Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Boy- Girl room sharing?

who's talking here?

Keystone 1
GCan 13
ilovemykids1030 1
Fallon 2
QueenCassie 2
needrnr 1
funmom 1
MoveIt 2
JHMO 1
2girlygirls 1
ghostpost 1
justcat 1
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 13
ladybughomeschool 1
PHSMOMOF2 2
MomofTwins* 1
JohnLynch 6
Shenanigans 1
jamie 1
*momof5* 1
mum2dj&c 11
░magic░ 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

I have a 4 year old girl and a 3 year old boy. I would like to put them in a bedroom together. Only for a few years, not through middle school or anything! They each have their own bed, and would sleep at opposite ends of the room. My husband has deep objections and he can't articulate why. The room will be decorated in a gender neutral theme. I have seen this done before and thought it was well accepted. Am I nuts? 

needrnr --- 17 years ago -

I do not think at that age there would anything wrong. I agree with Steve you have to make do with the space that you have. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

When we were young, my brother and I shared a room until our next sibling came along about three or four years. I don't think it's a big deal. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

They are still too young and should do fine. Even if they are in middle school its your house right??? LOL :) Make due with the space you have. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

My husband has deep objections and he can't articulate why. Machismo. You make due with what you have. I don't think there's anything wrong with putting them in the same room, so many lessons can be learned from sharing a room, boundaries, respect, tolerance, unity (against you, lol), they will learn to comfort one another, lean on each other. If my husband couldn't give a definitive reason, he'd be helping me move furniture. 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

Space is not the problem... if it was, I would have a better case. We have a comfortably sized home with 4-5 bedrooms. My desire for the kids to room share is more a selfish one. We also have a 1 year old who needs his own room right now. So, if my husband gets his way,every child will have their own room. These kids will have more of the house than we do- and what for? I just don't get it? They are little, they don't need all that space. They have a playroom that is full of their stuff, they need a bedroom to sleep in, that's it! Once my 1 year old son is old enough (in 2-3 years) I plan to switch him into the room with my 3 year old son and my daughter will have her own room. She's be about 7 at the time. My husband is so against this and I can not understand why. Thank you guys for all your input 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Space is not the problem... if it was, I would have a better case. if space is not a problem, then they should have their own rooms. i don't understand the "So, if my husband gets his way,every child will have their own room. These kids will have more of the house than we do- and what for? I just don't get it? They are little, they don't need all that space" attitude. sounds like selfishness? i also don't understand why you would want to go against your husband on this. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

i also don't understand why you would want to go against your husband on this. Why does he want to go against her on this? 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

JohnLynch, by my comment I mean that the children have a playroom for their toys and games, so their bedrooms are really only for sleeping. That being the case, I am trying to understand why each of these very young children must have their own room? It's a lot of space in our home to be claimed by children. My desire is somewhat selfish. As it is our home, I feel I can be selfish. I am not making a case for older children to room share, where modesty and sexual identities come into play. I am talking about a 3 year old and a 4 year old. Since you clearly object, could you enlighten me as to why? It would help a great deal, thanks 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

May I ask you this? What will you use the other rooms for then? 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

What will you use the other rooms for then? Nothing like having less rooms to clean! 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Sounds like one room is for parents, one is for one child, one is for the two toddlers. Perhaps the remaining room is for guests, an office, a workroom? 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

SexyEyez, I would use the room for a dedicated guestroom. It's very large and a has a private bath. That is the room in question. Initially, I had the one year old in there, and it's ridiculous to have all that space for a baby (or any child really!) Our intention was to set it up as a guest bedroom and put the crib in there. That's how we've had it. But it still becomes a baby room when he's in there All his stuff in the closet and the dresser- really makes it hard to use it as a guest room. Also, the childproofing necessary for a baby's room makes it very hard to decorate as a guest bedroom. There is plenty of room in my 3 year old son's room for two children. I moved the baby in there 2 weeks ago, and the baby is just not ready. He keeps his big brother up and constantly wants to play. My daughter and son are very close and could do it. Their sleep schedules are very similar. 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

The other room is a playroom... so yes, 1 for parents, 1 for two children, 1 for one child, 1 for guest and storage, and 1 for playroom... 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

It's a lot of space in our home to be claimed by children. i can't understand that reasoning My desire is somewhat selfish. As it is our home, I feel I can be selfish. sorry, but i don't feel that selfishness is ever a good attribute I am not making a case for older children to room share, where modesty and sexual identities come into play. I am talking about a 3 year old and a 4 year old. i would have a problem with it myself since space is not an issue. i have heard and read where children of the opposite sex are inquisitive at around 4 0r 5 about differing body parts. what are you going to do? have them share a room for a year or so and then split them up? what will be accomplished by that? if they were of the same gender, i would feel differently Why does he want to go against her on this? i don't know why, can't read his mind, but it apparently is not out of selfishness. it could be, that like me, he has a problem with boys and girls sharing the same room 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

It's very large and a has a private bath. That's the perfect guest room because it does have a private bath. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

i don't know why, can't read his mind, but it apparently is not out of selfishness. The first half contradicts the second half. Nothing about the father's wishes is apparent, especially if you can't read his mind. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I would say from babies through elementary school age, brothers and sisters can share a room. Once you hit 11, 12, etc, it's time for them to have their own room, or share one with the same gender. I think a guest room with a private bath is a great idea if it's an option! Your guests will think so too. :) 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

Ok, JohnLynch, my question to you is WHY DO YOU HAVE A PROBLEM WITH YOUNG BOYS AND GIRLS SHARING A ROOM? That is the big question my husband won't answer. I would really like to hear your response. 4 and 5 year olds are inquisitive about their bodies and others. It is NOT a sexual inquiry, though. I, too, have read up on this topic, and children of this age are not sexually aware. They each know and understand each others body parts. They still bathe together. Not to mention my children are still on room monitors, so honestly, there is nothing going on in the rooms that is unsupervised. Their bedrooms are for sleeping only (because they have a playroom). They also have a toy box in the family room and they have games in the office. My plan would be to do this for a max of 3 years. 

QueenCassie --- 17 years ago -

I do not see a problem with them sharing a room through elementary age. I would be curious to hear a reason on why your husband (and JohnLynch) are so against boys and girls sharing a room at the age. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

The first half contradicts the second half. lol, what could be selfish about the kids having their own room? WHY DO YOU HAVE A PROBLEM WITH YOUNG BOYS AND GIRLS SHARING A ROOM? don't know why you are so upset. already told you why. you asked for opinions and i gave you mine. then you asked me personally for my reason and i told you why. it is very simple. if you don't want opinions, then don't ask for them. why do you have a problem with them having their own room other than selfishness? 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

*momof5* I agree- 11 or 12 would be too old!!! 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

didn't mean to offend, JohnLynch, I was really looking to hear your reasoning. Beyond objecting to boys and girls room sharing, I am interested in what specifically about boys and girls in a room you object to. Not a feeling, a supporting argument... 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

didn't mean to offend, JohnLynch, I was really looking to hear your reasoning. Beyond objecting to boys and girls room sharing, I am interested in what specifically about boys and girls in a room you object to. Not a feeling, a supporting argument... 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

Beyond objecting to boys and girls room sharing, I am interested in what specifically about boys and girls in a room you object to. as i previously typed "i have heard and read where children of the opposite sex are inquisitive at around 4 or 5 about differing body parts." sharing a room can put more emphasis on that, in the opinion of some psychologists, which i do agree with 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

these are siblings for cryin out loud john lynch!!! I shared a room with my brother for several years around that age. It was nice b/c there were no "afraid of the dark" stages. My mom could come in, read us a book together and tuck us in. Not a big deal at all at that age. We didn't grope each other, we NEVER even THOUGHT about it. (gross) I even remember sharing a bed with my male cousin when we were twelve and sleeping at my grandparents house. We just didn't think the way some people do now. IT WAS MY COUSIN. It's so weird to me that people think this way about little kids. I don't have weird relationships with my bro/cousin now, we don't think anything of it. And I don't think the "exploring the body" mentality ever crossed anybody's mind. I say let them share a room. I don't think any harm can be done by doing that. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

We just didn't think the way some people do now. the internet and cable tv have changed the way kids think these days as opposed to when you grew up 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

I shared a room with my brother until I was about 11, then my parents moved me in with my sisters. It is no big deal. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

I shared a room with my brother until I was about 11, then my parents moved me in with my sisters. It is no big deal. Except now I know where the stinkbug side comes from. 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

So, if I am understanding correctly, JohnLynch, your objection is based on what you believe is the possibility of sexual exploration. Thank you for expounding upon your opinion. It has been proven that 4 and 5 year olds are not yet sexually "awake". An emphasis of a sexual nature would be learned from the relationships they witness and images they see (or don't see, as I restrict TV to age appropriateness only). I do appreciate yours and all the opinions. I was really trying to hear the other side of my argument for room sharing. I thought maybe there was a point of view I was missing- one that was non-sexual. thank you again... 

JHMO --- 17 years ago -

I personally believe at 3 & 4, there are no problems. I do know however, from working with children, that around 5 or 6 (for little girls, not boys), modesty sets in. I know my niece at 6 years old, hardly wanted to change into her pajamas with even me present, let alone a little brother. Sharing a room for 3 years when they are already 4, may be too extensive. JMHO. However, you may encounter problems with other parents, in the event your daughter chooses to have a friend sleep over. Fortunately enough these problems can be resolved by having the children change seperately before bed, and allowing one of the children to sleep in the playroom or guestroom if the other has a friend over. The problems could also be resolved by foregoing a guestroom and just allowing the children to have their own rooms. LOL Now speaking of bathing together, at 3 and 4, I don't see a problem (as long as the children don't either)... Any older than that, I believe children of ANY gender or relation should not bathe together, and this is not because of the possibility of anything sexual happening. It's just because I think bathtime after a certain age is a private thing and you shouldn't be sharing a bath with anyone until you are of legal age. Bathing alone after 5 also promotes better hygiene and less playtime. 

MoveIt --- 17 years ago -

I grew up poor and shared a room with my brother thru high school...no choice only 2 bedrooms in our luxury mobil home in sticks. He did start sleeping in the living room in jr high- but the "stuff" in the room was ours. Bottom line, it is no issue for small children...and sometimes it has to be okay for older kids...everyone doesn't have the luxury of "square footage for all". We need to remember that all of us with a roof over our heads live privileged lives in contrast to much of the global population. This lady has a choice...it is no big deal for kids of this age. 

mum2dj&c --- 17 years ago -

*JMHO*, THANK YOU!!!! This is the type of opposing voice I was hoping to hear! The sleepover thing is something I had not thought of... my daughter is my oldest at 4, so we have not gotten into the world of sleepovers... definitely something to consider. On the bath thing, I am waiting for some cues from my daughter. I think when the modesty thing pops up it will be separate baths. I don't want to push that on her because I don't want to teach shame about our bodies, so once I see she is wanting privacy in that way, I will accommodate her. Right now the kids get dressed in their bathroom (it's large enough) and they are not usually in there together.. Thank you all again! 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

My boys share a room and yes their own modesty has kicked in with each other as well as with us. They take turns showering and while one is in the bathroom, the other one's in the room getting dressed. If they remember to bring their clothing into the bathroom, they change in there. Right now they sleep in their skivvies. This summer is the first time they have chosen to skip the pjs. 

MomofTwins* --- 17 years ago -

I am against it, but it has nothing to do with sexuality. I have friends whose b/g twins shared a room into elementary age. I think, that if you can swing it, it is nice for a child to have their own room. A place to read, be quiet, listen to music, display their favorites (trophies, pictures, etc) that are their own. I know that you can do this in a shared room, but having your own room is special. My twins are almost 8, and while they enjoy their time together, ds would have a fit if he had to share a room with his sister. Most boys at this age don't want all of the girly stuff around (or girls for that matter). Just my opinion - I think you will do what works best for you. I also think that you have to take your husband's feelings into account. Even if it is more convenient to have them together, if he is against it, I wouldn't put them together. (And I wouldn't say that the folks on KU think they should share a room as part of your argument). 

ilovemykids1030 --- 17 years ago -

i dont see anything wrong with it. but if your husband isnt on the same page as you, it would turn something minor into something major. why not put the baby into the same room as which ever toddler is the same sex? let the single girl, or single boy have his/her own room? 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

I think she tried that but the baby son wakes up the older son. These kids are only 3 and 4 years old. She doesn't plan on keeping them together for more than a few years, most likely when the youngest child settles down in his sleeping pattern he'll be moved in with his brother. At that time, mom wants to move daughter into her own room. I don't see the problem. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

So, if I am understanding correctly, JohnLynch, your objection is based on what you believe is the possibility of sexual exploration. didn't say that at all. being curious about differing body parts and having modesty concerning your body has nothing to do with sexual exploration 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

I don't see it being an issue not at that age. But if space is not an issue, then why do this at all? I mean why have a room sitting empty that a guest may use at some point if they happen to show up? Why have the problem at all with dh? You have the room, let the kids all have their own room. Put the gameroom into the bedroom that is larger with it's own bath. Add a couch that pulls out into a queen sized bed. Viola, you have a usable gameroom, and a perfect quest room should you need it. DH is happy, and all the kids have their own room. 

funmom --- 17 years ago -

i shared a room with my brother until we moved to texas i was 8 he was 5 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground