Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

What does the Bible say about murder

who's talking here?

Zionist NightOwl 3
Donkey Hodie 2
Possum 1
Ogre1 11
JohnLynch 5
evolved 5
allday 1
textualchocolate 1

CAUTION: This topic is dangerous. Enter at own risk.

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

there is one person on this forum who recently said that the death penalty is murder. they also said "an intruder breaks into your house and tries to kill you and rape your wife.....you have the chance to shoot him and you do and kill him." this person also believes that self defense is murder if we look to the Bible, Exodus 20:13 says "Thou shalt not murder". this act of murder is defined in Numbers 23 and the penalty for murder is death as indicated in Leviticus 24 and Exodus 21. so God instituted the death penalty for murder, but does not call it murder. the Bible also gives other instances where killing was allowed, and therefore NOT murder, and they were for self-defense in Exodus 22 and during war in Joshua 10  

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Where in Numbers 23 does it define murder? Numbers 23 (in the KJV) is about the blessing of the Israelites in Moab and how Balaam, in spite of being asked by the King of Moab to curse the Jews, blesses them instead. Never mind Numbers 22 and the whole conversation between Balaam, his @ss (donkey) and an Angel. "Wherefore hast thou smitten thine @ss these three times?" We never got to this one in Bible School. And of course, you're picking and choosing. I don't hear you complaining that blasphemers aren't being stoned, or eye for an eye (Lev 24:19 & 20). How about Lev 25:44, 45, and others? Don't hear you saying we should make slaves of the "heathens". How many burnt offerings have you made on the sabbath? Lev 23:12. It's called Buffet Religion where you pick and choose what you wish to believe. And do you REALLY want to get into Exodus 21? The laws there are addressed towards the slaves of the Jews. And I've always found it interesting that Ex 22: 28 says "Thou shalt not revile the gods, nor curse the ruler of thy people." 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Where in Numbers 23 does it define murder? sorry, i meant to type Numbers 35 It's called Buffet Religion where you pick and choose what you wish to believe. no, it isn't. it is combining the NT with the OT - understanding the Bible as a whole And I've always found it interesting that Ex 22: 28 says "Thou shalt not revile the gods, nor curse the ruler of thy people." what is so interesting about that? 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

Most Christians don't read the Bible in it's entirety and are willfully ignorant of its content yet continue on their pastor, righteous, etc. inspired rampage of "TRUTH" LOL In reading the garbage it's easy to see the so called loving God of Abraham wants heresy expunged at ALL COSTS. One look at the butchery and stupidity of Deuteronomy proves that. Your loving God has something very specific and sinister in mind if your son or daughter come back from the gym and have an interst in Krishna for example. Here it is from the horses' mouth so to speak. "If your brother, the son of your father or of your mother, or your son or daughter, or the spouse whom you embrace, or your most intimate friend, tries to secretly seduce you saying, "let us go and serve other gods," unknown to your or your ancestors before you, gods of the people surrounding you, whether near you or far away, anywhere throughout the world, you must not consent, you must not listen to him; you must show him no pity, you must not spare or conceal his guilt. No, you MUST KILL him, your hand must strike the first blow in putting him to DEATH and the hands of the rest of the people following. You must stone him to death, since he tried to divert you from your God. (Deuteronomy 13:7-11) While the stonoing of children has fallen out of favor by the liberalism of the West you will not hear a "moderate" Christian asking for a symbolic reading of passages of this sort. (In fact, one seems to be expilicitly blocked by your loving GOD in Deuteronomy 13:1--"Whatever I am now commanding you, you must keep and observe, adding nothing to it, taking nothing away.") The above passage is as canonical as any in the Bible and it is ONLY by IGNORING it that Chritians can get an ounce of sleep at night or try to reconcile such garbage with the modern world. 

textualchocolate --- 17 years ago -

Second assignment. Read the history of some of the areas that surrounded Israel of that day. Read about their religions. Does it not make you the least bit curious as to why God would command the death of a whole people on more than one occasion? You will be surprised at the attrocities that you will find. Third assignment. Understand why there was a Law handed out. Even if you don't get the context of what was going on then and you are trying to place 2009 values on a situation that happened over 5000 years ago. Try to understand that the ultimate goal of everyone on earth is heaven. Some understand this, some do not. In order to effect this the Law was given to the lawless in order to prove to them that they were not capable of doing it on their own. Assignment 4 Understanding the New Covenant. The law was given so that it might be shown how necessary Grace was. Grace was planned from the fall of mankind in the Garden. However, the set-up had to be in place because we are such a hardheaded creation. The entire Old Testament points toward the New Testament unless of course you listen to the bloggers who hand feed you, in single sentences and thoughts, the theology of a religion they do not even believe. It is kind of like trying to tell someone else what THEY mean when THEY speak. It is exceptionally hippocritical to presume excellence in understanding something that you do not, in fact, believe. Assignement 5. Salvation. Reading about God in the bible you will find many consistancies. One is that He is all about relationship. He created man to have relationship with. His original intention was His final decision on the matter. While he is omniescent that does not mean that he has experienced everything. There is a difference between knowing a thing and doing a thing. He sent his Son to earth to experience life and death as a man. (So he can relate to use and our struggles) Through the Son, God experienced the human condition, birth, temptation, death. Now we are permitted to pass on the "letter of the law" but still keep the "spirit of the law" because we love Him. (because he loved us enough to set this up from the beginning) So no, there are no more stonings or sacrifices of lambs and doves. But God did mention that if a person chooses to try and follow the Old Testament then He would oblidge them and judge them with it. God really does Love you. That has nothing to do with anything. it's jibberish!! 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

Second assignment. Read the history of some of the areas that surrounded Israel of that day. Read about their religions. Does it not make you the least bit curious as to why God would command the death of a whole people on more than one occasion? You will be surprised at the attrocities that you will find. All it takes is a reading as God implores by the following: Here it is from the horses' mouth so to speak. "If your brother, the son of your father or of your mother, or your son or daughter, or the spouse whom you embrace, or your most intimate friend, tries to secretly seduce you saying, "let us go and serve other gods," unknown to your or your ancestors before you, gods of the people surrounding you, whether near you or far away, anywhere throughout the world, you must not consent, you must not listen to him; you must show him no pity, you must not spare or conceal his guilt. No, you MUST KILL him, your hand must strike the first blow in putting him to DEATH and the hands of the rest of the people following. You must stone him to death, since he tried to divert you from your God. (Deuteronomy 13:7-11) While the stonoing of children has fallen out of favor by the liberalism of the West you will not hear a "moderate" Christian asking for a symbolic reading of passages of this sort. (In fact, one seems to be expilicitly blocked by your loving GOD in Deuteronomy 13:1--"Whatever I am now commanding you, you must keep and observe, adding nothing to it, taking nothing away.") The above passage is as canonical as any in the Bible and it is ONLY by IGNORING it that Chritians can get an ounce of sleep at night or try to reconcile such garbage with the modern world. Just curious if you give the Koran with it's butchery as equally brutal as God's words the same leeway as the Bible? Or do you use literalist views when it suits you and contextual iterations to fool the foolish?? 

allday --- 17 years ago -

(*Disclaimer* I do believe Muhammed was a false prophet and the teachings in the Koran are in line with what the bible warns about such false prophets. That being said even the Koran recognizes the God of Israel) Well, isn't that convenient. Steve, you're not an as3hole like Lynch but one book is no better than the other and a non believer is the same as a believer minus the HATE and SUPERIORITY complex. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

what is so interesting about that? GODS 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

no, it isn't. yes it is. You cannot quote the bible and say this is the incarnate word of god. ... oh, except for that part. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

who teach that it is OK to murder anyone who is not a believer in the strictest form Do you honestly beleive that the Bible doesn't teach the same thing? I'm not in a good place to do a lot of research right now, but no matter, I'm not even going to quote anything here, it's just all over the place. 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

What about the Book of Mormon? Is that book Scripture? (Remember, the owner of this site who bans people is a Mormon.) 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

(Remember, the owner of this site who bans people is a Mormon.) Proof positive that SOME people will believe ANYTHING!!!!!!!!! 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

What about the Book of Mormon? Is that book Scripture? Steve & JohnLynch, you have no comment about the Book of Mormon? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

The bible does recognize the gods This is why I find it interesting. When Yahweh told Moses "Thou shalt have no other Gods before me." He wasn't saying the Jews couldn't worship other gods, he was saying that Yahweh should be their chief god. A lot of Christians have been taught to beleive that is a ban on "lesser" gods. Doesn't seem to be to me especially when coupled with Exodus 22:28. It seems to me to be a message that say something along the lines of "Hey, other people worship other Gods, but you worship me first and foremost, if you choose to honor those other Gods, fine, but I come first." But because of "Buffet Religion" and the fact that the vast majority of people who read the Bible do so by rote and with little actual understanding, that message gets lost. There is also a prohibition against worshiping false idols. But that's a fairly common prohibition throughout most religions. When the Jews created their Golden Calf they created a "God" they could see. They were violating their own precepts and mimicking the actions of their former masters, the Egyptians, who created many idols. But behind the idols of the Egyptians were concepts of their Gods. Thus they are not FALSE Idols. One does not worship the statue of Ra or Isis (or Odin, or Zeus), one is worshiping the spirit that inspired its creation. The Golden Calf was an empty vessel. Some take that to the extreme to beleive that all images of God are idolotry (Christian as well as Islamic sects do this!), but that wasn't the message. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Yes I do believe that it does NOT teach that in the present tense. AH! And there is a reason for that as well. Islam is about 600 years younger thant the Christianity. SO, ISLAM can be compared to Christianiyt about 600 years ago. When you adjust for maturity, then that becomes an Apples to Apples comparison. But even then, if you are a biblical literalist, the time difference shouldn't matter. If the Bible says to stone a sinner, you stone the sinner! 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I'm out of time on this computer (2 hr limit at UHD library) so rock and roll guys, I'll be home later tonight without the time limit. 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

There was a time when God spoke to specific issues at hand and condoned genocide. There was also the death penalty for just about everything from stealing to being unclean (ritualistically) Interesting that the omniscient God changes his rules given the times?? 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

Nope just the enforcement method. Hence, rule. Funny! 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

When Yahweh told Moses "Thou shalt have no other Gods before me." He wasn't saying the Jews couldn't worship other gods, he was saying that Yahweh should be their chief god. that is not what God was saying. btw, the word gods is not capitalized. God said "before me". in other words "in my presence" "Exodus 22:28" the Hebrew word used for "gods" there is the exact same word used for "God". so the verse would be understood as "You shall not revile God." God is "the ruler of thy people". in Acts 23:5 Paul makes reference to this verse in his defense before the Sanhedrin 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

It is not "buffet religion" to accept that some parts of the Bible were given to specific people at a specific time. Noah was told to go build an ark. That doesn't mean that we all have to build an ark, nor does it mean we're "picking and choosing" what to believe. Even within Judaism, there is the concept that nobody can keep the entire Torah, as some laws tell men to do something, and other laws tell women to do something. The million dollar question, then, is not whether we can believe the Bible in its entirety, but which of its teachings were meant as universal principles, and which ones were meant for specific people only, i.e., which ones were provisional (such as the ones regarding slavery). 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

o accept that some parts of the Bible were given to specific people at a specific time. And your example is bad. Those instructions were NOT originally addressed to everyone. Noah's instructions were for a specific singular act. As were Moses' instructions to lead the Israelites out of Egypt. So no, we don't all have to do that. But when people pick and choose what are considered universal laws. Laws handed down to be followed by all I.e. the prohibition against eating pork, or the rules for when to make burnt offerings, or the rules indicating that heretics (or adulterers, or homosexuals, or beastiality practicioners (and why does the Donkey deserve to be stoned too?)) are to be stoned to death. and then people say, oh, those rules don't apply to us anymore, we've grown past that. But THESE rules that support our political position (I.E. suffer not a witch to live, eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth, etc), we'll keep those. That is EXACTLY the definition of Buffet Religion. When you quote a piece of scripture and base your position on that scripture saying it is the word of almighty god, and then ignore the very next verse because it doesn't fit into your world view, then that destroys any credibility you may have had and makes you a complete hypocrite. That is EXACTLY the definition of Buffet Religion. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I don't agree with your interpretation. the word gods is not capitalized. As a PAGAN, for me, the word Gods most certainly IS capitalized. 

Possum --- 17 years ago -

See my thread that I just posted on their plan to re-write the bible so that it jives with their agenda :D 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Hubris, that's the term that comes to mind, Hubris. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

and then people say, oh, those rules don't apply to us anymore, we've grown past that. no, we don't say that. i wonder why it is necessary for you to lie. But THESE rules that support our political position (I.E. suffer not a witch to live, eye for an eye, tooth for a tooth, etc), we'll keep those. no, we don't say that either. again, i wonder why it is necessary for you to lie. Hubris, that's the term that comes to mind, Hubris. yes, that term describes your efforts precisely I don't agree with your interpretation. no interpretation was needed. apparently your definition of interpretation is skewed 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

and then ignore the very next verse because it doesn't fit into your world view, How would you know WHY I say some verses apply and some don't? It's not because they just don't "fit into my world view". Sometimes it's because a verse wasn't meant for me, and other times it's because I've already fulfilled the commitment, and other times it's because the law was provisional for a set time and place. For example, since we don't live in a theocracy, as the Israelites did when Moses received the Torah, then we don't have the same laws on our books as they did. We can't just stone murderers in a democracy that affords defendants a certain "due process" in the same way that the Israelites could living in a theocracy. That's not being hypocritical, saying that we're "ignoring" that verse. We're not ignoring anything; we're saying that that isn't a law our society practices. MOST Christian Biblical scholars will tell you that there are different covenants covered within the Bible. The main ones between God and other people are: the Noahide Covenant, the Abrahamic Covenant, the Mosaic Covenant, the Davidic Covenant, and the Messianic ("New") Covenant. These Covenants, or agreements, are between God and another party. Most of the laws you mentioned fall within the Mosaic Covenant. Again, MOST Christian and Jewish scholars will tell you that the Mosaic Law was intended only for the Jewish people or for non-Jews ("foreigners", in the Tanakh) who have aligned themselves with the Jewish people. As such, that law is not binding on non-Jews. Other parts of the Bible, such as the Noahide Covenant, are intended for all peoples of the earth, regardless of religion. Other parts of the Bible, such as the commandments of Jesus, were given to his disciples. MOST Christian scholars will tell you that those commandments, therefore, are binding on all people who claim to be Jesus' disciples, regardless of era. The fact that Jesus reiterated the 10 commandments in his life and his teachings compels most believers to feel they should comply with them. But most believers do not believe that they are bound by ALL the rules of the covenant between Israel and God. Let me give you a few examples for clarity: (a) Setting up just courts--commandment given to Noah and therefore binding on every society. (b) Offering blood sacrifices in the Temple--provisional commandment given to Jews during a time when there was a physical temple. Not binding if there IS NO temple. (c) Substituting Jesus' blood for our propitiation for our sins--a concept introduced by Jesus to His followers, thereby FULFILLING the blood sacrifice requirement portion of the Torah for those requesting it. (d) Following the principles found in the book of Proverbs--something wise people will do, although it isn't part of any binding covenant. I really don't understand your argument in its entirety. Surely you recognize that different societies had different laws on their books, different cultural norms, different conveniences, etc. Moreover, you understand that private agreements between other parties aren't binding on everyone else. So you can surely understand that there are passages of the Bible that were provisional (like how to treat your slaves, or how to treat women), requirements that have been fulfilled (sacrifices), and passages that were specific to a person or a group of people. That said, there is nothing preventing non-participants of a covenant from looking at the provisions and saying, "That sounds like a good principle. I think I'll try it out." And that, in a nutshell, is how I approach the Torah. Although I'm not bound by it as law, I do think that the Creator God would have wanted the very best for His children, so I adopt as many of the practices as are practical for me, living in this non-Jewish, non-theocratic, post-temple-destruction, Messianic Age community. I also try to follow the rest of the Bible--the wisdom literature, the prophets, the Gospels--as closely as I possibly can. Whether I'm required to do so, or whether it's just a good idea, I'll leave to my judge. Do I fall short? Of course I do! But I study the Scriptures and try to learn the best way to live and do my best. I see nothing hypocritical about that. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

How would you know WHY I say some verses apply and some don't? How about this then. IT DOESN'T MATTER WHY YOU IGNORE THE VERY NEXT VERSE. No matter what the reason, if you pick and choose it is "Buffet Religion". And what you describe, the changing of Biblical law because we have a different type of government, that's exactly what I'm talking about. THE PROBLEM occurs when people pick and choose what laws they wish to follow from the Torah. By proclaiming one part the word of god the next part unnecessary.  

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

THE PROBLEM occurs when people pick and choose what laws they wish to follow from the Torah. By proclaiming one part the word of god the next part unnecessary. The Torah IS the word of God, but it was given to Israel at Mt. Sinai. Some of its specific principles are a little hard to comply with today. Nevertheless, it was God's design for how He wanted His people to live. Therefore, it would be wise to study it and observe its spirit, even if the letter isn't followed. One more example to try to illustrate the point I'm trying to make: The Torah told Israel to show skin lesions to a priest to determine if they have leprosy. Now, I have no priest in my community trained in the field of dermatology. Does that mean that God didn't tell his people to go to a priest when they had skin lesions? NO. Does it mean I'm out of compliance if I don't go to the priest the next time I suspect I have leprosy? Maybe. But I'm just out of luck, because our community doesn't offer that priestly service. Now, re. the prohibition against murder--should I be obligated to concede that murder is permissible, because other parts of the Law are impractical for me to keep? Of course not! But that is what your reasoning is applying! That because I can't or won't keep numerous points of the Torah, then I have to throw the whole thing out as a guide. Do you keep every single law on our books? I mean, you never let your car registration lapse for a few days, never speed? Now, I'm sure you TRY to follow them. But you don't lose sleep over it if you don't, right? Does that mean you invalidate ALL the laws on our books? One or two of them aren't that important to you, so therefore you're disqualified from EVER using ANY of the laws to your advantage? You can't stop a thief from coming into your home, because that would be hypocritical of you to say that's against the law, when you get to pick and choose which laws you keep. See how silly that sounds? The underlying Torah principles of justice, mercy, truth, love, and grace do not become obsolete, but transcend time and cultural references. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

No matter what the reason, if you pick and choose it is "Buffet Religion". which "rules" a Christian follows in obedience to God because of our love for God is God's choice, not ours. the purpose of Christ dying on the cross for us was to establish a NEW covenant on how God deals with us in relation to our sin 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground