mph in busy day-after-Thanksgiving traffic on Interstate 64 near O'Fallon while sending and receiving e-mails and talking to his girlfriend on his cell phone moments before the crash. Mitchell was responding to an accident near Lebanon, but help already was at the scene of the accident where Mitchell was responding, authorities said.

Mitchell crossed over the median and hit the girls' car head-on. He sustained severe leg injuries.

After the accident, Mitchell was suspended with pay for nearly two years, drawing his $68,000 annual salary. He resigned from the Illinois State Police after pleading guilty to the criminal charges.

Mitchell pleaded guilty to reckless homicide and reckless driving in exchange for a sentence of 30 months probation.
 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

Three worker's compensation lawyers say they believe Mitchell could receive compensation for the injuries he received in a Nov. 23, 2007, high-speed crash that resulted in the deaths of sisters Kelli and Jessica Uhl and injured Kelly and Christine Marler, of Fayetteville.

"This man has no shame. He has no shame when he recanted his plea of guilty. He has no shame when he insisted on the stand that he was not responsible for this crash," Keefe said. "And he has no shame when he files for worker's compensation benefits."

Mitchell was driving 126 mph in busy day-after-Thanksgiving traffic on Interstate 64 near O'Fallon while sending and receiving e-mails and talking to his girlfriend on his cell phone moments before the crash.

case closed!!!!! 

txsweetpotato --- 16 years ago -

So did the parents lose the civil suit? That doesn't seem possible with this man's blatant disregard for others! 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

he did not receive any injuries at all


he only caused them 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

So did the parents lose the civil suit?


From the article:


During the hearing on the civil suit filed by the Uhls' parents in the Illinois Court of Claims, the Illinois attorney general, who represented the state police in the suit, signed a stipulation agreeing that, despite his plea to the criminal charges, Mitchell was acting in his capacity as a state trooper when the accident occurred.

"That admission seals the deal," Thompson said. "That's all you need to get a compensible injury."

During the April Court of Claims hearing, Mitchell denied that he was responsible for the crash, despite pleading guilty three days earlier to reckless homicide and reckless driving charges.

Illinois worker's compensation was designed to allow injured workers easier access to health benefits and awards, Cook said, adding that "this claim is an insult to taxpayers and those two girls' families."
 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

There are tons of cases like this, where the employee is injured through fault of their own but allowed to collect comp.

So JusticeForAll, what do you think about this case and do you think differently about it because it is a police officer or would you feel the same if it were perhaps an autoworker or construction worker? 

ExLady In Blue --- 16 years ago -

Obviously this is abuse of our civil laws, but while this leaves a bad taste in my mouth, it's not any worse than burglars that get injured (sometimes paralyzed) while trying to enter your home or business and then turn around and sue the home owner and the home owner's insurance company. Unfortunately, with a civil suit, the main focus will be, was he injured during the course of his duties.

Personally, I hope he rots in hell, but with the abuses of our sue happy nation, I'm going to bet he's going to get compensation. Morally right? Absolutely not! Legally right? Unfortunately, yes. :-( 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

that's great. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

So JusticeForAll, what do you think about this case and do you think differently about it because it is a police officer or would you feel the same if it were perhaps an autoworker or construction worker?

I think it's deplorable that a man who is supposed to serve and protect, was driving 126 mph while talking on the phone AND emailing. During the TODAY show, they had a computer re-enactment of the accident; his car jumped the big grass median separating the highway and sheared the top off of the sisters' car. It was a horrible thing to see. :(

I don't think he should have been awarded 2 years salary and 30 years probation due to HIS negligence. A normal person in that situation would have had the book thrown at them.

I think it would be a horrible miscarriage of justice if he's awarded workman's comp given his specific set of circumstances.


I feel so sad for the girls family... :( 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

So you would not feel the same if it were another type of worker who through their own negligence caused their injuries? 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

The outrage is that he got no prison time. Yet Ramos and Compean got to spend nearly two years in prison for shooting and wounding a drug smuggler and using their guns which made it a felony. At least this POS, will not be able to own any guns any more. I hope that the probation officers do their job and raid and search his home on a regular basis. I will bet that he will have some guns, and then he can do some hard time.

He is basically set for life and will never have to work again for being a crook! Incredible and the law needs to be changed, especially in cases which result in the deaths of others. THAT is the kind of law which I think will be able to get passed. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

So you would not feel the same if it were another type of worker who through their own negligence caused their injuries?

I have no idea how I would feel...I consider these situations on a case by case basis with their specific set of circumstances in mind.

Do you feel there's a "one size fits all" when it comes to neglience cases, Chunky?

I'm talking about THIS situation...not sure what situation you're referring to or if you even have a specific case in mind. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

It's funny when you have someone pleading guilty to something awful, it's almost as if that admission is some lofty step towards healing. 

allday --- 16 years ago -

He's probably a tea sack. Rails against the system while he suckles off of it.

Typical! 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

He's probably a tea sack. Rails against the system while he suckles off of it.

You didn't read. Admit it. :P 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

He's probably a tea sack. Rails against the system while he suckles off of it.

Typical!


Well he is in good company with Gingrich, Gramm et al all having sucked off the government tit from the day they were born to the day they die. But they sure hate government spending, except when it comes to THEM! This guy will be doing the same now at $60,000/yr for life. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

randyjet, not to go off topic but look at how much Candidate Brown is making off the government in California. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Candidate Brown is making off the government in California.

I was unaware that as the son of the Gov of CA that he got tuition breaks and all the perks of military families. He was NOT born into the government as Gingrich and Gramm were. I have no problem with people who have worked for the state getting retirement benefits, especially back then when the salaries were lower than in the private sector. That is no longer true though. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground