Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Solar Attic fans

who's talking here?

PS 1
Gigix4 3
G Keeng 2
StevieW 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Gigix4 --- 16 years ago -

Just saw an ad on KYS for these. I have been thinking about getting one installed. Anybody have one or thought about getting one? What's good or what's bad about them. Did a little research on-line and the only thing I would consider a "con" is that they don't come with a thermostat. Maybe that's goof - I don't know. Appreciate any legitimate comments.  

PS --- 16 years ago -

Listening to AM talk radio on the weekends, the home improvement guys speak favorably of solar attic fans. The one negative I can remember is to size them properly. If you get one that is too powerful, they just suck the air through the ridge cap vents and won't properly circulate the attic air from the soffit vents. 

G Keeng --- 16 years ago -

A. They don't mix with other "passive" attic exhaust solutions, for example ridge vent. So, if you have ridge vent, attic fans (solar or otherwise) would really be a no-no. B. If the attic fan would be removing more air from the attic than your attic can take in (typically through your eave vents - aka soffit vents), then the fan will indeed draw air through your ceiling. You don't want that! That air is expensive air conditioned air. And while your attic will certainly become much cooler, it would also be defeating the purpose of lowering your energy cost. The right fan in combination with the right ventilation device(s) is the only way to be sure to improve your present situation and not make it worse. If anyone is interested in scheduling a free assessment just send me a personal message and I can hook you up with a reputable company (one the home improvement guys speak very fondly of). 

Gigix4 --- 16 years ago -

So ... G Keeng (or anyone else that might know or have experience with), I've got ridge vents. Do you have any idea, other than the heat shield stuff, would be good to suck the hot air out of the attic? Or, if sized correctly, will one of the solar fans could help? I've had a structural engineer tell me recently that the heat shield stuff is pretty hard on your shingles ... starts to bake them after a while and they become brittle. TIA 

G Keeng --- 16 years ago -

I've had a structural engineer tell me recently that the heat shield stuff is pretty hard on your shingles ... starts to bake them after a while and they become brittle. While radiant barrier products applied/installed to the underside of the roof deck does elevate the temperature of the shingle, it is only by a couple of degrees and is nominal enough to not concern even the shingle manufacturers (in other words: doesn't void any warranties). The resulting overall reduction in attic space temperature far outweighs any supposed detriment to the shingles. They are still not any hotter than they get from being on your roof in direct sunlight to begin with. If you have ridge vent (passive exhaust solution), as I said above, you do want to mix an attic fan of any sort or size with it (active exhaust ventilation). The fan will suck air from the nearest place it can get it. And since attic fans are hardly effective unless installed high and center, they would indeed only suck air from your ridge vent (also high and center!) and not from the lowest place of your attic: where the fresh cooler air is able to find its way in: the eave vents. The idea of proper attic ventilation is to carry heat AND moisture out of your attic space. Ideally from bottom to top, not just along the top. A professional can measure your attic space, measure the amount of air able to come in and get out with your present ventilation devices (typically eave vents, ridge vents, turbines, etc.) and compare that to what is recommended for your sized attic space. If intake, exhaust or even both are found to be inadequate, then the proper solutions can be considered. For example if you have a large attic space but only a few feet of ridge vent, it may be best to block off the existing ridge vent and install something more active like turbines or even a powered fan (solar-powered preferably) if intake will support it. Professionals typically go by government DOE standards and use actual measurements and net free air flow guidelines. There are lots of "engineers", "roofers", "heating and cooling" servicemen and even insulation installers that all have their opinions and theories. Be sure, whatever you do, you deal with someone who specializes in these matters of attic ventilation, insulation and even radiant barrier. Make sure they actually measure and can show you the math when they start recommending that you install stuff. Many think that all they have to do is toss on a solar fan or two and their troubles are solved. And that is usually validated by cooler temperature readings in their attic. What they don't realize is that often they are creating a situation where the fans are sucking air conditioned air right through the ceiling into the attic. This, of course, increases energy costs not reduce them. Also, if you are experiencing troublesome cooling or heating costs or troubles with a particular room or floor, be sure to have your ductwork checked out by a qualified A/C guy. If they are leaking, that's even worse and usually an easy and inexpensive fix (relatively speaking). So many times, solutions to these sorts of things are quite counter-intuitive and homemade fixes can just make things mystifyingly worse. 

Gigix4 --- 16 years ago -

Thanks a million G Keeng. Sent you a PM. 

StevieW --- 16 years ago -

NOT true. The only issue is proximity of the attic vent to the ridge vent. Unless you have the Godzilla Attic Vent, four feet separation is more than sufficient to avoid "cycling" the ridge vent air. They just don't produce that much flow. I put 3 Solar Star solar-powered attic vents on my house and I have ridge venting. They lowered the attic temperature nearly 35 degrees (which is HUGE) compared to just having the ridge vent. The Solar Star are fully solar powered and thermostatically controlled so they don't exhaust warm air out of your attic in the winter like a whirlybird will do. My calculations show the pay-back period to be 1.5 cooling seasons but that can vary depending on where you set your thermostat, how much shade you have, how much insulation you have, etc. In Houston, I couldn't see it being more than 2 seasons for full payback since the government has a 30% tax credit for them. The lower attic temperatures lower your utility bill and extend the life of your AC unit since it doesn't have to work as hard. I'm not sure how to quantify that so I just consider it "bonus" dollars. If you have an AC powered vent, use it until it dies and then get a solar powered attic vent. Ridge vents work on convection and convection works on heat differential. Bottom line, they don't work until the attic temperature is already elevated and the horse is out of the barn then. The Solar Star vents keep that temperature lower sooner. WAY better than ridge vents, whirlybirds or any other passive vent system. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground