Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Need dog advice!! They got into a fight! =(

who's talking here?

outermaga 2
Justwatching72 2
Deltadawn 1
Zionist NightOwl 1
ExLady In Blue 4
OH SNAP! 3
clockwatcher. 1
pumpkinsmom2 2
alreadygone~~ 3
MeriZephyr 4
dylansaunt 1
karma 9

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

I have a little Boston and a larger mutt that we rescued from the SPCA. The Boston thinks she's the alpha dog, and a lot of the time she'll jump up and start biting at the bigger dog's snout to try to establish dominance. The rest of the time, she's really sweet-natured although active. Just now, my daughter was outside playing with them, and the Boston came up and started attacking the bigger one. This time, the bigger one I guess had, had enough and tried to stop her by biting down on the back of her neck. This caused my Boston to go nuts, and they started fighting. My daughter was terrified and started screaming, and it took me a good 2-3 minutes of trying to separate them with a broom before I could finally get the Boston off of her. My question is what to do now. My Boston is around 11 pounds, and the rescue is over 50. The rescue has a really strong maternal instinct, so she never tried to hurt her. She could've killed her if she did and my Boston doesn't have a mark on her. The rescue, however, is bleeding from two places on her paw. I'm afraid to let them anywhere near each other, because if the rescue has lost patience with my Boston jumping on her, this will continue to happen. I'm glad my daughter had the presence of mind to not try to separate them herself or she could've gotten really hurt. Right now I have one in the garage and one outside. Am I going to need to rehome one of them for their own safety? I've never had 2 dogs before, and I'm still shaking from the whole thing. 

outermaga --- 17 years ago -

It sounds like you will need to put the dominate one in a kennel every time she starts. Maybe then she will get the point. Ours did that for a little while until we started doing that.. now he gets it. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

I do have a kennel for her. I'll give it a try. Right now I'm just scared to let them anywhere near each other. I guess I'll keep them separated tonight and let them cool their heels, then maybe bring the Boston around with a leash on and see if she tries to pick a fight again. 

outermaga --- 17 years ago -

I was told if you get the dominate one on the ground with you over her that will also help. It lets her know that you are the boss not her. I have seen in work on a couple of dogs. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

OH SNAP! If you follow Cesar Milan's way (which I think is pretty good), you should have been addressing the dominance issue as soon as it started. Okay, I'm not going to jump on you - hind sight 20/20. Anyway, there are a couple of things you need to do. First, you need to stop the smaller one trying to show its dominance ASAP. Second, you need to assume the "alpha" role, so the dogs will not try to be dominant over each other. For me, as soon as they start squaring off, growling or showing teeth, you need to break it up and put the aggressor in their place. It's not always easy, and a lot of times it can be scary. Dogs can sense your fear, so no matter what your brain is telling you (maybe to run and get the broom), try to remain calm and put the dog in the position that outermaga has describe. I had this problem for a while, and things started settling down for a while, and then out of no where, I noticed some aggression again in one of the dogs. My dogs have actually fought over dog spittle in their bowls after they've eaten! One of the things that I found that worked, when it seemed like they were destined to go after each other was to act really upbeat and call one of the dogs over like I was going to give them a treat or give them extra attention. A lot of times this diverted them away from the source of the aggression (the spittle in the bowl), and over to me so I could try to get them in a happy mood. There is a lot more than just this, but my brain is fried from a long work day. If I think of anything else, I will post it later. Oh, and Cesar says dogs need exercise, discipline, and affection (in that order). 

clockwatcher. --- 17 years ago -

GREAT advice, Ex-lady in blue...;)...with dogs, it will always be a pack mentality...and owners should always be alpha. 

alreadygone~~ --- 17 years ago -

One thing for sure, this issue will not be settled between them by separating them. They need to settle this, without human intervention, the only intervention should be if they actually try to kill each other. It will be hard to watch but they must be allowed to settle this themselves! 

dylansaunt --- 17 years ago -

Everyones advice is really good. I will try to help with the other question you have. I work for a vet clinic, and our doctor says wash the foot with saline wound wash ( you can get it from walgreens) and then neosporin. Just the plain one not the one with pain med in it. And watch it to make sure it doesnt start to look infected. If it does you should go to the vet and get some antibiotics. Good Luck and Hope this helps!!!! 

pumpkinsmom2 --- 17 years ago -

Great advice ExLadyinBlue...what do you think of airhorns? As a foster mom I get the fighting thing, too. I can control it at my home, but the dog park is another thing. We've starting tooting an airhorn (we get the large ones at Walmart)and it gets their attention, but I'm wondering if it just delays the problem instead of fixing it. It's a little different at the dog park because some people react to their dog's aggression differently. But, boy...it stops them in their tracks, lol. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

I don't know about airhorns. That could actually be too loud and startle a dog, thereby causing it to get defensive and show aggression. 

pumpkinsmom2 --- 17 years ago -

Thanks...I'm good at fostering but still learning about training! 

MeriZephyr --- 17 years ago -

Excellent advice,exlib. I have done many of the techniques described and it does stop the agression.I also have small dogs, so I use a LARGE squirt bottle on them(kinda like trainin a cat),and it works quite well. Good luck,OhSnap, and hang in there,it should prove worth the effort....and if not,come get some more fried pickles,lol!(I enjoyed seeing you and your little one that day,even if the crazies reached in and took your wares!) 

MeriZephyr --- 17 years ago -

Excellent advice,exlib. I have done many of the techniques described and it does stop the agression.I also have small dogs, so I use a LARGE squirt bottle on them(kinda like trainin a cat),and it works quite well. Good luck,OhSnap, and hang in there,it should prove worth the effort....and if not,come get some more fried pickles,lol!(I enjoyed seeing you and your little one that day,even if the crazies reached in and took your wares!) 

MeriZephyr --- 17 years ago -

Excellent advice,exlib. I have done many of the techniques described and it does stop the agression.I also have small dogs, so I use a LARGE squirt bottle on them(kinda like trainin a cat),and it works quite well. Good luck,OhSnap, and hang in there,it should prove worth the effort....and if not,come get some more fried pickles,lol!(I enjoyed seeing you and your little one that day,even if the crazies reached in and took your wares!) 

MeriZephyr --- 17 years ago -

sorry for the many posts....my comp is going psycho! 

karma --- 17 years ago -

The "alpha roll" is a very dated method and can be dangerous for the handler if you mess with a dog who doesn't want to back down and wants to challenge. Fighting fire with fire is not always the smart thing to do. You need to be one step ahead of the dog...we're the ones with the bigger brains and opposable thumbs. Cesar Milan is an expert in extreme cases and what they show in 30 minutes or an hour is not all that goes on I guarantee you. It is actually really upsetting that he recommends the alpha roll on his show...most people have no business even attempting that maneuver on an aggressive dog. I think Victoria Stillwell gives better advice and training methods for the general public to use. A link to some good reading about the alpha roll and why you shouldn't use it. http://www.dogstardaily.com/blogs/alpha-roll-or-alpha-role Some reasons why you shouldn't force your dog to the ground wannago, that is HORRIBLE advice. Who wants badly injured or dead dogs on their hands? Obviously OP's dogs were not going to stop. Alpha dogs rarely resort to actual fighting to prove a point or their rank. Could your Boston be resource guarding your daughter? How does she react to other bigger dogs out on walks or in public, does she bark or lunge? Could she just be insecure and since you aren't taking the lead as the alpha, she is taking it into her own hands? Since you have a dog pack and need some direction on how to handle them I highly suggest this book, it's an easy short read and it helped me out a lot: leader of the pack You might also want to try consulting a professional behaviorist that has experience with dog aggression. 

alreadygone~~ --- 17 years ago -

wannago, that is HORRIBLE advice. Who wants badly injured or dead dogs on their hands? Obviously OP's dogs were not going to stop. I'll be sure to let the lead trainer at the HPD K9 unit know. That is where I've been trained in this field. Thanks. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

K9 dogs go through different training than your average family pets. They also NEED to be drivey. We're talking about a Boston terrier and a shelter mutt here. In some instances You need to let the dogs establish a heirarchy(I probably butchered that word) however one dog jumping on another for an all out war is NOT normal or acceptable. The Boston could very easily be killed. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

Btw you're talking to someone who does rescue work for Houston German Shepherd and Dobermans here, who knows the difference between SchH/PPT and regular OB training, grew up in a law enforcement family and is currently with an HPD officer. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Was I supposed to list my credentials, too? I've owned dogs all of my life, am a former police officer (don't know what living with an HPD officer has to do with this, but I will play along) and have been in dog resue for years. Regarding whether or not Cesar Milan's way works, or not, all I can say is what has and has not worked for me. I have had numerous alpha type dogs. One of my rescues is a Shiba Inu/Chow mix that had some major aggression issues. Since I found her dumped, in an industrial area near work, I did not have the luxury of knowing her background. She hated men, was aggressive toward children, and used to nip (not bite) every person she met. She is now a happy dog and does not display any of those characteristics anymore, but it took me a while to get her there and Cesar's way was the only thing that worked. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

BTW, the Boston Terrier is the one with the alpha tendencies which is somewhat to be expected with a terrier breed. If she can nip this in the bud now, it will be easy peasy for her down the road. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

I don't give a crap about credentials but since that card was played.. Cesar's techniques can and do work in some cases but there are numerous studies and new research in the training world that de-bunks the alpha roll method.....just so some googling. You sound like you know what you are doing and you have experience whereas the OP does not. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

Ex lady I agree...those terriers are tenacious! We are currently training our pit bull and she's in that teen angst stage. A good, solid foundation and consistency are key with training! You also have to keep in mind that not every dog can be rehabilitated and dog aggression may never go away, but it can be managed. Even Cesar says this.... 

Deltadawn --- 17 years ago -

Having been involved with Boston rescue, terriers can be handful to try and train. Yes, OS you need to be in control and stop your BT's behavior. Put a harness on her and a long lead, and the minute she starts to show any signs of aggression, call her to you, pull her if necessary, and make her sit and stay until she calms down, but do not give her any real attention, they hate being ignored, which is what it will feel like to her. You will likely have to do this repeatedly before she gets the message. BTs are known for being stubborn. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

I've been dealing with an aggressive male kitty (who isn't slated for neutering until Monday, the 12th) who keeps harassing the older (spayed) female. At first it was just kitten play--he wanted her to play-fight with him, and she wouldn't play along. Now it's sexual aggression. I've just been separating them, hoping everything will be resolved on the 12th. While reading this, I was thinking that these were all great techniques to try on my cats, except for this one, of course: make her sit and stay until she calms down, but do not give her any real attention; they hate being ignored. Hahahahahahaha. Cats rule in the ignoring department. I wouldn't win that one. 

Justwatching72 --- 17 years ago -

that de-bunks the alpha roll method. Not-true. Moved in with now ex-wife. She had two dogs. One lab/rott mix 120 lbs, one pit/lab mix 75 lbs. Both male. Before i had moved in, her son had brought over his female pitbull, not fixed, a few months prior to me moving in. The two males always got along great until this female was introduced, they started after each other every time, all time, ex-wife had to keep them separated ALL the time. I moved in and was not going to mess with them being separated every day. I got a hold of BOTH of them, by their collars, held them at arms length from each other, they were fighting and and trying to get at each other, I just kept a hold of them would not let them do it and kept saying 'No' in a firm voice, after about 5-10 minutes of them fussing, they both calmed down and were back to their normal ways. I used the alpha role method and it worked just fine. It has not been debunked. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

Cool beans, Justwatching...but that's not an alpha roll, you just simply held your dogs apart from each other until they calmed down(and great that it worked and you didn't give in!) An alpha roll is where you grab a dog by the neck and forcefully flip or roll it on it's side or back and force it to "submit" by putting the fear of Jesus into it like a wolf would do in the wild if it is about to kill a fellow wolf or seriously do some damage. 

Justwatching72 --- 17 years ago -

!) An alpha roll is where you grab a dog by the neck and forcefully flip or roll it on it's side or back and force it to "submit" by putting the fear of Jesus into it like a wolf would do in the wild if it is about to kill a fellow wolf or seriously do some damage. Sorry, I misunderstood. I had to do that as well with others dogs and it worked fine. Never had any problems getting unruly dogs to submit. It's all about your tone and how you carry yourself. I only ever did with with dogs I had to live with though. Would never do it for someone elses dog, they have to be the ones to do it. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

Exactly...body language and attitude go a long way with dogs because that is the language they speak. If you are truly the alpha of your pack you don't have to resort to physical punishment to prove your rank. If you think this is BS then please google and do some reading up. Alphas control with body language and attitude and not by making their dogs fear them, fear is not the same as respect and trust. I can make my 80 lb Male German Shepherd submit and roll over just by eyeing him and standing over him and I have never physically inflicted pain or force on him to get him to submit, it's all in how you carry yourself, not your fist. And I'm a 105 lb girl. 

karma --- 17 years ago -

In general, If a dog obeys you because you hit or beat him it is solely because you have scared the crap out of him, not because he respects and trusts you as his alpha regardless of what you may want to think. Dogs that undergo this type of "training" and correction will usually be a bit hand shy. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Just wanted to update everyone and let them know that since that incident, Chloe has been on her best behavior. I think she felt bad about what she did. She was kinda mopey the next day, but now they're back to being bff's. Girls! haha 

karma --- 17 years ago -

B!tch fights are crazy. They are the more dominant of the sexes in the dog world! My females are always messin' with each other while the male just kicks back and chills/takes no part in it. 

alreadygone~~ --- 17 years ago -

One thing for sure, this issue will not be settled between them by separating them. They need to settle this, without human intervention, the only intervention should be if they actually try to kill each other. It will be hard to watch but they must be allowed to settle this themselves!  

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground