Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Change in filling Kennedy's seat ..is this a double standard?

who's talking here?

marthas attic 14
smartypants 5
planemom 6
Sandyr9111 1
qpc 1
AuthorMan 1
ghostpost 3
~sassy~ 5
Perfection 3
Meme2my5 3
anti-antichange 1
barefoot and pregnant 1
genxer 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

OAK BLUFFS, Mass. (Map, News) - Talk about changing how Massachusetts fills its congressional vacancies may hinge on who would take a proposed interim appointment to replace the late Sen. Edward M. Kennedy. Former Democratic Party Chairman Paul G. Kirk Jr. and 1988 presidential nominee Michael Dukakis are among the so-called graybeards considered the best way to retract a 2004 law change that replaced a direct gubernatorial appointment with a special election. Democrats made the switch to block then-Gov. Mitt Romney from picking a fellow Republican if Sen. John Kerry won that year's presidential race. Now Democrats say they need an immediate replacement in the Senate to preserve their 60-vote, filibuster-proof margin in the chamber. Tufts University political science professor Jeffrey Berry says leaking the name of a local party elder may be the best way to sell the public on the change.  

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

The Dem's changed it to prevent Mitt but now want to change the rules again to allow them to do what they want! With the death of Edward M. Kennedy, seven seats in the Senate have been opened since the last election or soon will be, the most in any one year in six decades. Two of the vacancies resulted from the victory of Sens. Barack Obama and Joe Biden in the presidential election. After that, Obama named two senators to the Cabinet - former Colorado Sen. Kenneth Salazar to Interior and former New York Sen. Hillary Rodham Clinton to State. Since then, two Republican senators, Mel Martinez of Florida and Kay Bailey Hutchison of Texas, have said they will leave office this fall, before their terms expire. With the exception of the Kennedy seat, the other six have been or will be filled by people appointed by their state's governors. FairVote, a nonpartisan group that promotes greater access to the political process, said that the departures of lawmakers means that four out of the five most populous states - Illinois, New York, Florida and Texas - and almost 27 percent of the U.S. population, will be represented by unelected senators. There are calls for change in a replacement system that many say is not democratic. Critics point not only to the high number of vacancies but the manner in which some have been filled. In Illinois, impeached former Gov. Rod Blagojevich faces charges that he tried to sell Obama's old seat. Roland Burris, the eventual appointee, has not been implicated in the scandal but has been tainted by the controversy and will not be running for a full term. New York endured a media frenzy as Caroline Kennedy announced her desire to replace Clinton, and then eventually withdrew her name after a lackluster effort to prove she was qualified. Gov. David Paterson then appointed Kirsten Gillibrand, a little-known congresswoman from upstate New York. Delaware Gov. Ruth Ann Minner tapped Ted Kaufman, a former Biden aide and law school professor who had never held elected office, to hold Biden's seat until next year, when Biden's son Beau, the state attorney general, returns from duty in Iraq and is expected to contend for the Senate seat. The Congressional Research Service said there have been 184 Senate appointments since 1913, when the 17th Amendment became effective, replacing the election of senators by state legislatures by direct popular votes. Of those, seven were the widows of senators, two the spouses of the governor, three the sons of senators and one the daughter of a governor. Frank Murkowski's appointment of his daughter Lisa in 2002 after he left the Senate to successfully run for governor of Alaska prompted legislature and a voter referendum that require quick special elections, although with differing provisions on the governor's authority to make temporary appointments. Sen. Russ Feingold, D-Wis., joined by Sens. John McCain, R-Ariz., and Mark Begich, D-Alaska, has introduced a constitutional amendment requiring elections for Senate vacancies - the Constitution already requires House vacancies to be filled by elections - and end what Feingold called "an antidemocratic process that denies voters the opportunity to determine who represents them in the U.S. Senate." Rep. David Dreier of California, the top Republican on the Rules Committee, and Judiciary Committee chairman John Conyers, D-Mich., have introduced an identical proposal in the House. The Feingold measure cleared a Senate Judiciary subcommittee in early August, but faces the very high hurdles that defeat almost all efforts to alter the Constitution. Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid, D-Nev., has made clear he doesn't support it, saying at a news conference that he did not favor "dictating to a state what they should do." If that fails, House Republicans led by Rep. Aaron Schock of Illinois, have proposed a measure that would allow governors or state legislatures to make interim appointments but require special elections within 90 days of a vacancy. Special elections have their detractors, who argue that they are too expensive, take too much time to organize and are characterized by low voter turnouts that are not particularly representative of democracy at work. The Democratic-controlled legislature in Kennedy's home state of Massachusetts in 2004 changed state law to require special elections and prevent then Gov. Mitt Romney, a Republican, from naming a replacement had Sen. John Kerry won the presidency. Just days before his death Kennedy asked state lawmakers to revert to the old system so that the current Democratic Gov. Deval Patrick could name a successor if Kennedy had to leave office, avoiding the gap of up to five months between the vacancy and the holding of a special election and ensuring that Democrats wouldn't lose a vote crucial to passing the health care legislation that Kennedy was so passionate about. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Martha, Martha, Martha..you act so surprised at this.....The law was only for the repubs it was never intended for them!! 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

an I the ony one thinking this is not right, no matter what party it is? 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

Martha, Martha, Martha..you act so surprised at this.....The law was only for the repubs it was never intended for them!! I guess you're right! Its very sad 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

The Dem's changed it to prevent Mitt but now want to change the rules again to allow them to do what they want! This shouldn't surprise anyone. I say let 'em show their true selves. Pople are watching....and 2010 is around the corner ;D 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

It's not right. The law should be applied to every party. It shouldn't be a law that is changed to suit a different party every couple years. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

"Do as I say....." 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

It hurts when you change the rules to suit yourself and it bites you in the rear. This doesn't surprise me. Afterall, rules are only for the little people not elected officials. Too bad for us both parties do it. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Afterall, rules are only for the little people not elected officials There doesn't seem to be any rules for elected officials anymore. They are completley out of control. It seems they use to sneak and do these things behind our backs, now they just do it in front of everyone and they have the "screw you" attitude. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Yes it is a double standard, yes it is wrong. Regardless of which party. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

so tired of all the political bull.. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Are you suggesting that those seats remain empty for months, and the people of those districts have no representation in Washington? If not, what would you propose as an alternative to interim appointment? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

smartypants --- 52 sec ago - quote - flag comment Are you suggesting that those seats remain empty for months, and the people of those districts have no representation in Washington? If not, what would you propose as an alternative to interim appointment? smartypants, why wasn't that a consideration when the democrats changed it before? They felt it would be more fair for the people to be without representation than for a Republican to appoint someone. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

If not, what would you propose as an alternative to interim appointment? Let the govenor appoint. That he would ofcourse appoint a republican is what all the hoopla is about, no? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

~sassy~ --- 7 min ago - quote - flag comment If not, what would you propose as an alternative to interim appointment? Let the govenor appoint. That he would ofcourse appoint a republican is what all the hoopla is about, no? No sassy you have it wrong. Originally the Gov could appoint, then Mitch Romney was Governor and the democrats were running John Kerry for VP. So the Dems change the rules in Mass to require an election 5 months after the vacancy - so the Governor could not appoint and the seat would be vacant. Now they want to change it again, because now there is a Dem Governor. That is the issue. They are truly playing politics and didn't care about their constituency when it was a Rep Governor but now they have all this compassion when it is a Dem Gov. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

its only an issue if the empty seat is a demwit seat.. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

Let the govenor appoint. That he would ofcourse appoint a republican is what all the hoopla is about, no? Why do you think Gov. Patrick would select a Republican? I am not understanding your question, I guess. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

Now they want to change it again, because now there is a Dem Governor. Yes, that is how I understood the reasoning. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

smartypants, why wasn't that a consideration when the democrats changed it before? No idea. My questions are: should the seat(s) remain vacant? If not, what is the alternative to interim appointment? 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

It would suit the dems needs, therefore they will try to change the rules to work for them. Its called playing politics. Funny how they did not care about the people when Mitt was gov. but now there is all of this concern. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

No idea. My questions are: should the seat remain vacant? If not, what is the alternative to interim appointment? They wait 5 months like they wanted them to do when Mitt was gov. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

I agree the rules should be consistant, whatever they are. So, were the Democrats worried Romney would appoint a Republican to John Kerry's seat? It would make sense to require an appointee to be of the same party who the people originally elected to the seat. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

also why do they think its ok to appoint a spouse, child or relative to the seat? That just boggles my mind. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

In most cases the gov. appointee is a member of the governors party. It's not like they didn't know Teddy was close to the end. He could have resigned months ago and the election would be over or the state could have changed the rules months ago. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

the state could have changed the rules months ago. Changing the rules now is not okay, but changing the rules months ago would have been? 

qpc --- 17 years ago -

Are you suggesting that those seats remain empty for months, and the people of those districts have no representation in Washington? If not, what would you propose as an alternative to interim appointment? That's EXACTLY what the democrats of Massachusetts proposed when they changed their law regarding the matter. Of course, then it was to ensure that a Republican governor didn't get to make the appointment. It's just come back to bite them in the butt. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I don't think it would have been okay months ago either. However, one of the reasons listed to change the rules now is there are too many important bills to allow the seat to go unfilled. If the state had changed the rules earlier they wouldn't be dealing with leaving the seat vacant for an extended period of time. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

if he had resigned months ago, they could have had the special election 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Of course, then it was to ensure that a Republican governor didn't get to make the appointment. Why would they trust the Republican governor to appoint a Democratic replacement to a seat won by a Democrat? Obviously they didn't. They should probably just rewrite the law to say interim appointees should be of the same party the people elected to the seat. Then it wouldn't matter who the governor was at the time, and the will of the majority of people who voted would be represented until the next election. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

also why do they think its ok to appoint a spouse, child or relative to the seat? That just boggles my mind. I remember when Sonny Bono (Republican) died, his wife, Mary Bono occupied his seat. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

also why do they think its ok to appoint a spouse, child or relative to the seat? That just boggles my mind. Yeah i mean honestly...how many senators wives have a clue about what they do? 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

I just don't think thats right 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

I think the spouses are appointed as place fillers. They don't want a politcal career but will keep the seat for the party until the next election. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

If they are going to vote on issues I would want someone who knew something about the issues, not just a spouse, child or relative.. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Why do you think Gov. Patrick would select a Republican? I am not understanding your question, I guess. lol apparently sassy stands corrected again. I thought it was a rep guv 

genxer --- 17 years ago -

My questions are: should the seat(s) remain vacant? If not, what is the alternative to interim appointment? It was okay for the seat to sit empty when there was a republican governor. Now that there is a democrat govenor its not okay. make up your mind and stop change the law based on who is in the state house. 

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

It was okay for the seat to sit empty when there was a republican governor. Now that there is a democrat govenor its not okay. make up your mind and stop change the law based on who is in the state house. Amen! 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

If they are going to vote on issues I would want someone who knew something about the issues, not just a spouse, child or relative..  Since when are they suppose to know what they are voting on? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

It was okay for the seat to sit empty when there was a republican governor. Now that there is a democrat govenor its not okay. make up your mind and stop change the law based on who is in the state house. Amen! In that case, Double amen! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground