Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Fatal Distraction: Forgetting a Child in the Backseat of a Car Is a Horrifying Mistake. Is It a Crim

who's talking here?

Sandyr9111 1
Mabbers 1
txdaddy 4
~sassy~ 1
rEVOLution 1
Perfection 3
Laurabeth 1
Ogre1 3
voice of reason 2
tamsy 1
OH SNAP 3
Sufferbus 1
TexasOma 1
*OH SNAP* 3
PICASSO 2
Work in Progress 1
It is I WhyWhyWhy 1
SagaciousSighFiGurl 1
JAP129 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

This article is a must read for anyone who's ever wondered how on earth someone could forget their child in the car. Posted it in the thread about the toddler being left in the car, but thought it deserves its own thread. It won a Pulitzer. Fatal Distraction 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I can't bear to read it. This happens every single year. I just don't get it. I can not comprehend how a parent could forget their child. Most are men though, and being the major creature of habit I am, I can at least understand a tiny bit how a man might forget, if it's out of the norm for him. But In NO WAY should this excuse it. I can't imagine being cooked alive. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

I know when I was a single mom and my daughter was brand new, there were a couple of times that I was parking my car at work before I remembered she was still in the back seat. I had a Jeep Grand Cherokee, and her car seat was behind my seat. Because of it, I had frequent nightmares the first two years of her life where I'd wake up in the middle of the night convinced I'd either left her at daycare or left her in the car. It was sheer terror. I'd leap out of bed with my heart racing and start getting dressed, trying to find the number for the daycare, etc. only to (thankfully) realize she was asleep in her crib in the next room. I guess that's why I found myself having empathy for these people, especially when they talk about that walk to the parking lot once they've realized what they've done. 

Laurabeth --- 16 years ago -

I read it.....so sad. I've ran a 911 call where this happened....just awful. I can't imagine being able to continue in life knowing that my inattentiveness caused ny sons death. Its scary being a parent. I used to leave reminders for myself everywhere about all kinds of things, because I am so forgetful. there were a couple of times that I was parking my car at work before I remembered she was still in the back seat. LO...my kid is ten and we can be in the middle of a conversation and I can start driving to work instead of bringing him to school! My son stays with his father some, so I don't have him every morning. I always had the nightmare that I would get ready in the morning and leave him home alone, thinking that he is at his dad's. To this day, I still go in his room every morning....doesn't matter if he's home or not! LOL! 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

Most are men though whoa there. not true. article says same chance...woman or man. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Awesome journalism work there. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

What differentiates accidents from crimes? 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

What differentiates accidents from crimes? Intent. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

What differentiates accidents from crimes? intent? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

First - I do NOT believe it is a crime, a horrorific accident but not a crime. However, the intent logic isn't right either - drunks don't intend on killing anyone but they do it every day and that IS a crime. I don't know where the line is either, I am just glad I don't have to make that decision. I was very intrigued by the detail in the article. Great reference to how transportation habits have changed in the past 20 years as well as the recent focus on putting kids in the back seat facing backwards and how that may have some impact here. I just hope I never am in that situation. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

I just hope I never am in that situation. don't put yourself in that situation. I was very intrigued by the detail in the article. Great reference to how transportation habits have changed in the past 20 years as well as the recent focus on putting kids in the back seat facing backwards and how that may have some impact here. it read like an excuse manual of everything you could blame except the parent. blame the brain, blame car seats in the back....how about blame the constantly self cetered parents that believe their conversations and/or "worries" are important enough to distract them into to killing their child. funny...i bet the same ones that refer to this article as some kind of proof it wasn't the parents' fault because of how the brain works would be horrified to find out they tried to use the same argument to excuse a man from raping someone. not his fault, his brain betrayed him....yea right. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

However, the intent logic isn't right either - drunks don't intend on killing anyone but they do it every day and that IS a crime. yes i thought of the dui manslaughter thingy which is why i included the quesiton mark. 

*OH SNAP* --- 16 years ago -

Nobody is saying it isn't the parents' fault, including the parents. Every single one of them says that THEY did this to their child. Somehow you're still missing the point, txdaddy. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

I disagree Chunky, Negligent homicide is a crime. If, by your own negligence (i.e, forgetting you got a godsdamned kid in the backseat!), you cause the death of another individual. Then you can and should go to jail. Most cases where a DUI kills someone are prosecuted under criminally negligent homicide. These child left in car cases should be also. INTENT is a part of most criminal actions, but not all. I.E. there is no intent element for child molestation. In other words guys and gals, if she turns out to be 14 and you thought she was 19, shame on ya. It doesn't matter. And there is no intent element for criminal negligence. The negligence element, defined as, "careless, inattentive, neglectful, willfully blind, or in the case of gross negligence what would have been reckless in any other defendant." (taken from Wiki, but it's close enough). There are plenty of way to not have intent, but still be criminally negligent. If enough people were put in jail for doing this, then maybe people would get their heads out of their butts. I won't even leave my dogs in the car, much less a child. 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

Somehow you're still missing the point, txdaddy. the point being that "distractions" caused these parents to actually forget their child was in the vehicle, and leave them there to die a horrible death? nope, i pretty much got it, thanks. oh and your "point" that you "get" and my "point" that i "get" could be different. many could read the same article and have differing opinions of what the point is...right? 

txdaddy --- 16 years ago -

ogre...i was hoping you would opine. thanks. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Nobody is saying it isn't the parents' fault, including the parents. Every single one of them says that THEY did this to their child. Somehow you're still missing the point, txdaddy. So when does fault and blame equal a crime? 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

So when does fault and blame equal a crime? That depends on the circumstances. Look, if you forget the ice cream in the car, fine, that isn't a crime. But if you forget a living, breathing creature in the car, whether human or pet, then it is a crime. Sadly, right now, you can actually get more time for killing your dog in the car that way than you can for killing your kid! And I'm not exaggerating. Misdemeanor Homicide (Criminally Negligent Homicide) carries a sentence of 6 mos to 2 years with up to a $10,000.00 fine. Animal Cruelty in Texas? Since ... I think 2006, Animal Cruelty in Texas is a felony and get you up to 10 years and a $10,000 fine (per instance!) 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

Look, if you forget the ice cream in the car, fine, that isn't a crime. I take this back, with stipulations... If I'M the one waiting for the ice cream, then you forgetting it in the care is a crime. Otherwise, ...whatever. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

It's that time of year again.

*sigh* 

SagaciousSighFiGurl (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

I heard YET another story like this while traveling North a month ago. In Oklahoma, a 4 year old climbed into the family vehicle, which was unlocked, and preceeded to lock the doors while playing. It was extremely hot. She couldn't get out and died before the parents noticed she was missing and went to look for her.

Look, at some point an intelligent person has to ask some questions. Why was a 4 year old allowed to roam outside away from a parents' view? How long does it take to cook a 4 year old in a locked car? And, one has to admit, yes, little ones move fast, but a responsible parent WATCHES them despite that fact. The truth is some people just aren't the best parents and many young lives are lost because of it. Even tho every single summer more kids die, and it's all over the news to remind us. It's the same thing as parents/guardians not putting seat belts on their kids. 

PICASSO --- 15 years ago -

accidents, I see people do it on purpose ,I went into the verizon store by Target a few years ago and confronted alady very loudly for leaving her toddlers locked in the car (in summer) while she paid her bill and shopped.I never did it with my kids,its just laziness wich is par for most parents today. 

JAP129 --- 15 years ago -

This topic is just sad and thinking of a poor helpless child "cooking" in a car breaks my heart.

There should be a sensor in the back seat that beeps LOUDLY and flashes lights on your dash when there is weight registering in a car seat.

Kind of the same as the car goes "ding ding" when you open your door and the keys are still in the ignition.

With all the things people are able to invent these days I think something like that is feasible... even ONE child's life lost to this is too much in my book! 

rEVOLution --- 15 years ago -

My opinion is that if the fear of killing their child is not enough to prevent them from making this mistake, the fear of jail certainly isn't going to deter anyone from forgetting their child in the backseat. Many people mistakenly kill their children every year, I don't think it should be considered a crime if it were an honest mistake. But then again how do you prove it was a mistake with so many people these days not wanting their children.

I think our environment and prescription drugs have a lot to do with this uptick in occurrences over the past two decades.

Many people in America today are mindless zombies on any given day. 

Sufferbus --- 15 years ago -

There should be a sensor in the back seat that beeps LOUDLY and flashes lights on your dash when there is weight registering in a car seat.

I keep tools in the back seat of my car, and they're a lot heavier than a kid. Why should I have to have an alarm like that when I'll never have a kid in a car seat in my car? 

TexasOma --- 15 years ago -

Why was a 4 year old allowed to roam outside away from a parents' view?



SciFiGurl --- I see this right here in our subdivision. Ever since one of my neighbors moved in, they have turned their kids out on the street --- even the youngest who was about 4. They just wander the street and into people's houses. This one 4 year old didn't have an older sibling where you could say the sibling was watching the child -- they just turned the kid out - PERIOD. The neighbors across the street turn theirs out also but there is an older sibling, but that sibling made it a point to run off and leave the younger kid to cry in the middle of the street.

Yes, our street is a quiet cul-de-sac street, but the teens drive like maniacs --- I am so surprised that one of these kids haven't been hit.

Now the youngest is 5 and they still wander the street, but now they don't hang out in the middle of the street.

I just don't understand letting a very young kid wander aimlessly up and down a street daily. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

I keep tools in the back seat of my car, and they're a lot heavier than a kid. Why should I have to have an alarm like that when I'll never have a kid in a car seat in my car?

They'd have to make it where you could arm or disarm it yourself, kind of like the front airbags. 

tamsy --- 15 years ago -

I do not understand how you can forget a child in the car.My daughter is a teen and still do not like to leave in the car while I get a drink from the gas station. 

It is I WhyWhyWhy --- 15 years ago -

Yes it is a crime. If there is no intent then wouldn't it be involuntary manslaughter? 

JAP129 --- 15 years ago -

I keep tools in the back seat of my car, and they're a lot heavier than a kid. Why should I have to have an alarm like that when I'll never have a kid in a car seat in my car?

They'd have to make it where you could arm or disarm it yourself, kind of like the front airbags.


Right! You could turn it on or off. 

PICASSO --- 15 years ago -

I see this right here in our subdivision. Ever since one of my neighbors moved in, they have turned their kids out on the street --- even the youngest who was about 4. They just wander the street and into people's houses.

when my kids were younger 8&12 a couple moved on to our street with two younger 3-5 year old girls,they were so prety ,looked like pocilin dolls.They would walk up and down the streetlooking for kids to play with,no parent insight,the girl came to my neighbors house one morning she let them stay there till mom started walking the street looking for them.It took six hours for her to wonder where they were,my neighbor chewed her out bbigtime,it never happened again. 

Work in Progress --- 15 years ago -

First, I completely understand how it happens. The first 6 months of a baby's life, the parents are so sleep deprived that distraction is just a normal part of life.

When my boys were little babies, I remember people asking me questions, and I would stare at them for 30 seconds or more before my brain could process what they just asked me. Quadruple that exhaustion with each kid you have, because they take turns keeping you up ALL of the time.

Add in all of your other worries. . .long hours at work, differences in routine, carseats where you can't SEE the child. It totally makes sense.

As far as it being a crime. . .what would incarceration do? Would it punish them? THEY JUST KILLED THEIR CHILD, the torment their own minds will give them is much worse than jail.

Is it to protect the public? Unless they are a bus driver, that's not really pertinent. 

OH SNAP --- 15 years ago -

This article still haunts me. I cried and cried when I read it the first time. The part where the worker told the story of the baby who pulled all her hair out before she died pops into my head at random sometimes when I open my car door and feel that heat pouring out. I can't imagine what it would be like to walk outside and realize your baby is dead in the back seat of your car and that you did it. It's the stuff nightmares are made of. I remember there were a couple of times that I started to walk away from my car then remembered my daughter was in it. I could see how it could happen to a new parent. Like cruella said, sleep deprivation and stress does terrible things to your memory and concentration. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground