Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Let's design a welfare system

who's talking here?

adam 1
Empty Nest 1
love4bdd 1
Fiona 1
Justwatching72 3
steinhoister 3
lizandmike 2
ukchristine 2
wayward1 2
AuthorMan 1
Deltadawn 2
Zionist NightOwl 1
justforfun 7
~sassy~ 3
Perfection 5
Betty 9
Meme2my5 1
Nightstorm 1
Laurabeth 1
JusticeForAll 5
Warren Peace 4
voice of reason 1
Ogre2 1
Grumpy 2
rightwingmom 3
needrnr 2
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
~ MARY C ~ 5
Puss In Boots 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

adam (Wizard) --- 16 years ago -

Many people complain about the current state of federal welfare...too much handout, creates a mentality of entitlement and laziness in some of those on welfare. So let's design a better welfare system. Here on KU. :)

How would you want it to work? 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -

Well, hello, Adam! 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

First of all, mods would be indentified. 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

Hmmmmm... do we have denote the sources used to pay for this new KUWelfare?

or just how we want it to be? because the money to pay for it always plays a major part in what can or cannot be paid for. 

Fiona --- 16 years ago -

There should be a limit of time spent on welfare. It should help you through the slim times but give you the incentive to do better for yourself and your family. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Everyone working person should give me a dollar before December 31st and I promise I will never apply for welfare. (come one you all will just throw it away on some other mindless thing show some love already ;0)) 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Make the ones receiving welfare attend college. If they drop out then welfare stops. Help people to help themselves. Don't teach them how to be dependent. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

And who will pick up the bill for that college attendance? 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

People or families would have to meet specific qualifications, time relying on welfare should be limited, welfare should not be the ONLY source of support, users should have to be able to pass drug screening, and actively be able to show that they are attempting to get back on their feet. Only AMERICAN citizens should receive welfare. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

I don't like anything about the welfare system.

If you watched the video about the govt housing, in I think, Atlanta, you realize very quickly that the government does not keep the occupants of this housing well informed. They have no idea what is going to happen next.

I also wonder about the section 8 housing.....what kind of standards for this housing?

I think people should have a decent place to live, even if it is government housing. I think the people that live in government housing should have a standard to meet also and be evicted if they do not maintain the unit they live in.......They should have people inspect the units on a regular basis.....if you are making holes in the walls or tearing up crap, out you go......

I would think it would be fairly easy to do some classes at these sites also. Parenting classes, maybe classes on nutrition.........they should be mandatory.

Absolutely education should be tied to the welfare system and it should be mandatory.

It amazed me watching that video that these people have no control over their lives at all...........just go from one gov't house to another......they need to want more and they need to want to earn it on their own. 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

This will get me yelled at... while on welfare you are also on mandatory birth control. No WELFARE BABIES! 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

And who will pick up the bill for that college attendance?

The same administration that allows them to sit at home and keep having babies. Make welfare a set amount whether you have one child or five. Teach them to be responsible instead of what we do now. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

This will get me yelled at... while on welfare you are also on mandatory birth control. No WELFARE BABIES!


Bravo! 

wayward1 --- 16 years ago -

The same administration that allows them to sit at home and keep having babies.

The Rick Perry administration? That's the one who decides who, how much and for how long people get funds in Texas. Welfare is a State program. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

Education has to be tied to it. Also as has been mentioned our country's infrastructure needs help desperately. No reason why all able bodied folks could not sign up to help work on it, this way they get paid to work, not sit on their butts. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Education has to be tied to it. Also as has been mentioned our country's infrastructure needs help desperately. No reason why all able bodied folks could not sign up to help work on it, this way they get paid to work, not sit on their butts.


Great idea. Make the welfare people work for a living. Why is it we allow them to stay at home and do nothing? If you start them out right by making them work maybe then they will strive to do better and better. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

So, all welfare recipients get a free education?

How many families that are not on welfare, (that work hard every day...but can never scrape together the money to pay for an expensive college education) would suddenly lose their interest in scraping by....and then fall into the welfare system just for that free education system? 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

So, all welfare recipients get a free education?

How many families that are not on welfare, (that work hard every day...but can never scrape together the money to pay for an expensive college education) would suddenly lose their interest in scraping by....and then fall into the welfare system just for that free education system?




Hmmm, I see what you are saying. Maybe a trade school would be better but we have to tie education to welfare. 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

So, all welfare recipients get a free education?

You would be surprised how many foster kids get a free education........not housing, but tuition and books. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

A. You are assuming we NEED a welfare system. That is an incorrect and defeatist attitude.

B. If we create a manufacturing/farming/production based economy again the need for public assistance is limited to those who truly are in need of assistance, not those who are simply unskilled.

C. Tie assistance to work - If you work a lower paying job, offer assistance for housing and food. You choose not to work, you choose to not have your family.

D. See above, if you choose not to follow the guidelines, children are removed and placed in other homes - could be family. Yes, this is just as costly, but it puts the children in a better place.

E. The way to reduce assistance is by creating a strong economy and by going back to looking to our families first, nto government. Focus on family structures. Reward good behavior, not bad behavior. There should be disincentives to not follwoing rules, not rewards.

But again, if you create a strong, production based economy you will not need welfare as it stands today. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

While receiving "limited" welfare you must put in a min of 8 hours a week in some sort of social service arena. I dont think there is any place where some sort of service can be provided by anyone unless they are completely disabled. It can be a job as easy as riding the metro system and wiping down the seats and picking up trash, or taking a ticket at the zoo or museum. Standing in a city parking lot watching out for vandals and picking up pieces of litter. 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

The ones on welfare should be required to go to college, but since they are on welfare, the welfare would have to pay for the schooling, that is why i was asking how this new welfare would be funded.

req to go to schooling that welfare would pay for. If grades don't stay up or you dont go, then what? stop all help and let people live on the streets and resort to crime costing taxpayers even more money? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Justwatching72, there are some that are beyond help. Where are their families? Make the families responsible and let's get back to being able to help the truly needy among us. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

When I said education, I meant they have to at least get a GED and then on to testing to find out what kind of work they are best suited to, and have them apply for scholarships for college or trade school, to help them apply for internships so they can get the education/training. They should also have nutrition and, if they have kids, parenting classes as well as learning how to budget. 

rightwingmom --- 16 years ago -

The welfare system is a fraud from the start. FDR implemented it to grow the fed. gov't. It's all about power and making "the people" dependent.

Simple solution ~
1. Churches and communities ban together and help those who have fallen on hard times...temporarily.
2. They also help the widows, orphans, and disabled.

No more Nanny State free rides. We have 4th and 5th generation welfare recipients who have NEVER done an honest day's labor for an honest day's pay...and guess how they vote! 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

There's plenty of financial aid available for low income students already. But you have to have some amount of motivation to go to school...if someone is doing it just for the welfare they won't succeed, and the program will fail.

I do believe in welfare to work...people should be working to earn their welfare and pay a percentage of it back once they are off. My family and I had welfare for a few months about 15 years ago when I lost a job and I had to work at a hospital to be able to receive the aid. I didn't mind doing it, it was actually a pretty cool job. But then I got another good paying job and got off of govt. aid. 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

Chucky, here is another what if, what if they have no families and refuse to go to school and refuse to work, then what?


turn them to the streets where they have to resort to crime and cost tax payers even more money?

your 'plan' solves nothing Charles 

~ MARY C ~ --- 16 years ago -

If grades don't stay up or you dont go, then what? stop all help and let people live on the streets and resort to crime costing taxpayers even more money?

College is not for everyone. If they cannot keep up their grades or do not want to go, then they would have to get a job........at that point welfare would only be continued for a limited amount of time.

The one thing I do know, is that there are some who believe it is their "lot in life" to live this way. It worked for their grandmother, it worked for their mother and they think it will work for them.

We need to change this. The poor have not come out of the welfare system with new lives.........the system is doing nothing but keeping the poor in the same situation.........if we are going to spend the money, spend it on help that will actually get them out of this situation and able to make a better life for themselves and future generations. 

love4bdd --- 16 years ago -

Bored today Adam? lol 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 16 years ago -

Chucky, here is another what if, what if they have no families and refuse to go to school and refuse to work, then what?


turn them to the streets where they have to resort to crime and cost tax payers even more money?


debtors prison 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Justwatching72 --- 4 min ago - quote - flag comment
Chucky, here is another what if, what if they have no families and refuse to go to school and refuse to work, then what?


turn them to the streets where they have to resort to crime and cost tax payers even more money?

your 'plan' solves nothing Charles



Justwatching72, if they choose not to be active members of society that is their choice. If they choose to rob, they accept the consequences of those choices. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -


turn them to the streets where they have to resort to crime and cost tax payers even more money?



So are you saying we keep paying them so they don't rob or steal? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

College is not for everyone. If they cannot keep up their grades or do not want to go, then they would have to get a job........at that point welfare would only be continued for a limited amount of time.


MaryC, I agree that college isn't for everyone.

We need more trade schools, more productivity, not more supervisors. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

If we create a manufacturing/farming/production based economy again


how would we go about doing that?

The usual argument given against this is it's cheaper for "big business" to get work done overseas than have Americans produce...so, what's the incentive to bring the manufacturing back to our country and pay the workers a livable wage? 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Maybe we could ask Walmart.... 

Grumpy --- 16 years ago -

Have ANY of you EVER been to a public housing ghetto in a major city ?

I don't think anyone posting on here has ever faced, seen, or experienced true grinding mulit-generational poverty.

IF you started having children at 13, have no education, no clothes suitable for work, no transportation, no experience, no HEB or Kroger in your neighborhood, no gas stations - only stop & robs, it gets pretty hopeless.

Welfare at best provides subsistence. The more people that need it, the less each gets from the pie.

My solution to the problem is mandatory sterilization after 2 kids. Mandatory education, although I don't know how to educate a 40 years old first grader. Mandatory work programs, clean graffiti, litter, etc, but who is going to watch the 5 rug rats at home?

Difficult decisions. Is using taxes to redistribute resources to those that don't from those that do the answer?

Either provide for them, or they will steal it from you !! 

rightwingmom --- 16 years ago -

I don't think anyone posting on here has ever faced, seen, or experienced true grinding mulit-generational poverty.


Many came here from New Orleans after Katrina...and we bused them in. 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

I view this proposal as more economically valuable than the status quo. My goal in this proposal is to provide a “humanitarian wage” that incentivizes businesses to hire workers that are in the US legally, while adapting the social welfare programs that currently pay money for nothing in return. The effect is it should create more jobs in the US, while simultaneously disincentivizing illegal immigration.

The core of this proposal is the below chart. It obviously needs to be tweaked for financial stability, so the exact figures in the chart should be viewed with a flexible eye. Look at the theory rather than the data, because I’m only proposing this as a starting point to a conversation about what a better system of national incentives and security should look like.

0

Currently, taxpayer money and state unemployment insurance is being used to pay out “benefits” in exchange for unproductive behavior that adds negligible value to the economy and minimal value to the recipient. In my proposal (which obviously has not been vetted by the Congressional Budgeting Office to be financially sound), there would be a national fund for employment assistance. All funds currently being collected by States as unemployment insurance would be nationalized for the regulation of interstate commerce. They would be combined with all federal funds that currently go to employment assistance programs as well. All food stamp programs as well as taxpayer funded housing, and childcare assistance programs will be directed to this National Employment Agency. Why? Because all of that depends on the sustainable employment of workers that are legally in the US.

Agencies tasked with providing humanitarian assistance can continue to work with the handicapped and the elderly as they do now. Government workers will be required to demonstrate that their efforts to make referrals to private charities for assistance have been exhausted before using taxpayer money. But that’s not the core of my proposal. The core, again is better illustrated with the above chart.

The chart attempts to demonstrate why private businesses will create new jobs and choose to hire workers legally in the US over illegal aliens. They will do it because it will be cheaper for them, as a result of the government subsidy (funds already used for unemployment) that they can only receive if they file under this employment program. It’s a shame that using unemployment funds for employment is a crazy idea, but suspend reality for a moment and roll with it. Any job they create for less than some hypothetical sum will have a minimal government subsidy that is wage regressive until the point of zero contribution.

Though this appears to impact only a small segment of the economy, what it does is give the unemployed something they do not currently have – an opportunity to remain in the workplace and build on their skills, effort, and attitudes that ultimately add value to them as productive workers.

We have the most upwardly mobile income spectrum in the world. In no other country does someone have a comparable probability of starting out in the bottom 20% and end up in higher wage brackets than they do in the US. But by subsidizing unemployment, we're not maximizing the potential of our lower wage earners in a way that is a win for them individually and a win for the US economically.

Some workers are really only worth $1 an hour. Because they cannot keep a minimum wage job, they don’t get to find out what their true value is. And as result of current minimum wage laws, we do not get the benefit of having these folks continue learning the lessons of the workplace. These “workers” don’t show up on time, call in sick often, or walk away when their feelings get hurt. But they don’t get this information right now because they are unemployed. We need them to hear these things more often they do now. That’s what learning looks like. So this chart shows how employers can be freed to pay what a worker is worth to them while workers can still receive the wage deemed essential by idealistic politicians insisting that their labor should be compensated that sum.

Of course it’ll never pass in the current political environment. But again, this is my view of what a better national system of incentives balanced with social assistance should look like. This is taxpayer money going to something of a direct and measurable benefit to the economy. Where else in government spending can we say that applies? 

Warren Peace --- 16 years ago -

So no love for my plan?

Just make me King. I swear I'll fix this place and then will walk away once this ship is righted. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Tying education to welfare is the ONLY way to break the cycle of poverty. This is completely within the realm of possibility yet the "GIVERNMENT" refuses to act.

Entitlement's promote givernment dependency and hinders personal independence. It enslaves and entraps. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground