Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Bil Jac puppy food

who's talking here?

QueenCassie 1
Sandyr9111 2
SoftT 1
Peace out 1
PHSMOMOF2 4
jtcitrus 7
tinman 4
alreadygone~~ 4
NICKLE PICKLE 1
karma 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

PHSMOMOF2 --- 16 years ago -

I have a quick question, last night I went to petsmart, I wanted to change my dog's food. I have a 21wk old yorkie, I am currently feeding him Nurta holistic puppy food. So I walk in and a bil jack rep is there, ok so she sold me. I go online now and that food has a one star. I am a little disappointed but my dog ate it. I am returning it because I only want to feed him the best. Any suggestions. That bil jac has horrible ratings and nothing good in it. She told me nothing but great things. So please help!!!! Thanks guys. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

I like Taste of the Wild @ Tractor Supply which is 5 stars BUT for a lil doggie my Harley Belle LOVED Ziwi Peak @ Pampered Paws. Its a dry raw and is a lil softer than kibble...looksd kinda like lil jerky pcs but its a lil expensive. 

tinman --- 16 years ago -

Not sure where you are reading your reviews. I typed in bil jac and this site was the first to pop up with reviews http://www.rateitall.com/i-24980-bil-jac.aspx and three or four more links down is this one.... http://www.epinions.com/review/Bil_Jac_Select_Dog_Food/content_37194337924 I use bil jac and I happen to know the young lady who reps it here locally. She is also well known here on this board and would not risk her reputation on this board or in the "doggie community" in order to "sell" anyone, and in particular, you, on a particular type of dog food. As with all things, you have a choice and the right to exercise that choice. At the end of your post you asked for suggestions. Here's one. I will suggest that before you stir things up on this board, you might want to take a minute and do a little more exhaustive research than you have. 

Sandyr9111 --- 16 years ago -

Only dog food site Ive ever used is www.dogfoodanalysis.com. Tinman maybe she didnt know of any other info. She wasnt stirring trouble, least today anyway! She wants the best food for her furbaby. 

alreadygone~~ --- 16 years ago -

The original Bil Jac (frozen brick) was top notch and used by the Iditerod races for years for maximum caloric intake and energy generation. As years passed, the manufacturers wanted a bigger share of the pet food market. Realizing that frozen was an unlikley form to be mass merchandised, they produced a "dry" kibble which, from a quality standpoint, is only a distant relative to it's higher quality frozen form. There are SOOOO many affordable, high quality alternatives on the market today! I personally would seek out an alternative. I know Kent at the Pet Ranch is extremely knowledgeable about pet food... you might want to drop in there and discuss some alternatives. 

karma --- 16 years ago -

Bil-Jac is chock full of by-products, fillers, and molasses(this is one of their tricks to how they say your dog will love it guaranteed because what dog wouldn't love something sweet?). Reps are their to market and sell a product to you, they will tell you what you want to hear to persuade you, it's their job and they are good at it. At the dog show last year I walked up to a bil-jac rep who was trying to sell me on their food. He told me it was very nutritional and high quality. I looked at the ingredients saw the first one(by product) and laughed in his face. I feel sorry for the dog owners who actually get duped into buying this crap bc reps lie to them. Sucks for the dogs. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

here are the rules for good dogfood: 1) no corn, wheat, or soy 2) 1st ingredient is a specific meat 3) 3 out of 5 top ingredients are specific meats/meat prouducts 4) majority of starch comes from whole grains or potatoes & the like 5) No dog food is perfect. mix it up: change brands &/or flavors once in a while. give a good canned food or a whole raw egg sometimes, and always spare some veggies from the kitchen (carrots etc.) 

tinman --- 16 years ago -

Sandy.... I agree that Brooklyn didn't know of any other info because she didn't educate herself prior to purchasing the food. I am betting that Brooklyn would not have changed baby formula for her baby without checking into it first. So, Brooklyn buys this food, does a quick check of the product on the internet after she gets home with it, gets buyer's remorse, and then publicly blames the retail rep for inducing her into making what she thought was a bad decision. That's what ticks me off the most. Hey Brooklyn, how about you take ownership for your decision? The young lady at Petsmart didn't hold a gun to your head and she sure didn't threaten you if you didn't buy. But, I bet she gave you a coupon or something like that to induce you to buy the food and that's all it took for you to do so. If you don't like the food, then that's your prerogative. But please don't come on here and insinuate that someone talked you into buying an inferior brand just so you can feel better about your buyer's remorse. BTW, I use Bil-Jac and both of my dogs (Great Dane and a German Shepherd) think this stuff is the equivalent of crack cocaine. They have never looked better and they both act like puppies. I've gone from free feeding to feeding them twice a day which is better for them. They were on Purina Pro Plan. I have nothing against Purina, but I am convinced that Bil-Jac is better. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

www.dogfoodanalysis.com www.thedogfoodproject.com www.consumerresearch.com these & some googleing is where you can find this info 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 16 years ago -

Tinman, I am not going to lower myself to your level. I am not blaming anyone, since you want to be a total jerk. You are right she did not put a gun to my head. I did buy it willingly. I will not feed it to him anymore I am returning it today. will suggest that before you stir things up on this board, you might want to take a minute and do a little more exhaustive research than you have. I am stirring up a DAMN thing.... you might be trying to but I am not nor will I. So for those of you who would like to continue suggesting please do so I appreciate it very much. 

NICKLE PICKLE --- 16 years ago -

I stick with the holistic dog foods. I like Nature's Variety Prairie or Instinct formulas. Instinct is high in protein with no grains, dogs don't need grains!! Also, Wellness is a good food. The holistic brands use higher quality protein. No by-products!! Good luck! 

alreadygone~~ --- 16 years ago -

5) No dog food is perfect. mix it up: change brands &/or flavors once in a while. give a good canned food or a whole raw egg sometimes, and always spare some veggies from the kitchen (carrots etc.) Poor advice. A stable feeding regime is best for your pet. Consistency begets stable metabolism. 

tinman --- 16 years ago -

That bil jac has horrible ratings and nothing good in it. She told me nothing but great things. So please help!!!! LOL....that cracks me up. I would love to see the review you read. Please post a link to it. I provided you with reviews that say the exact opposite. In case you still don't get it, the fact that you say the food has horrible things in it and that she told you nothing but great things infers that she lied to you. That's the reason for my response. In fact, this entire thread isn't about the food as much as it is about your insinuations about the person at Petsmart and what you were willing to type in order to make yourself feel better. And before you get all up on your high horse, remember, no one told you it was a good idea to post what you did. When you took the time to do that, you also invited the criticism that came along with your post. You want to call me a jerk, then fine. I'm here and can defend myself. The person at Petsmart isn't here, but I am and now you've made me mad. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

I didn't say give them something different every day. give an egg 2 to 3 times a month, or one can every now and then. I sometimes take the high quality free samples and mix those in... again, only once in a while. switch of your main dog food for maybe one or two bags out of the year (and as always gradually transition the dog back an forth) the fact is that EVERY dog food will be deficient in some way and you don't want a persistent deficiency. dogs didn't eat the same thing every day in the wild, why should they do it in your home? adding carrots and the like to their food is an awesome treat, and healthy for them. stability? Feed them mostly the same dog food at a usual time, and in pack pecking order. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

and Tinman, to be fair to you, Bil Jac is a good dog food... compared to most of the complete garbage that's sold. But that doesn't make it high quality, or premium. Brooklyn: I feed my dogs Chicken Soup for the pet lover's soul. It's not the best, but I think it's the best for the money. Unfortunately it's not widely available so check the website for availability you might also want to check out Innova Evo, Cannidae, Origen. they aint cheap, but without going to homemade, their as good as it gets: others: wellness, california natural... there are more, check the websites I listed above for more info / third party reviews (by people not selling the product) 

karma --- 16 years ago -

Tinman, of course it's like crack to them, did you read my post? Bil-jac has molasses in it which no dog is going to turn down. That's part of their marketing scheme. And I am glad you got your dogs off of free feeding and created a schedule. German Shepherds and Great Danes are at very high risks for bloat so it is very scary and not safe for you to free feed those breeds. They especially should not be exercising 30 mins to an hour before and after meals because it increase the chance of bloat so you can see why free feeding is not good for deep chested/large breeds. 

alreadygone~~ --- 16 years ago -

stability? Feed them mostly the same dog food at a usual time, and in pack pecking order. thank you... much clearer...you obviously understand nutrition/pet food but your original statement would lead the average person to go food hopping! And tinman, who put the burr in your britches... you are sure taking this awful personally... It seems to me Brooklyn, NYC was simply putting her question out there for feedback..CHILL! 

QueenCassie --- 16 years ago -

Brooklyn, I have a 2 yr old Yorkie and 3 yr old Cocker Spaniel. I feed them 75% Natures Variety Kibble/25% Natures Variety Raw.. They get fed 2x a day, and this food has done wonders for their activity level, coats, and overall health. I would encourage you to go talk to the people at Pampered Paws, they can give you good advice on different foods and what would be best for your dog. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

thank you... much clearer...you obviously understand nutrition/pet food but your original statement would lead the average person to go food hopping! you're right I should have been more clear... I was typing one handed at the time while bottle feeding my daughter :) 

alreadygone~~ --- 16 years ago -

you're right I should have been more clear... I was tying one handed at the time while bottle feeding my daughter :) LOL! 

karma --- 16 years ago -

I personally am a huge fan of EVO :) my husky looks and does beautiful on it. Thinking of switching the Dobe to it since it has double the protein that his current kibble does(natural balance) and he needs the extra because he's pretty insanely active. A raw egg mixed in with kibble 1-2x a week for large dogs and 1x a week for small dogs will give their coats a boost. When the egg is cooked though it loses the nutrients that help the dog. So no scrambled for the coat :) 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 16 years ago -

I went to dog food anaylsis.com and saw that review for bil jac. But its ok I am changing his food to something else. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

When the egg is cooked though it loses the nutrients that help the dog. So no scrambled for the coat :) be carefull though something like 1/10,000 raw eggs has salmonella in it... ;) 

Peace out --- 16 years ago -

Brooklyn...what size bag did you buy? 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 16 years ago -

I want to say this, The rep was wonderful sweet and very kind. I can not go by everything I read. I have to make the choice to either continue feeding him this or finding something else. I want him to have a shiny coat and have a great long healthy life. I do want to be on a organic holistic food, so I will continue doing my research. Again thank you to the rep who help me. It was not your fault, I appreciate what you did. you were a sweetheart. I am not here to ruin anyone's reputation. 

SoftT --- 16 years ago -

Our vet told me that Bil Jac is terrible for leaving tartar on their teeth. My daughter has a Wheaten Terrier and is very careful not to feed him anything with gluten, etc. Check with your vet or check the Yorkshire website. 

tinman --- 16 years ago -

Karma, Here is a link to a website that describes bloat and the causes of bloat. http://www.globalspan.net/bloat.htm I suggest you read it. Here is another link for you to look at. http://www.bil-jac.com/products.php That's Bil Jac's website and more specifically, the page that lists the ingredients for the Large Breed brand of their food. I don't see molasses as an ingredient, but that doesn't mean it's not there. Let me know if I'm wrong about that. Brooklyn, I appreciate you saying the things you did about the rep at Petsmart. As far as I am concerned, the matter is closed. 

jtcitrus --- 16 years ago -

NoNo's in Bold: Bil Jac Select Adult "Chicken, Chicken By-Products (organs only, source of arginine), Corn Meal, Chicken By-Product Meal, Dried Beet Pulp, Brewers Dried Yeast, Oatmeal and Flaxseed." ps. beet pulp is sugar and a little bit of fiber The recipe is the same for all of their products: - Corn Meal is the third most plentiful ingredient - Chicken and Chicken By-Products(organs only) change places, and some of the relative amounts change between products - by adding the flax, the dogs get oils to make their coats shinier. like I said, bil Jac isn't terrible, but its not in the same league as some others. If they used brown rice or sweet potato as a starch instead of corn meal I would say that they warrant further investigation into any other additives ingredient quality. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground