Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I'll be vilified, but shouldn't we let nature decide if premature babies survive?

who's talking here?

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees 1
Denise C 1
QueenCassie 1
ShookUpRamen 2
~sassy~ 1
Anna 1
Unichic™ 2
voice of reason 1
JohnLynch 1
Niki 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

The Awe Inspiring JoelleDrees (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Disclaimer: This is not my opinion, this is just an article I thought interesting. I think all life deserves a chance, from the unborn fetus to the premature baby to the person on the feeding tube... ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ I'll be vilified, but shouldn't we let nature decide if premature babies survive? by I'll be vilified, but shouldn't we let nature decide if premature babies survive? by Virginia Ironside As the number of babies born weighing just 2lb doubles in two years, a provocative view from respected advice columnist VIRGINIA IRONSIDE. At first glance, it seems such wonderful news. The number of babies born weighing only 2lbs has more than doubled over the past two years. Their survival is miraculous, and often seems like a feat of tiny, wilful endurance against overwhelming odds. One can only imagine the joy of these vulnerable children's anxious parents as it becomes clear their child will live. And it is thanks to the advances of modern medicine that these little miracles have now become an everyday reality - after all, these are babies who are often no bigger than a bag of sugar. Without the support of modern technology, how else could they possibly have survived? Small miracle: But premature babies can have serious problems It is a natural response for us all to rejoice along with these families and their exceptionally premature babies - by which I mean those children born before 24 weeks. We all hope that these little ones can go on to live long and fruitful lives. But, sadly, the hard fact must be acknowledged that in many cases, this will not happen. None of us likes to even think of children being in pain, so it is tragic to realise that half of these children born at such an early stage of pregnancy will suffer from cerebral palsy. Many will also have bowel, kidney, respiratory or developmental problems. Often, the hours spent waiting in hope at the side of an incubator as these tiny babies battle for life will be replaced in later weeks, months and years by hours inserting feeding tubes, doing painful physiotherapy work, or comforting a child in distress. There are thousands of devoted parents of disabled children who do just this, day in, day out. They do a fantastic job and are to be much admired. Despite such devotion, and although I know my thoughts go against the current tide of opinion, I want to plead on behalf of these children. Faced with a desperately premature and undeveloped baby, I can't help but wonder whether in some instances it is the right thing to fight to keep them alive. Should modern medicine be saving these babies who often face a life dominated by pain and illness? I feel uncomfortable saying this, but I don't believe it should in every case. Why do I feel this way? A lot of people say that life is worth preserving at any cost. And yes, thankfully, some of these extremely premature children will have healthy, happy lives. Every one must be counted a blessing. But the sad fact is that it is a huge gamble to resuscitate a premature baby, and may risk bequeathing those tiny babies a lifetime of agony. Often there is a reason a child is born early - because they have either a disability or weakness. Isn't this Mother Nature's way of saying that they are not meant for this world? But then we intervene with all our gadgets and scientific advances. Sometimes, of course - and I can't emphasise this enough - intervention can be absolutely the right thing to do. There is nothing more heartening than reading the story of a baby that has triumphed against the odds, who has passed its milestones unscathed by his or her premature birth. But often prolonging the life of a tiny baby that would otherwise have died can be irresponsible. In practical terms, keeping these exceptionally premature babies alive places huge pressure - some £125 million a year - on the already heavily burdened health service. The resources that are keeping these babies alive are, by necessity, being taken away from those who have a strong chance of life: the young mothers and fathers hit by cancer, or the sick five-year-olds desperately in need of treatment. But most of all, and more importantly than any financial cost, is the human cost to the baby. As an agony aunt, I read about so much suffering. Allowing these babies to die isn't an easy option - far from it. It can cause parents and families pain and guilt for years. But I believe that it can sometimes be an unselfish and loving act not to prolong the life of a child who will never leave hospital or be free from intrusive and distressing medical intervention, before he or she can suffer. Parents who make that tough decision should be supported. Instead, though, it is often the parents who - albeit unwittingly and with the best of intentions - prolong their child's suffering who are praised. I have written extensively about the pain of bereavement, of losing a loved one. But there does come a time when you have to accept that death comes to us all. While I know my argument may sound hard-hearted, anyone who saw this week's BBC programme Caught in the Machine, about the children being cared for in the Intensive Care Unit (ICU) at Great Ormond Street Hospital, will empathise - and perhaps even share my concerns. Take tiny Uzoma Igwe. The eight-month-old little girl had never left the hospital in the course of her young life, and had been admitted to ICU four times with respiratory failure. Her delicate face covered in bandages holding an artificial ventilator in place, she was born at just 27 weeks and faced the harshest of battles from then. Indeed, the child's consultant, Dr Christine Pierce, said: 'Her lungs aren't strong enough for her to do the things normal babies do at her age. She is still the same size she was seven months ago - all the energy she has is used in surviving, not in growing or developing.' It was heartbreaking watching nurses trying to sit her up in a baby chair. One said: 'I do feel sometimes we do things you wouldn't do to an animal. Sometimes the treatment is futile.' She was given a tracheotomy, a hole in her throat to help her breath, but became increasingly distressed. Eventually, after a month in ICU and an operation on her stomach, she died. Another minute baby was born on the very cusp of survival, at 24 weeks. By eight months, she had suffered almost every complication possible, from severe chronic lung disease, to bleeding in the brain causing severe brain damage. She eventually went home, but will face continuing problems. I would never wish to proscribe what is right or wrong in individual cases, but as a general principle I worry that just because medical science can keep more and more desperately premature babies alive, it doesn't always mean it is the right thing to do. That may sound cruel and uncaring. But in many cases I believe the opposite to be true. Sometimes letting go can be the bravest - and most unselfish - decision a parent can make. Article 

Denise C --- 16 years ago -

Sometimes letting go can be the bravest - and most unselfish - decision a parent can make Based on my personal experience, I agree. When my son was born with no kidneys and put on life support he was given the best medical treatment there was available. Only one other baby had actually survived with a transplant. So of course, at the time I was hoping for that too. When the doctors told me that nightthat he was basically suffocating to death I knew I had to take him off of life support. Years later, I realized that was the best decision because he would have had to have been on medication and dialysis all of his life. And that imo would have been no life. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

It is tough and there is not a single "right answer" My thoughts exactly 

ShookUpRamen --- 16 years ago -

When we stop giving organ transplants to chronic drug users (e.g. David Crosby), HIV meds to IV drug users, lung cancer treatments to smokers, bypass surgeries to over-eaters, etc., then we can talk about when it is right to deny life support to people who committed no sin except that of being born prematurely. Now, to directly address the costs of prolonging life, why would the costs for infants be any different than the costs for any other group of people? The fact is, our ability to treat people is greatly exceeding our ability to pay for it. Neonatal care is just one area where this is true. Parents need to do what is right, and not bring money into their personal decisions. Nor do we need a government official to tell us when life is worth enough to save. Denise, it sounds like you made a painful but fair decision, one that I could only make after much prayer. 

Anna --- 16 years ago -

As a teacher of early childhood with disabilities, I feel the same. I have worked with too many children that have NO quality of life... oxygen, suctioning, feeding tube, no muscle control, seizures,blind, and the list goes on. We need to stop playing God. 

Niki --- 16 years ago -

my niece was born at 28 weeks and only weighed 1 lb 8 oz. She is now 11 and healthy - they did at one point want my SIL to give up but she fought and all came out perfect - weird how momma just knew 

ShookUpRamen --- 16 years ago -

Playing God? After approximately 50 milion abortions in this country since 1973, is it your contention that we play God more often in the neonatal ICU or in the abortion practitioner's office? I'm not trying to malign you, as I don't even know you or your views. I'm just trying to flesh out people's logic. 

QueenCassie --- 16 years ago -

After losing my son who was born at 24 weeks, this is a difficult subject for me. While nothing compares to pain of losing a child, and I would not wish that on anyone- I have to agree that often times we are just prolonging the child's agony by keeping them alive by artificial means. 

Unichic™ --- 16 years ago -

When we stop giving organ transplants to chronic drug users (e.g. David Crosby), HIV meds to IV drug users, lung cancer treatments to smokers, bypass surgeries to over-eaters, etc. Is there a shrouded message of judgement in this post? WOW, I sure hope not. We are humans with faults and vices. It really has little to do with this thread and I think there is a big difference. I am assuming, by the way, that we are talking about severely premature infants that probably won't survive with a quality life, not babies born at 32 weeks with a good fighting chance. 

voice of reason --- 16 years ago -

Often there is a reason a child is born early - because they have either a disability or weakness. Isn't this Mother Nature's way of saying that they are not meant for this world? yes. 

JohnLynch --- 16 years ago -

with a quality life i guess it depends upon who's definition of "quality of life' you are using this man has a great life  

Unichic™ --- 16 years ago -

i guess it depends upon who's definition of "quality of life' you are using this man has a great life Yes, you are right, but like Denise posted, her little boy would have suffered through a lot without kidneys. That's not a quality life for a small child. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground