Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

teachers in Hisd threaten mass walk outs over recent board ruling

who's talking here?

freshhell 1
cmi 2
randyjet 1
Sandyr9111 2
movedagain 1
Mabbers 4
HsMommy 2
~sassy~ 7
Catgirl Loves Animal_Control 6
Perfection 17
pollyanna 1
yeahsowhat 1
realitycheck 11
Allimama 1
ladyjane 1
iheartboxers 10
Shenanigans 1
evolved 2
Sufferbus 25
MxMike. 17
canobeans 1
susie q 1
*Goatlady* 1
couldbetrue 9
Tipsyhic 1
pharlap 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

What the heck?? Something about "evosa". It's meant to serve as a means of tracking incompetent teachers??? Can't find anything on it, but why would teachers ever threaten to walk out? 

pharlap --- 16 years ago -

I think it is because teachers might get fired if their students do not perform well on the TAKS/standardized tests.....Well, for teachers like me, who enjoy teaching the lower level/more challenging/probably not going to college high school math students - this new ruling would not be good for me. I think the schools will have a hard time keeping teachers in the difficult/lower achieving classes or schools. Among other things too, but I haven't heard the whole details on HISD's ruling. :) 

Allimama --- 16 years ago -

Although it is not politically correct to say it, a child's performance on the TAKS is due more to their zip code than their teacher. There are exceptions, and a good teacher can bring kids up that are right on the verge of passing. But no teacher can make up for what didn't happen in the home. 

Shenanigans --- 16 years ago -

Just one more way the TAKS test helps ruin education in HISD. Like teachers weren't worried about it enough as it is, now this. I feel sorry for the teachers in HISD sometimes who are just trying to enjoy their job. 

iheartboxers --- 16 years ago -

I think this move is just going to make it harder for Title 1 schools to get and retain good teachers. I don't see why it's necessary to go this far to ditch poor performing teachers. 

couldbetrue --- 16 years ago -

Although it is not politically correct to say it, a child's performance on the TAKS is due more to their zip code than their teacher. There are exceptions, and a good teacher can bring kids up that are right on the verge of passing. But no teacher can make up for what didn't happen in the home. The data also gauges growth for kids that do well. In some cases the higher level kids barely show growth, and aren't getting pushed. The schools that have used data for student growth have had success with both high and lower level students. I believe it is easier to move kids from lower performance to higher performance, so the teachers most impacted will probably those working with the higher kids. If you want to compare how kids that live in an area just like yours do go to the National Center for Accountability. The TAKS test is not a super demanding test, so celebrating "passing" does not mean much when in some cases the passing score is @ 60%. The stats say the "commended" performance is more likely a college bound score. In life, you have to pass an SAT to get into college, a Board, or an LSAT, so test taking is part of life. In the end, only your ability to stick it out will determine whether you finish school, college, etc. Not test scores alone. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Every job is measured on performance, some fair some not so fair. Teachers and politicians have seemed to be exempt from this and from the consequences of poor performance for years. Now is finally the time when they will be held accountable for their performance. Welcome to adulthood. Nothing is guaranteed, you succeed based upon performance not seniority. 

pharlap --- 16 years ago -

ChunkyHeifer, I would also say there should be a way to hold the parents accountable for what their kids do once they leave school...like actually doing their homework, etc... I, as a teacher, get SO angry when people say stuff like that. Of course, we are held accountable for how/what we teach - it is called appraisals. Title 1 schools (where I teach is one of them) have MANY students that live in such poverty, that the only meals they get are while they are at school...Some have such bad home-lives that they can barely function at school. There is NO WAY what-so-ever that some kids like some of the HISD schools can compare to schools that aren't Title 1 - like Kingwood High School. I do think they are really going to have a hard time retaining teachers that do not teach to the higher achieving kids (which most of the time is DIRECTLY related to the PARENT'S involvement with THEIR kids). I am sorry to sound this angry, but it makes me so mad. People who are not teachers, or do not know what teachers go through/deal with should not "throw stones...." 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Jennifer, every one has something that makes their jobs difficult yet they are judged on it every day, fairly or unfairly that's how it is. My partner is a teacher as well and has taught in some of the roughest neighborhoods in Houston so yes I do know what I am speaking of. Every one knows what a job is like and the difficulties of it when they take the job. They also know the perks. Teachers have some great perks for what they have to put up with. Ya can't have all the good without any accountability. 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

Very typical to compare private sector jobs to that of teachers - your comparison is fatally flawed because of the variables involved. In the private sector, much of what you deal with is standardized, quality controlled, researched and developed before a great deal of money is invested. In other words, the "parts" you get are engineered to work unless an idiot puts them together. If your "standardized" product fails, then of course there should be consequences. The "parts" teachers get to work with are not standardized or quality controlled. They are living, breathing unique children, each one different with unknown potential, rather they are the "raw materials". The TAKS and other testing they undergo IS the research and development, but teachers don't get to decide or pick and choose which ones to invest in, or only work with proven products that are deemed of "quality" and guaranteed for success. They take what they are given every year, every day, and do the very best they can to make the most of the "raw products", which may be crack babies, fetal alcohol babies, learning disabled children, emotionally or physically abused children, gifted children, average children, children who have NEVER been read to or taught any social skills, children of privilege, children who doubt their own abilities and trust no one, children who will only be able to eat at school because there is no food at home, children who have no home, and the list goes on. The only common and predictable factor or "part" with which teachers have to work is that these are "children". The potential of the "product" is unpredictable, and the variables are impossible to control. So you see, this comparison is hardly valid. Oh, and for comparing teachers to politicians, um, well, that is one totally messed up foul comparison. Teachers are grossly underpaid, are not in it for ANY recognition, and are certainly never lavished praises in the public eye, or have their own money to praise themselves in the public eye, and you'll never see lobbyists at their office (because teachers don't have one. Oh, and if you count a box lunch from Jason's Deli as a kickback from a textbook company, then they should all be fired. I dare anyone to step into a teacher's shoes for one week, but I doubt they would return after one day... Any other comparisons?? 

pollyanna --- 16 years ago -

You got lunch from Jason's Deli? Lucky duck.. =) 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

"Teachers have some great perks for what they have to put up with." What??? Are you talking about the box lunch from Jason's, because teachers only get those once every ten years when textbooks are adopted. Oh, oh, of course, you meant the gleam in a child's eye, the touch of a warm hand on a cold winter's day, the lavish heaps of praise for a job well done, the media attention and contracts for book deals, requests for interviews on talk shows... I know, I know - the perks are too many to count... 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

All in good humor, Chunk 

pharlap --- 16 years ago -

AMEN to that realitycheck!!!! :) Hey, we got cafeteria prepared turkey lunch for thanksgiving this year! WOOHOO!!! Another perk. :) Okay, I am not going to complain about having my summer time though - I do have to admit...that is a perk. :) 

freshhell --- 16 years ago -

It would do more good to fire the parents. 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

okay, now, the turkey lunch was pretty good this year :) I remember one year I got a whole pumpkin pie for a Christmas "bonus"! What a perk!!! I teach or train for weeks at a time during the summers, so that perk is long gone for me... But I love it! Just watch the comparisons... :) 

cmi --- 16 years ago -

Two thumbs up for realitycheck! Great post. 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

fresh, if we fired the parents, then who would pay the taxes??? Haha!! 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

In other words, the "parts" you get are engineered to work unless an idiot puts them together. So if you get a part (child) to put together and it doesn't are you the idiot? 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

Thanks cmi! Just having a little fun...:) 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

Although it is not politically correct to say it, a child's performance on the TAKS is due more to their zip code than their teacher. Absolutely true 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

It would do more good to fire the parents. Absolutely true! 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

sorry chunk - you missed the point... remember, the parts are not quality-controlled, researched, develo... oh, never mind. I forgot, I don't teach remedial classes... 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

I spoke with an honors high school student last night and he says both teachers and students agree taks testing is a huge waste of time. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

And nurses work weekends, nights, holidays without summers off and yet they are accountable for human errors as well. Yeah we have heard it all before, teachers get in to teaching for the love of it, not for the summers off, not for the spring breaks, Christmas breaks, not for the hours. Look, all I am saying is that having measurable performance standards is not a bad thing. If you are afraid of them, well then it isn't the standards fault. 

cmi --- 16 years ago -

In other words, the "parts" you get are engineered to work unless an idiot puts them together. So if you get a part (child) to put together and it doesn't are you the idiot? No, you don't get it. The "parts" aren't always engineered to work by the parents or other circumstances. 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

realitycheck --- 39 sec ago - quote - flag comment sorry chunk - you missed the point... remember, the parts are not quality-controlled, researched, develo... oh, never mind. I forgot, I don't teach remedial classes... So if adults who wished to have children were quality controlled so that only the strong genetic structure was allowed to reproduce would that be acceptable? Should parents have a license to have children? Should they be required to conduct the education at home so it could be quality measured since the parent is the one who truly educates? 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

You all are way too easy to lead to where I want to go LMAO. 

pharlap --- 16 years ago -

Let me first preface this by saying I teach high school math - everyone's favorite...Anyway, what I HATE the most is when a parent says "Well, I was never good at math, so 'johnny' probably won't be either.....he struggles so much at it, he just doesn't do his homework." I really didn't know math skills - or any other educational skill was totally hereditary!?!?!?!! Chunky, In other words, the "parts" you get are engineered to work unless an idiot puts them together. So if you get a part (child) to put together and it doesn't are you the idiot? I think it is the parents who first put the child together (X and Y chromosomes) - not the teachers.... lol! 

~sassy~ --- 16 years ago -

So if adults who wished to have children were quality controlled so that only the strong genetic structure was allowed to reproduce would that be acceptable? Should parents have a license to have children? Should they be required to conduct the education at home so it could be quality measured since the parent is the one who truly educates? I love reading your posts :) 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

Chunk - Hey, no whining here!! Teaching is my superpower! Like the saying goes, "If you can read this, thank a teacher." Peace out :) 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Oh come on, don't give up now, I was ready to do a checkmate on ya. 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

Ok, ok Chunk - who knew?? You and genetic engineering?? Well, no more remediation for you! Now you do get to go the top of the class :) "You all are way too easy to lead to where I want to go LMAO." Is that blindly off a cliff? ;) 

Perfection --- 16 years ago -

Is that blindly off a cliff? ;) Sometimes leading only to the precipice is enough for me. 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

Happy Valentine's Day, Chunk! And for what it's worth, I know there are some crummy teachers out there who need to go. Just don't necessarily agree with using the TAKS test as the measuring stick, and PLEASE, do not lump teachers in with politicians...what a nasty insult in today's political climate. :) Looking forward to another banter with you although it may be quite a while... Grade school... need I say more??? 

Tipsyhic --- 16 years ago -

What the hell. Let them all walk off for all I care. Pick out some good teachers and video conference them to all schools throughout the state and just rid of the worthless ones. 

realitycheck --- 16 years ago -

OMG!! I meant GRAD school (accidentally hit the "e" - a Freudian slip perhaps?) 

couldbetrue --- 16 years ago -

I had a professor who always said, "We teach the children that are here. Not the ones we wish were here." They claim data will show that there are some people who are better at reaching kids then others. The outcome is based on whether the student learned what was taught, not how hard the teacher worked to teach the lesson. I can workout really hard everyday, and sweat a lot, and pour my heart and soul into training. But, if the objective is to win a race, and I don't, then I need to change how I train. Not blame the race course, right? If some people are able to reach kids, and others aren't, what is the point of protecting the people who are ineffective? Adults can get in a car, fill out a job application, and start a new career. A student, is a child, who is stuck with someone who is possibly in the wrong career and they are ultimately the ones that are punished. Is that fair? 

pharlap --- 16 years ago -

realitycheck - I TOTALLY agree with you on this one. :) Chunck - were you in debate when you were in school or something like that? :) 

yeahsowhat --- 16 years ago -

Can we also start firing the police officers? I've noticed crime keeps getting worse. Shouldn't they be held accountable? Please don't feed me that line about the criminals coming from a poor area, have a tough homelife, or their parents were bad too. If the cops can't stop the crime from rising, they all should be fired and hire the officers that can do the job. Don't even get me started on the numbers of people that are dying of cancer and other diseases...those doctors and nurses in these hospitals had better get their act together or we'll get rid of them and hire the ones that CAN cure these deadly illnesses. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground