Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

*CIA run drone operations...

who's talking here?

CIA_DUDE 2
rEVOLution 4
The Famous Living Dead 1
deltoid1 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

The United States is the only country in the world that openly admits to having the technological resources to launch pilot less drones armed with missiles that can then strike and destroy targets on the ground. The use of armed drones against terrorist targets began under President George W. Bush but greatly accelerated under President Barack Obama. There was roughly one drone attack in the border area of Afghanistan-Pakistan in 2009 and the tempo has increased this year. The attacks in 2009 killed an estimated 700 Pakistani civilians though it is likely that only a few of the dead were known terrorist leaders. It is difficult to determine the results as there has been little in the way of any public accounting of the deaths, most of which take place in a part of Pakistan that is inaccessible to journalists. The drones have caused political problems for the Pakistani government, which has provided two airbases inside its own territory to support their operations. Washington, curiously, has confirmed that the attacks are taking place but provides few details beyond a "no comment," meaning that the program is, to a certain extent, shrouded in mystery. There should be two questions about the CIA run drone operations. First, are they legal and second, are they effective. Taking the second question first, one has to rely to a certain extent on the opinions of government officials. Director of National Intelligence Dennis Blair, CIA Director Leon Panetta, and the Obama White House have all said that the drones are the most effective tool against terrorism, but they fail to provide much real evidence that that is the case. You have to look elsewhere to determine what the impact has been. According to the foreign media , of the 700 people killed during 2009 there were only three that were regarded as senior members of al-Qaeda or the Taliban and only two others that were regarded as known terrorists. That means that the ratio of civilians to terrorists among the year’s toll was roughly 140 to one. A much more conservative estimate by the New America Foundation, which counts "suspected militants" as confirmed terrorists, comes up with 30% civilian casualty levels. As many of those killed are invariably described as "suspected" by US military sources or the Pakistani military, one might reasonably assume that the true numbers lie between the two estimates. Effectiveness must also be measured in terms of blowback. The drones have been very unpopular inside Pakistan and have contributed to a poor perception of the United States among the Pakistani people. Only 9% of Pakistanis regard the US favorably. And then there is the old rule of unanticipated consequences. The recent bombing attempt in Times Square appears to have been motivated by the drone strike that killed Tehreek-e-Taliban Pakistan leader Baitullah Mehsud last year. If twenty New Yorkers had died one would have to ask whether it had been worth it to kill a Taliban leader in Pakistan who was almost immediately replaced? It is therefore safe to say that the drone strikes have had little to do with making America safer, quite the contrary, which should be the only reason that the government would resort to them in the first place. But the advocates of the policy have, as usual, come up with other reasons to continue the program. On May 4th, CNN reported that both the Bush and Obama White Houses have actually been pursuing a policy that has "moved beyond" the targeted killing of terrorists. It has expanded to include homes and other buildings believed to be used by terrorists, suspected training centers, and other support activities. The objective is to "protect" US forces in neighboring Afghanistan. The question, which CNN conveniently did not ask, becomes to what extent does the CIA have the kind of good intelligence that enables it to target inside Pakistan without killing a large number of civilians? The answer is that it doesn’t have that kind of intelligence and it often doesn’t know who it is killing. Last June a drone fired a hellfire missile that destroyed a "suspected militant hideout" in a border village, burying a family inside the ruins of the building. When rescuers rushed to help the injured, the hovering drone fired a second missile, killing 13 of those seeking to help the victims of the first strike. On the next day, a funeral procession for the dead was also hit, killing 80 civilians. The legal case for the United States using lethal force against a country with which it is not at war is even more suspect. The CIA runs the drone operation precisely because if the Defense Department were to do so there would be no legal fig leaf for the activity. The United States military is in Afghanistan based on a resolution passed by Congress in 2001in response to 9/11. There has never been an act of war, which the constitution of the United States requires, but the Bush and Obama Administrations regard the congressional resolution as sufficient legal justification. But that does not cover CIA operations directed against Pakistan, not to mention Yemen and Somalia, both of which have also been on the receiving end of drones operating out of Djibouti. The argument is that the CIA has authority to carry out the operations based on its founding document, the National Security Act of 1947, which authorizes the president to task the Agency as required. But it is clear that the intent of the original legislation was not to include the CIA undertaking acts of war, an authority that is explicitly subject under the constitution to congressional approval. That a series of presidents since 1947 have ordered the CIA to carry out the so-called "covert actions" that include overthrowing legitimate governments and assassination should not imply that the activity is either legal or moral. Congress has merely chosen to look the other way and not exercise oversight or assert its constitutional role. The media, for its part, has consistently buried stories of intelligence abuses. So the drones continue to fly and continue to kill. If the program is justified to make more secure the United States, the Obama Administration should make its case, opening the books to tell the public how many confirmed terrorists have been killed as a result. Once all is revealed there can be a reasonable public debate on whether such a policy of targeted killing should be part of a responsible and sustainable national security program. Such a debate is particularly urgent as the White House has revealed that American citizens are now included among the targets that can be killed on sight. If the program is vital to the national interest, the White House should then go to Congress to obtain authority to continue. I personally believe that once the program is exposed to scrutiny the American people will be horrified by what they see. They might also begin to understand that killing people overseas produces blowback and opens the door to more terrorist attacks here at home, as Congressman Ron Paul has repeatedly warned. Targeted killing from the sky is as horrible as it sounds. Doing so against civilians in a country with which the US is not at war is neither legally nor morally justifiable. If extreme measures truly are necessary to protect our country, the government must absolutely make a case for the action that it is taking. Up until now, they have made no attempt to do so. http://www.campaignforliberty.com/article.php?view=841 

CIA_DUDE --- 16 years ago -

I did not, I dont know who told you that, but they and you sir are a liar! 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

I did not, I dont know who told you that, but they and you sir are a liar! LOL, yeah right! Good to hear from you, hope all is going well with you. 

CIA_DUDE --- 16 years ago -

Everything is going very well. May 29th I officially am let loose into the world >:) 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

May 29th I officially am let loose into the world >:) God be with us all, LOL Just kidding, that's terrific. Enjoy your time buddy. 

rEVOLution --- 16 years ago -

 

The Famous Living Dead --- 16 years ago -

don't we all miss CIA_DUDE??? 

deltoid1 --- 16 years ago -

Oh my gosh!

I think I just dropped a few dozen IQ points from reading this thread?

Guess everybody's got to be doing something? 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground