Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

A thought on treating students with kid gloves...

who's talking here?

GCan 2
ms_mm 2
Fiona 2
randyjet 1
Sandyr9111 1
Going off air 1
Mr Mark 3
HsMommy 3
ExLady In Blue 1
Jen 1
Allimama 1
JusticeForAll 1
Ogre1 4
JustGoWithIt 1
ladyjane 3
Niki 1
Sufferbus 1
Nightbirdsinging 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

You guys all remember what Mary Poppins said, right? "A spoon full of sugar helps the medicine go down..." We've turned this saying to mean, that if you find something "sweet" to say instead of something "bitter" it will be accepted better. So, instead of telling kids they are being wrong, or telling kids they did a poor job, the tendency today is to tell them "Nice try" or ignore their behavior all together. In my not-so-humble opinion, and no matter what the Psycho/psychiatr/sociologists say, this is Hogwash. In fact, as a chef, I know that a sugar and bitter do not bind, so when you have to take some bitter medicine, if you take it with sugar, all you get is a sickly sweet bitter flavor. HOWEVER, if you mix the bitter with some salt you get a different effect. Salt tends to bind to bitter flavors, chemically changing it to a more palatable, and thus, consumable product. So to follow that line of thought, (Plus the idea that modern kids are more like Klingons than Humans). I think it's better to be a bit "rough" with the kiddies when they screw up, they remember it better, and they respect you better for it. So really, Poppins was a bloody fool. The Banks kids would have been better off if Popeye had come to take care of them, because then they would have gotten both spinach (which is tasty and nutritious) and plenty of SALT! And since I spent eight years at sea, it is safe to assume that my kids will get a lot more salt than sugar! 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Alot of them do need it there is no doubt about it. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

I grew up with a daddy who emphasized that it was our responsibility to make this world better than when we found it. He wasn't afraid to hurt our feelings or tell us we were being stupid or acting like dumb-a**es. Praise wasn't handed out on a whim. If you did well on something he wasn't overly impressed. If you got a "good job", you were lucky. It was expected that we would do well because we had the ability and the brains. One of his favorite lines..."Use your head, it's not a hat rack." 

Going off air --- 16 years ago -

I am still for the good ol butt whoopin which may be illegal today (not sure) i agree ogre and think it is what is wrong with r country today There is no Personal Accountability 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

which may be illegal today (not sure) AH, to answer that question: In 2005, the Texas Attorney General issued an opinion stating that House Bill 383, adopted by the 79th Legislature, does not limit the authority of school personnel to administer corporal punishment pursuant to a policy adopted by the board of trustees. The law added a provision to the Texas Family Code providing that only the following persons may administer corporal punishment: “1) a parent or grandparent of the child; (2) a stepparent of the child who has the duty of control and reasonable discipline of the child; and (3) an individual who is a guardian of the child and who has the duty of control and reasonable discipline of the child.” So, it's not ILLEGAL to administer a few swats, but more than likely it IS against school policy. I intend to post house bill 383 in my classroom. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I intend to post house bill 383 in my classroom. That is great. I had a German professor who was a WWII Hungarian Army vet. He had a big paddle in the room for giving students a good swat. One time I had not done my homework, so I got called to the front, was bent over, and got a good swat. The guy was short, but built like a tank and he put POWER into his swing. It lifted me off the floor and over a desk. I can tell you that the FIRST homework I did was my German. I also still speak a fair amount of it to this day. 

HsMommy --- 16 years ago -

I intend to post house bill 383 in my classroom. This made me chuckle. What grade are you teaching? I honestly think it depends on the child your working with how you praise or don't praise him/her. 

Niki --- 16 years ago -

I honestly think it depends on the child your working with how you praise or don't praise him/her. I agree with this - my dh and I grew up in totally different types of homes. I lived in a house where praise was key and he lived in a home where negativity ruled. He is still somewhat a negative person from time to time and I am rarely negative. My mom had a poem on our wall called "Children Learn What They Live." I believe it is very true. I want my dd to know that you don't always win and it is ok to be wrong and no matter what always try your hardest, but I don't believe in being negative to her. I don't think anyone gains from that! 

Fiona --- 16 years ago -

Totally agree with niki...I have seen the effects of a child that was guided negatively and he does not have a great outlook on life. 

Jen --- 16 years ago -

School given physical discipline isn't allowed, and like the law says, it's now up to the parent. My nephew got in trouble at school and my sister was called up there to give him a spanking...she asked them if they were nuts. What he did didn't warrant getting a call to come whip him, but she did whip him for getting in trouble when he got home because of what he did. It's not up to the schools to discipline in that manner, it's the schools responsibility to report and let the parent make the judgement call, granted it's not always the right call. 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

Those school officials are more culpable than the kids that tormented and caused that girls suicide. We have all been either victims or bystanders of school violence as students. School officials see this everyday since the dawn of public school. Why they are not held to account gets me. As far as the students that are directly involved...They need therapy. We as a society live in a violent and mean environment. 

ExLady In Blue --- 16 years ago -

GCan, I think our fathers may have been separated at birth. On the other hand, my mom was the sweet and gentle one in the family. Spankings were very hard for her when Dad was not around (usually working). My dad always used to say, "every child has a weakness". Whether you give them a dirty look, spank them, take away privileges, something will eventually make them correct their behavior. P.S. Ogre, we agree on something, again. You might not want this to become a habit. :-) 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

GCan, I think our fathers may have been separated at birth. On the other hand, my mom was the sweet and gentle one in the family. My mom was the one who softened dad's rough edges. Probably too much. She'd cover for us a lot. But while she had tons of patience...it occasionally would run out. Then she could be scarier than dad! My dad always used to say, "every child has a weakness". Whether you give them a dirty look, spank them, take away privileges, something will eventually make them correct their behavior. Mine was having my dad or mom say they was disappointed in me. I would have rather been spanked. To this day, I could care less what anyone might call me but to hear from anyone that I respect that I have disappointed or let them down, just kills me. 

HsMommy --- 16 years ago -

Those school officials are more culpable than the kids that tormented and caused that girls suicide. We have all been either victims or bystanders of school violence as students. School officials see this everyday since the dawn of public school. Why they are not held to account gets me. I have already commented on this thread, but I am going to add to it. I don't think its fair for anyone to completely judge school officials and teachers for anything, if you have never walked into the school and spent time in a classroom and see the day-to-day running of a school. I spent eight years as a paraprofessional and I have seen my fair share of right and wrong, by both parents and school personel. I believe that the foundation of education should start at home. Parents need to teach their children right and wrong, not leave it all to the teachers. The teachers can't get everything taught as it is because they have to deal with behavior issues. . Some teachers and schools have little to no parent involvement and this not make for an easy day for anyone, children mainly. Children are not getting the help and knowledge to feed their minds like they should be, because of ongoing behavior problems that have to be dealt with. Corporal punishment is still allowed in the school district i work in, however the steps to actually getting to that point are unreal. I believe, honestly, it should still be allowed in schools, but parents are fighting against it. Yet, ironically when kids do wrong and do things like bullying parents get mad and blame the schools saying they haven't done anything about it. No one is totally to blame here. 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

No one is totally to blame here. Not so fast....First of all. 1. The foundation of education does start at home. 2. The teachers dont have to teach everything. however they and admin officials do have a responsibility to all concerned for the safety of those that report abuse as in the case of the girl that committed suicide. They did nothing. I have personal instances where bullying by other students were reported to teachers and principals and only when I intervened the matter was taken seriously. I said it b4. Those kids need therapy and those school officials involved need replacing, and re-training b4 being aloud back in a class-room or admin. position. 

HsMommy --- 16 years ago -

1. The foundation of education does start at home. The foundatino SHOULD start at home, unfortunately it does not always. This is becoming more of the norm. As far as this current case you are talking about I have not read it. So I can not comment. My last statment was just a general statement about the everday school day. Personally, I will not just let things go when it comes to things like bullying. I will do what I can do, as a future teacher, to stop it. 

Mr Mark --- 16 years ago -

Personally, I will not just let things go when it comes to things like bullying. I will do what I can do, as a future teacher, to stop it. Fair enough.. Thanks for being a teacher :D 

Nightbirdsinging --- 16 years ago -

intend to post house bill 383 in my classroom A real-life government lesson in English class! 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

I want to know the specifics on the suicide case of the Irish girl. What did the school know? That poor girl, I cannot imagine how tortured she must have been. My best friend from high school and I were talking about this just the other day. The "popular" cheerleader girls in our school weren't mean. They were actually some of the nicest girls in the school. I know that they had an honor code and it must have been enforced. That "Mean Girls" stuff did happen in middle school, but definitely not in high school. Did any of you see bullying going on when you were in high school? I saw some as a teacher. But man, those kids are sneaky. It's VERY hard to catch them. 

Fiona --- 16 years ago -

Our cheerleaders and drill team were held to honor code too they were never mean. I know bulling is hard to catch but when it is brought to the schools attention swift action should be taken. Call all of the kids and their parents in and in most cases the parents will put a stop to it. I think in the case of suicide due to bullying if the school did nothing than they are just as responsible as the kids that did the bullying and they should be right there held accountable. Bet then they would get there butt in to gear and do their part to help the victims of bullying. 

JustGoWithIt --- 16 years ago -

As with everything, there is a balance. You have to teach consequences and accountability. But also need to teach about redemption and self confidence. 

Sufferbus --- 16 years ago -

A lot of y'all's darling little /b/tards need the daylights beaten out of them. Do you prefer to straighten them out at home, or wait until they get stupid and get a shotgun blast to the chest to learn their lesson? 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

We have all been either victims or bystanders of school violence as students. School officials see this everyday since the dawn of public school. Why they are not held to account gets me. As far as the students that are directly involved...They need therapy. We as a society live in a violent and mean environment.  I totally agree. A lot of the meanness is directly related to our kids' environments - what are the boys supposed to be like when they watch violent movies and play violent video games all the time? What are the girls supposed to be like when so much of what they see of female behavior on tv, in movies, everywhere, encourages them to compete with each other for who's the sexiest, who's "attracted" (lol) the most boys, who's got the foulest mouth, etc. It's hard for parents to find and highlight good role models for kids - you can see the pressures on them right here on KU (recall chats in which parents are told how ridiculous it is - in cruder terms - to choose not to take their kids to places like Hooters, etc.). But parents need to stay strong against these influences. And we should expect school administrators to stand stronger, too. They've gotten so afraid of being called "bullies," racist, stupid, etc. to use their common sense and DISCIPLINE some of the punks who run our schools today. I just want to tell some of them - hey, man-(or woman-)up and take a stand! 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

And by the way, Ogre, I see your point, but I got to give props to the Poppin. The reason she was so successful with those kids was that she was really available to them, when their parents were just doing their own thing. She taught them frustration tolerance, problem solving, persistence, and using their creativity to make life better - More people today need to remember to conjure up their own "spoon full of sugar," as in find the good in stuff and quit whining, rather than waiting around, bored and unhappy, for someone else to intervene. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

What grade are you teaching? I'm not, yet. Take the TEXES on May 1. I'll take it the second time 60 days later (hopefully not..but the math, d@mnit, the math!!!) but I got to give props to the Poppin. I have actually never seen Mary Poppins. For all I know she was an umbrella flying old witch (Could she secretly be the mother of The Penguin?) who made Nurse Cratchet look like Mother Teresa. But I'll take your word for it that she was a good nanny. 

ms_mm --- 16 years ago -

"Use your head, it's not a hat rack." I love it! 

ms_mm --- 16 years ago -

Mine was having my dad or mom say they was disappointed in me. Exactly - I remember my father saying "I just want you to know I'm very disappointed." - I was so hurt. From my experience teaching, I don't think there are many households today that operate the way ours did. 

JusticeForAll --- 16 years ago -

Ogre, I think there's a happy medium here. I also think from what I gather in the way you post, you have a strong presence about you that demands respect. I don't see the kids trying to walk on you or act out...I think you could probably get away with "the look" and never have to say a word...lol. :) 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

I think there's a happy medium here. Well, yah, there always is a happy medium. The challenge lies in finding it. I don't mean to say you have to be tyrant to demand respect. The students that I'm dealing with now all (well, maybe not all) show the proper respect to me. But I haven't had them all year like my mentor has. Today I had the "JOY" of assisting a substitute teacher though, if I hadn't had been there, our third block would have just run her over. I felt for the woman, especially since I had to leave her alone with the next class. But because the kids knew that I meant business, they were, if not perfect, acceptable. as to the "look"... my father has it, he can look at a child of almost any age, (and it works on Dogs also) not say a word and that child will stop what they are doing and pay attention to him. I've never mastered it to that level. Though I do tend to get through with non-verbal signals (like making eye contact w/ a student and pointing to his desk or paper). 

ladyjane --- 16 years ago -

You guys all remember what Mary Poppins said, right? "A spoon full of sugar helps the medicine go down..." We've turned this saying to mean, that if you find something "sweet" to say instead of something "bitter" it will be accepted better. The Popster was able to be strict and hold high standards for the kids without being highly punitive because she demonstrated respect for them by encouraging, speaking civilly, modeling high expectations for them, etc. She was able to do these things because she made herself more available to the kids than their parents. (If you see the movie, you'll note that the kids are largely ignored, though loved, by their parents before Poppins). This is what's missing for many kids today - that relationship that communicates high expectations but also gives kids something they want and need - a real connection with an adult. When a kid has this relationship, they can accept surprisingly "bitter" (i.e., corrective) comments without coming unglued, because they have an abundance of the "sweet," the positive recognition they need. Poor teachers are often in the job of filling this need for kids more than they had to in the past. The ones who are able to make those connections have fewer problems with kids - look at some of the coaches kids would just, well, eat dirt for, and the ones they all hate. I guarantee, the difference in their relationships makes my point. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground