Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

MINIMUM LEGALIZATION STANDARDS IF ILLEGALS ARE LET IN

who's talking here?

randyjet 11
planemom 4
Sandyr9111 1
lizandmike 1
funmom 1
justforfun 1
~sassy~ 1
Meme2my5 4
BigPantiesHatesMe 2
evolved 1
~hopscotch~ 4
MxMike. 2
amabo 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

It looks as though some effort at legalization of illegals may pass at some point in this administration. The very best that those who are opposed to this can do, will be to make sure it is NOT a farce as it was last time in 1986 under Reagan. Here are some points which MUST be part of any such bill. The first problem will be to determine WHO the person is. To that end, ONLY a valid passport from the home country should be accepted, or in the case of Mexico, a voter ID card will be acceptable. It will be virtually impossible for the US to determine who the person is other than to take their word if this is NOT a requirement. The home country will have a BIG incentive to make sure that these are indeed their citizens and that they have no criminal record. The reason is that they want them to stay here and keep sending money home. The other reason is that if they are crooks, they WILL be deported BACK to that home country. If they want to accept all the crooks from other countries, they are more than welcome to do so. Another point will be to mandate that ALL males under the age of 40 MUST SHOW proof of registration with Selective Service as is required by law. The max age for any male to register should be raised to 40 if they did not register at age 18. It will also prevent fudging on age and be a penalty for the fact that they violated the law to begin with. There must be NO amnesty for crimes committed in keeping their illegal status hidden or to keep working. If the rest of us must abide by those laws, they damn well can too! To encourage them to make their status legal, there should be a provision that if they confess to the crimes such as ID theft, forgery, perjury that they go before a judge to determine the sentence and have that in their record. I would think that a period of probation would be a recommended guidelines for such things depending on the amount of damages done. That they get the standard of no benefits for at least FIVE years as ALL other LEGAL immigrants have to wait on. That they get no Federal benefits for education unless ALL American students get the SAME benefit as in state tuition. The one exception should be for ROTC scholarships. That ALL Federal contractors MUST use E-Verify to get Federal contracts and use it for ALL employees. That all Social Security no match letters be taken care of or the person who fails to resolve the problem will be fired and the ICE notified of their lack of legal status. That the border fencing must be completed and increased enforcement along the border be mandated. If this requires Federal troops, then they will be authorized to be used indefinitely, along with funding for the National Guard to augment them. That all state and local police agencies MUST report any suspected illegals in their custody and held until their status is determined. NO BAIL will be allowed until such a determination is made. That NO amnesty governmental entities will be able to get ANY Federal funds whatsoever. If they refuse to take part in any of these provisions, then all funds will be withdrawn until such time as they follow the law. These are but some of the things that MUST be insisted upon, and I seriously doubt that any Democratic legislator who wants to keep their job will be able to vote against any of these. I know that I wll NOT be voting for any of them if they do NOT support them.  

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Heres my question, so if they get amnesty and let's say they are 62, then they file for social sec., tell me how fair that is? How fair with Medicare? Social Sec. recipients aren't getting their measly raise this yr. so how would we have money for amnesty but not for those who have pd in? 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Heres my question, so if they get amnesty and let's say they are 62, then they file for social sec., tell me how fair that is? How fair with Medicare? Social Sec. recipients aren't getting their measly raise this yr. so how would we have money for amnesty but not for those who have pd in? This was my problem on the other thread. Why the hell should we pay in all these years but those who havent can access medicare, and SSI??? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Good point that needs to be addressed! I can't think of everything. That is the reason I posted this since it is a way to get a rational bill that will not be a farce. It is better to make friendly amendments if you are in favor of a bill, and a good way to make sure that the open borders types don't get their wish list. Also, it is a way for the GOP to deny that they are mainly anti-Hispanic too. Common sense legislation on this is possible and be bi-partisan too. It will aslo be a way to step up enforcement and drive out those who do NOT take the deal. Of course, a US criminal background check should be mandated, along with mandatory DNA sampling too. Then the real crooks will be discouraged from even attempting to become legal. It will also cut down on the numbers of people having to be processed and make such US background checks more serious. Trying to do 12 million would be a joke. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Heres my question, so if they get amnesty and let's say they are 62, then they file for social sec., tell me What does fairness have to do with anything? Now you just watch the influx of illegals...California is breaking under the strain...us too! 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Common sense legislation on this is possible and be bi-partisan too. It will aslo be a way to step up enforcement and drive out those who do NOT take the deal. How can they drive out those who don't take the deal? They can't even drive out those that are criminals. They have lost complete control with illegals. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

How fair with Medicare? Social Sec. recipients aren't getting their measly raise this yr. so how would we have money for amnesty but not for those who have pd in? That is a REALLY complex problem for a number of reasons. Under Reagan, the Congress passed a bill allowing older refugees SS payments if they were of that age. Even if they NEVER paid a dime into it. This was continued as far as I know. WE would have to change the SS law to stop this kind of thing. I would be in support of that too. The other problem is the unclaimed SS benefits that some illegals have paid into SS fund. That has been estimated to run to billions. I would think that ONLY the most restrictive criterion should be used before they get credit for such payments. For example, an illegal who has worked here for at least ten years at the same employer and using the same name. That will still exclude a large number, but they knew the rules when they entered, so I don't think that they have any room to gripe about it. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

How can they drive out those who don't take the deal? They can't even drive out those that are criminals They can do that by increasing enforcement and data sharing with ICE. They can step up work place raids, increased use of E-Verify, no match letters, etc.. It will take time, there is NO quick fix, but we DO have to have means and methods to knock down the problem to more managable levels. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

And what if they don't work for them for 10yrs, they wouldn't get SS? Then what would they live on? They can't live on nothing or they would be in the streets. The U.S. has become a welfare country and we are going broke doing it. There has to be some tough decisions made. Would illegals be given amnesty then qualify for WIC? How about welfare? What if they are given amnesty and lose their jobs do they then qualify for unemployment? There are just too many programs the 35 million could benefit from and it's not only the cost but the fairness.We put into the system and then someone else draws from it. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I agree we need to secure the borders. This needs to happen before any amnesty bill. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

And what if they don't work for them for 10yrs, they wouldn't get SS? That is right since there has to be some cutoff point. Of course, being here illegally, they get nothing at all in any case. They will simply have to go back home where ever that may be. I do NOT support any amnesty at all. The last bill was touted as NOT being an amnesty since there were some things that the illegals would have to do and pay. In fact, while it was not an amnesty for coming into the US illegally, it WAS in FACT an amnesty since it granted an amnesty for ALL CRIMES COMMITTED in connection with their being here illegally. Thus forgery, ID theft, perjury, document theft, SS fraud, etc.. were all forgiven. Securing the border FIRST is a no brainer, but we can best get votes from all if it is in an immigration reform bill. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Would illegals be given amnesty then qualify for WIC? They already qualify if their children were born here. How about welfare? What if they are given amnesty and lose their jobs do they then qualify for unemployment? As I said in my post, they would have to have the FIVE year period of legal residency that ALL LEGAL immigrants must wait for before they get any such benefits. If they are listed as employees now, they get unemployment since their employer has already paid into the fund. There would be no change in that, except that there may be more funds since the illegals would have every incentive to work ON the books rather than under the table. The employers would not like that much though, and the newly legalized people would be able to report their employers if they are not paid on the books. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

But we know that even with this, there will still be those that come across the border and work under the table in hopes of another amnesty, so when and how does that end? I know something needs to be done, but illegals aren't going to raise their hands and declare themselves here. Something needs to be done,we all know that.I liked the bill they talked about where they would pay a $5000 fine and then start paying ss, but that bill went away. Too many groups want a full amnesty with no conditions. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

And what if they don't work for them for 10yrs, they wouldn't get SS? Then what would they live on? They can't live on nothing or they would be in the streets. The U.S. has become a welfare country and we are going broke doing it. There has to be some tough decisions made. Would illegals be given amnesty then qualify for WIC? How about welfare? What if they are given amnesty and lose their jobs do they then qualify for unemployment? There are just too many programs the 35 million could benefit from and it's not only the cost but the fairness.We put into the system and then someone else draws from it. But look at the votes that will come from this. It'll be fun to watch this country explode finally. 

lizandmike --- 17 years ago -

I'm sorry, but illegal is illegal. If we're going to have rules on immigration to this country, then everyone who comes in should have to follow them. Period. If they are too hard, difficult, whatever, then change them. ALL ILLEGALS should be deported. Period. That's why it's called illegal. Furthermore, the whole "anchor baby" provision should be completely eliminated. Why do we have immigration laws if they are not inforced??? JMO (on a Friday afternoon...) 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

there will still be those that come across the border and work under the table in hopes of another amnesty, so when and how does that end? The FACT is that the fencing has worked quite well in reducing the number of illegals in those sectors. The increased fencing, BP and if needed,US Army troops will cut that down to a trickle, to damn near zero. Nothing is absolutely foolproof, but that is not the point. By cutting it down so drastically, it will free up enforcement on other more pressing issues, such as smuggling drugs. Also, by having more workplace enforcement, it will free up more agents to round up more day laborers as well. Thus undercutting the underground trade and all those who work off the books. I doubt that we will be 100% effective in making sure only those who should be here are here legally, but I will be happy with 99% which is pretty good. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I find it interesting that trying to have a discussion on substantial matters in detail provokes so little comment. I was hoping that at least having a provocative topic might garner some interest or thinking and an informative exchange of ideas and concerns. 

~hopscotch~ --- 17 years ago -

Just build the f**king fence and get it over with for cryin out loud!!!!!!!!!!! Either that or start offering a bounty for their ears like the game wardens offer us hunters for coyote ears. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I find it interesting that trying to have a discussion on substantial matters in detail provokes so little comment. I was hoping that at least having a provocative topic might garner some interest or thinking and an informative exchange of ideas and concerns. This is one topic that has been beat to death over the years. Congress will do something. Hopefully, it'll be a good piece of legislation but I have my doubts. The federal government doesn't seem to keen on strengthening our borders and until that is done nothing else matters. 

evolved --- 17 years ago -

The GOP needs to live up to it's principles. No aid to the bleeding and dying in emergency rooms that are uninsured and deny food to Mexicans. According to Confederate logic then they'll leave. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Just build the f**king fence and get it over with for cryin out loud!!!!!!!!!!! I agree, BUT the funding for the rest of it is being held up pending new legislation from what I understand. In short, they want to hold it hostage to "immigration reform". That is why we need to know the contents of such bills and their provisions. The fence won't solve the problem of those who are here already. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

That is why we need to know the contents of such bills and their provisions. The fence won't solve the problem of those who are here already. I agree. Both need to be done. However, securing our borders first, would prevent the problem from becoming worse. Here is a CNN article about a school district in Del Rio. It's not about immigration but it highlights one of the many problems with our current system. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

My neighbors in McAllen were LEGAL Mexican immigrants who moved there for the good schools compared to Mexico. They were being hurt by this same thing too. Not only were they paying taxes to school their own children, but they were paying for the kids of those who wanted a free ride on THEM. I saw that the article mentioned the fact that the school district would lose money by kicking the non-residents out. I have NO problem with that since Texas citizens have NO obligation to subsidize free education for Mexicans. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

These same neighbors had to work for substandard wages since most of the people they worked with lived in Mexico. That drove their wages DOWN. They simply commuted to work every day over the border. THAT is why we need E-Verify. It is also why border politicians HATE that idea since it will cut out the cheap labor their main contributors can exploit. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

THAT is why we need E-Verify Is that the program that requires employers to verify immigration status? 

~hopscotch~ --- 17 years ago -

The fence won't solve the problem of those who are here already. Correct you are! However, the fence and bounty offering combined will certainly help. No new illegals, and the ones that are here will either go home or get really really good at hiding. 

amabo --- 17 years ago -

Until ALL AMERICANS have JOBS, the f'g Mexican should NOT be allowed in. 

BigPantiesHatesMe --- 17 years ago -

kindly deleted :-) 

BigPantiesHatesMe --- 17 years ago -

amabo, " f'g Mexican should NOT be allowed in." Well this f'ging Mexican is just glad to be here. ;) But honestly----it is NOT just Mexicans. I don't see many Mexicans in NC---I see people from Honduras, Chili and Peru. 

~hopscotch~ --- 17 years ago -

Dont put yourself in the dark on this one people! Its not just all about "mexicans". Its about illegals, but the main problem does come from the south. 

funmom --- 17 years ago -

i have a friend that works for border and customs in brownsvile and he is always telling me how he will bust someone and they are deported and in a few weeks they are back.. he has busted some of the same people over a half a dozen times.. he carries a gun 24/7 and the other stories he tells me would blow your mind.. 

~hopscotch~ --- 17 years ago -

he has busted some of the same people over a half a dozen times.. Turn the safety off, squeeze the trigger, and allow the river to wash the fresh fish food to the gulf! A few of these sightings of this and a border crossing may become less desirable! JMO 

MxMike. --- 17 years ago -

Agreed, hopscotch. Being nice obviously ain't working. They are here by the millions. This is a silent INVASION of our nation. These people have the nerve to take to OUR streets and protest OUR government for their "rights" while they leech off of our system. NO AMNESTIA, COMPRENDE?!  

MxMike. --- 17 years ago -

This MUST be stopped: Most Americans won't even stand up for their rights, but we've got millions of people here destroying our land and demanding more from us. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground