Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

ever gained weight while exercising?

who's talking here?

twingirl 1
Feisty1 1
Jpgirl 3
Yosamitesa 2
Big Ben 1
quiettype 1
STNL 1
kelsren 8
Puss In Boots 3
funguy74 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

kelsren --- 16 years ago -

This week I have gained 5 pounds. No change in my eating habits and I have logged 5 60 minute cardio workouts. I am knowledgable about how many calories to consume to match activity level, what to get heart rate up to in order to burn calories etc, etc..I am a nurse and know that muscle does not weigh more than fat...it's denser is all. 5 pounds is 5 pounds. For all the women readers I am not even close to my cycle so shouldnt be retaining fluid. Clothes are tighter then they were before as in almost can even button buttons and weight is up 5 pounds. The body is amazing machine, but very strange. Anyone else ever experience this? I wanna keep exercising and eating right, but man if I keep going at this rate I will be 20 pounds heavier in September and I cant really afford a whole new wardrobe. Geez. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Great topic kelsren. You sound very knowledgable about the topic. If you are absolutely certain that you aren't eating more calories (the positive benefits of excercise are mostly negated because the increase in exercise makes us hungrier and we eat more to compensate....) I would look at thyroid issues first, then look at Vitamin D and Calcium levels next. As being low in these two components can make losing weight harder.

I am no expert on this issue, but have been reading about it because the more I excercise, the more my weight stays the same. :( 

funguy74 --- 16 years ago -

The only time I gained weight while exercising is when I'm lifting weights, but then again muscle weighs more than fat. 

Yosamitesa --- 16 years ago -

That happened to me once in the summer when it was really hot. My body was holding water and salt due to the heat. Just keep up your water intake and cut back salt a little. The other thing I did was on my salads instead of dressing I used apple cider vinegar(acv). That was better than doing 2 shots of the acv a day. 

STNL --- 16 years ago -

Could you possibly be pregnant? Very strange to gain 5lbs after that kind of workout after a week and still eating properly. Any other symptoms - (hopefully you don't but as a nurse you know Cancer can sometimes make you gain/lose weight unexpectedly). Watch your weight over the next 2wks then follow up w/a Doctor to get checked out. Hope everything will turn out to be good for you. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Absolutely certain that your scale is on the up and up? 

kelsren --- 16 years ago -

Thyroid fine, Vit C and Calcium fine. All lab tests are great. I am lifting 10 pounds bicep curls and tricep extensions 3 times a week to assist with metabolism. Man, its just frustrating, when I lay around and maintain my caloric intake and drink alcohol, I maintain, when I stop the alcohol consumption, eat great (1500 to 1800 cal) 5 small meals, no processed foods and up the activity level to where my heart rate is 170 to 180 for 60 minutes I gain 5 pounds. How do the great looking toned people at the gym get that way? thats who I want to hear from, LOL 

kelsren --- 16 years ago -

Nope, not pregnant and no symptoms to suspect anything abnormal. scale fine. i consume around 1 gram of sodium, less than RDA recommends and consume at least 1 1/2 L water daily and water and skim milk is all i drink. weird. 

Yosamitesa --- 16 years ago -

You might have hit a plateau. 

Puss In Boots --- 16 years ago -

Wow, 170 to 180 for 60 minutes! This is hard core, isn't that 90% or more of your MHR?? 

kelsren --- 16 years ago -

target heart rate is 161, so yea...kicking butt, but still able to hold conversations, etc etc...im a sweaty mess at the end of the workout, but feel great otherwise. No plateau, just switched up the cardio workout this week. thanks for all the help though...i'll just keep goin and see what happens... 

twingirl --- 16 years ago -

Just curious...what type of cardio are you doing? 

Feisty1 --- 16 years ago -

I feel ya. I am currently in your same situation. I do not eat that badly but do love a chocolate or a hamburger every now and then so I do indulge but I have been going to the gym for about 2 years now and I am still gaining weight! I even went and had my fit point test at the gym because I was P!*@D. Well, I'm right in the middle as far as their fat % goes and I get to enjoy the foods I want so I have no advice to give you but wish you luck. Oh, and if you figure it out, let me know. :D 

kelsren --- 16 years ago -

twingirl- I am doing an hour on the eliptical. The weight loss program for 30 min, then I do a manual program (incline of 10 resistance of 6). I have walked the treadmill at 4.5 mph on an incline and without for several weeks (no results), I have ran at a 5.5 mph pace for 3 miles 5-6 days a week on the treadmill for 3 weeks (no results) I have tried cycling, nothing....so now I am on the eliptical. I must confess I feel I get the best workout on the eliptical. So with that said, getting pretty discouraged... :( 

kelsren --- 16 years ago -

I have participated in body pump, combat and zumba as well...not consistently but do try to get to a class here and there for the variety. 

Big Ben --- 16 years ago -

If you are building muscles, depending on where, I can see your clothes maybe being tighter. When I do leg workouts such as squats and leg press, my thigh, or quadracep area tends to get larger and my pants may fit tighter in the thigh area, but not the waist. When I do chest workouts or shoulders, my shirts do fit tighter in in the upper body, but not as bad in the gut area. So in answer to your question, yes you can gain weight. Now what you said is right, 5 lbs is 5 lbs. Its just that 5lbs of muscle takes up "less space" then 5 lbs of fat. You may be building more muscle then you realize.

Question, are your clothes tighter in certain areas that wasn't tight before, but more loose in others that used to be tight? 

kelsren --- 16 years ago -

I don't work out my legs at all...only my biceps, triceps and abs. I am gaining weight around my hips and abd and chest. Big Ben if I was training for a show or contest and wanting to "bulk up" I would def expect a change in my body type, but really just doing cardio now with light weights to burn fat. I have great natural muscle beneath the fat, just trying to get the fat off. I am not that much overweight, goal is to lose 30 pounds...after this weeks 5 pound weight gain, according to BMI I am 10 pounds overweight. 

Jpgirl --- 16 years ago -

How old are you? If you're approaching or are in perimenopause and/ or menopause then all logic is thrown out the window- seriously!
As far as your HR zones- do not I repeat do not use age adjusted formulas- its archaic and inaccurate. There are protocols for doing submit tests and you could even spend the $$$$ on a VO2 max if you're really serious. Case in point I'm 52 so on adjusted my 100% would be 168 but my submit 100% is estimated to be 200 and my 80% is 160. When I'm training I regularly work at 165-175. Your max HR contrary to popular belief does not go down because you have a birthday! What gym do you go to! A qualified trainer or group ex instructor should be able to do a submit on you! If they say use age adjusted RUN away 

quiettype --- 16 years ago -

Jpgirl this is good to know. I'm the same age as you and yes had the same problem with weight after menopause started then I kicked up my cardio and made sure I was in my old range (not the one the trainer gave me) and the weight came off. Unfortunately it seems to reappear periodically and I have to do something different to keep up with the changes in my metabolism. 

Jpgirl --- 16 years ago -

Also it's a myth that there's a "fat burning zone" yes the body utilizes two processes to provide fuel to the muscles but it's more complex than saying fat burning vs carb burning because our muscles can not use a fat cell or a carb cell- it uses ATP as a fuel but how the body makes ATP is where the confusion that mixes up many inexperienced trainers and group fitness peeps. Research Sally Edwards- another good resource is ACE- American Council on Exercise.
Lastly you're doing a big disservice to your body by just doing biceps and triceps. Women have a difficult time bulking. I myself can do 360lbs on the leg press and 160 lbs on leg extensions and am no where close to bulked. General rule of thumb for basic strength is 1 exercise per muscle group12-16 reps per exercise at 75%(I think can't think off the top of my head) of your one rep max. Muscle groups are quads/hamstrings, gluts, upper and lower back, abs, shoulders, chest, biceps and triceps. Muscle building=higher metabolism which is exactly what you want for weight loss especially as you age!
Good luck- it is hard! 

kelsren --- 16 years ago -

Im 36. Uterus and ovaries still intact. I have heard hysterectomys can cause weight gain as well due to the disruption in hormone. I work out at the Y. I really wish I could find a mentor. I don't want to pay a trainer, they are so expensive and the ones at the Y are too busy trying to look cute. I only do my triceps and biceps cause I dont know what machines or free weights I need to use to achieve the look I want to obtain. If anyone out there would be willing to meet with me and write me out a cardio/weight lifting plan to obtain my desired results I would be willing to pay you. I am very serious about wanting to lose this weight. 

Jpgirl --- 16 years ago -

At 36 you might be starting perimenopause- I started at 37! Not sure about Y policies but the Y I worked at allowed us trainers to hire out at single sessions. There was a trainer at your Y named Laura Bush- see if shes still there and hire her to set you up on a general strength training program using the machines. Such a routine should take no more than 30 minutes 3x a week. I'd offer my services but the Y and all other clubs do not allow outside trainers- too many liability issues. Good luck- I feel for you and you are right to try and get a handle on the weight thing now- it just gets worse as time goes on! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground