Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Six Facts No War Supporters Know

who's talking here?

smartypants 4
randyjet 2
steinhoister 1
AuthorMan 1
SoupIsGoodFood 1
rEVOLution 2
oneyedman 3
bhsurf4 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
james osterberg 1
alreadygone~~ 1
MeriZephyr 1
Zombie Slayer! 1
A Simple Equation 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

By: David Swanson Saturday July 24, 2010 6:01 am
Tweet Share19



This coming week, the House of Representatives is expected to vote on $33 billion for war. A majority of Americans opposes this, but a sizable minority of Americans supports it. No one who supports it can be aware of any of the following six facts.

1. For many months, probably years, at least the second largest and probably the largest source of revenue for the Taliban has been U.S. taxpayers. We are giving the Taliban our money instead of investing it in useful things at home or abroad. "WARLORD, INC.: Extortion and Corruption Along the U.S. Supply Chain in Afghanistan," is a report from the Majority Staff of the Subcommittee on National Security and Foreign Affairs in the U.S. House of Representatives. The report documents payoffs to the Taliban for safe passage of U.S. goods, payoffs very likely greater than the Taliban’s profits from opium, its other big money maker. And this is neither new nor unknown to top U.S. officials. But it must be unknown to Americans supporting the war. You can’t support a war where you’re funding both sides unless you want both sides to lose. We lock people away for giving a pair of socks to the enemy, while our own government serves as chief financial sponsor.

2. Our top consumer of oil is the U.S. military. We don’t just fight wars in areas of the globe that are coincidentally rich in oil, but fighting those wars is the single biggest way in which we burn oil. We pollute the air in the process of poisoning the earth with all variety of weaponry. According to the 2007 CIA World Fact Book, when oil consumption is broken down per capita, the U.S. military ranks fourth in the world, behind just three actual nations. There’s no way to care about the environment while allowing the money that could create renewable energy to be spent instead on an operation whose destructiveness is rivaled only by BP. We could have 20 green energy jobs at $50 K each for what it costs to send one soldier to Afghanistan. We’re fighting wars for the fuel to fight wars, even though the process is eating up the funds we could use to try to survive its side-effects.

3. Over half of every U.S. tax dollar is spent on wars, the military, and payments on debt for past wars and military spending. Here’s a pie chart that breaks it down for you. If you’re concerned about government spending, you can’t just be concerned with the minority of it that is carefully funded with taxes and off-setting cuts elsewhere. You have to also consider the single biggest item, the one that takes up a majority of the budget, large chunks of which are routinely funded off the books, borrowed from China, and passed with so-called "emergency supplemental" bills of the sort now before the House of Representatives, the sole purpose of which is to keep the money outside the budget. Numerous economic studies have shown that investing in the military, even at home, does less for the economy than tax cuts, which do less for the economy than investing in education, energy, infrastructure, and other areas. Its wars or jobs, we can’t have both. The labor movement has mostly (with some good exceptions) been silent on war spending, in part because jobs spending has been packaged into the same bill. Now it’s not. Now the House is confronted with a bill that spends on war the money that is needed for jobs, for housing, for schools, for green energy, for retirement. Will advocates of these raise their voices this week?

4. A leading, and probably the leading, cause of death in the U.S. military is suicide. U.S. troops are killing themselves in record numbers. One central reason for this is likely that these troops have no idea what it is they are risking their lives, and taking others’ lives, for. Can we expect them to know, when top officials in Washington don’t? When the President’s special representative to Afghanistan testified in the Senate recently, senators from both parties asked him repeatedly what the goal was, what success would look like, for what purpose the war went on. Richard Holbrooke had no answers. Senator Bob Corker (R-Tenn.) told the Los Angeles Times: "A lot of folks on both sides of the aisle think this effort is adrift. A lot of folks you’d consider the strongest hawks in the country are scratching their heads in concern." Corker complained that after listening for 90 minutes to Holbrooke he had "no earthly idea what our objectives are on the civilian front. So far, this has been an incredible waste of time."

5. The $33 billion about to be voted on cannot possibly be needed to continue the war in Afghanistan, because it is exclusively to be used for escalating that war. The President was publicly pressured by his generals several months ago to begin an escalation, but Congress has yet to fund it. To the extent that it has been begun unfunded, it can be undone. CNN reports: "Defense Secretary Robert Gates warned senators in June that military operations will need to be reduced for the rest of the year unless Congress approves additional funding for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan." This is nonsense. If this escalation funding were blocked, the war would remain at the level it was at before. And that’s if the Pentagon respects the authority of the Congress. The other alternative, openly indicated by Gates, is that the Pentagon will fund the escalation out of its standard budget. Congressman Alan Grayson has a bill called "The War Is Making You Poor Act" which would require that wars be funded out of the military budget, which would eliminate federal taxes on the first $35,000 anyone earned and reduce the national debt. How horrible would that be?

6. War would be the greatest evil on earth even if it were free. Watch this new video of a man whose father was shot and killed while sleeping in bed. More of our tax dollars at work. How many of these stories of what our military does can we write off? Our drones kill both civilians and "insurgents," as do our night raids and check points. Or, maybe not the check points. General Stanley McChrystal said that of the amazing number of people we’ve killed at check points, none of them have been any threat. And the damage lasts in the places we destroy. Look at this new report on the damage done to the children of Fallujah. This is not because U.S. soldiers aren’t brave or their parents didn’t raise them well. It’s because these wars don’t involve pairs of armies on battlefields. We’re occupying countries where the enemies look like everyone except us.

Well, maybe our representatives know all of this and still fund wars because people who fund them tell them to. But what can we do about it? We vote whenever there’s an election, or at least some of us do. Isn’t that our role? What does this have to do with elections? It should have everything to do with them. When we call our congress members this week we should not just ask them to vote No on war money, we should demand it, and we should let them know that we will work to unelect them, even replacing them with someone worse (since you can’t get much worse), if they vote for this money. And we should spend August rewarding and punishing accordingly. Here are 88 candidates for Congress this year who have committed to not voting a dime for these wars. They are from every party and political inclination. They should be supported.

If this war funding can be blocked for another week it will be blocked until mid-September and perhaps for good. If we can get closer to doing that than we have before, we will have something to build on. Just holding a straightforward vote in which war opponents vote No and war supporters vote Yes, no matter how close or far we are from winning, will identify who needs to keep their job and who doesn’t. If most of the Yes votes are Republican, we will be able to confront the President with the opposition of his own party. We’re moving toward peace.

Get resources from http://defundwar.org
FCNL has a toll-free number to call your representative: 1-888-493-5443. Use it. 

SoupIsGoodFood --- 16 years ago -

What is your solution, smarty? 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

I will be calling my Congressmen to vote no to more funding.

Continue bringing the troops home from Iraq. I don't have an answer for Afghanistan, but I think we blew it already. 

steinhoister --- 16 years ago -

I don't have an answer for Afghanistan, but I think we blew it already.


Agreed, our troops could be back home with their families and taking on the border patrol issue, since a lot of people consider that to be an invasion, clearly the biggest threat to our security is the southern border... 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

David Swanson

Uber leftist nutjob.
Thought he could single handedly impeach Bush. 

smartypants --- 16 years ago -

Which points in the article do you think Swanson is incorrect about? 

james osterberg --- 16 years ago -

answer for Afghanistan,

Get the F*CK out. Now 

MeriZephyr --- 16 years ago -

A realliy insightful book to be read is the autobiography "It Doesn't Take A Hero" by a 4 star general named General H. Norman Schwarzkope...he takes you thru his experience from attending West point in the 50's all the way through the Gulf War(Dessert Storm)...it is an insiders view,very insightful,very awesome management techs....a must read for anyone who would like to read the diary of an excellent General,his rise to Commander In Chief working under Secretary Cheney and Collin Powell during Dessert sheild/Dessert Storm....
(it is very insightful because of all the details and CONFUSIONS/POWER plays in Washington.
That being said, he was a great General,and at least you can see the necessity of Dessert Storm and the problems with Iraq,even then.While I can see the need for the Gulf War, I see no advantage of the current war we are in currently....Good read, I advise it to those who would like a military insight and political view. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

War. What is it good for? Absolutely nothing! Say it again!

 

alreadygone~~ --- 16 years ago -

Wo a Wo a baby~``~~`` 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

Thi$ i$ all WAR ha$ EVER been about:

IRAQ FOR $ALE



War is a Racket by Major General Smedley Darling Ton Butler  

bhsurf4 --- 16 years ago -

Sad fact is that we will probably be at war with Iran before we ever get a chance to bring anyone home! 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

Past time we cut our losses and got out of Afghanistan.

Don't even get me started on Iraq 

Zombie Slayer! --- 16 years ago -

interesting thread smarty. 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

love that song!!! I think everyone knows by now Iraq was a stupid mistake-I can see why we went in to Afghanistan, but it time to get out-As for Iran, that's one country that's asking for it- 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

As for Iran, that's one country that's asking for it- 

Please expand on that thought because it is this same media-manipulated mentality that provided public support to invade Iraq in the first place...

How soon we forget. =( 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

The saddest fact is that we live in a free country where we the people are supposed to be electing representatives who represent us, our wishes, and our beliefs. The sad thing is that being a free country where we elect our leaders, their actions represent us all even if what they are doing is not our will. It's up to us to stop it, they will not do it out of the kindness of their own hearts. Until Americans get fed up enough, it will never end.

Take away american idol and sunday night football and then you'll see an uprising. Thousands murdered over seas with our own money, who care's? At least that seems to be how people feel. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

Right now I can see no rational reason to get out of Afghanistan. All the doom and gloom is media hype from what I can see. I would say that the offensive should be given a chance to work. The problem is that Bush screwed it up so badly, it will take awhile to put the Taliban back in its box.

I can guarantee what will happen if we leave is that the Taliban will come back, the place will become a dictatorship with no human rights at all. Even worse, Al Qeada will have its old base back in operation. I really don't want another 9/11 if you don't mind.

It is better to keep them fighting for THEIR lives there, than us trying to duck the bombs that they will be sending our way. Your choice, fight them there or here! 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

It is better to keep them fighting for THEIR lives there

For how long? is 50 years enough? 100??

How long will we waste our blood and treasure in the a$$ of the planet....

FYI there are FAR more dangerous places on Earth where we should turn our attention.... 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

FYI there are FAR more dangerous places on Earth where we should turn our attention....

Like the drug war on our southern border perhaps...? 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

For how long?

For a couple of years as Obama has laid out. Unfortunately, we have to deal with the fact that Bush went after the oil instead of Al Qeada. I have been impressed by some of the remarks given by the military commanders who seem to have gotten the point of counter insurgency warfare. I am more than willing to give them a chance since so much depends on it.

If it goes on at the same pace at the end of two years, then it will be time to have another look, but to pull the plug NOW is absurd. 

oneyedman --- 16 years ago -

Like the drug war on our southern border perhaps...?

That's 1 place.... There are others as well 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

Right now I can see no rational reason to get out of Afghanistan. All the doom and gloom is media hype from what I can see. I would say that the offensive should be given a chance to work. The problem is that Bush screwed it up so badly, it will take awhile to put the Taliban back in its box.

I can guarantee what will happen if we leave is that the Taliban will come back, the place will become a dictatorship with no human rights at all. Even worse, Al Qeada will have its old base back in operation. I really don't want another 9/11 if you don't mind.

It is better to keep them fighting for THEIR lives there, than us trying to duck the bombs that they will be sending our way. Your choice, fight them there or here!



that all makes perfect sense if you still believe, after all of the proof stating that the taliban nor al queda could have pulled of 911, that they in fact could have done it without our government's assistance. It is far more absurd to believe that they pulled off 911 without help than they did on their own. And if they EVER had a reason to attack America I'd say that 9 years of killing their civilians, stealing their natural resources, and poisoning their environment with all of our trash, pollution, and weaponry that it takes to sustain the longest American invasion in history, that's a reason to attack us. And with our borders wide open do you mean to tell me that they couldn't do it again if they really did it to begin with? Of course not. Because they were never here to do it in the first place. Some patsies were and that's all they were. Heck, most of them have been found still alive and breathing, not dead in plane crashes. But that's another topic.

The day of another "terror" attack is coming, and it will have nothing to do with our freedom, it will have everything to do with our government trying to gain the trust of the sheeple back. And sadly Faux news will assist greatly, as they did in the Iraq invasion, to get the sheeple behind the government once again. I'm willing to be that by the end of October, some sort of false flag "terror" event takes place and more Americans will lose more freedoms. I traveled via air today and actually saw a 20 something year old kid getting his freaking hands swabbed by TSA, do you think I felt safer? He11 no, I felt more in danger because at some point common sense in this nation was replaced by fear and idiocy.

Apathy will be the death of our great nation. 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

Apathy will be the death of our great nation.

Ditto, rEV! The most apathetic are those denying the obvious and declaring, "It can't happen here!" USA! USA! USA!!

Give me a break... They have no idea what they're cheering for. Our nation is being used as the strong arm of the New World Order mafia. Period. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground