Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Is active support of California Proposition 8 — retaining the man-woman definition of marriage

who's talking here?

JDB2 12
randyjet 3
steinhoister 5
Donkey Hodie 11
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 25
Perfection 1
Nightstorm 3
Hiro Protagonist 13
JusticeForAll 9
oneyedman 2
SueRDH 2
voice of reason 2
JohnLynch 10
evolved 1
Ogre2 10
Bringit 4
texanraindrop 2
Grumpy 1
In AbsentiaW 2
midland 10

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Is active support of California Proposition 8 — retaining the man-woman definition of marriage

Is active support of California Proposition 8 — retaining the man-woman definition of marriage — an act of hate?

YES Vote
 
 25.0% (10)
NO Vote
 
 70.0% (28)
OTHER Vote
 
 5.0% (2)
oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

Is active support of California Proposition 8 — retaining the man-woman definition of marriage — an act of hate? 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

No, just an act of arrogance.. 

Grumpy --- 16 years ago -

Marriage as it exists today bears about as much to the original ideal as does Christmas. It is an institutionalized buried in law legal contract. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

 

SueRDH --- 16 years ago -

An act of stupidity perhaps.

Stupidity: a lack of intelligence, understanding, reason, wit, or sense. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

An act of stupidity perhaps.

Can one support Prop 8 and not be stupid or is it a prerequsite? 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -


Can one support Prop 8 and not be stupid or is it a prerequsite? 



Yes, just because a person does something stupid doesn't necessarily mean they're a stupid person... 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

If one can show a pressing state need for gay marriage, or some rational basis for the state sanctioning it, I am opposed to it. There are other ways to deal with some legal problems gays and OTHERS have such as civil unions. All of the Democratic Presidential candidates have had that position and I see no reason to change that. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Yes, just because a person does something stupid doesn't necessarily mean they're a stupid person...

Glad to see you called ALL of our major Presidential candidates stupid. I think that I will stay in such good company thank you. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -


Yes, just because a person does something stupid doesn't necessarily mean they're a stupid person...

Glad to see you called ALL of our major Presidential candidates stupid. I think that I will stay in such good company thank you. 



I didn't call anyone stupid... 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I didn't call anyone stupid...

sorry they and the whole party just did stupid things. They are smart, but they disagree with you so what their positions have been are stupid. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

sorry they and the whole party just did stupid things. They are smart, but they disagree with you so what their positions have been are stupid. 


In this case, yes. I don't consider ALL of our major presidential candidates to be the best and the brightest btw... 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

ughhhhhhhh

NO, NO NO 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

I love how the propaganda goes ape crazy on anything. Everything is hate or love in some eyes and nothing is that black and white. It isn't hate and never has been. Some people haven't a clue how simple life really is. 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

How about this, Supporting prop 8 is unconstitutional and therefore anti-American.

I have yet to hear a single argument against gay marriage that has a rational basis or one that even comes close to not violating the 14th. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I have yet to hear a single argument against gay marriage that has a rational basis or one that even co

How about if we redefine marriage for one group, the next thing we know, we're redefining it to allow Mr. Jones to marry Missus Jones cat - or the weirdo in Houston who wants the right to marry his rubber blow up doll. Who are we to say who he can't marry? lol

You know if we mess with this it's opening a whole case of weird worms. 

midland --- 16 years ago -

I DO NOT agree with the government recognizing gay marriage. Not just because of my PERSONAL beliefs, but because logic! The ONLY reason the government had to step in an define marriage in the first place is to protect the children that can come from a man + woman marriage. Men were leaving their families with nothing...and this was a time when women were not educated and had no real rights. SO, to keep the children off the streets and fed, the government had to step in. Great! BUT, the bottom line, the marriage pact IS a religious preference - if your gay, why do you need the government to validate your love for each other? 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

How about if we redefine marriage for one group, the next thing we know, we're redefining it to allow Mr. Jones to marry Missus Jones cat ...etc.

Never happen. Animals can't give consent. Neither can the blow up doll. Neither can a child.

There ARE places where things like this happen. India for instance. And their society, as psychotic as it seems to us, hasn't fallen apart.

Midland, the current court decision refutes ALL that logic saying it's not valid. And actually, most of what you said had nothing to do with MARRIAGE laws. It was DIVORCE laws that were changed.

The marriage pact CAN be a religious pact,but it doesn't have to be. There are civil marriages as well. There are also common law marriages in Texas and...fifteen other states, marriages that have neither a religious nor civil component but are recognized by statute.

why do you need the government to validate your love for each other?

Because there are certain rights that legally recognized marriages have that have been denied to gay partners.

Inheritance being chief amongst them. But also access to their partner during emergencies at hospitals. The right to make medical decisions for their partners. There is a whole...lawyers call it a "bundle of sticks" of rights which come with a legally recognized marriage (or,even a properly designed civil union) that people without that don't have.

Some are financially devastating, such as denial of inheritance (Happens ALL THE TIME). I let my wife stay married to her ex-husband for eight years after we were together and hand-fasted in the eyes of the Goddess just so that if he passed, his uber-Christian sister would deny inheritance to his partner of eight years. (His sister is also a P.O.S. druggie, she'd have sold everything for crack).

Some are emotionally devastating, how would you feel if they wouldn't let you in to see the person you love in the recovery room?

How would you feel if you and the person you loved had spent thirty, forty years together, building a home and a life together and then he/she/it died and his family told you that you couldn't keep anything that YOU had helped build because it was all in his name. THAT HAPPENS.

Being protected by legal recognition would prevent it.

Again, I've seen no logical, nor legal reason to deny gays the right to marry. NONE. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

How about if we redefine marriage for one group, the next thing we know, we're redefining it to allow Mr. Jones to marry Missus Jones cat -


These arguments are the frickin stupidest thing ever. Marriage is a contract. Can a cat sign a contract? To sign a contract you have to be an adult PERSON! That would never change! 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

To sign a contract you have to be an adult PERSON!

The guy wanting to marry his rubber blow up doll is an adult......who are we to say who he can and can not love and or marry? Love is in the eye of the beer holder. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

There ARE places where things like this happen. India for instance. And their society, as psychotic as it seems to us, hasn't fallen apart.


America is next to fall if good ol republican conservatives don't step in and control freaks like these that I speak of. :)

NO REDEFINING MARRIAGE - WE REALLY DON'T WANNA GO THERE! 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Some are financially devastating, such as denial of inheritance

PUT 'EM IN YOUR WILL 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

who are we to say who he can and can not love and or marry?

To enter into any contract you have to be and adult person, so anything else, kids, animals.....etc. obviously would never fly and is BS argument. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

These arguments are the frickin stupidest thing ever.

Yes, they ARE, but these freaks walk amongst us and I for one don't wanna open that door even a tiny bit. 

texanraindrop --- 16 years ago -

The guy wanting to marry his rubber blow up doll is an adult......who are we to say who he can and can not love and or marry? Love is in the eye of the beer holder.

LOL. love the way you put that!! 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

0 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

LOL. love the way you put that!!

Right??? But he loves his dolly SOOOO much! 

texanraindrop --- 16 years ago -

Right??? But he loves his dolly SOOOO much!

who's got a thumb tack? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Yea! Steiny can speak again - google is back up! 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

Right??? But he loves his dolly SOOOO much!


I'll just say this again.


To enter into any contract you have to be and adult person, so anything else, kids, animals.....etc. obviously would never fly and is BS argument.  

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I'll just say this again.


To enter into any contract you have to be and adult person, so anything else, kids, animals.....etc. obviously would never fly and is BS argument.



And I'll just say this again, open that door and all the freaks walk through......besides, it may be a BS argument but so was gay marriage at one time ;) 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

PUT 'EM IN YOUR WILL

Doesn't necessarily fly in conservative states like Texas.

I can think of at least FOUR court cases in the past thirty years where the will was contested and the partner lost.

And Marcellus is right, marriage being a contract, not only does it have to be two (or more!) consenting ADULTS (defined as, of legal age, usually 18), they have to be of sound mind and KNOW what they are doing, and there has to be an "offer and acceptance".

Will you marry me?
Yes I will
Is an offer and acceptance.

Will you marry me?
Are you crazy?
Is an example of a NON-Acceptance.

Offers can be withdrawn up and until the signing of the contract and the exchange of consideration. It's a lot like prostitution in that way. 

Ogre2 --- 16 years ago -

And I'll just say this again, open that door and all the freaks walk through

Nope. Our contract law is much older, and much better established than our marriage law.

It is HIGHLY unlikely that the definition of a contract will ever change. And since marriage law is a sub-category of contract law, the basic requirements will still remain the same.

1. two parties (or more)
2. Of legal age
3. Consenting
4. Offer and acceptance
5. Exchange of consideration.

Been that way for about six hundred years. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

There's something about "two consenting adults" that seems to fall on deaf ears with this argument.

The only people who 'define marriage' are the ones in the marriage! No one else's marriage or lifestyle affects you.

Read Ogre's post regarding the REAL REASONING behind the importance of gay marriage. Being able to see your loved one in the hospital/make medical decisions and have them inherit your estate when you pass, etc is something we take for granted as married couples. They do not have these same rights, and it is wrong that they are denied them. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

These arguments are the frickin stupidest thing ever. Marriage is a contract. Can a cat sign a contract? To sign a contract you have to be an adult PERSON! That would never change!

and to be legally married, you must be opposite sexes...what else would you like to change marcellus? If you get to change things because you don't care, can't I then justify changes that fit my needs? The definition of a contract could be changed for instance.


I have yet to hear a single argument against gay marriage that has a rational basis or one that even comes close to not violating the 14th.

I have yet to hear one single argument for it that has a rational basis. 

JDB2 --- 16 years ago -

I can think of at least FOUR court cases in the past thirty years where the will was contested and the partner lost.

can you cite the cases? I'd like to read that. Must be more to the story than you are sharing...or the lawyer that drafted the will sucked.

It is HIGHLY unlikely that the definition of a contract will ever change. And since marriage law is a sub-category of contract law, the basic requirements will still remain the same.

it was highly unlikely that folks would think that some other things were ok too. Regardless of your religious beliefs, or lack thereof, many of us are pretty sure that if you have two plugs or two recepticals, there is no possibility of reproduction...the species would ultimately end...maybe something isn't right... and then to realize that many of us are pretty sure that we really do have free will and make choices, and that perhaps making anything acceptable is not good for society...again, accepting that many of you don't believe the bible....it's simple to come to the conclusion that we should be wary when you want to change things that aren't broken. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Excerpts of what I posted earlier


If we step away from thousands of years of western tradition, if we take that first step in changing the definition from one man and one woman, where does that road lead? Where do we stop? It’s the slippery slope problem.


Sure, today we are arguing about two people of the same sex, but why could we not just as easily argue for one man and two women or three men or three women? Could we not use the same rationale to allow a salesman who lives in Miami but works in Charlotte to have a wife and children in Florida and another family in North Carolina?


And what if his Charlotte wife wanted to have a second husband from across town for the weekends when her salesman husband is down in Florida? Who says a person can’t be committed to two different people simultaneously?

In 1887 Utah was forced to outlaw polygamy as the price of admission into the United States because it was understood that marriage was between one man and one woman. Will the state now have the opportunity to amend its constitution to bring back the practice?


Once we change the definition the permutations could be endless. What about children? It was not so long ago that the marriage of children for political or dowry reasons was not uncommon. Do we want to go back there and allow 12 & 13 year old children to be married and traded for family favors or for “love”? Is not the age of consent arbitrary?



One might argue that much of the history of marriage had to do with the biological necessity of a heterosexual union for procreation purposes. Because science has now made an actual heterosexual union unnecessary for procreation is that sufficient grounds to abandon the principal in the first place? Scientists have been telling us for years that at some point computers will be smarter than humans.

Today there is even a report about a robot that expresses and detects emotions. Make that into an anatomically correct robot and we could have relationships without human partners, male or female. Should those unions then be granted marriage status as well? 

midland --- 16 years ago -

Because there are certain rights that legally recognized marriages have that have been denied to gay partners


again...check history! If you are in love you don't need the government to validate your marriage...marriage was set up legally by the government to protect the children that could be a result of a man/woman marriage...not a gay marriage. 

SueRDH --- 16 years ago -

Being able to see your loved one in the hospital/make medical decisions and have them inherit your estate when you pass, etc is something we take for granted as married couples. They do not have these same rights, and it is wrong that they are denied them.

Yes, I totally agree. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

sp
ecies would ultimately end...maybe something isn't right... and then to realize that many of us are pretty sure that we really do have free will and make choices, and that perhaps making anything acceptable is not good for society...again, accepting that many of you don't believe the bible....it's simple to come to the conclusion that we should be wary when you want to change things that aren't broken.





BRAVO 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground