Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is It Appropriate To Give An "F'

who's talking here?

marthas attic 1
freshhell 1
Wildcat 1
Denise C 15
duflochy 1
Sandyr9111 2
needrnr 1
*Annie* 2
AuthorMan 1
Clown Vomit 1
Mom's Taxi Service 1
Mabbers 4
Eliza2 1
Cindi 1
curlygirl 4
AFWife 1
RX8LVR 2
Fin and Feather 1
~sassy~ 11
Diamom 1
Perfection 9
my3kiddos 3
Allimama 1
genxer 1
Polly Ester 1
mommie21g1b 1
novastar 1
t-1616 3
*OH SNAP* 6
JTC 1
riverrock 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

to a student on a paper that is actually an A but turned in late by one day regardless of why it was turned in late. Or should just points be taken off? 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

In high school? Isn't the policy 50 points off? I know when I was in school if you didn't have your paper done you just skipped and turned it in the next day with no penalty. I guess with emails and such there is no way around a late paper. 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

6th grade 

Fin and Feather --- 17 years ago -

I don’t agree, but recall the same thing happening to me.. once! 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

let me rephrase, not a paper. The assignment was passed up (teacher doesn't pick up) right after bell rang. As student was getting back pack ready, a paper was handed to her which she put in backpack. When she got home, it was the assignment she had passed up. 

*OH SNAP* --- 17 years ago -

Unless there's a real REASON, not just an excuse, for the paper to be late then I'd say it doesn't deserve a passing grade. Like it or not, kids need to be taught responsibility. If you're one day late on an important assignment for work and don't have a good reason, how much slack are you cut? Or, for that matter, how much slack are you cut even if you DO have a good reason sometimes? Better to learn now than learn the hard way later on. 

*OH SNAP* --- 17 years ago -

Ah, ok, well that's different. If she's a good student with no previous track record of turning in late work and/or trying to pull one over on her teachers, I'd be ticked off if the teacher didn't take her word for it about what happened. 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

to a student on a paper that is actually an A but turned in late by one day regardless of why it was turned in late. Or should just points be taken off? At KHS the new policy is 10 points off per day late. I think this policy is far better than the automatic 50 rule. What is the point of working hard to finish the assignment if you know you are getting an F on it anyway? If I were you, I would take 10 points off if you think this person deserves a break. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

Don't ask us. Go directly to the teacher. So much is lost between teacher and parent. If you still feel it is unfair, then let her know. Then let the principal know. But I can predict, in most cases, there is a big gap your kid did not tell you about. 

*OH SNAP* --- 17 years ago -

What is the point of working hard to finish the assignment if you know you are getting an F on it anyway? What happened to working hard to get it turned in on time in the first place? 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

At KHS the new policy is 10 points off per day late. I think this policy is far better than the automatic 50 rule. What is the point of working hard to finish the assignment if you know you are getting an F on it anyway? If I were you, I would take 10 points off if you think this person deserves a break. Real life doesn't work that way...you don't get to have all those chances to turn your work in. 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

She has never ever turned in a paper late, always an E student, Straight A's in all honors classes. The actual grade was an A and it was completed during class. When she got home from school is when she discovered it. But I can predict, in most cases, there is a big gap your kid did not tell you about. Nope, not with this dd. Now my younger one, that would have been a different story. 

curlygirl --- 17 years ago -

I thought the policy was a 70 if late, then down from there. If this is your child, I would take it up with principal, assuming you have talked to the teacher. Check the handbook too. I know the middle school teachers love to threaten with a zero if a student doesn't do something right. Like "If you forget to write down one problem, just one, you will get a zero." Real life example. Makes for a lot of stress in the child. 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

What happened to working hard to get it turned in on time in the first place? $hit happens. You may forget about the assignment, or you have more important assignments to work on. Really, what is the point of homework? To prove that we can turn a piece of paper in on time? Even if I turn the assignment in a day late, I still get the intended educational value from it. Even if I write a magnificent essay, but I accidentally left it in the printer as I was running out to the bus stop, I deserve to fail it if I turn it in the next morning? 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

Humble ISD Policy for secondary students is a 50. I disagree with the policy. 

*OH SNAP* --- 17 years ago -

She has never ever turned in a paper late, always an E student, Straight A's in all honors classes. The actual grade was an A and it was completed during class. When she got home from school is when she discovered it Then it would be ridiculous if the teacher didn't give her the benefit of the doubt on this one. I'd just give him/her a call tomorrow. 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

The assignment was COMPLETED IN CLASS. This teacher relies on the work to be passed up by other students (which to me is weird). The assignment WAS PASSED UP. Do I believe my child. Yes I do. 

*OH SNAP* --- 17 years ago -

She has never ever turned in a paper late, always an E student, Straight A's in all honors classes. The actual grade was an A and it was completed during class. When she got home from school is when she discovered it Then it would be ridiculous if the teacher didn't give her the benefit of the doubt on this one. I'd just give him/her a call tomorrow. $hit happens. You may forget about the assignment, or you have more important assignments to work on. Really, what is the point of homework? To prove that we can turn a piece of paper in on time? Even if I turn the assignment in a day late, I still get the intended educational value from it. Even if I write a magnificent essay, but I accidentally left it in the printer as I was running out to the bus stop, I deserve to fail it if I turn it in the next morning? It's called life, and being a responsible adult. Obviously you aren't there yet, but I hope for your sake you get there sooner than later. 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

The assignment was COMPLETED IN CLASS. This teacher relies on the work to be passed up by other students (which to me is weird). The assignment WAS PASSED UP. Do I believe my child. Yes I do. 

curlygirl --- 17 years ago -

Humble ISD Policy for secondary students is a 50. I disagree with the policy. Then she should get a 50 not a zero. But I think the teacher is being unreasonable in this case. 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

She got a 50 which is an F. I think the teacher is being unreasonable. In fact, when she discussed it with her advisory teacher, she concurred. 

novastar --- 17 years ago -

I am glad this is about over for me. I remember staying up so late with ton's of homework and myds falling asleep trying to finish it all. 

curlygirl --- 17 years ago -

Sorry I thought she got a zero. That's all I hear from my dd...I'm going to get a zero if this, I'm going to get a zero if that. Sorry. I guess I was thinking point-wise not grade letter wise as in her overall gpa. 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

It's called life, and being a responsible adult. Obviously you aren't there yet, but I hope for your sake you get there sooner than later. Thank you for your concerns, but I am slightly offended you would personally offend me like that. You have no clue who I am, and to call me irresponsible is very contradictory to my character. My opinion stands, I agree with 10 points per day late policy, as a student who is taking all classes with honors. The only kids who abuse this policy are those who are already irresponsible in handling their grades. 10 points is still a whole letter grade, and thus those who give a d@mn about their grades rarely turn their assignments in late. But for the occasions it is necessary, it is comforting to know you won't automatically fail an assignment. I also agree with the district reversing the Humble ISD 50 policy, which I thought was a stupid idea to begin with. If you don't agree with me, then so be it. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Why should we teach kids that a rule is a rule? Heck, it's not really important and it is your child, so of course the rule shouldn't apply to you and your child. Just those lazy kids who can never come up with excuses like you can. 

Eliza2 --- 17 years ago -

you weren't in class to see if the work was really done, how did it get the A? did a student grade it? that seems fishy. EVERY teacher asks for work to be passed up. rooms are too small, aisles jammed with backpacks, etc. for the teacher, if the paper leaves the classroom you have no idea if the paper was changed or ajusted, i.e. CHEATED on it 

curlygirl --- 17 years ago -

did a student grade it? Most likely. They do it all the time at my dd middle school. 

*OH SNAP* --- 17 years ago -

Thank you for your concerns, but I am slightly offended you would personally offend me like that. You have no clue who I am, and to call me irresponsible is very contradictory to my character. Sorry that you're offended that I offended you then. Well, not really. Look, it's called life. I will let you in on another little secret: nobody in life gives a crap what you think is fair except for you. Not your future college professors, not your future employers, NOBODY. Well, maybe your parents if you're lucky, but even that only goes so far. So, you see, what happens when you walk up to a college professor whining about your paper only being 10 minutes late and therefore it's unfair for him to give you a zero because of all of the different reasons you just ticked off, is that they tell you that the due date was on the syllabus passed out at the beginning of the semester. Period. If you continue to bug them, they may helpfully suggest that perhaps you were not prepared for the college environment and might want to try again in a year or two when you are more mature. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

This will be a great learning experience for your dd..mom does not need to call on behalf of the student..let your dd make the effort to go talk to her teacher and see if they can come to an understanding..She will need to be able to speak up for herself from here on out with teachers. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Dang it OH SNAP, we agree again. We have to stop doing this LOL 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

I hate this policy....when we were in school it was either on time or u got a 0. I think it doesnt prepare kids for college or real world job situations. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

I think it doesnt prepare kids for college or real world job situations. In college way back when there were consequences for late work, in my MBA program now there are major consequences for late work. At my job if I do something late not only do I have to explain it to my team I suffer a poor review for it for bad time management skills. You can do your work late and not have a poor review or consequences? Dang, I want your job Sandyr9111. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

In a competitive environment you need to stand apart from the others. Being early with work done helps you stand out. Being late with work done helps you stand at the end of the line. 

*Annie* --- 17 years ago -

I hate this policy....when we were in school it was either on time or u got a 0. I think it doesnt prepare kids for college or real world job situations. I don't like either policy. The -10 points per day does too little. Many kids opt to copy the work that their friends have done and checked. They take the minimal points off and still get a passing grade - often an A or B. The -50 on the first day late is too severe. I feel a bit like the three bears are involved in this scenario! Where is the one that is Just Right? 

Diamom --- 17 years ago -

If I am reading this correctly, your DD is in 6th grade, this was an in class assignment that was pass forward (up the rows) & turned in. Someone just handed her a paper & she thought it was nothing special & stuck in her backpack & realized later it was her assignment. Yes, I think the teacher is being unreasonable b/c (1) any student could be vindictive and walk away with another students paper & therefore cause a student to get a zero and (2) accidents due happen. Your DD need to talk to this teacher herself and see what the teacher says. Explain the situation. If that does not resolve anything, then you need to send her a note. Have your DD get her advisory teacher to help her talk to this teacher. As a sixth grader, you are attempting to teach her how to resolve conflict on her own but are still there to help if something does not work out. A kid starting middle school does not equal starting college. You are SUPPOSED to still be there to help them at this point. You are weaning them off your support more & more as the grow older. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Yes middle school is a bit much but here they do it all through high school too. Let them make up failing grades for a 70, let them turn work in late for 10 pts a day off etc. And yes my job has a problem with me conpleting tasks late....i try my damndest not to let it happen. 

duflochy --- 17 years ago -

A teacher told me that "school is no longer about the student" a couple of weeks ago..... 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

Diamond, you are correct. My dd did speak with the teacher. Considering the high schools give a 70 for late work, yes, I think 50 is harsh for middle school. I also think there is a first time for everything. In the real world if you are late for work you are disciplined, not fired. For a first time offender in school, yes, an F is ridiculous. There is no standard policy in HISD, it is up the each campus. 

Denise C --- 17 years ago -

My opinion stands, I agree with 10 points per day late policy, as a student who is taking all classes with honors. The only kids who abuse this policy are those who are already irresponsible in handling their grades. 10 points is still a whole letter grade, and thus those who give a d@mn about their grades rarely turn their assignments in late. But for the occasions it is necessary, it is comforting to know you won't automatically fail an assignment. I also agree with the district reversing the Humble ISD 50 policy, which I thought was a stupid idea to begin with. If you don't agree with me, then so be it. Excellent post. For a child who is in honors and makes all A's, responsible, does all work as assigned, and makes even homework a priority, then a 50 is ridiculous. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

In a nut shell, there are exceptions to every rule. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground