Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What are your thoughts? Sensitive subject - you are warned

who's talking here?

~grandma again~ 3
randyjet 2
AuthorMan 4
ladybeachbum 1
Mabbers 2
d:-] 1
Brennan 3
RX8LVR 1
ExLady In Blue 2
Perfection 4
Jrzygrl 3
Scottie's Hottie 2
Lillabeth 34
Meme2my5 4
keepinitreal09 2
my3kiddos 1
POTUS 2
PHSMOMOF2 3
JusticeForAll 10
oneyedman 1
anti-antichange 1
Nickie 2
TakeTheGlovesOff 1
*Alli* 2
moltobella 2
will4u2 11
jtcitrus 8
gawdawful 5
Polly Ester 2
NewNanna 2
Shenanigans 1
evolved 3
Wynter 8
Sufferbus 2
BigTuna 1
sadiesmom 2
I_Am_You 1
SuzyQ 6
toxiccutie 1
Nightbirdsinging 1
allday 4
truthmiser 2
Bringit 8
just lisa 1
tennis anyone? 1
Johnson 1
Zombie Slayer! 1
karma 1
***maryc 2
JTC 1
jessemyles 2
Cora 1
Andy Dick 26
thinking... 3

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I know this is a sensitive subject but it is one that my partner and I were talking a lot about this evening while at Starbucks. What are your thoughts on suicide? Do you feel it is a selfish act on the person's part? Do you think it is a way to make those who live feel guilty for whatever is bothering the other person? Does your soul go to heaven? Do you believe that suicide is the easy way out or does it take more strength to end your own life while leaving others behind? Yes, this is a toughie............ Just wanted some other input. Thanks 

thinking... --- 17 years ago -

Do you feel it is a selfish act on the person's part? I do feel it is a selfish act on the person's part. Do you think it is a way to make those who live feel guilty for whatever is bothering the other person? No, I don't. I believe it is a person's way to end the pain, guilt, etc. that they themselves are struggling with. Does your soul go to heaven? I do believe yoursoul goes to heaven because God is a merciful, forgiving God and I believe that the person is mentally handicapped that does this and just as God wouldn't send a mentally retarded person to hell, I don't believe he would send this person to hell. Do you believe that suicide is the easy way out or does it take more strength to end your own life while leaving others behind? I do not believe it is the easy way out. It is pretty hard to kill yourself.... 

thinking... --- 17 years ago -

Great questions btw. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

It all depends on circumstances and conditions. I had some friends who lived in military dictatorships in Latin America and Iran, and they fought against them. They all were very careful to save one bullet for themselves. They had no hestitation about killing themselves to avoid the torture that they would experience from the American trained torturers. The US remember hid the Nazi war criminal Klaus Barbie from international justice since he was being used as an American asset in Latin America for the purpose. For terminally ill people, I think it is a rational alternative to prolonged suffering. I am in favor of doctor assisted suicide since it will ironically save some lives to prolong life. My 90 year old grandfather committed suicide because he saw so many of the elderly bedridden and existing as vegetables. He did not want to end up in such a state and unable to commit suicide to end his life. I think that if he had had an opportunity that if he became incapacitated that he could be put out of his misery, he would not have done that. It was an entirely rational act on his part. Another airline pilot I knew, was forced out at age 60. On the last day of his time on the United list of employees, he killed himself to allow his children to collect on his multimillion dollar life insurance policy. I can understand why he did that, and while I think that there may have been other options, it was not ann irrational act either. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

This is a really tough question. My answer to the religious aspect is I have no clue but I never want to find out. I hope that God would not punish but I'm fearful that he would since he put us here on this earth for a reason and by committing suicide you are removing yourself from being a tool for Him. I understand the reasons an ill person would want to commit suicide. However, I must say, I could care less about any multimillion dollar life insurance. I can not imagine my mother taking her life to provide me with money. That absolutely blows my mind. I would much rather have her for another 20+ years than any amount of money on this earth. 

Zombie Slayer! --- 17 years ago -

i dont think about suicide. its a downer. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

Hit send too fast... Do you feel it is a selfish act on the person's part? Technically, I say yes. Anything you do only for yourself without regard for others is selfish. Do you think it is a way to make those who live feel guilty for whatever is bothering the other person? (If I'm understanding your question correctly) I suppose it depends. If someone is a a little mental then yeah they could commit suicide to make someone feel guilty. It's been known to happen. Does your soul go to heaven? Answered above. Do you believe that suicide is the easy way out or does it take more strength to end your own life while leaving others behind? I don't think it's easy to do but I do think it's the easy way out. Life is tough. Hard situations get thrown at people. I think it takes a weak person to commit suicide rather than fight their way to happiness. edited to add: (Combining the religious and easy/hard aspect) Unfortunately, I think certain people are meant to go through hard situations to be able to help others. Like a person who is abused that goes on to be an abuse counselor or advocate of some type. That being said, I believe that it could be Satan at work when a person commits suicide. Taking that person that was meant to do good from this earth. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

That absolutely blows my mind. I would much rather have her for another 20+ years than any amount of money on this earth. That was his childrens reaction too. But he was more concerned for their welfare and future than his own. I can understand a parent committing suicide to protect their kids in some circumstances. It is a VERY tough question that has to be answered by each person individually and according to their own reason and traditions. The Eskimo elderly simply go out into the wild when they feel their time has come. I think that Oregon's law is a good model for the rest of us. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

Cut my life into pieces, this is my last resort *hums* 

JusticeForAll --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

JTC --- 17 years ago -

I do believe it is a selfish act however I think the people who follow thru with it honestly have no selfish intentions. I would say its likely that they feel just the opposite and that they are doing the world a favor. Do I think its a way to make the people left behind feel guilty? Maybe it started as such in the case of people with serious personality disorders but I think it all comes down to the inability to cope and see the possiblity of resolution to current problems and situations. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it is so much selfish as it is the easy way out. It is the ultimate version of "I Quit." I know that there are a LOT of people who have been through situations I will never be able to understand, but the only person who benefits from suicide is the person who committs it. And, no, I believe the person's soul does not go to heaven b/c they put themselves before everyone else in their life, including God's word. If you believe in God, you must also believe He will never give you more than you can handle. 

toxiccutie --- 17 years ago -

JTC - I really liked your response! Have any of you ever been depressed? I mean TRULY depressed - diagnosed? I am sure that in a lot of suicide cases - they didnt JUST kill themselves to "make those who live feel guilty for whatever is bothering the other person". It makes me laugh that some of you say its a selfish act and/or that it was done to make others feel guilty...isnt that kind of a selfish statement for YOU to say? To say that this depressed and hurt person killed themselves because of you? to make you feel guilty - or others? That they couldnt have possibly killed themselves because they actually were sick and hurt and saw no other alternative? depression has a way of sucking all life and "normal" thinking from you! To me its this kind of thinking that contributes to depression!!! and not in a positive way. At one point in my life I was diganosed as maniac depressive...I went through a lot of turmoil. I eventually got better because I had people in my life that cared and knew it wasnt about THEM! I became a "cutter" at one point too...simply because I was so numb that this helped me feel...also like Justice said...you go through a state of euphoria because of the endorphins that are being released due to the cuts...this is the main reason that people begin cutting! Depression is a horrible horrible thing to experience and when someone is at the point of suicide...I seriously doubt that YOU are what they are thinking about...they are thinking that "I will no longer hurt and I will no longer hurt others". 

thinking... --- 17 years ago -

It makes me laugh that some of you say its a selfish act I have been depressed (diagnosed) and I have attempted suicide more than once. I still believe it is a selfish act. It was selfish for me to cause the suffering that my family & friends felt as they stood by my hospital bed when the doctors told them that I wouldn't make it and if I did I would be a vegetable. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Permanent solution for a short term problem. 

just lisa --- 17 years ago -

I have a close family member that committed suicide. Do I think he went to heaven? Absolutely! God knew his heart and if he committed a sin in taking his life, I know he was forgiven. I think by the time someone gets to this point they are beyond trying to make others feel guilty or thinking rationally. I think they are probably in some kind of psychotic phase or moment so rational thought as we know it is not there. I don't think is just a matter of taking the easy way out or punishing other people. I think it just the only way the person can imagine that their pain will end. In some cases, I think they believe they are sparing the rest of us from their existence. It took me a long time to try and find compassion and empathy for the person that took themselves from my life. He missed so much. But I have come to terms with it. 

I_Am_You --- 17 years ago -

In my opinion using suicide to make others feel guilty or to hurt someone is simply an ill thought out idea. If you actually DO commit suicide (not just attempt), you won't be there to see their guilt or pain. Generally when you want to make someone feel bad, you also want to SEE it. So suicide to "get back" at someone is like pulling a practical joke on a guy in the middle of the alaskan wilderness while you sit in a townhouse in Kingwood...not all that fun. Selfish? Well if the person is in utter pain and misery and they continue to live on....are the people they love then the selfish ones? And I don't think its easy. If it was easy, we would have alot less suicide attempts. Self preservation is a pretty strong instinct. Normal people (not those with severe mental disturbance) don't want to die. They might think they do, but in the final moment they know....I want to live. So no, its not easy to over ride everything your instincts tell you and the world has taught you. Heaven? Of course you get to move on to whatever other side is out there. Would I tell my child "YOU ARE CONDEMNED I DON'T LOVE YOU AND YOU DESERVE TO BE OBLITIRATED!" just because she made a mistake (even a big mistake)? No, no I would not and neither would most people (well except that guy talked about in that other thread). 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

1. It's your life, you have the right to end it if you want. 2. If you kill yourself just to try and make someone else feel guilty, you are an idiot and the world is better off without you. 3. There is no Heaven or Hell. 4. Sometimes it's the easy way out, sometimes it's the best way. Depends on the situation. 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

will4u2 --- 17 years ago -

According to lots for priest and preachers suicide is an immortal sin but there is nothing in the bible to support that teaching. I believe if a person is of sound mind and looks to suicide to avoid suffering or hardship, it is okay and will be forgiving. 

Nickie --- 17 years ago -

Another airline pilot I knew, was forced out at age 60. On the last day of his time on the United list of employees, he killed himself to allow his children to collect on his multimillion dollar life insurance policy. most insurance companies wont pay out if its suicide..? 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

Interesting. 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

There are others in the Bible, but those are woman and I guess those don't count. That was a good one. 

will4u2 --- 17 years ago -

Sorry if I was misunderstood but I was not implying that suicide did not exist in the bible but that there is nothing that says your soul is lost if you commit suicide. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

most insurance companies wont pay out if its suicide..? Most ins co have this clause, because they don't want to have to pay out b/c of suicide. My cousin committed suicide when he was 16 yrs old because of a girl who broke up with him.We were about the same age, it was devastaing. Like AM says it is a permanent solution to a temporary problem. I think he hurt so much and he just wanted the pain to go away. So sad. He could have done great things, he was so intelligent, but did this really stupid thing. 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

jessemyles --- 17 years ago -

Suicide can be an act of bravery and selflessness. 

Nickie --- 17 years ago -

my uncle committed suicide last year and i really just think the thought of it being selfish on their part is subjective. he was not in the right frame of mind and i honestly don't think he did it out of selfishness, that was not his way. he was one of the strongest men i knew and i believe the meds played a huge part in his scenario. its scary how many "helpful" drugs are on the market in todays world. 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

Do you feel it is a selfish act on the person's part? Yes, but that doesn't necessarily mean its unjustified or wrong. terminal patients with nothing to look forward to for example. Also, while suicide will hurt the ones you love, it might be wrong to require someone to continue living indefinitely for the benefit of others. Imagining the pain I would cause my family and friends was what tipped the balance and prevented me from making the attempt. People might philosophize about Pascal's Wager, but in the moment, it's the balance of pain, fear, guilt, sense of obligation, and love that sets the course. Do you think it is a way to make those who live feel guilty for whatever is bothering the other person? That can be a motivation, but ultimately would be a rationalization of the real desire to escape. Does your soul go to heaven? I don't know. Part of me wants to believe that they could... But I doubt heaven and "hell" are the only options. I think Reincarnation and oblivion are on the table too. do you believe that suicide is the easy way out or does it take more strength to end your own life while leaving others behind? Suicide is always the easy way out. Dieing is easy, Life is hard. 

will4u2 --- 17 years ago -

Will the Mentally Ill go to Heaven? Dunno, but according to the bible god makes provisions for those who are too young or unable to understand, so I would hope so, the majot component of sin is your intent, if you do bad without knowing what bad is, it is not a sin 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

Suicide can be an act of bravery and selflessness. Outside of a terminal patient sparing themselves and their family the physical, emotional, and financial hardship of their certain and agonizing death... No it can't. Soldiers sent to certain death don't set out to die, they set out to save lives knowing that it will cost them their life. That's not suicide. there's a big difference between dieing for what you believe (suicide), and dieing in the course of living for what you believe. 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

It's none of my damn business what someone else chooses to do with their body. If it infringes on me, we'll talk. 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

will4u2 --- 17 years ago -

Lots of countries and religions use suicide attacks as military strategies, include US, we just call it something else so it does not sound so bad. Have to sugar coat for the American people. Only in America. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

Sorry if I was misunderstood but I was not implying that suicide did not exist in the bible but that there is nothing that says your soul is lost if you commit suicide. "Thou shalt not kill". 

jtcitrus --- 17 years ago -

I dunno, if someone broke into our house and said that the only way they wouldn't kill our kids was for me to kill myself, I would do it in a heartbeat. and then he would kill your children. no witnesses. well thought out plan you've got there. Also in the Bible it speaks of one who killed himself by pulling a pillar down on top of him and the enemy soldiers to protect the city. which wasn't suicide. he died in the course of protecting the lives of his people. Lots of countries and religions use suicide attacks as military strategies Ah, so the kamikaze (a last ditch effort to preserve their people) and the suicide bomber (fighting to destroy the infidel) are the same.... 

will4u2 --- 17 years ago -

Ah, so the kamikaze (a last ditch effort to preserve their people) and the suicide bomber (fighting to destroy the infidel) are the same.... Yep 

page 1 2 3 4 5 6
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground