Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Cantor To Uninsured Woman With Growing Tumors: Get ‘An Existing Government Program’ Or Find Charity

who's talking here?

Empty Nest 1
NoNameNoLastName 1
david 1
~sassy~ 1
Wilstar77 1
ladyjane 3
james osterberg 5
Missus Cravitz 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

Keep in mind,this guy is 2nd in command. At the Richmond Times-Dispatch “public square” forum yesterday, Rep. Eric Cantor (R-VA) fielded open questions from his constituents on the health reform debate for the first time this summer. Patricia Churchill relayed a story about a close family member who recently lost a high paying job and her health insurance. Churchill told Cantor that her relative was dying of stomach tumors and needs an operation as soon as possible. Cantor responded by suggesting that Churchill’s relative should seek “existing government programs” or find charity. Cantor, who serves as the chief whip for his party, has said that he cannot support a health reform bill with a public option. But despite his political opposition to government insurance programs, Cantor then emphasized to Churchill that every American should be given an “option” for health care, including a government program: CHURCHILL: I have a very close relative, a woman in her early forties, who did have a wonderful, high-paying job, owns her own home and is a real contributing member of society. She lost her job. Just a couple of weeks ago, she found out that she has tumors in her belly and that she needs an operation. Her doctors told her that they are growing and that she needs to get this operation quickly. She has no insurance. [...] CANTOR: First of all I guess I would ask what the situation is in terms of income eligibility and the existing programs that are out there. Because if we look at the uninsured that are out there right now, there is probably 23, 24% of the uninsured that is already eligible for an existing government program [...] Beyond that, I know that there are programs, there are charitable organizations, there are hospitals here who do provide charity care if there’s an instance of indigency and the individual is not eligible for existing programs that there can be some cooperative effort. No one in this country, given who we are, should be sitting without an option to be addressed. thinkprogress.org 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

how is this spin. Video of his exact words are on youtube. who is spinning? me,Cantor,Patricia,the video?? http://thinkprogress.org/2009/09/22-uninsured-option/ www.huffingtonpost/politics/ 

david --- 17 years ago -

www.huffingtonpost/politics/ lmao 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

Beyond that, I know that there are programs, there are charitable organizations, there are hospitals here who do provide charity care if there’s an instance of indigency and the individual is not eligible for existing programs that there can be some cooperative effort 1. Charity giving is low because the economy sucks, stocks tanked, and some people stole from them-- Madoff 2. People who are ill are not in a position to do charity and indigent care shopping. Goddness, how long does it take for you to get through to you Dr. to get test results? And you're healthy! Now get busy with your indigent care shopping. 3. A Congressperson who gets govt. sponsored healthcare for life (via our tax dollars), is certainly an odd person to be telling people that this should not be an option for all. 4. So a person who has worked all of their life should give up there assets in order to become indigent to qualify for health care? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

A Congressperson who gets govt. sponsored healthcare for life (via our tax dollars), is certainly an odd person to be telling people that this should not be an option for all. Hence my point the other day - if those representatives felt really strong about private insurance, they should give up their government sponsored plan and shop around. Not a single one has the stones to do it. But they have the stones to defend private health insurance. And people fall for it... 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

This type of story is alien to people in Canada, England and France. America is #1, lets start treating our citizens like it. 

ladyjane --- 17 years ago -

1. Charity giving is low because the economy sucks, stocks tanked, and some people stole from them-- Madoff And because tax incentives for charitable giving are going away, along with jobs, so people with money are battening the hatches and waiting for the government to seize their "contributions" through tax increases. Many people I talk to who have pretty good incomes are afraid they won't be able to use their extra funds to help family members anymore....sad. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

This type of story is alien to a good number of people here in this country and on KU. Some are on Medicare,others rely on their employer provided coverage and can't imagine this happening to them. I found it to be describing a situation tyhat could very well happen to all the hard working,home owning,good paying job,community minded,church and society involved people around here. Yet,they have a blind eye to the fact that they are not as secure as their boss makes them think. Also,in light of the convention recently held by the religious right spotlighting their lack of any real compassion for this subject,we see no responses here defending this,or discussion of why these leaders grip the bible with both hands and ignore Matthew 25,Tony Perkins,himself,justifying their position saying "There aren't really that many people needing help" I was shocked to find out that in the religious right's world of compassion and mercy,it all a numbers game. Praise the modern day church. 

ladyjane --- 17 years ago -

I'm not talking about "very rich relatives," I'm talking about people who work hard and save, maybe have good educations or good business sense who can spare a thousand here or there. When these people make it into the 200-plus tax range, which, yes, is a lot of money but not rich in my eyes, the government doesn't care how many hours they work to make that income. I'm thinking of people who may work a full-time job and have a catering, or cleaning, or other additional business on the side so they can help out family members, maybe send their kids to a private school, or, um, finance their kid's way to medical school. Those people are worried, and wondering if their superhuman efforts are worth it. They're afraid to give to their church, the animal rescue, or the arts society for fear that, after the tax man cometh, they won't have enough to take care of mom when she needs somewhere to live, or deadbeat brother who leaves his kids....You know, normal life that the government probably will frown on allowing exceptions for.... 

Missus Cravitz --- 17 years ago -

I found it to be describing a situation tyhat could very well happen to all the hard working,home owning,good paying job,community minded,church and society involved people around here. Yet,they have a blind eye to the fact that they are not as secure as their boss makes them think. I shared on the other thread, that all learning begins with what we know and live.They assume the choices they made have saved them from healthcare problems or financial issues. I believe you are correct, that many saying, "Let them eat cake", aren't royalty, and it is only the absence of an accidents, job loss, or illness that has spared them from feeling the pain. Allowing this broken system to continue, because they haven't felt the pain, is ignoring a problem that impacts everyone, and one they are not immune to. I also cannot understand how people claim to be religious, but are willing to allow some people to go without care because they are poor, uninsured, lost a job, or insured and bankrupt because of co-pays, % payments, and major hospital bills for chronic care. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

I also cannot understand how people claim to be religious, but are willing to allow some people to go without care because they are poor, We all have a learned view,from days of being dragged to sunday school and a lifetime to come,of the tithe.Is that the helping hand we have given the church's stewarts.I think we believe it and it clears our marker. Why should we need be further concerned? retorically 

Empty Nest --- 17 years ago -

Are you saying that non-Christians are the only ones who give to the poor? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

4. So a person who has worked all of their life should give up there assets in order to become indigent to qualify for health care? Freaking sucks...and I agree that something needs to be done, but not on such a massive scale as in being proposed. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

scoutmom --- 27 min ago I'm saying that I think this is how the modern day conservative Christian leaders explain why they are not all over this issue with unquestioned support,They preach the importance of the fisrt tenth going to God.But what is it going toward in this new Church? I see bigger,shiney Churches raising bigger money to get bigger,etc,etc. Somewhere I heard about this parabel(?) about the guy who contimplated building bigger barns because of his success. Did God step in a say somthing about his soul needing to be somewhere else tonight,forget the big barns? My point of contention is with the leaders of this modern day Church,They are a mockery of themselves,and I can't follow people like this. their behavior mocks the gospel books beyond my belief. 

ladyjane --- 17 years ago -

Cry me a river baby!!!!! Earning over $200,000 annually is a VERY GOOD SALARY!!!!! They're afraid to give????? Those poor people!!!!BWAHAHAHAHAHahaaaaaaaaaaa  Sure, that's good money, but don't tell me you don't have anyone in your world who, along with their spouse, works a full-time job, then goes off to apply wallpaper, mow lawns, cater parties, etc. There are so many people who work long hours to try to reach the bigger bucks so that they can take care of their families better. While I don't know anyone doing this kind of this who isn't grateful for the opportunity to make extra income, I also know they'd say it doesn't go as far as you'd think if you have a disabled child, if you need to house one or more elderly parents, if you want to take in foster children, etc. In my world, people with this type of work ethic are trying to batten the hatches in preparation for higher taxes, they're hesitant to give as much to charities they used to support, and they certainly aren't looking for opportunities to take on new employees. The government doesn't care how many hours you work to "cross the line," or what you need or want to do with it, they just want the money. Just a reminder, not everyone who works this hard is vacationing in Tahiti, sometimes they're just trying to take care of their own. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground