Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

I don't usually agree in large court settlements......

who's talking here?

randyjet 5
needrnr 1
*Annie* 2
AuthorMan 4
ladybeachbum 1
d:-] 1
outspoken1 1
HsMommy 1
~sassy~ 1
Catgirl Loves Animal_Control 1
Perfection 1
justcat 3
Ogre1 2
moltobella 1
AwesomeTattooedDragon 1
truthmiser 1
Roadrunner 1
workingmommiex2 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

justcat --- 16 years ago -

And I am not necessarily a Walmart hater.. BUT I am actually glad to see this in this case.. 9 million awarded  

*Annie* --- 16 years ago -

I can see receiving something but isn't $9M excessive? Granted, much of that will be negotiated down and gone for legal expenses but isn't that "too much?" What sort of hardships were there / will there be to merit that much money? 

justcat --- 16 years ago -

I just like the message it sent.. If you remember the story. This lady sold her car to pay for her college tuition. She was paid in WALMART money orders,that if questioned,could have been easily verified.But the police were called,and she was arrested on the spot,without the police investigation or question it. This was in Meyerland BTW... She was singled out,plain and simple,and thrown in jail for 2 days... No,it doesn't warrant that much of a judgment, but it sends a huge message to Walmart.. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

What message to Walmart? It is their insurance company that will pay it - and then they will charge Walmart more for insurance and Walmart will in turn charge you more for items. Yeah, good idea to have big settlements for two days of jail. 

justcat --- 16 years ago -

lol great message not...Lets do anything we want to our customers,cause its just insurance that will pay... yeah,cause thats the way business think. And no,it wont cost me a dime,cause I don't shop there. 

Roadrunner --- 16 years ago -

What they did was wrong and a form of bullying. The only way to make an impact on a large company like Walmart is to have big financial penalties. That is especially true if you want to have less regulatory oversight. This will hopefully cause them to act more cautiously in the future which is a good thing since the same thing could have happened to anyone of us. Penalties like this, if impacting the bottom line, will hurt their stockholder's. It will not impact the consumer much because the price competition in the market place is too great right now. 

Catgirl Loves Animal_Control --- 16 years ago -

Deleted by me, sorry I am slow this morning. 

moltobella --- 16 years ago -

It is their insurance company that will pay it - and then they will charge Walmart more for insurance and Walmart will in turn charge you more for items. It's a good thing I don't shop at Wal-Mart. ;D But really I don't lol 

*Annie* --- 16 years ago -

Target gets my money. Just a little more expensive but would rather shop there any day over WM! In reality, the 9m expense will be passed on to the shoppers. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

I think it is sad that companies have to pay for the idiotic mistakes of employees. BTW- the 9m will not stand up in appeal- excessive. 

workingmommiex2 --- 16 years ago -

I wonder what the family got for the door greater being trampled to death during the "Early Bird" door busters? Seems Walmart has had too maney problems with lawsuits, remember the one with the woman who was hit by truck got a seetlement then Walmart wanted the settlement money to repay what they paid in her medical insurance Walmart has taken may jobs from small business that cant compete...Chalk one up for the little guy ! Im glad she won,they were "profiling" for sure ! Though they will appeal, it will be alot less when its over.Hope they dont pay her in Money Orders! 

AwesomeTattooedDragon --- 16 years ago -

I don't understand-is the tort reform bill we passed simply to let doctors off? 

outspoken1 --- 16 years ago -

It is my understanding that the monitary amount can not be changed. The woman will get her $9 million. However, they can change how it is to be paid to her. For example, $ amount for a year, over ? years. WalMart must show that they can not pay the $9 million by the time that was settled upon. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

I dont know what type of price I could put on the humiliation she had to go through. I would not want to be locked up in the county jail for 2 days, with real criminals. If they confiscated her money how did she pay for her college tuition? That incident may have kept her from enrolling that semester. Yes like someone else posted, they could have easily traced the money orders. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I don't understand-is the tort reform bill we passed simply to let doctors off? This reminds me........instead of BO going after doctors who file millions and millions of dollars in fraudulent medicaid/medicare claims, what does he do instead? Hikes what they now get.....anything to get health care passed I guess. Sorry for the hijack :) 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

I dont know what type of price I could put on the humiliation she had to go through. I would not want to be locked up in the county jail for 2 days, with real criminals. At $1,000 per hour, two days is $48,000. $187,500 per hour is a bit much. 

d:-] --- 16 years ago -

I'm with the lady on this one. The department stores have way too much power when it comes to these situations. 

ladybeachbum --- 16 years ago -

All this will do is make ALL business be more careful what each employee does which means we pay for all the crooks that will now get away with fraudulent mo, cashier's checks, and bills. She should have received money, maybe even her tuition paid but not 9 m. 

truthmiser --- 16 years ago -

Wonder is there is any validity in the story that the woman was arrested on outstanding traffic warrants which may have put her in jail for 2 days? 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

In reality, the 9m expense will be passed on to the shoppers. No Walmart will simply cut the low wages of its Chinese workers to make up for it. They cannot have a union, so they can get away with it. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

I don't understand-is the tort reform bill we passed simply to let doctors off? YES By limiting the damages that can be assessed for pain, and suffering and non-monetary damages it has made it less likely to find a lawyer willing to take such cases on a contingency fee basis. You can sue anybody for anything if you have the money for it. You are SOL if you don't. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

She should have received money, maybe even her tuition paid but not 9 m. Well I hope that you don't vote Republican for Texas Attorney General then. Mr. Abbott got TEN million for being hit by a falling tree when he was out jogging. He must have been a really slow or clueless jogger. He is against such awards for OTHERS, and has done his best to let big companies off the hook and limited awards for real medical malpractice. HIS pain and suffering was worth 10 million, but YOURS is worth only $250,000 MAX no matter how many operations you need to get better. Typical GOPer! 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

I can see receiving something but isn't $9M excessive? I'm not reading all this, but here's an answer to that. PUNITIVE AWARDS are meant to punish. Since Walmart is a massive corporation with income in the billions, (a bit over $4bn in '08) I would ask, is $9,000,000 enough? Should it all go to the litigant? (Well no, 22% of it should go to her attorneys..but then, I would think that wouldn't I?) The current school of thought is that it should ... it's called the courthouse lottery. If a person has the wherewithal to go through with a civil suit against Goliath, then they reap the benefits. The next case of this nature will pay out less (Mainly because it will probably be settled out of court). Generally, when people talk of tort reform what they're really saying is "AWARDED DAMAGES" reform. The solution is NOT to limit the amount of damages received, because no one can really predict how much damage will be done. So, like many, I don't necessarily think the litigant should be made wealthy on punitives, but the punitives MUST be punishing enough that the behavior is discouraged. The ONLY tort reform I want to see (in relation to this) is that the company should NOT be allowed to pass on this expense to the consumer, but should be required to pass it FIRST on to the stockholders. And then the stockholders can decide if the company is moving in the right direction and decide whether to punish the board members or not. 

Ogre1 --- 16 years ago -

OH, plus, Walmart will have insurance to cover this sort of thing. So really, the only people paying out will be the insurance company which ALSO will be making billions. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

(Well no, 22% of it should go to her attorneys..but then, I would think that wouldn't I?) Is that all? When I was looking at a lawsuit, they were going to take 40% on a contingency basis. I doubt that this woman had enough money to pay up front for the costs of a lawsuit. I also have NO problem with the lawyers getting 40% since they invest a lot of time and their OWN money in a risky business. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

Punish all entities that make any money, especially if they make a lot. Wonderful strategy. 

HsMommy --- 16 years ago -

The news didn't say, but I'm sure the reason she was arrested was for the traffic tickets she had. There is no way the police had legal grounds to arrest her otherwise. Why did she not sue the police with faulse arrest? The walmart EMPLOYEE were wrong in how they handled this, but the amount the lady was awarded is way to much. 

randyjet --- 16 years ago -

There is no way the police had legal grounds to arrest her otherwise. If the store manager says that the money orders, especially since they were WalMart ones, were either stolen or forged, the cop had no choice but to make the arrest. Punish all entities that make any money, especially if they make a lot. You miss the point. Walmart was NOT punished for making money, but falsely accusing and JAILING an innocent person who had committed no crime. It was especially egregious since a simple check could have shown that the checks were good. Walmart has to be punished in a way that makes them LESS likely to do such things in the future. A couple thousand dollars will not even be a blip on their corporate business. A million dollar award WILL get their attention. Thus the reason for that high award. It is like charging a $2 fine for speeding. It is hardly a deterent and basically invites people to speed. 

AuthorMan --- 16 years ago -

You miss the point. I am not the one who missed it. LOL 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground