Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Would you skip your child a grade level?

who's talking here?

Sweetie Pie 1
GCan 1
RoseSr 1
planemom 1
needrnr 1
lizandmike 1
auntmarsa 3
Mabbers 2
HsMommy 1
chunksNbones 1
~sassy~ 5
Lillabeth 3
~Songbird~ 1
PHSMOMOF2 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

Just about every year we've been asked if we would like to skip our oldest into the next grade level. Every year I tell them NO. I'm just wondering if I'm some how failing my son by not allowing him to be in a class were he has to "dumb" it down. He is in 6th grade in all Honors, and is getting all A's. In fact several 100's. So what do you guys think? I'll be back in a little while. I've gotta go finish making dinner. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I say go for it, otherwise, you risk stiffling his ability to learn at his level. The pack will hold him back. 

GCan --- 16 years ago -

Depending on his age, I might ask how he would feel moving up. That's just to start. I'd also analyze where he's at as far as maturity level. Some kids are very bright but they are not as socially advanced and that could be problematic. Then take into consideration that the other kids might know he was moved up and give him some grief as well. Other things I would consider is keeping him in the same grade but having the teacher provide some alternative or extra assignments that are geared towards his abilities. My son's teachers have done this over the last few years. He sometimes has to expand upon a particular assignment that the class is working on. 

Sweetie Pie --- 16 years ago -

What grade are you talking about? If it's in one of the elementary grades I would not. It will start to become more challenging in the upper grades when the teachers can tailor things for the students. Maturity is often what lags behind when elementary school kids get moved up. Not to mention when older everybody else will be older, driving, etc. and he will be a year younger. 

auntmarsa --- 16 years ago -

Elizabeth, what grade is he in? I skipped 3rd grade but it was a lot of years ago. To be completely honest, I never really missed it. I would hesitate, though, if he's higher than that since they're getting out of the remedial type of things. It really was a relief since, in second grade, I was always the first one finished with assignments and then I was bored. I'm not sure if I was doing anything wrong while I waited but the teacher would send me to the hall to sit when I finished early. I spent a LOT of time alone in the hall that year so 4th grade was great and I don't recall feeling "behind" in any sense - not academically nor socially. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I'll ad this. I have friends who held smart kids back due to social/maturity level and have regretted it. Smart kids - and I'm talking REALLY smart kids, can't help but become bored if they aren't challenged. That's what school does. Take away the challenge, what's left? 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

He is in 6th grade. I do worry about the maturity level issues, which is why we have said NO. 

auntmarsa --- 16 years ago -

Do the people who recommend this option think he's mature enough? I'm curious. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

I don't think so, but that's just me. Guys are a tad different though. My parents were asked to skip me and they refused which I ended up being thankful cuz it just would've been weird. LOL. But weirder still for guys. Middle ds has found honors to be quite easy so far as well, straight A's and what-not, not even doing much homework either but this also allows for the extracurriculars to be less of a strain. It all works out in the end. Neither me or my kids are geniuses though and are hardly brain surgeons so it's a non-issue. :D 

Lillabeth --- 16 years ago -

auntmarsa --- 1 min ago - quote - flag comment Do the people who recommend this option think he's mature enough? I'm curious. LOL, they SEEM to think he is, but he is my son and I don't want him to feel left out maturity wise or education wise. So I'm torn. 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

He is in 6th grade. I do worry about the maturity level issues, which is why we have said NO. One year is not that big a deal, imo, but you know him best. He'll fit in socially I feel. Intelligence wise, I can't imagine spending a whole year unchallenged. I'd die of boredom. 

Mabbers --- 16 years ago -

Hell I've been bored my whole life sass. LOL. 

~Songbird~ --- 16 years ago -

I will say that that is a kid to kid basis. I wish I would have moved up. I ended up so bored with school, it killed everything I could have accomplished bc I didn't care anymore. There was no longer any challenge. I quit trying, because I no longer had to. I used to love school...then I got bored and ended up hating it. I wish they would have moved me up a grade instead of keeping me back. However, i was EMOTIONALLY mature as well. I had more friends in higher grades than i did in my own. I think that the kid should be both mentally AND emotionally ahead of his/her age group. Lacking one or the other would be a no. You know your son the best and what is best for him. :) 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Hell I've been bored my whole life sass. LOL. rofl. Funny, artsy types do tend to experience boredom more than most, but damn they're entertaining for the rest of us! 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

will say that that is a kid to kid basis. I wish I would have moved up. I ended up so bored with school, it killed everything I could have accomplished bc I didn't care anymore. There was no longer any challenge. Thar ya go......just what I said :) 

HsMommy --- 16 years ago -

I had the option of putting my DD straight into the 1st grade this year, but struggled with the decision. I decided to keep her in K because of her maturity level. She does go to first grade for reading and she loves it. 

auntmarsa --- 16 years ago -

I don't think I would as late as 6th grade. Mine was a little easier because we moved the year I skipped and so it wasn't like all of my friends were down the hall in another grade. 

RoseSr --- 16 years ago -

Mine was a little easier because we moved the year I skipped and so it wasn't like all of my friends were down the hall in another grade. Take it from one who skipped a full grade - in two halves. I feel like I wasn't ready on a social level. I've always advised those asking not to let their child skip. The social element is just as important as the learning thing. 

chunksNbones --- 16 years ago -

I dunno....I was offered the opportunity to skip a grade in junior high and I didn't take it simply because I wanted to stay with my friends. It was stupid though, because I ended up finishing a year early anyway.... I'd definitely consider moving my son up a grade in 6th grade vs in high school....but that's just me. 

needrnr --- 16 years ago -

Imo if it was me I would have done it before mid school. They have so much social/peer pressure in this age group, let him continue being top of the class. There are so many things you can do at this grade level to expand his mind. For me it just makes me realize he just will graduate and leave home a year earlier, maybe 1 year earlier than I AM ready for.... ;0) 

lizandmike --- 16 years ago -

1st, let me say I haven't read the whole thread. I would absolutely not skip him. There are so many challenges he will face in high school. Let him have that extra year to be ready. I was one of the youngest in my class and always got along better with those a year behind me. When he's a junior and just driving, when all his friends have been driving for a year etc. He will be behind the pack physically and emotionally for some time. It's great that he's smart. And a dedicated student, sounds like. But don't make the social and emotional aspects of school that much harder. When he gets to high school, he can tale AP and dual credit classes if he wants to to get ahead, but IMO as a parent of a high school boy and as a teacher, I wouldn't skip a grade. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 16 years ago -

I have a 13 year old son, who since he has been in the 3rd grade has excelled in school. We would get calls from his teachers because he would misbehave not because he would not do the work but because he was bored.... he would finish the work way ahead of the class. Would get upset because the teacher would not pick him not giving the other kids a chance. He is very mature for his age, So for years we tried to figure out what the issue was. We thought about skipping him but being in the military they dont really do that. So now he is in the 8th grade taking all advance classes and is doing waay beyond our expectations. He has two older brothers and his social skills are right on target. He is a great leader as well. Holding him and hindering may not be a great idea, some kids need that challenge too. He may feel being in a classromm with kids that are not up to his level he may feel he should regress. Good luck to you!!!!. 

planemom --- 16 years ago -

For me it just makes me realize he just will graduate and leave home a year earlier, I'm making my child that will only be 17 when she is able to go off to college take classes at Lonestar for a year. If not there, she can live at home and go to U of H for a year. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground