Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is 13 too young? What would you do? Should government step in?

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
GCan 1
Sandyr9111 2
rose8304 1
Zionist NightOwl 4
Clown Vomit 1
R.E.B. 1
~sassy~ 3
rEVOLution 2
Chris 2
keepinitreal09 1
TexasOma 1
*momof5* 1
John 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Authorities Try to Prevent Girl, 13, From Solo Sail Around The World by Amy Hatch The Dutch government wants to block 13-year-old Laura Dekker from sailing around the world. Dutch authorities are attempting to gain temporary custody of a 13-year-old girl in order to prevent the teen from sailing around the world in a 26-foot sailboat by herself. According to MSNBC, Laura Dekker is making a bid to become the youngest person to sail solo around the world, and she has the full support of her parents. The Dutch Council for Child Protection is less enthused about Laura's proposed adventure, and has asked for temporary custody of the girl to stop her trip -- something her parents refuse to do. The court battle has opened a public debate in the Netherlands over so-called "super kids" and their ambitious parents. In Laura's case, authorities believe, the desire to achieve stems from her parents' divorce -- she lives with her Dutch father, who is divorced from her German mother. Both parents say they fully support Laura's risky adventure, although her mother did not show up in court for the custody hearing. "Laura has divorced parents and it is very normal for a child of this age to be very loyal to the parent (he or she) is living with," Child Protection spokesman Richard Bakker told The Associated Press. "How much does she identify herself with her father, who is a good sailor?" The girl is already an experienced sailor, and was even born during an around-the-world voyage. However, experts believe that no child her age should attempt a similar voyage on their own. Concerns about a 13-year-old sailing around the are wide-ranging, from pirates to psychological issues. Other obvious perils include weather-related crises and navigational errors, but the girl could also be tracked by bandits and even suffer long-term damage from spending too much time alone at sea during a crucial point in her adolescence. "A 13-year-old girl is in the middle of her development and you don't do that alone - you need peers and adults," said Micha de Winter, a professor of child psychology at Utrecht University. A 17-year-old California boy currently holds the youngest solo sailing record, having completed a 28,000-mile trip in 13 months, sailing his 36-foot boat. Zac Sunderland admitted to The Associated Press that he was tracked by pirates and had to call the Australian authorities for help. Past attempts by children to break world records have ended in tragedy, such as the 1996 death of Jessica Dubroff, who died along with her father and flight instructor, when her plane crashed in Cheyenne, Wyoming. Jessica was attempting to be the youngest person to fly across the United States. According to The Associated Press, a spokesman for the Guinness Book of World records said that it does not encourage attempts by minors to break records. "(We have) a standard policy that does not sanction, endorse or encourage attempts by minors (people under the age of 16) on records which are dangerous or potentially life-threatening," Guinness spokesman Damian Field said. Should the Dutch government stop her from attempting to break this record?  

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Someone needs to do something. This child and her endeavors could endanger alot of people if someone has to go rescue her. Im sorry but thats stupidity on the parents part. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Im sorry but thats stupidity on the parents part. I wouldn't want my ADULT kids doing this, let alone a child. I say it's time CPS steps in on the Gosslin family too. It's time these parents stop pimping out these kids and allow them some form of normalcy before they're completely robbed of a normal childhood, imo. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

I read this yesterday. It's very disturbing. I encourage parents helping children succeed but there must be a line drawn somewhere. What if she runs across pirates on her voyage? What if she becomes ill? What if she be-friends some random stranger in one of the many ports she's going to stop in. Look what happened to Natalie Holloway. 

TexasOma --- 17 years ago -

I say it's time CPS steps in on the Gosslin family too. Same with the Octomom -- she's getting her own reality show & pimping out her kids too. Octomom TV Show 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

DS is 13, and we wouldn't let him sail up to Radio Shack solo on his bike. I can't imagine sending him into scary port cities for supplies. 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

The sea is dangerous and unpredictable. It claims hundreds of lives every year. It would be dangerous enough with and adult. No way I would let a 13 year old go it alone. If the Dutch has their version of CPS, they need to step in. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

she's getting her own reality show & pimping out her kids too. Octomom TV Show Disgusting! CPS where are you????? 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

DS is 13, and we wouldn't let him sail up to Radio Shack solo on his bike. I can't imagine sending him into scary port cities for supplies. I wouldn't allow my 17 year old dd to jog around our block by herself in broad daylight! I can't imagine! 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

I would, as long as she brought me back something cool. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

lmao! you're the best CV! 13 is too young for something of this magnitude. I don't know if it's CPS worthy, but, someone needs to think about the "what if's" in this situation. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

rofl, poster formerly known as Bill Cosby. Hilarious! 

Chris --- 17 years ago -

Maybe she is mature enough to do this by herself. People grow up much faster now then they did before. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Maybe she is mature enough to do this by herself. People grow up much faster now then they did before. Im sorry but no they dont. Most of the kids ive seen around DD's school at 12 and 13 are much more immature than I was at that age. Do u give the 13 yr old a gun too so she can shoot pirates? 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

If the kid is qualified to do so and is monitored I say go for it. And NO the government should absolutely not intervene. People need to realize that it is NOT the governments place to protect people from themselves. 

keepinitreal09 --- 17 years ago -

Nope, its not govt place...This is what one would call natural selection... 

Chris --- 17 years ago -

Girls in other countries are much more mature than here in the U.S. 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

And NO the government should absolutely not intervene. People need to realize that it is NOT the governments place to protect people from themselves. I usually agree, but not in the case of protecting children. If adults want to take extreme risks, that's one thing, but to put a child in that kind of danger is wrong. Ports are usually the seediest of towns, given the itinerant sailors coming in for a drunken night or two. Furthermore, there is usually a red light district nearby. I just cannot imagine she would be safe in a place like that. 

rose8304 --- 17 years ago -

Yeah let the government step in. You remember, the thing you say you want to have no control over your life and your life choices!!!!!! HYPOCRITES!!!! I agree. It seems like many people around here think that when you disagree with someone else's choices, government interference is ok but when it comes to your choices it's not. I wouldn't let my kid do it but this isn't my kid. None of us know this kid or what she's been through, how much training she has, or how mature she is. The Dutch government doesn't know any of that either. If her parents think she can do it and she wants to do it, she should be allowed to do it. What would it be like if every decision a parent could make regarding their child was voted on by committee or had to be approved by the government?! 

John --- 17 years ago -

I agree Rose and others. The Government has no business whatsoever interferring with our lives. Dutch, American, whatever (it's getting more difficult to tell the diff anyway) it doesn't matter. History is riddled with examples of government "support" and it always ends badly. Keep on giving away your liberties and rights and one day you'll be asking what happened to America the way it used to be. I also personally believe a 13-yr old is too young for this adventure, but so is a grown man/woman. It's dangerous. PERIOD. And it has little to do with the port cities either folks. The Sea is treacherous and the physiological, mental, physical and all concerns are valid ones, but we ALL must be accountable to ourselves. We, as parents, are accountable for not only ourselves but also our children's actions, decisions, etc. I see it EVERY DAY in Kingwood where you people expect someone else to be accountable for little Johnny or Sweet Suzy. Its not the school's fault that your little angel makes bad grades. it's not the community's fault that your kid didn't get the golden sash or the biggest trophy or the gold star or whatever. It's their own fault or no fault at all. If this child wants to do this and the RESPONSIBLE PARTIES in her life condone it with all implied accountabilities and sensibilities, then I wish (and hope) they let her. My child wouldn't have made it though the first request made of me, but that's MY story, not hers. And BTW; why the HECK are you all talking about this in KINGWOOD, TX? ;-) Have a great day all, and heed Rose8304's words... you allow the gov to do one thing and then another and still yet mandate even more... before you know it, all of you sheep will be much more easily herded... Pre-nazi Germany advocated the "public responsibility" for Gun Control.... We see how that turned out.... STUDY HISTORY, READ, LEARN, THINK, ACT!!! 

Zionist NightOwl --- 17 years ago -

People need to realize that it is NOT the governments place to protect people from themselves. But they should protect us from others seeking to do us harm. **** John, I can sympathize with protecting the rights of the individual. I firmly believe in individual rights, freedoms, and responsibilities. But this isn't about personal accountability or government intrusion. It isn't about parental rights. It isn't about a government protecting someone from themselves. It's about the government stepping in and protecting someone from a third party who is either wishing them harm, or being completely negligent about their well-being. It's about protecting the most vulnerable members of our society. It isn't government intrusion if the police, for example, make a preemptive arrest of a drunk driver. They are simply protecting the rest of us from selfish and irresponsible behavior. Likewise, these parents are being completely irresponsible, and unfortunately, it isn't their lives they are endangering. It is the life of an innocent child. If a parent wanted to boil their children and eat them, would we say, "Well, they're the parents,"? What about letting the kid inject herself with coke because they have no problem with it? Of course not. Nor does it matter that the child wants to do this. The legal concept of "diminished capacity"--that a child doesn't know the full dangers ahead--applies here. I am all for parental rights. But that "right" does NOT allow them to harm, or fail to keep safe, their children. This falls under "egregious endangerment of a child". 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

It isn't government intrusion if the police, for example, make a preemptive arrest of a drunk driver. They are simply protecting the rest of us from selfish and irresponsible behavior. I partially agree with that but the word "preemptive" is where it gets sketchy. Sure we could have some "Minority Report" where they arrest us and try us for crimes we've yet to commit but until they come up with some tamper proof way of knowing that if someone drives after having a few drinks that they will kill someone, there is no way to do this without trampling on peoples freedom. The very definition of a free country is one that allows it's citizen to exercise their God given right of free will. The government nor police can protect us all from everything all the time. Like an idiot many of us have driven drunk and never crashed nor killed anyone, had been imprisoned for it our lives would be much different today. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground