Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Merck Researcher Admits: Gardasil Guards Against Almost Nothing

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
GCan 1
Sandyr9111 4
jjfingrainalready 4
Syrah1214 1
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 1
rEVOLution 1
Unichic™ 1
Meme2my5 1
JusticeForAll 1
ladyjane 1
kab 1
Bringit 1
magic3.0 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

The Gardasil vaccine has made millions for Merck, but it will prevent very few cases of cervical cancer. And it has caused tens of thousands of prepubescent girls to suffer side effects. Steven W. Mosher Merck Researcher Admits: Gardasil Guards Against Almost Nothing by Joan Robinson and Steven W. Mosher On the morning of 2 October 2009, one of us (Joan) joined an audience of mostly health professionals and listened as Dr. Diane Harper, the leading international developer of the HPV vaccines, gave a sales pitch for Gardasil. Gardasil, as you may know, is the new vaccine that is supposed to confer protection against four strains of the sexually transmitted Human Papillomavirus (HPV). Dr. Harper came to the 4th International Public Conference on Vaccination to prove to us the real benefits of Gardasil. Sadly, her own presentation left me (Joan) and others filled with doubts. By her own admission, Gardasil has the doctors surrounding me glaring at a poor promise of efficacy as a vaccine married to a high risk of life-threatening side effects. Gardasil, Dr. Harper explained, is promoted by Merck, the pharmaceutical manufacturer, as a “safe and effective” prevention measure against cervical cancer. The theory behind the vaccine is that, as HPV may cause cervical cancer, conferring a greater immunity of some strains of HPV might reduce the incidence of this form of cancer. In pursuit of this goal, tens of millions of American girls have been vaccinated to date. As I sat scribbling down Merck’s claims, I wondered why such mass vaccination campaigns were necessary. After all, as Dr. Harper explained, 70% of HPV infections resolve themselves without treatment in one year. After two years, this rate climbs to 90%. Of the remaining 10% of HPV infections, only half coincide with the development of cervical cancer. Dr. Harper further undercut the case for mass vaccination campaigns in the U.S. when she pointed out that “4 out of 5 women with cervical cancer are in developing countries.” (Harper serves as a consultant to the World Health Organization (WHO) for HPV vaccination in the developing world.) Indeed, she surprised her audience by stating that the incidence of cervical cancer in the U.S. is so low that “if we get the vaccine and continue PAP screening, we will not lower the rate of cervical cancer in the US.” If this is the case, I thought, then why vaccinate at all? From the murmurs of the doctors in the audience, it was apparent that the same thought had occurred to them. In the U.S. the cervical cancer rate is 8 per 100,000 women.1 Moreover, it is one of the most treatable forms of cancer. The current death rate from cervical cancer is between 1.6 to 3.7 deaths per 100,000 cases of the disease.2 The American Cancer Society (ACS) notes that “between 1955 and 1992, the cervical cancer death rate declined by 74%” and adds that “the death rate from cervical cancer continues to decline by nearly 4% each year.”3 At this point, I began to wriggle around in my seat, uncomfortably wondering, is the vaccine really effective? Using data from trials funded by Merck, Dr. Harper cheerfully continued to demolish the case for the vaccine that she was ostensibly there to promote. She informed us that “with the use of Gardasil, there will be no decrease in cervical cancer until at least 70% of the population is vaccinated, and in that case, the decrease will be very minimal. The highest amount of minimal decrease will appear in 60 years.” It is hard to imagine a less compelling case for Gardasil. First of all, it is highly unlikely that 70% or more of the female population will continue to get routine Gardasil shots and boosters, along with annual PAP smears. And even if it did, according to Dr. Harper, “after 60 years, the vaccination will [only] have prevented 70% of incidences” of cervical cancer. But rates of death from cervical cancer are already declining. Let’s do the math. If the 4% annual decline in cervical cancer death continues, in 60 years there will have been a 91.4% decline in cervical cancer death just from current cancer monitoring and treatment. Comparing this rate of decline to Gardasil’s projected “very minimal” reduction in the rate of cervical cancer of only 70 % of incidences in 60 years, it is hard to resist the conclusion that Gardasil does almost nothing for the health of American women. Despite these dismal projections, Gardasil continues to be widely and aggressively promoted among pre-teen girls. The CDC reports that, by 1 June 2009, over 26 million doses of Gardasil have been distributed in the U.S.4 With hopes of soon tapping the adolescent male demographic, Merck, the pharmaceutical manufacturer of the vaccine, and certain Merck-funded U.S. medical organizations are targeting girls between the ages of 9 and 13.5 As CBS news reports, “Gardasil, launched in 2006 for girls and young women, quickly became one of Merck's top-selling vaccines, thanks to aggressive marketing and attempts to get states to require girls to get the vaccine as a requirement for school attendance.”6 Just as I began, in my own mind, to question ethics of mass vaccinations of prepubescent girls, Dr. Harper dropped another bombshell. “There have been no efficacy trials in girls under 15 years,” she told us. Merck did study a small group of girls under 16 who had been vaccinated, but did not follow them long enough to conclude sufficient presence of effective HPV antibodies. If I wasn’t skeptical enough already, I really started scratching my head when Dr. Harper explained, “if you vaccinate a child, she won’t keep immunity in puberty and you do nothing to prevent cervical cancer.” But it turned out that she wasn’t arguing for postponing Gardasil vaccination until later puberty, as I first thought. Rather, Dr. Harper only emphasized to the doctors in the audience the need for Gardasil booster shots, because it is still unknown how long the vaccine immunity lasts. More booster shots mean more money for Merck, obviously. I left Dr. Harper’s lecture convinced that Gardasil did little to stop cervical cancer, and determined to answer another question that she had largely ducked: Is this vaccine safe? Here’s what my research turned up. To date, 15,037 girls have officially reported adverse side effects from Gardasil to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS). These adverse effects include Guilliane Barre, lupus, seizures, paralysis, blood clots, brain inflammation and many others. The CDC acknowledges that there have been 44 reported deaths.7 Dr. Harper, who seems to specialize in dropping bombshells, dropped another in an interview with ABC News when she admitted that “The rate of serious adverse events is greater than the incidence rate of cervical cancer.”8 This being the case, one might want to take one’s chances with cancer, especially because the side effects of the vaccine are immediate, while the possibility of developing cancer is years in the future. In the clinical studies alone, 23 girls died after receiving either Gardasil or the Aluminum control injection. 15 of the 13,686 girls who received Gardasil died, while 8 died among the 11,004 who received the Aluminum shot. There was only one death among the group that had a saline placebo. What this means is that 1 out of every 912 girls in the Gardasil clinical studies died. (9, see page 8.) The cervical cancer death rate is 1 out of every 40,000 women per year.10 The numbers of deaths and adverse effects are undoubtedly underestimates. Dr. Harper’s comments to ABC News concur with the National Vaccine Information Center’s claim that “though nearly 70 percent of all Gardasil reaction reports were filed by Merck, a whopping 89 percent of the reports Merck did file were so incomplete there was not enough information for health officials to do a proper follow-up and review.”11 On average, less than 10 percent—perhaps even less than 1 percent—of serious vaccine adverse events are ever reported, according to the American Journal of Public Health.12 Given the severity and frequency of Gardasil adverse reactions, I definitely wasn’t the only one in Dr. Harper’s audience who winced when she dismissed most Gardasil side effects as “easily just needle phobia.” Due to the young age of the trial participants and the short duration of the studies, the effects of Gardasil on female fecundity have not been studied. I did discover, in my post-conference reading, that Polysorbate 80, an ingredient in the vaccine (13, see page 12), has been observed in a European clinical study to cause infertility in rats.14 Is this an additional concern? Time will tell. I do not wish to give the impression that Dr. Harper presented, even inadvertently, a consistently negative view of her own vaccine. She did tout certain “real benefits,” chief among them that “the vaccine will reduce the number of follow-up tests after abnormal PAP smears,” and thereby reduce the “relationship tension,” “stress and anxiety” of abnormal or false HPV positive results. To me, however, this seems a rather slim promise, especially when weighed against the deaths and side effects caused by the Gardasil campaign. Should millions of girls in the United States, many as young as 9, be put at risk, so that sexually active adults can have less “relationship tension” about false positive Hepatitis results? Is the current rate of death, sterility and serious immune dysfunction from Gardasil worth the potential that in 60 years a minimal amount of a cervical disease (that is already decreasing on its own) may perhaps be reduced? But what I really wanted to know is why Merck is so eagerly marketing such a dangerous and ineffective vaccine? Aren’t there other ways they could make a profit? While Merck’s behavior is probably adequately explained by the profit motive, what about those in the Health and Human Services bureaucracy who apparently see Gardasil as medicine’s gift to women? What motivates them? I (Steve) think that they see Gardasil as what one might call a “wedge” drug. For them, the success of this public vaccination campaign has less to do with stopping cervical cancer, than it does with opening the door to other vaccination campaigns for other sexually transmitted diseases, and perhaps even including pregnancy itself. For if they can overcome the objections of parents and religious organizations to vaccinating pre-pubescent—and not sexually active—girls against one form of STD, then it will make it easier for them to embark on similar programs in the future. After all, the proponents of sexual liberation are determined not to let mere disease—or even death—stand in the way of their pleasures. They believe that there must be technological solutions to the diseases that have arisen from their relentless promotion of promiscuity. After all, the alternative is too horrible to contemplate: They might have to learn to control their appetites. And they might have to teach abstinence. Steven W. Mosher is the President of the Population Research Institute. Joan Robinson is an Assistant Editor at the Population Research Institute 

Syrah1214 --- 17 years ago -

That's SCARY. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

That's criminal..how terrible,, 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

It's probably just like the H1N1. Will make the drugs companies billions but kill lot of people. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

If this is true they're azz holes! 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

I can tell you one thing for sure that it's doing. Making some girls very sick and ruining many lives. More than cancer? Who knows but both are preventable. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

THIS is why ive questioned this shot. They could never show its effectiveness in everything I read on the trials and such. Then you have all the articles about sick and dead girls who got the shot. One of DDs friends moms asked me b4 school started when i took DD for shots if i was getting her the Gardisil too? I said not no but hell no. She said why not? Told her about all the stuff I had read and she;s like "Why didnt you tell me!?!?" I said u didnt research that crap before u let them inject ur kid with it? She said no the clinic told me she needed it. And herein lies the problem....you have a bunch of parents who never bothered to research this crap....the clinic told them their daughters needed it so they shot them up, the governor said she needed it......They dont bother to research. Luckily as far as i know the child is ok but im not willing to take that chance. 

ladyjane --- 17 years ago -

Of the people who are so ardently for government control of health care, I notice none have posted so far. Does anyone doubt that, with Obama's plan, we'll all be REQUIRED to take flu shots, make our kids get Gardisil shots, etc? And our protests of ineffectiveness or possible dangers will not matter, just like our concerns about losing choices in medical care fall on deaf ears now. And how in the world does anyone doubt the financial connection between this move toward socialized medicine and big pharma? I would think our anti-capitalist friends on KU would be livid at how much money apparent scams like Gardisil are making. If government was so concerned about people's health, they'd give out vitamins C, D, magnesium, etc. but, oh wait, no one would make millions off that because you can't patent those. And dessicated thyroid is so cheap and effective and can ward off a host of serious illnesses - but wait, our government is hunting down and trying to prosecute pharmacies who dare try to compound this cheap, effective stuff so the public is FORCED to use synthetic crap from big pharma. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

Quick, let's all rush out an get our kids vaccinated!!! I swear, it's this kinda crap that has caused me to lose all faith in the medical society. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

my pedi's office gave this to my dd against my wishes. I had previously told them no on 2 occasions. they waited until my DH brought her in for something and approached him with it by telling him all girls in this age group needed it. they made it sound like it was required, like she really NEEDED it. not that it was suggested, or optional. I was pissed beyond belief and seriously it caused lots of tension b/w us. I do most of the primary care of the children, he does not usually do the dr. office. that day, he was simply there to get her physical form signed to turn into the school. I tell him what is going on with the kids, but he doesn't pay attn. or he just doesn't remember. I had talked with him about this shot before, but I guess when he was there that day, it didn't click in his head that this was the one I was scared about. I wanted to kill him and the dr. I am still pissed about it. I couldn't believe he didn't pick up the phone to call me and ask me about it, that he would just sign any paper they put in front of him and let them do anything to our child in the name of "healthcare". Luckily, she had no adverse effects. It would have devastated her, but it definitely would have devastated us, and also the dr. office, b/c I would have sued the absolute $hit out of them. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

JJF...What pedi's office do you use? I'm so stunned that they would do something so sneaky when you'd already told them no. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

I am over in The Woodlands, it is not local to Humble/KW, so y'all can breathe a sigh of relief! I was floored as well, we have 4 kids and she has been seeing them for 5 years now. I have generally loved the office and especially her, but this was over the top. You can bet your a$$ that office manager got an earful. They were all so scared we were gonna sue, there was lots of azz kissing by them before it was done. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Id have requested copies of her record from the last few visits where u told them no and if it was documented i would have had their heads! I watched VERY carefully and checked the vials MYSELF when i took my daughter to a typical "medicaid" clinic(not her regular Dr) for her shots because they asked me 3 times if i wanted it and i told them NO! I made them draw the syringes in front of me because they asked 3 times. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

Sandy, turns out that was the issue. I had taken her in twice the year before, 6 months apart, for a Hep Series. I had been approached about the HPV vaccine both visits and told them no both times. It had not been documented either time, so when dear old dad who doesn't know any better showed up, they pounced on the opportunity. Seriously, are they getting kickbacks for each shot they convince people to get? It became a huge deal. They had staff meetings. They redid their system so it --hopefully--won't happen again. There were phone calls. It still pisses me off though, especially every time I read an article like this and see what could have happened to her. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

It became a huge deal. They had staff meetings. They redid their system so it --hopefully--won't happen again. There were phone calls. It still pisses me off though, especially every time I read an article like this and see what could have happened to her. It should be a big deal. Any dr's office i would have thought would have the brains not to let dad "no offense intended" make a descision like that when normally mom is the primary caregiver in MOST situations. Now if dad is the primary then thats fine. Stuff like this is why i just about wont let DH take DD to the Dr. 

jjfingrainalready --- 17 years ago -

Stuff like this is why i just about wont let DH take DD to the Dr. I thought I was safe, they were just supposed to get a form signed! I didn't even hear about it until a day or two later, when DD said, my arm is so sore. I said why? She said from that shot they gave me. And then, my head almost exploded and we almost divorced b/c things slid steadily downhill from there! 

magic3.0 --- 17 years ago -

Dr. Harper, who seems to specialize in dropping bombshells, dropped another in an interview with ABC News when she admitted that “The rate of serious adverse events is greater than the incidence rate of cervical cancer. cure is sometimes worse than the disease. and these shots aren't even cures. there will be many lawsuits. 

kab --- 17 years ago -

To all the parents out there please do not do these. I’ve had a hand full of doctor’s tell me that this vaccine is not the problem but I just don’t believe it. My daughter had one health issue which the doctors at TCH told me that it would be fine to give this vaccine to her. Immediately following her first shot of Gardasil, her arm went numb and remained that way for several minutes. She could not move her arm for 5 days after receiving the shot. Three weeks after the shot she collapsed from an episode with chest pains and shortness of breath. She has irregular heart beat and blood pressure which in now controlled with a beta-blocker. When she has these episodes she has low oxygen levels, numbness and tingling in her feet, headaches, dizziness, rash, arching of the back and feet, and chest pains. Her menstrual cycles have become extremely irregular and she has also begun losing her hair. We have been to so many doctors and no one knows what it is. They all say that if it was the vaccine it wouldn’t have taken almost a month to start having side effects. In my heart I feel this is the problem and wish everyday that we never did it she was healthy before she received this. We are now seeing another doctor and hopefully will get answers soon. It’s heart breaking sometimes to watch because she doesn’t understand and wants to be normal. She started playing sports when she was 5 and is now in high school and can’t even pass a physical. She can’t do the things she loves to do. Last year she missed 82 days of school and made 7 trips to the ER. This school year she’s missed 15 days already and 2 trips to the ER. To look at her she seems like a normal kid but you just never know when things are going to change. We just pray everyday that we will get answers and she will get better. We never went back for the second shot. 

Bringit --- 17 years ago -

This is really sad. When this vaccine first came out, my sister called and asked for my input on it. I am glad that she took my advice and did not allow my neice to take it. 

JusticeForAll --- 17 years ago -

I can tell you one thing for sure that it's doing. Making some girls very sick and ruining many lives. More than cancer? Who knows but both are preventable.  It's so obvious that none of you have dealt with a cancerous strain of HPV. It's helpful to do some research into this virus, how it works, how it's contracted etc. Also, do some research on the author of this article, Steven W. Mosher. Knowledge is power, fear is non productive. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

kab im so sorry to hear about your daughter. Many prayers for her. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground