Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Advice for a preschool teacher? Please?

who's talking here?

momma0204 2
lindagail 1
teachermom 1
cmi 1
*JR* 2
Valentine 1
*emily 9
KayCat 2
3monkeysmomma 1
Dotti 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

*emily --- 17 years ago -

Ok, so the preschool I work at offers "Handwriting Without Tears." It is a wonderful way to teach the alphabet and how to correctly write each letter. We have someone trained come in to our classroom once a week and work on the letter of the week and we are supposed to review the rest of the week. Here's the deal. Most of the schools in Kingwood teach the D'Nealian alphabet. That is the alphabet that has the little curves and the letters are on a slant. HWT is the plain, straight, up and down letters. Do I continue to stick with HWT and let the kids become really comfortable with the letters? Do I try to incorporate both and possibly confuse them? They could end up writing words with letters of both style. Do I strictly teach D'Nealian and throw out everything the HWT specialist is teaching? I can't seem to come to a good conclusion and I have been thinking about it for days. 

KayCat --- 17 years ago -

I'd stick to HWT ... then they can get familiar with the letters. They can work on D'Nealian when they get in kindergarten. We're teaching D'Nealian at Little Friends. Our 5's class is doing a great job. The 4's are working on it - it's hit & miss. I'm mainly focusing on letter recognition & spacing. I'm actually thinking about purchasing HWT for our 3's and young 4's. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

We have HWT for the 4's and 5's class but they are already so familiar with the letters. I was approached by another teacher who doesn't agree that I have been sticking with HWT. She said I was doing them a dis-service. I don't want to confuse them is the only thing... Sigh... 

KayCat --- 17 years ago -

I don't think you're doing them a disservice! I introduce everything in D'Nealian so they are familiar with it. Some kids just aren't ready for it & making them do something that isn't comfortable isn't right in my opinion. They'll try it when they're ready. 

Valentine --- 17 years ago -

As an occupational therapist, i believe that HWT is easier to understand for little ones. In kindergarten they can learn to perfect (and add the little tails and such), but as long as they have learned the basics of properly forming the letters, the rest should come easy. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

Thank you Valentine! I appreciate that. I am going to just stick with what I am doing. I don't think they are ready to learn both at the same time. 

3monkeysmomma --- 17 years ago -

My kids learn HWT in preschool and my oldest 2 have had no problems adapting. In fact, my kinder kid is learning to write so quickly now that I can't keep up with what he knows! 

Dotti --- 17 years ago -

My aunt just had this issue at the new school in Lakeshore. She was teaching her son HWT and so was his MDO program and then the first week he came home with D'Nealian. I believe she was told that they teach them both. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

Dotti, I don't think it would be an issue if the preschool was not teaching HWT. I would just teach D'Nealian with no second thought because that is what they are going to learn in Kindergarten. But since the school offers HWT I feel like I should stick with that. Then they can focus on D'Nealian next year. 

Dotti --- 17 years ago -

My daugther is in Kindercare and all they do at this point in the 4 class is HWT. I dont see an issue sticking with HWT and then when they are in Kindergarden (and alittle older) they will know every letter inside and out then they can change. My daugther wouldn't know a D'Nealian letter from an HWT at this point because they don't teach her both. One or both should be fine. JMO 

lindagail --- 17 years ago -

I would check with the school district in your area and see what they teach and use that one. My son started with one and it was confussing switching the following year. Humble uses D'Nealian. I just do not see why you would would not want to teach that if you are in that area. 

teachermom --- 17 years ago -

Handwriting without tears is awesome. I taught it in Oklahoma and it is great!! 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

Linda, like I said, I don't have a problem teaching either one. I have a problem with the kids having to learn 2 different things (and confusing the 2) because the preschool offers something different than the district. I just teach and have no say on what "specials" are taught at the school. But it will be something I offer my opinion for next year. This is our first year with HWT. And I don't think this problem was considered when being decided upon. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

And I have to agree with he others, HWT is awesome! The kids are doing so well!! 

momma0204 --- 17 years ago -

As a preschool teacher...I say that HWT is awesome!!! It is perfect for developing both pre-writing and writing skills. As a mom, I also love HWT. Transitioning to D'Nealian in Kindergarten has proven to be no problem for my kiddo! 

cmi --- 17 years ago -

I would be absolutely pissed off if as my kids teacher you weren't sticking with HWT. It is the main reason I chose to switch preschools. I wanted my child to learn through HWT. It is an awesome program and my child comes home each day reciting how to draw a certain letter. He wouldn't even try to write letters before the program and he will be in Kindergarten next year. As far as the schools go, even thogh they do D'Nealian, they didn't seem to exactly teach letters anyways. Sure they traced letters and practiced, but it wasn't a whole lot of "this is how you make a letter." As far as transitioning, my older son won't be required to. We're happy he writes! He is doing HWT at home in 1st grade and still writes at school. Sometimes he uses HWT letters and sometimes he uses D'Nealian. 

momma0204 --- 17 years ago -

It is an awesome program and my child comes home each day reciting how to draw a certain letter. I think this is exactly what makes HWT so special! The kids learn HOW to build the letters step-by-step and the fun little sayings help them remember. It is truly a fun way to learn to write. Honestly, the kids don't even realize how much they are learning when they are "playing" with wooden lines and curves! :) 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

I am bumping this to see if anyone else would like to add an opinion. This is still something I am struggling with. Mainly because another teacher has very strong opinions and I just want to do what is best. 

*JR* --- 17 years ago -

If you found a way to teach kids writing that is fun, by all means do it! My son is learning to write in Kindergarten, and some of the letters are different than I taught him, and he is having no problems. I get irritated with people who think that kids should come out of pre-school ready for first grade. I think they should have fun, feel loved, and get a basic introduction to what they will learn in Kindergarten. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

Agreed JR. My goal is to prepare them. Make them familiar. To encourage and love. To enjoy school and learning so that they have a desire to go forever. 

*JR* --- 17 years ago -

Emily, you sound like a wonderful teacher and the kids are lucky to have you. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

Thank you! I love them so much!!! I am more passionte about teaching than I am educated about it. But I try my best and research tons and ask lots of questions of experienced friends and colleagues. Its my second year full time and I subbed before. Best job ever! Besides my summer job of teaching swim. :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground