Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Should children face consequences for their behavior?

who's talking here?

Fallon 1
planemom 1
Deltadawn 2
Joybell 3
Mabbers 2
txdaddy 3
SoupIsGoodFood 1
RX8LVR 2
Perfection 5
Panties' Revenge 2
quiettype 1
oneyedman 1
bhsurf4 1
youngkwmom 1
Crusty Undies Revenge! 1
PICASSO 1
Work in Progress 2
~ MARY C ~ 2
Puss In Boots 1
PiratePersona 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Let's say you tell your child that they have to clean their room and if they don't they can't go to the movie this weekend. You look and their room isn't clean - do you let them go to the movie?

What about at school, if your child is in an activity, sports, dance, band, art club or whatever, and one of the requirements for participating in trips and events is keeping grades up - and their grades fall. Do you let them go or do you support the schools rule about not participating unless you meet the guidelines?

Do you support consequences imposed by others on your children even if you don't agree with them? 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

Yes, children should face the consequences for their behavior. Now, which adults is this really about? 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

Of course, they should face consequences for their behavior. 

Panties' Revenge --- 16 years ago -

Now, which adults is this really about?

*snicker*

Everyone is catching on to the Twisted Sister. 

youngkwmom --- 16 years ago -

I would give them another chance to clean their room, but yes I would follow the school rules about not going on the trip. However, I do agree with that rule. I usually always support school rules, to the best of my ability. :) 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

I remember my son having a wreck on the way to school one day. He had his girlfriend with him. They were not hurt, but the car had to be towed.

I brought both of them to school and we had to go to the principal's office because they were late.

The principal would not give them an "excused" tardy because the wreck was my son's fault. I thought she was out of line, but I let what she said stand. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Actually it is about teaching our kids to accept the consequences of their choices.

If we don't do that at a young age then when are they supposed to learn them?

So the question remains.

Do you support consequences imposed by others on your children even if you don't agree with them? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

youngkwmom, so if you know the rules ahead of time and you don't agree, do you take the teacher aside and express your concern? 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

I support the school or other organizations rules. If my child wants to participate we go over what the rules are in advance, so they know what they are getting into. If their participation is important to me, and grades are an issue I make sure my child does their homework and provide tutoring if necessary. Heck, if isn't the school's rule that grades be kept up, it would be mine and if grades slipped I would pull them out of the activity. Sorry, but you don't get rewards for poor performance or disobeying your parents. 

Crusty Undies Revenge! --- 16 years ago -

My children are subject to both UIL rules & mom's rule. My son is not in UIL sports due to his age yet, his grades have to remain a B or better in order to participate in little league. His behavior is another thing all together.While he normally is a good little guy. My son does better when he has a coach(positive male figure) somewhere in his life even if it is only for an hour in the evenings. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

Mostly, yes. But what if you don't agree with the rule and have no power to change it? Let me explain:

Humble ISD (and most public schools) have the rule that if a student is struck by another, they are not to hit back, but are instead to tell a teacher. If they do strike back (in accordance with self-defense laws in Texas), they will be punished along with the offender.

My kids have been taught you had better NEVER start a fight. However, if someone hits you, you should hit them back. (I'm not raising bullies, but I REFUSE to raise victims.) My oldest DD was being bullied by a kid at school when she was younger. She knew the rules, tried to follow them, and nothing happened to the bully (other than the bully was told not to do it again). I told DD if the bully hit her again, hit her back one time AS HARD AS SHE COULD. I explained to her that she might get in trouble at school (and there might not be anything I could do about it - but I would try), but she would suffer NO consequences at home. Well, it happened again. DD hit the other child back. The child cried, told the teacher, and we ended up in the office with the principal. I was okay with that.

(The best part, though, was the bully was told by the two teachers and principal that she got what she deserved. No punishment for my kiddo...and the bully left her alone after that.)

The rule was wrong, but DD accepted she might get in trouble for violating it. The possible "consequences" of the rule violation were far better than a school year of suffering at the hands of a bully. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Do you support consequences imposed by others on your children even if you don't agree with them?

If the consequences are fair and are keeping with our values, then yes. However, if those consequences are unethical, immoral, or FAR too severe, then no. I would fight for my child.

I will teach my children that following the rules and obeying authority is usually the right thing to do. However, if that authority encourages hurting someone else or yourself, then it is your duty to disobey. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

I really like Joybell's answer. You can decide to civilly disobey authority, but expect to serve the consequences of that disobedience. 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

Alli, the best part about that situation was that the principal apologized to DD for the problem not being handled the first two times she complained to teachers. It taught her a great lesson.

Sometimes adults get it wrong...but sometimes they get it right. 

Fallon --- 16 years ago -

I really like Joybell's answer. You can decide to civilly disobey authority, but expect to serve the consequences of that disobedience. 


Excellent quote.

And it is spot on.

Well said Joybell. Same here with my children. They may have to face punishment at school, but they will not at home. They do know I would punish them for not standing up for themselves. It is never a good idea to have to fight, but I always tell them at some point in their lives, they have to take a stand. Everyone of us has that line in the sand. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Joybell that is awesome, I love how you told your child that there might be school consequences but not home ones. 

bhsurf4 --- 16 years ago -

Absolutely not! Chrildren should be free to do whatever they want without any consequences!


What the he11 kind of question is this? Did you expect someone to answer no? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

bhsurf4, the question has been getting great suggestions and comments from others.

I think Joybell, Alli.Sneaks.On, Fallon, Deltadawn, sew2forMe and MaryC have all offered great discussions. 

PiratePersona --- 16 years ago -

Joybell's answer got it absolutely right!

She taught her daughter that even though in HER opinion the rule was wrong, she would STILL have to face the consequences of her actions. They were just willing to ACCEPT those consequences in order to do what was morally right. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

Silly question. Of course they should suffer the consequenses of their bad decisions.
Don't you? 

Joybell --- 16 years ago -

Joybell that is awesome, I love how you told your child that there might be school consequences but not home ones.

Chunk, this is because NORMALLY, if my kiddos get in trouble at school, HEAVEN HELP THEM when they get home. ;) 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

yes. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

My kids have been taught you had better NEVER start a fight. However, if someone hits you, you should hit them back. (I'm not raising bullies, but I REFUSE to raise victims.)

joybell...this 'rule' absolutely teaches your son to be the victim. fights rarely last very long and getting the first punch off leads to victory more times than not.

teach them to understand the situation, how to diffuse if possible, but for goodness sakes do not take a punch based on some rule that you cannot hit first.

not punching first has nothing to do with whether your son is a bully or not.

just my two cents, you can ask for change back...lol 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

Joybell, that is the exact same thing we told our children. 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

My children grew up knowing there would be consequences for their actions or lack thereof and it was applied many times regarding home and school stuff.

There were several times when neither they nor I agreed with a rule or how an authority figure enforced it. I always told them it was ok to disagree with the rule or action but that they knew the rule going in and the authority figure had the right to enforce it as they saw fit. We would would respectfully and logically attempt to change any rule or behavior we thought was unfair or just plain stupid but were well prepared to live with it if the efforts were unsuccessful. Usually whatever it was (generally a teacher) I told them that the particular person or rule would only be a part of their life for a limited time and that it taught them that not everything in life was always fair and sometimes even your best effort would not give you the desired result. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

Do you support consequences imposed by others on your children even if you don't agree with them?

Yes. The issue I have is there are parents that don't. Some parents won't take the time to explain to kids, these are the rules. If you want to participate you have to follow them. The parents would rather undercut authority because they disagree with the rules or the consequences. 

Panties' Revenge --- 16 years ago -

fights rarely last very long and getting the first punch off leads to victory more times than not.


YAY!!!! 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

No Chunk. They should not face consequences. Consequences are pfft. 

RX8LVR --- 16 years ago -

This is why parenting is hard, but YES, there must be consequences!! Children must learn to follow the rules, or suffer the consequences. DUH! 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

Consequences are pfft.

i thought super's flaggin priviledges were pfffft.

dammit. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

{hiccup} 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

It's all pfft tx. 

RX8LVR --- 16 years ago -

I have a child with ADHD and a weird automatic impulse to always want to do opposite of what he is supposed to do - this makes raising him a challenge because he has yet to understand that Ma'ma doesn't play around and no matter how angry he gets, he will do things right no matter how long it takes or how many times he will do it over, until it is right (or at least the way that I want it done). 

PICASSO --- 16 years ago -

My kids have been taught you had better NEVER start a fight. However, if someone hits you, you should hit them back.

I have a son that is in college now and there were times that he had to defend him self ,and he was able to very well after being in martial arts for seven years.wewent thru the school first ,you know tell the teacher ,tell the principle,some times it made it worse.I finaly told the principle that since they could not difuse the situation that I gave my son permission to defend himself.I told not hurt anybody but also not to get hurt.It never realy came to that because once the bully figured out that my son was not scared and could actualy take him,it stoped.Once he got to high school no problems he was very well liked by everybody (girls).my wife is ateacher at KHS so we allways dis ageed about the zero tollerance policy that teaches our kids to shy away from confrontations so they are victims in the real world outside of kingwood .I didnt grow up in a sheltered area like kingwood it was either stand up for yourself or givem your lunch money and sit down,and I did not like to give up my money, so I sscrapped alot. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground