Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

* Why did so many Republicans vote against a bill for 9/11 Rescue workers?

who's talking here?

randyjet 1
lizandmike 2
SoupIsGoodFood 3
justforfun 2
~sassy~ 2
rEVOLution 5
Nightstorm 2
POTUS 1
voice of reason 2
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
james osterberg 5
r2d2 1
Grumpy 1
A Simple Equation 2
johnregalman517 1
Pops 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I found it interesting that Ron Paul and Ted Poe both voted NAY on this bill. This tells me that there is obviously something else that has been added to the bill that would cause Republicans to vote against it. I have not read the entire bill yet so if anyone else knows why so many Republicans voted against please do tell.

MANY people if not all of the people who were there that day and the days after volunteering, risking their lives for their country, their neighbors, their friends, are the true heroes and deserve the medical attention they need. Many of them are now dying or have already passed.






House Republicans late Thursday were able to corral enough votes to defeat a bill that would have provided up to $7.4 billion in aid to those sickened by toxins resulting from the 9/11 attacks. In the process, they set off a host of fiery speeches and denunciations from their Democratic colleagues and produced a veritable YouTube moment from Rep. Anthony Weiner (D-N.Y), whose district includes many of the affected. At the heart of the debate was a procedural maneuver made by Democrats to suspend the rules before consideration of the James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act. The move allowed leadership to block potential GOP amendments to the measure (there was worry that Republicans would attach something overtly partisan in hopes that it could pass on the otherwise widely-popular measure). It also meant that the party needed a two-thirds majority vote.




This is the bill that he is so passionate about.

H.R.847 - James Zadroga 9/11 Health and Compensation Act of 2010

Here are some interesting comments posted on OpenCongress concerning this Bill.

#

This bill needs to be passed! My husband was there on 9/11 and suffered no ill effects until 2 years ago. He has had 3 operations and is now on all kinds of respiratory medications. It is a battle to get the medications covered and going to the doctors has become a full time job. He is waiting for the other shoe to drop. This is only the beginning, he can't even go anywhere without a WTC coughing fit. His quality of life has diminished rapidly and he is not the only one. He will ultimately be another casualtly of 9/11 and be degraded along the way. Please support this bill for all the workers who survived that horrific day only to suffer in the subsequent years.
Thank you from a wife who is watching her former hulk of a husband wither before her eyes.
#


Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
redmond 04/26/2009 11:13pm

While I agree there are likey many who deserve some assistance for their time working on the recovery, I am immensely distrubed that the poster child for this bill continues to be a person that I believe is using 9/11 for his own gain. Mr. Arrigo was overweight with significant health issue for more than 15 years. He traveled daily with a huge bag of nebulizers and other various drugs. Yes his health issues have worsened, but if you smoked at least a pack or two a day and also enjoyed the other type of smoking routinely how the heck can you say it is from 40+ hours at the pit? By the way if you read all his accounts, he was there 40hrs, 100 hrs, 2 months, 6 months...keeps seeming to change. Lets hear about folks who were healthy first then came down with issues and get the frauds out of this!!!!
#


Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
jkkdbm 04/28/2009 1:48pm

It is up to the powers that be to put into effect the proof you need to produce to prove that you were indeed involved in 9/11. You should also need to provide consistent medical documentation that shows the deterioration of your health. For those who are not fraudulent, this documentation should not be an issue. There are many, many people who are in dire need of the passage of this bill. I would not wish the consequences of 9/11 on anyone. Healthy men and women who were non-smokers are now chemically dependent on respiratory medications to make it through the day. Please do not have your judgement clouded by others. You want to hear about folks who were healthy first? That's my FDNY husband, and at least 20 other FDNY rescue workers that I know, in addition to the multitude that I don't personally know, who have MAJOR problems. They have developed ailments within the past few years.
#

Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
smitty 02/11/2009 2:54pm


I'm a 40 year old retired cop from the First Pct. in lower manhattan. I was there the morning of 9/11 and worked over 2,100 hours in the pit the months that followed. My breathing ailments are too long to get into and I understand I will be heavily medicated for whatever time I have left. I'm writing this and urging passage of this bill for my kids sake. (Ages 8 & 6)What's done is done but at least give me the peace of mind of knowing they will be taken care of. Ret. PO Dave Smith
#

Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
smbfec 05/05/2009 1:38pm

I am one of the forgotten rescue workers who spent weeks and months in the "pit". I do not seek glory or a pat on the back for what I did. I live with the choices I made. I wouldn't change a thing except I hate to see my family watch me deteriorate. I can't do things I used to, I have no energy, I can't breathe, I can't sleep. I am waiting for the inevitable and it sucks. I never smoked and now I am on all kinds of respiratory meds and a machine at night. Please pass this bill, I am not the only one in this position. Passage will help the people and families of those who dedicated their time and for some, their lives, to help others in need. God Bless America!
#

Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
Drmini 07/13/2009 7:30pm


I am one of the very forgotten ones. I was a pure volunteer on 9/11, was one of the first on the scene to help rescue Will and John, have pics to prove it. But after going in circles with the powers to be about my health and what seemed to be a correlation between Mt.Sinai losing our info and my health care getting cancelled I wonder if I would do it again. It would be nice to know that it all wasn't for nothing. How quickly we were forgotten and treated like second class citizens. I never smoked and was in tremendously fit condition before my time at the WTC. Now I am plagued with respiratory and other health issues. All I hear is we're studying it and we'll let you know what if any help is available to you.So it's about time those of us who volunteered, weren't paid are remembered and at least given the dignity of good health care. We don't have union benefits to fall back on. It was bad for all of us that were there, we were there when you needed us now be there when we need you.
#

Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
rescueman 06/25/2009 1:19pm

I am a retired fireman who spent countless hours in "the pit". There are no pictures of me down at the site because i was deep in bowels of what was left of these buildings.
i used to run marthons now i can't walk up a flight of stairs with wheezing.i take eight medications and need a machne to sleep. i know there are men woman and children that are in worse shape than me, so i don't complain. i just want to urge our elected officials to to pass this bill.
Thank you and god bless
#

Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
CBCMan 08/27/2009 11:35pm


Tragic yes, but does it need a bill? I do not agree. Spend some time in the military and then try to get proper health care! Have a VA doctor tell you that they will not give you the treatment because they do not feel it is giving you enough relief. I do feel for the WTC survivors, but I do not think that a bill should do what the state is not willing to do.


Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
wreckehead 09/04/2009 5:42am


Since when is it that the military are better than ground zero workers.
Since my work at ground zero i almost died from mold infection in march 2002. I was in respiratory failure. I now have PTSD, Fibromyalgia, Thyroid cancer, chronic headaches, Acid reflux, Chronic fatigue, Sinusitis, Asthma,and concrete nodules in my lung. Wde share the same burdens. Many men are no longer able to work to support our familys.We cannot afford health insurance. I hope that as americans we are all united together. thank you and god bless.


Filtered Comment [show]
How helpful was this comment for you? Use the slider bar to rate it 1-10, with 10 being very helpful and 1 being least helpful.
jamesirc 10/11/2009 1:02pm

God bless Firefighter John Mcnamara E234 who passed in aug 09. Richie Mannetta E276 and PO's Diaz and Grossman from the 28 pct. All died this week of 9/11 related disease. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

This was the quickest and best explanation of why they may have voted no.


quick scan of overview of bill reveals:
Submitted by cee cee on Fri, 07/30/2010 - 21:34.

1. quality assurance program
2. 2 steering committees
3. uniform data collection/collation system
4. education & outreach (always love that one)
5. registry creations via grants to city and other agencies
6. conduct of "research"

1-6 cost a lot of money, increase government, and benefit NO ill person

how much of that nearly 8 billion (which would never be enough....you KNOW how these budgets go)

would actually go the medical care for responders and others chemically injured?

disclaimer: have NO IDEA what other garbage was buried in that bill....did not bother to try to determine 1-6 told me all I really want to know 

Grumpy --- 16 years ago -

NO funding through other reductions, just keep the $100 bill presses running some more. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

Because the CRIMINAL GOVERNMENT doesn't give a RAT'S A$$ about "We the People". Will the sheeple ever begin to understand? 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

I found this but I'm sure there are more reasons that haven't been released.


You don't bother to address the REASON Republicans voted against it. Not because of objection to assisting legitimate victims but because of:

Wanting better protection against fraudsters that routinely flock to entitlement programs.

Perpetual benefits vs annual review and appropriations, which is how veteran's benefits are handled.

Refusal to incorporate an amendment that excludes illegal immigrants. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

there was no other stuff in the bill. that is why the pubs were a no. the bill was a straight up yea or nay,without the possibility of any amendments. Thus,the party of no complained about "the process" because they wanted a chance to tie some immigration or healthcare changes to it.
Douchebag Peter King was for the bill,he says,but led a coalition to keep enough gop members from voting for this straight up bill. He put his party before his concerns for the responders. He wasn't happy with "the process" Same old sh1t from the party of obstruction. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

It was a game the dems played and they lost. They made it so it took two thirds to pass the bill hoping to make Conservatives look bad. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Actually these are just six "other" items that were found in the bill.


1. quality assurance program
2. 2 steering committees
3. uniform data collection/collation system
4. education & outreach (always love that one)
5. registry creations via grants to city and other agencies
6. conduct of "research"

Then there's this..

To amend the Public Health Service Act to extend and improve protections and services to individuals directly impacted by the terrorist attack in New York City on September 11, 2001, and for other purposes. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

hoping to make Conservatives look bad.

Pubs need no help in that area. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

It was a game the dems played and they lost. They made it so it took two thirds to pass the bill hoping to make Conservatives look bad.


Sadly the real losers here are the ones who are dying for volunteering to save peoples lives. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

This movie documents the suffering and dismissal of the first responders by our government... Filmed in veritas style with news footage and actual testimonials from first responders. Great documentary for all to see.

 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

I thought Obama Care would cover all this, making a separate bill to cover a certain segment of the population unnecessary. I mean, isn't that what Obama Care is supposed to do? Make healthcare accessable to everyone? 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

damn good question rev.
same reason they don't want to take care of our vets. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

I thought Obama Care would cover all this, making a separate bill to cover a certain segment of the population unnecessary. I mean, isn't that what Obama Care is supposed to do? Make healthcare accessable to everyone?


you are missing the big picture and part of this equation. they are like vets and should be taken care of by our government for their work in this case. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I'm all for smaller government but yes I agree with Voice of reason on this one. From day one there should have been a foundation setup by the government to help these people. The Government Absolutely knew that there would be many people sick and dying from their efforts or simply from just being in the area.

They knew about the buildings being full of asbestos decades ago. Actually before 9/11 the city of New York was working on forcing the WTC complex to remove all of it's asbestos, costing millions of dollars to the owners.

Then combine that with all of the other crap they were breathing and it's obvious to see that yet again, our government has proven that they do NOT CARE about our well being. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

I thought Obama Care would cover all this,

You will be welcomed back when you actually know something about this.

You must be this tall to ride this attraction

This ride requires a E ticket 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

hey are like vets and should be taken care of by our government for their work in this case

So they want to get more crappy care from overcrowded hospitals and get the run around every time they need something? (And yes, I know from experience. I'm a vet and my dh is still in the service).

Please don't misinterpret my comments. I have great admiration for the men and women who worked selflessly to help others. My frustration is with the lawmakers of this country. Every move they make is politically motivated, especially as we move closer to the midterm elections. Obama care was touted by many as the solution to all the ills of the healcare industry. If it is all that Pelosi and Reed promised it was, why is additional legislation needed? 

POTUS --- 16 years ago -

They didn't vote for it because it's basically a tax increase, and would only make Obama look good while he stomped on the graves of 9/11 victims, claiming it was all in their name.

Just more sick games on both sides, really. 

Pops --- 16 years ago -

Jon Stewart's take on it:

The Daily Show With Jon Stewart Mon - Thurs 11p / 10c I Give Up - 9/11 Responders Bill www.thedailyshow.com Daily Show Full Episodes Political Humor Tea Party 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

and would only make Obama look good while he stomped on the graves of 9/11 victims,

I'm sure you know this bill was worked on for the last 5 years,leader of the initiative is Peter King (R) NY. Oh, I guess not,but why let facts get in the way of your doofus view.
Much easier to blame Obama than to actually research anything that might make you credible. 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

by Mike Hall, Sep 18, 2007

Share



The Bush administration has been dragging its feet on monitoring and treating the health problems of the more than 40,000 World Trade Center first responders and recovery workers who worked on the massive and toxic rubble pile following the Sept. 11 attacks of Ground Zero, says Rep. Frank Pallone (D-N.J.).

For too long, the health concerns of first responders have been ignored here in Washington. Unfortunately, for the past six years, the administration has been dragging its feet. This is the first year the Bush administration has asked for money for health care.

Pallone’s remarks came as the House Energy and Commerce Committee’s Health Subcommittee examined the lingering health effects of Sept. 11 and the need for a larger federal role in tracking and treating World Trade Center-related illnesses.

The hearing came the day after a bipartisan group of House lawmakers introduced legislation to ensure that everyone exposed to the toxins at Ground Zero has a right to be medically monitored and anyone who is sick, as a result, has a right to treatment. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

Silly games by the Dems. The two-thirds vote trick wasn't even needed. They could have passed this with a simple majority.

Now who's looking stoopid?

What a joke! They (Dems) couldn't even pull off this simple charade. 

Nightstorm --- 16 years ago -

James, you made me laugh in your response to lizandmike.

Leave it to Stewart to tell it like it is and to make me laugh. Again. Cry, too.

Leave it to Kevin Brady (R-TX) to make a fool of himself. Again. Who voted for *that* doofus? 

Nightstorm --- 16 years ago -

Now who's looking stoopid?



Everyone. 

r2d2 --- 16 years ago -

The DemoNazis staged....they rigged it so that they needed 291 instead of 218 so that they could feign outrage at the “insensitivity” of Republicans....not to mention they added perks for illegals and disallowed amendments. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

Weiner should get an academy award. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

The two-thirds vote trick wasn't even needed. They could have passed this with a simple majority.

It was to prevent your hated pork barrel amendments being tacked onto the bill since it would have passed easily and those projects would go with it. The GOP could not and would not vote for a clean bill is the point.
They like their perks better than doing the right thing. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

It was to prevent your hated pork barrel amendments being tacked onto the bill since it would have passed easily

Yeah, because we know the Dems never attach pork barrel amendments.......

Weak argument. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I don't know about the bill but if it involves monetary compensation, and I don't know that it does, but if it does, if we're gonna do that, why wouldn't we do the same for our soldiers?

As for Medical care, I'm willing to bet most had their own insurance. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

I want to think we'd be bi-partisan on this subject-what ever the reasons for voting it down, these people need to be taken care of, period. 

johnregalman517 --- 16 years ago -

I want to think we'd be bi-partisan on this subject-what ever the reasons for voting it down, these people need to be taken care of, period.

Why? 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

t-what ever the reasons for voting it down, these people need to be taken care of, period.


For those who lack medical care, I agree. I would disagree with monetary compensation. Unless it comes from the private sector. ;) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

health
politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground