Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Diaper Genie vs Diaper Genie II vs Diaper Champ vs the trash can lol

who's talking here?

Melanie 1
GCan 1
la guerita 2
HIAAK 8
Valentine 1
My 3 and Me 1
kuca 2
ShookUpRamen 1
Mabbers 2
Tylers Journey 1
chunksNbones 1
reh6110 2
Diamom 2
Squareduck 3
AshleyTHEPrincess$ 1
N&L'sMommy! 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

HIAAK --- 16 years ago -

Which one do you prefer? I have the Diaper Genie from when my 4 year old was a baby. What do you prefer? 

reh6110 --- 16 years ago -

I don't have kids, but as a much older sister (14 years) and babysitter, I always prefered there to be somewhere in the area I was changing diapers to put it and not have to run out to the trash can each time, especially when they were little. 

reh6110 --- 16 years ago -

I don't have kids, but as a much older sister (14 years) and babysitter, I always prefered there to be somewhere in the area I was changing diapers to put it and not have to run out to the trash can each time, especially when they were little. 

Squareduck --- 16 years ago -

With my 11 year old I had a Diaper Genie. Loved it. Now with my 11 month old I have a Diaper Genie 11. It's bigger and I still love it. They also sell the refills in a three pack at Babies R Us.

I also highly suggest if you register etc. and want to do it at BRU do it at the one on 1960 near Willowbrook Mall. It's bigger and has lots more to offer. The one in Humble sucks!

Good Luck! :) 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

We had the diaper champ and I liked it because we could use regular trash bags. To me it held WAY more than the diaper genie. I have not seen the genie II.

I will say as they got older and the diapers got bigger, we tended to use a plastic grocery sack or used ziploc and threw them in the kitchen trash. We empty our trash daily so there was never an smell issue. 

HIAAK --- 16 years ago -

So is the difference with the DG and DGII just the size?

I am registering at BRU so thanks for the tip :) 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Ya know Hiakk, I had the genies, etc. and my very best disposal method (and consequently, the most affordable) was to put each diaper as I changed it in a plastic grocery bag, tie it up, throw it in a lid-covered trash can and taking out the trash daily. LOL. Nothing to buy. No special refill bags and it forced me to take care of it asap. Every day. 

HIAAK --- 16 years ago -

Mabbers that's pretty much how we ended up by the time my daughter was 6 months old. Just trying to decide before this little one gets here if it's worth the effort. Our trash is taken out either every day or every other day. When she got bigger and the smells were worse we just took it to the outside trash lol. I guess more or less it depends (other than the Diaper champ using trash bags) it's do you want to add the expense of the refills.... 

Squareduck --- 16 years ago -

So is the difference with the DG and DGII just the size?

I am registering at BRU so thanks for the tip :)


I believe it's the size of the container. But the refills (the thing that holds the bag) is smaller than the original one. Which sucks. I always forget to buy refills. So I end up using grocery bags and just throw them in the trash. Right now the diaper genie is sitting empty because yet again I forgot to buy refills. It's just something I don't think about. All in all I love it but just find it hard to remember the stinkn refills! hahaha :) 

N&L'sMommy! --- 16 years ago -

I have a Diaper Genie with one new refill inside and an extra one for sale, 15$! Used it for maybe 2 months with my first child and never used it with my second who is now 5 months. I thought the poo still was stinky even being in the DG II. So, I just used the trash can! 

HIAAK --- 16 years ago -

It's just something I don't think about. All in all I love it but just find it hard to remember the stinkn refills! hahaha :)
page 1
lol thanks for the honesty :) That's honestly why we ended up using the trash can with my 4 year old because I would forget to add that to the list and get them in time lol. I guess if I get anything it will be a diaper champ so I can use regular bags but I may just use the trash can again lol... 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Well, and if you go the regular trash can route, there's oh so much more to choose from, decoratively speaking. But yeah, as soon as a poopy came (after they actually started stinking) they immediately went outside. Might as well drive the neighborhood dogs mad than us. :P 

My 3 and Me --- 16 years ago -

I had both. I like the Diaper Chanp so much more! You can use a regular trash bag which was nice! 

HIAAK --- 16 years ago -

Mommy of Two I thought the same thing about our DG. Maybe I'll just sell mine too and use that money for something else more useful lol. 

Tylers Journey --- 16 years ago -

I had the Safety 1st Easy Saver Diaper Pail with 2 babies and I have never had funk come out of it. 

Squareduck --- 16 years ago -

I thought the poo still was stinky even being in the DG II

I don't smell it in mine. And my DS goes 4 times a day! Bleh.... :P
I smell it in the bag for sure! :)

Now if I could remember to buy the dang refills I'd be good! :) 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

Trash bag. With first kid we had the genie and DH would foget to empty it all the time. I just found it was one more gadget taking up space when garbage worked just as well. 

N&L'sMommy! --- 16 years ago -

I know I couldnt put my 2yr olds poo in there without stinkin the whole room out. Maybe its just my mommy nose, i can smell the crap from another room. I can still get away with my 5mth old, his doesnt stink yet :) 

AshleyTHEPrincess$ --- 16 years ago -

Ya know Hiakk, I had the genies, etc. and my very best disposal method (and consequently, the most affordable) was to put each diaper as I changed it in a plastic grocery bag, tie it up, throw it in a lid-covered trash can and taking out the trash daily. LOL. Nothing to buy. No special refill bags and it forced me to take care of it asap. Every day.



I completely agree! I just put it in the trash, when I forgot to empty out the genie the smell was AWFUL omg ! I would rather put a poopy diaper in the trash in the kitchen and then be forced to take it out cause of the smell blech!



Dont waste your money :) 

ShookUpRamen --- 16 years ago -

Diaper Champ >>>>> Diaper Genie. Take it from the parents of 4.

However, the garbage can with regular dumping is also okay. 

Valentine --- 16 years ago -

grocery sacks here!

with my twins and my singleton- i just kept a container of grocery sacks hanging behind the nursery door and i'd throw them in a bag and tie it shut. as they got older and needed less frequent changes i would just run the diapers to the garage and do my best to make a shot in the big trash can- luckily there were never any explosions. lol. 

la guerita --- 16 years ago -

grocery sacks here!

same here 

kuca --- 16 years ago -

Congrats HIAAK! I have the The First Years Clean Air Diaper Disposal System....it takes regular garbage bags and has a battery run filter. It's been great but I do not see it on BBRU.com anymore? I am exclusively Breastfeeding(nearly at our 10 mos. mark and counting...whoo-hoo)so poopy diapers are very infrequent! At about 3 mos. the poopies start coming only once a week or so! Another bonus of exclusively breastfeeding! 

HIAAK --- 16 years ago -

Thanks kuca :) How are you and baby doing? Wow 10 months already. I bet he is getting so big now :) I have not seen/heard of this system before? I'm just starting to look at all of these (only 14 weeks to go whoohoo) and trying to get everything lined up and research done while I still have the opportunity lol. 

Diamom --- 16 years ago -

MY BF exclusively babies pooped everyday ??? Once a week? 

HIAAK --- 16 years ago -

Diamom I just thought about that one too lol. My youngest daughter pooped once a day and I exclusively breastfed her. 

Melanie --- 16 years ago -

I like the Diaper Chanp so much more! You can use a regular trash bag which was nice!

Ditto. 

la guerita --- 16 years ago -

Diamom I just thought about that one too lol. My youngest daughter pooped once a day and I exclusively breastfed her.

Although every baby is different, to my understanding, generally breastfed babies poop more frequently. 

chunksNbones --- 16 years ago -

Dg 2! No smell and i have a 14mth old and an 8wk old...we only use it for poop diapers though...i think the wet pee makes it worse. Blech. We use a refill about every month 

kuca --- 16 years ago -

mother-2-mother
"At around the age of six weeks, the stooling pattern of a breastfed baby may change. It is not uncommon for the breastfed baby to skip days between bowel movements. Some babies skip every other day, some go every two or three days, some once every 5 - 7 days, and some babies hold out for up to 11 or 12 days at a time - then have quite a FULL diaper when they DO go!" 

HIAAK --- 16 years ago -

dang how did you get so lucky ~K~? I'm telling you mine was a once a dayer lol. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground