Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Channel 2 reports - it's hospital CHARGES that are driving up costs

who's talking here?

randyjet 1
planemom 1
lizandmike 7
AuthorMan 1
Deltadawn 1
Mabbers 1
justforfun 14
~sassy~ 55
oopsy 1
Perfection 26
Betty 1
Cookin' Queen 1
Mommyto3kiddos 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
JusticeForAll 22
bhsurf4 12
voice of reason 7
genxer 1
evolved 6
mommie21g1b 1
TexasOma 1
allday 2
Dr Aborto 1
sweetscreaminmonkey 2
Work in Progress 14
It is I WhyWhyWhy 9
steinhoister2016 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Hhhhm ya think someone is finally listening to me?

I have been telling you all along, it isn't insurance that's the problem but the cost the hospitals and physicians are charging that is the true problem.


Ahhhh, nothing says neener neener neener better than neener neener neener.....



---------------------

Local 2 Investigates Your Hospital Bill
By Amy Davis

POSTED: Wednesday, July 14, 2010
UPDATED: 7:10 am CDT July 15, 2010

HOUSTON -- Are you getting a fair price when you or someone in your family needs medical care? To find out, we're breaking down three bills for the same surgery from three different hospitals. Investigative reporter Amy Davis explains why some say hospital bills are far from fair and reasonable.

WATCH IT: Local 2 Investigates Your Hospital Bill

Your baby's first cry and first yawn -- these are the moments you want to remember. But J.J. Birmingham says what he will never forget is the first bill.

"It seemed extraordinarily high to me," Birmingham told Davis.

Birmingham and his wife both have insurance, but it was the price Conroe Regional Hospital billed the insurance companies for the cesarean section when Carmen was born that made her dad do a double take.

The price was $18,071.54.

"You have to understand what you're paying for," said Marc Chapman, the owner of Hospital Bill Review, a hospital billing analyst company.

To help us understand Birmingham's itemized bill, Chapman reviewed it for us.

"We're kind of like the Kelley Blue Book for health care," explained Chapman. "We can give you the cost of the procedure and we can give you, on average, what everyone else is paying."

Chapman says Conroe Regional's charges for some of the drugs administered at the hospital far exceeded the hospital's cost. The hospital charged Birmingham $77 for a drug called Fentanyl, when Chapman says the drug cost the hospital 32 cents.

Ondansetron was billed at $95.76, when it costs the hospital 21 cents.

Overall, Chapman says Birmingham's bill was 60 percent higher than what most Conroe Regional patients pay for C-sections. In the end, Birmingham's insurance company paid just $5,989.18, just one-third of the original bill.

Birmingham called his congressman, Kevin Brady.

"I'm convinced that original price is the sticker price that no one actually pays," Brady told Davis. "I don't understand how they get to the bottom line cost."

We didn't get it either, so we sent Chapman the bills for C-sections from two other local hospitals.

Memorial Hermann hospital billed $20,827 for the surgery, but then accepted a payment of $6,479.32. St. Luke's charged $13,046. for a C-section, then dropped the bill to $4,898.

We wondered if the true cost of delivering your baby by C-section is anywhere near what the hospitals charged, how can they accept such a small payment in the end? Chapman says it's because the prices are extremely inflated.

"There's not a connection with the cost and the prices," he said.

Federal records show prices at St. Luke's have increased by 317 percent since 1996, while expenses have only increased by 133 percent.

At Conroe Regional Hospital, prices have jumped 367 percent, while expenses went up by just 128 percent.

And at Memorial Hermann, prices have spiked 202 percent in the same time period, while expenses went up by only 154 percent.

While the cost of health care goes up every year, we wanted to know who's monitoring the prices set by hospitals for various surgeries.

Prices are not regulated in the health care industry," said Dr. Vivian Ho, the chair who studies health economics policy at Rice University's Baker Institute.

"It should make consumers angry because here we are in the midst of a recession where most companies are facing declines in profits and it looks as though hospitals have been able to experience an increase in profits over time," Ho said.

Ho and Chapman say the various charges thrown out by hospitals make it nearly impossible for consumers to shop for the lowest price.

"I got one hospital charging $1,100 to $1,200 for an MRI," said Chapman. "I've got another hospital I can show you that charges almost $8,000 to $9,000 for the same MRI."

They say insurance contracts with hospitals help set the prices because most of the contracts require that the hospital take a certain percentage off the overall bill, say 65 percent.

"So, if they raise the total charge, then suddenly that discounted price is not as small as it used to seem," Ho explained.

We asked all three hospitals about the big bills for delivering the babies. While all three were born within six months of each other and required the same three-day stay, the hospitals told us comparing the three bills is not an apples-to-apples comparison.

"I don't really think that is a completely fair response because one could ask hospitals to at least just provide a standard price for an uncomplicated delivery," said Ho. "… so that patients actually have some idea of which hospitals are high-priced and which hospitals are low-priced."

"As long as there's not an openness and the ability for you and I to go online and compare costs and quality, you're going to see this continue to happen unfortunately," Brady told Davis.

You might think that in the 1,000-page health care reform bill, this subject would be addressed, but both Ho and Brady say the bill doesn't cover price transparency with regard to your medical bills at all.

Lastly, some speculate that by charging inflated rates for services, hospitals can claim that they provide more charity care to people without insurance than they actually did.

Both St. Luke's and Memorial Hermann told us they report the true cost of uncompensated care to the government, not the amount they would charge the patient if they were paying.

None of the hospitals agreed to talk with us on camera, but they each sent statements for this story.

Conroe Regional Hospital:

"Conroe Regional Medical Center understands that payment for medical care can be difficult; however, the hospital works diligently with its patients to address any questions they may have about their financial responsibilities.

"Billing or charging for hospital services is different from how payments are received from insurance companies for such services. Hospitals and insurance companies often enter into a contract outlining the payments for hospital services provided to members of the insurance company’s health plan. The payment for hospital services is set in advance with the insurance company. Typically, the hospital is paid a set rate based on the type of case, procedure or hospital unit location (such as the Intensive Care Unit), the number of days for hospitalization, Diagnosis Related Group (DRG) for inpatient services or Ambulatory Payment Classification (APC) for outpatient services. The DRG and APC rates are determined by the geographic location of the hospital and the diagnosis and/or procedure performed.

"Additional charges can also be included in a bill for certain items such as costly medications or implants. Medication costs are determined, in part, by the fees charged by reputable pharmaceutical companies, but also include costs associated with the hospital’s dispensing and administration as required by law to ensure patient safety. It is a combination of all of these factors that contribute to the rising costs for the delivery of health care.

"Conroe Regional Medical Center takes its billing practices very seriously and has processes in place to monitor its charging of services to patients."

Memorial Hermann Hospital:

"Medicare regulations require hospitals to charge every patient the same amount for the individual items or services provided to a patient. These charges vary from one hospital or health care system to another based on many factors, but they are consistent across the Memorial Hermann system with the exception of our teaching hospital and level 1 trauma center, where they are generally higher. In this case, your comparison of C-section patients at three hospitals does not offer an apples to apples view. Mrs. Schulz delivered at Memorial Hermann-Texas Medical Center because she was at high risk due to a chronic illness. She also had an unusual 6.5 hours of continuous epidural anesthesia to control her pain during her labor and C-section.

"Memorial Hermann follows charity care reporting guidelines developed by the Catholic Health Association in 2006 and recently adopted by the IRS. Under these guidelines, charity care is reported at cost, not charges. These standardized accounting methods ensure that quantitative reports of community benefits are credible, accurate and comparable to reports from other organizations."

St. Luke's Hospital:

"Since every patient is unique, many factors contribute to the patient's cost of hospital services, including the patient's length of stay, the patient’s personal medication requirements and the patient's pre-existing health conditions.

"St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital takes great care in ensuring that patient charges are accurate and fair. Patients who require hospital care or medical services and cannot afford such care or services because of limitations in their health insurance or personal finances are provided partial or full financial assistance for medically necessary care in accordance with Texas law and hospital eligibility guidelines. Under Texas' annual charity care reporting standards, St. Luke’s Episcopal Hospital reports as charity care the estimated cost of providing such care, not its standard charges." 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I have been telling you all along, it isn't insurance that's the problem but the cost the hospitals and physicians are charging that is the true problem.


Nah, this won't change their thinking. Just wait til the REAL cost of health care hits. Today's cost will seem like the good ol days.


Thing is, the same people on medicaid, medicare today will still be on it then, plus millions and millions of formerly illegal invaders. And those who can barely afford ins. today will simply give up and opt for the palsy fine, leaving, once again, the responsible to pick up the tab. As IF we aren't already paying enough. 

genxer --- 16 years ago -

what the report assumes though is that the hospital has paying customers.

I was in the KWd ER years ago and they asked me the pay our deductible so we did. And she said many people tell them oh well i'll pay later. Or bill me.
Some people go as far as to say well what are you going to do if i dont pay... put it on my credit. I already have bad credit.

And then of course there are all the people that don't have good or legal contact info that are flooding the ER's.

In the end, it sounds insane than an asprin is $95 for something that costs 21 cents. but if you give our 100 asprins and only one person pays for it the other 99 have be be recouped.

I find it amazing that many who demand that illegal elements of the society be treated the same as legal elements are also the same people that don't research the problem, blame the insurance industry and want to legalize everyone so they legally can participate in bad behavior, not paying their bill. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

The thing is, it isn't insurance, it is the cost of care.

People expect care to be delivered for free and/or inexpensively yet when it isn't they errantly blame insurance. Insurance isn't the issue, it is the charges the hospitals and physicians charge.

Now mind you, because of things they are charged for they have to raise their rates - things such as malpractice coverage, liability coverage, cost of new technology, cost of benefits for employees, cost of staffing, electricity for a 24/7 high energy using building, marketing to differentiate themselves from all the others, and all other routine costs of business.

It is the unreasonable expectation of free or inexpensive care that has created a high demand for services that may or may not be necessary.

Heck, if you look at most treatment plans they include tests that clearly serve no purpose other than to protect from a lawsuit - um, that drives up cost.

Let's even look at another local example - just the other day someone on here was asking about which specialist to see for a rash - yet they had not yet gone to their PCP to see if it was something that even needed a specialist. But no, they immediately jumped to the higher priced/cost specialist which while their insurance may pay it - ultimately increases the cost the insurance company has to pay needlessly. If you do that hundred of thousands of times, you can see the problem.

It is over utilization of services, mis-ulitization of services and high cost of unncessary testing that play a huge part in this.

But will people change their behavior - I doubt it. Everyone wants what they want cause they want it and they want it now - regardless of what it cost someone else to pay for it. And unless you pay 100% cash for your care - someone else IS paying for it. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

and want to legalize everyone so they legally can participate in bad behavior, not paying their bill.


Right???? sigh 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

In the end, it sounds insane than an asprin is $95 for something that costs 21 cents. but if you give our 100 asprins and only one person pays for it the other 99 have be be recouped.

genxer you are right. One of the biggest line items is that line for uncompensated care. You explained it perfectly. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

This is what I've been complaining about the whole time. When I gave birth two years ago, I looked at the hospital bill and saw a $30 charge for a 1 oz. sample of Lansolin. Btw, the hospital gets those samples for free. I hadn't asked for the sample, it just appeared with all of the other "mommy samples" in my room. A 5 oz. bottle at Walgreens cost around $5.

The bill was FULL of charges like that. Also, the hospital will not allow you to bring your own your own prescriptions, so you must pay their price of $50/dose in order to "protect" you from taking the wrong pill. Ok, but who protects me from going broke and ending up on the street from their "concern" about my own stupidity?

I'm ashamed to say that at the time, I didn't question the bill, both because we were covered by a "Cadillac plan", and because we were adjusting to life with a new baby and chose our battles. However, with our cadillac plan cut drastically last year, I will question EVERYTHING that magically appears in my room from the nurses. I know that I will charged outrageously for their witch hazel, which would cost me a few dollars at Walgreens.

This time, those charges will hit US in the pocketbook, not our insurance, so we will pick and choose what we really need.

I think that most companies are starting to drop the great healthcare coverage they used to have for their employees, so more and more people will start demanding reasonable rates. If EVERYONE does it, it may change how hospitals do business. 

TexasOma --- 16 years ago -

When I was still working at the hospital, we were required to submit a 'charge sheet' when we administered blood so that the patient could be billed for the blood and for the administration of the blood by the nurse.

I always had a problem with this because the patient was being billed for my services anyway because I was his nurse for the full 8 hours - no matter what my assignment. Why should the patient be charged extra for my hanging blood and monitoring the administration. I might have to spend an extra 10 minutes devoted towards this patient, but down the line I might have to spend 20 minutes devoted to a patient that fell on the floor - they don't get charged extra for falling or maybe 30 minutes towards a heart attack - they don't get charged extra for dying. But the hospital claimed they wanted to recoup the cost of the nurse giving blood. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

However, with our cadillac plan cut drastically last year, I will question EVERYTHING t


I have seen this across the board by many.
It's going to get much worse if we don't get BO ousted. 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Yeah Sassy, it happened during a bad year for us. A high-risk pregnancy when you're paying out of pocket isn't cheap. But there's no going back. Companies have no incentive to offer those great plans anymore.

My husband and I have talked about it a lot, but changing to another company doesn't guarantee better health coverage, they can (and eventually will) switch up on us too. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Companies have no incentive to offer those great plans anymore.

That's EXACTLY right!

Which is why I always said there needs to be a program for poor folks to buy their OWN insurance, not further burden those already footing more than their fair share. BO refused to hear of any of THAT though.

I'm willing to help my fellow man, but I'm unwilling to give up what we can afford for our family so you can have what you can't afford for yours. If BO had his way we'd ALL be stuck with shitty Government run health care.

As it stands, people with great health care plans will pay dearly more for them for a lot less. Call me selfish, I can live with it. I'm not the one asking someone else to foot the bill for what I'm unwilling to take a second job to provide for myself. 

bhsurf4 --- 16 years ago -

But these huge mark-ups are to compensate for those who recieve care and don't have insurance, and can't pay. Anyone that goes to the E.R. and needs medical attention, gets it, and if they can't pay, those of us with insurance or who can afford to pay end up paying. That is why it's important for everyone to have some kind of health insurance. You can slam the bill that was passed all you want, but something had to be done. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

Know what would sove the problem? Single payer system. They wouldn't be forced to overcharge because of so many people not paying and the gov't could establish guidelines for pricing of procedures. Problem solved! 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Call me selfish, I can live with it. I'm not the one asking someone else to foot the bill for what I'm unwilling to take a second job to provide for myself.

You are talking about going to see a doctor, right?

We aren't talking about houses and cars and vacations, we're talking about seeing a freakin' doctor!!!

This shouldn't be about 'privilege', imo. Your income should have no bearing on the type of medical care you receive. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Redirecting people to the appropriate level of care.

Malpractice limits.

Health insurance is not a right.

Problem solved better than a bandaid of single payer, but hey, if you are simple maybe that's as deep as you can see. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

This shouldn't be about 'privilege', imo

Health care is not a right, you've admitted as much yourself.

We should have simply shored up medicaid and medicare, raised our damn taxes and tabled this crap coming down the pike. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Your income should have no bearing on the type of medical care you receive.


It does all the time. Senator Kennedy chose to go to Duke because he could afford to.

Many of you choose to go to TCH with your kids even though it is more expensive than Kingwood Medical because you WANT to and your insurance pays for it so you never really know the true cost.

It isn't a "privilege" but it isn't a right either. It is an earned benefit. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Problem solved better than a bandaid of single payer, but hey, if you are simple maybe that's as deep as you can see.

Amen 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

Health insurance is not a right.



Shout it from the roof tops.

Get a job and pay for insurance.

Can't afford it with one job, get two.

It's all about priorities. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

This shouldn't be about 'privilege', imo

Health care is not a right, you've admitted as much yourself.


no, I've never said that.

I do believe healthcare is a right. I think our country's system sucks. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

no, I've never said that.


I'm almost certain you alluded to the fact it isn't a right on one long ago thread, but ok, I could be wrong.

Health care is not a right, it's a responsibility, imo. 

sweetscreaminmonkey --- 16 years ago -

When i had my son 20 yrs ago i had excellent ins through my parents my dad asked for an itemized statement for my almost 4 weeks in the hospital.. my bill was over 100,00$ which we could understand with all that i had but they charged things like 20$ for a bottle of powder to dry shampoo my hair.. there were other that were so bad but it has been awhile and i cant remember them all but it blew our minds the things we were charged for.. 

Dr Aborto --- 16 years ago -

I thought you've always blamed it on the illegals. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

I do believe healthcare is a right


So is personal responsibility in one's own healthcare.

Obesity side effects are asthma, cancer, cardiac disease, diabetes as well as others. Yet we treat the others but not the personal issue of the person being obese.

Smokers develop cancer, asthma, other issues, yet we continue to allow them to smoke.

There must be personal responsibility before free healthcare. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

lololol @ the good doctor!

i thought it was a given that we need prices to be regulated in the health care industry. simple dimple. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

So is personal responsibility in one's own healthcare.

Obesity side effects are asthma, cancer, cardiac disease, diabetes as well as others. Yet we treat the others but not the personal issue of the person being obese.

Smokers develop cancer, asthma, other issues, yet we continue to allow them to smoke.

There must be personal responsibility before free healthcare.



does this mean you think the obese need to address their weight? i think they do because i do not want to pay for their poor habits and ensuing health issues. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

i thought it was a given that we need prices to be regulated in the health care industry. simple dimple.


How do you regulate prices without regulating costs?

If you regulate only the prices then there are two options for the hospitals and physicians. One they can reduce staff/hours/services they offer or two, they can reduce quality.

Again, if you are only looking to bandaid then choose that option. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

does this mean you think the obese need to address their weight? i


yes, they absolutely SHOULD. It's no one else's responsibility to pay for the poor eating habits of another. 

justforfun --- 16 years ago -

i thought it was a given that we need prices to be regulated in the health care industry. simple dimple.


How do you regulate prices without regulating costs?

If you regulate only the prices then there are two options for the hospitals and physicians. One they can reduce staff/hours/services they offer or two, they can reduce quality.

Again, if you are only looking to bandaid then choose that option.




Worth repeating again and again. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

does this mean you think the obese need to address their weight? i think they do because i do not want to pay for their poor habits and ensuing health issues.


Absolutely I do. I also think that if you ride a motorcycle without a helmet then you should receive lifesaving treatment of course, but long term rehab? hmmmm, not on my dime. You chose a risky behavior, not me.

If you smoke, then you need to address that and I don't need to pay for it.

If you have had gestational diabetes during a pregnancy since the risk is higher for developing it again, well if you become pregnant that is on you not me.


Yes risky behavior, high risk lifestyle - your dime not mine. My dime for me, not yours. 

Cookin' Queen --- 16 years ago -

When my CPA SIL had their first baby 30 years ago she went over the bill with a fine tooth comb. Found many items on the bill she never received. When she questioned the hospital they said they charged for these items as a standard even if you didn't received them.

Also just got a 12% raise in my insurance bill. Almost a $1000 a month. I haven't been to a doctor of 16 months. You better save for your retirement. Many companies are no longer covering you when you retire. My Brother worked for a major oil company and he is not covered after retiring at age 57. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 16 years ago -

Problem solved better than a bandaid of single payer, but hey, if you are simple maybe that's as deep as you can see.

The "simple" solution is most often the correct one. There is elegance in simplicity.



The republican solution for every problem for the last 50 years has been extremely simple. Cut taxes, increase military spending. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Yes risky behavior, high risk lifestyle - your dime not mine. My dime for me, not yours.


Such a simple concept. You'd think more would get it. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -


The republican solution for every problem for the last 50 years has been extremely simple. Cut taxes, increase military spending.



Oh Come on, you know nothing is that simple. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

If you have had gestational diabetes during a pregnancy since the risk is higher for developing it again, well if you become pregnant that is on you not me.


Really? So you think gestational diabetes patients should not have coverage at all?

What about mothers who get pregnant after the age of 35 and their baby has a birth defect and that child requires special care? Who should cover that cost?

Where is the line drawn for "high risk" or "personal responsibility" when it comes to pregnancy? 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

How do you regulate prices without regulating costs?

If you regulate only the prices then there are two options for the hospitals and physicians. One they can reduce staff/hours/services they offer or two, they can reduce quality.

Again, if you are only looking to bandaid then choose that option.



no i am not. we have known all along that they are accepting way less for payment than they bill and they are still in business. come on, the industry itself can keep track of the costs associated with the typical procedure. it is done in all corporations all the time. plus i am all for healthcare being non-profit. 

steinhoister2016 --- 16 years ago -

Ok, so Doctors and Hospital execs are pirates. Not a big shock there. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Look at the prescription drugs used today. Many of them are to treat symptoms and/or secondary illnesses without solving the primary cause.

We need to have that hard discussion on the root cause no matter how difficult.

Hey, I'm obese, no shocker there. I know the risks I take.

Now while it is also completely possible for a world class runner to have a heart attack I know I am at a greater risk than they are.

I should be held responsible for my risks. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

20 plus years ago I was charged $8.00 a piece for 2 generic acetaminophen tablets, so this is not a new thing. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

Yes risky behavior, high risk lifestyle - your dime not mine. My dime for me, not yours.


who pays for your insurance? what is the monthly cost? is your obesity factored into the cost? NO IT IS NOT. 

page 1 2 3 4 5
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground