Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should books be banned?

who's talking here?

eterry2 1
planemom 1
Justwatching72 1
Deltadawn 2
Zionist NightOwl 1
Mabbers 2
Perfection 4
JusticeForAll 4
bhsurf4 1
Ogre1 4
STRONGSOUTHERNMOM 4
Niki 1
toxiccutie 1
A Simple Equation 1
needrnr 2
Work in Progress 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should books be banned?

Sorry, I messed up the first attempt. Should books be subject to banning in either publishing or distribution?

Yes Vote
 
 2.3% (1)
No Vote
 
 97.7% (42)
Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Sorry, I messed up the first attempt.

Should books be subject to banning in either publishing or distribution? 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

I voted no but I do have one caveat. Books in schools should be age appropriate.

I'm also thinking your meaning by the government not by stores. It's nice that most places keep "dirty" books either off the shelves or in hard to find places. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

NO x 1000 - Fahrenheit 451 anyone? 

Justwatching72 --- 16 years ago -

DeltaDawn escreveu:
NO x 1000 - Fahrenheit 451 anyone?  



Mississippi School District Bans Book on Censorship: "Fahrenheit 451" by Ray Bradbury

February 1, 1999

West Marion High School in Foxworth, a rural Mississippi town, is the place where recent events aimed at censorship occurred. The book, Fahrenheit 451, was on the reading list for several of the English classes. However, after a parent complained to the superintendent about the use of the word "God damn" in the book, the book was removed from the required reading list. Interestingly, the complaint did not surface until the book report was due -- more than a month after the reading assignment was given. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

I did not vote. This can be hard question.. if you say no on banning, then you have books that were discussed on here several months ago which were "self help" for kids trying to find their sexual orientation. The excerpts on those books to me were confessionals of molestation events. Maybe others can relate to those stories may others can't. Then you have inspirational books written by different faiths where someone is bound to disagree with. Imo there are some books which are better left to be found at the public library or purchased at a book store. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Ok a little confused but get it now, distribution and publishing not specifally for schools. 

bhsurf4 --- 16 years ago -

You want to make sure a kid reads a book? BAN IT!! 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Certainly children should be protected from seeing pornography in stores and especially in schools, but government censorship that limits information to adults (except in obvious interest of national security) should not happen. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

There's a difference between banning and regulating.

Censorship is the pervue of the despot.

And the list of books that have been/are banned from school libraries is long and ridiculous.

No, Hustler Magazine or the Anne Rice's Sleeping Beauty probably shouldn't be found in any elementary or secondary school.

But what about Mark Twain's The Adventure's of Huckleberry Finn? It's been banned for the use of the word Nigger...as in Nigger Jim.

How about To Kill A Mockingbird - Profanity

Others include;
Of Mice and Men
The Harry Potter Series
The Color Purple


The American Heritage Dictionary? YES, I'm not kidding. the Anchorage School Board banned the dictionary in 1987 because it contained objectionable words.

Do you see how ridiculous this is?

Often times, it's only one or two parents or board members who are offended and the schools are so scared of having to fight they just cave in.

If your school censors a book, I suggest calling them up, telling them you're offended by the censorship and that you will sue them if they don't change their policy. It's even better if you can get a bunch of people to do it and say you'll file a class action against he school district. 

Niki --- 16 years ago -

I remember in junior hight they wanted to ban "A Day No Pigs Would Die". It is one of the best books I have ever read.

Along with Ogre's list - I have read all of the books he mentioned and some of them multiple times, I do not see any reason to ban.

We just need to educate our children if they are going to read Huck Finn or The Color Purple.

If you can't tell banning books infuriates me :) 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

What lobbyist group is behind wanting books banned, Chunky?

To Kill a Mockingbird is one of the best books I've ever read!

People are so ignorant. It still makes me LOL every time I hear someone say "Harry Potter" books are from the Devil. I'm sure the "Lightning Thief" books will be next on their hit list...

Which church teaches this nonsense? 

A Simple Equation --- 16 years ago -

Obama's nominee for SCOTUS justice, Elena Kagan thinks it is just fine...



God help this nation if this Communist piece of trash ever gets confirmed... 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

JusticeForAll --- 4 hours ago - quote - flag comment
What lobbyist group is behind wanting books banned, Chunky?


Supreme Court nominee Kagan.


Knowledge is power. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Supreme Court nominee Kagan.


Knowledge is power. 



One person isn't doing this alone...


So again, I ask you, What lobbyist group is behind this, Chunky? 

toxiccutie --- 16 years ago -

People are so ignorant. It still makes me LOL every time I hear someone say "Harry Potter" books are from the Devil. I'm sure the "Lightning Thief" books will be next on their hit list...


Makes me laugh as well.
I don't get it, if you don't like the books, don't read them...don't allow them in your home - but where do people get off telling others we can't read them if we want?

You want to make sure a kid reads a book? BAN IT!!

Yup, curiosity killed the cat, lol.


Books in schools should be age appropriate.


Exactly. I agree.
but not banned entirely.

However, after a parent complained to the superintendent about the use of the word "God damn" in the book, the book was removed from the required reading list.

LOL, I wonder what world this parent lives in...you can hear worse than that MANY times a day from the fellow students or just by going to the local store, gas station, post office, etc...or even in their own homes.

But what about Mark Twain's The Adventure's of Huckleberry Finn? It's been banned for the use of the word Nigger...as in Nigger Jim.


That's ridiculous!!! That book represents a time in history, which that word was used everyday...
I understood that just fine when I first read that book - I knew it was not appropriate to run around and scream it...it simply represented at time in our history where it was deemed acceptable...
So whats next? are we going to start banning all access to our history that involves anything that isn't all rainbows and butterflies??? Pfft! 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

For those of you who voted not to ban the publication or distribution of books - why not? 

Zionist NightOwl --- 16 years ago -


Others include;
Of Mice and Men


LOL.

DS' class had to read Of Mice and Men in English last year. As she was passing out the books, the teacher told them, "There is some bad language in here, so if any of you think that your parents might object to you reading it, you should talk with them, and then we'll see about getting you an alternative assignment."

One girl in his class piped in, "My momma uses language worse than that just getting me out of bed every morning." 

STRONGSOUTHERNMOM --- 16 years ago -

i do not think books should be banned but we as parents owe it to our kids to stay on top of what they are reading...

have any of you heard of the book

"The Rainbow Party" by Paul Ruditis

it is a known fact this book is in many school libraries across the country...
when 11 yr old starts KMS this year you can be sure i will be making sure this book is no where near that school...very disturbing material...there are many like it 

STRONGSOUTHERNMOM --- 16 years ago -

i do not think books should be banned but we as parents owe it to our kids to stay on top of what they are reading...

have any of you heard of the book

"The Rainbow Party" by Paul Ruditis

it is a known fact this book is in many school libraries across the country...
when 11 yr old starts KMS this year you can be sure i will be making sure this book is no where near that school...very disturbing material...there are many like it 

STRONGSOUTHERNMOM --- 16 years ago -

i do not think books should be banned but we as parents owe it to our kids to stay on top of what they are reading...

have any of you heard of the book

"The Rainbow Party" by Paul Ruditis

it is a known fact this book is in many school libraries across the country...
when 11 yr old starts KMS this year you can be sure i will be making sure this book is no where near that school...very disturbing material...there are many like it 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Elena Kagan thinks it is just fine...

NO DUMB@SS. She was an attorney representing the interests of her client. The Executive Branch. That does not mean that this is her opinion.

Top that off, she's arguing AGAINST McCain-Feingold censoring books. It was specifically designed to REGULATE political broadcasts. NOT publishing.

I guess lawyers who defend murderers think murder should be legal too? That's what you indicate here.

Cripes, you people don't even know what lawyers do.

This is completely out of context as well. As per usual, people taking PART of a conversation and construing it to mean what they want.

THAT IS CENSORSHIP! Bunch of f@cking hypocrites. 

Deltadawn --- 16 years ago -

NO BOOK BANNING! Shame on the school district that banned Fahrenheit 451 or any other book. You don't want to read it, don't! and you can make sure a public school library does not check out a particular book to your child, if you feel the need to do that. No one else is allowed to tell me what I can and can't read. 

STRONGSOUTHERNMOM --- 16 years ago -

sorry i swear i hit the "add comment" only once...my computer has a mind of its own lately 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Ban everything. No more paper. All the kids should get Kindles. :D 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

LOL JMABS.


Well if we think it's ok to censor books, what about speech.

Aren't books just representations of speech. If you ban one aren't you banning both? 

Work in Progress --- 16 years ago -

Keeping certain books away from children and keeping ideas away from adults are totally separate issues.

However, as a former English teacher, I can't imagine not allowing my child to read a certain book because of a questionable word. The theme of the book is of much more interest to me. For instance, with the Harry Potter books, yes there is witchcraft which drives the plot, but the THEME is that good conquers evil, love trumps hate, frienship is more powerful than coercion, etc. I would have no problem with my child reading that! The same with To Kill a Mockingbird or Huck Finn. It's not a word that is used that matters when the themes of those books were instrumental in changing views during the civil rights movement! I would have a problem if my child were asked to read The Golden Compass, because I REALLY don't agree with the themes. However, I could just choose to have my child not participate rather than attempting to ban the book. You can let your child read whatever you want!

But when books start being banned for political reasons, that's scary. That's an attempt to keep even our thoughts controlled, and it is inherently evil. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Aren't books just representations of speech. If you ban one aren't you banning both?

Which is why a global ban of books will never happen. It violates the 1st Amd. There must be a substantial reason for the government to blan/classify material.

NOW, NON-GOVERNMENT actors... I.e. churches, corporations, etc are NOT required to follow the first amendment. They can ban whatever they want. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

have any of you heard of the book

"The Rainbow Party" by Paul Ruditis



I hadn't until you mentioned it. Here's what wikipedia has to say about it:


Book

Rainbow Party is also a novel commissioned by a Simon & Schuster editor to "scare" kids.[2] The author was Paul Ruditis. The book, which Library Journal declined to review, is about teens who fantasize about having a rainbow party.
The book proved controversial, as it was meant for teenagers (recommended by the publisher for ages 14 and up), thus raising questions about its propriety. In turn, concerns were raised that excluding the book from bookstores and libraries would amount to censorship. The publishers justified Rainbow Party on the grounds that it was a cautionary tale intended to teach readers that oral sex can be dangerous.
 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

and for those who don't know what a "rainbow party" is...


A rainbow party is a supposed group sex event featured in an urban legend spread since the early 2000s. A variant of the standard sex party urban myth, the stories claim that at these events, allegedly increasingly popular among adolescents, females wearing various shades of lipstick take turns fellating males in sequence, leaving a "rainbow" of colors on their penises.[1] The idea was publicized on The Oprah Winfrey Show in 2003, and became the subject of a juvenile novel called Rainbow Party.[1] However, sex researchers and adolescent health care professionals have found no evidence for the existence of rainbow parties, and as such attribute the spread of the stories to a moral panic


Knowledge is power... 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

I personally can't imagine ANY female who'd subject themselves to multiple phallic suckage as part of a game. BLECHO. Can you say BARF? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Knowledge is power...

And KNOWING is half the battle!

0 

eterry2 --- 16 years ago -

ABSOLUTELY NOT!!!!!!!! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground