Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Consensual Living

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 2
outermaga 2
GCan 15
randyjet 2
planemom 2
Sandyr9111 2
Deltadawn 2
Superwitch 1
Mabbers 2
txdaddy 1
Rhea 2
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 2
ladybughomeschool 1
PHSMOMOF2 3
BigPantiesHatesMe 1
goatlady 1
*momof5* 5
!PiratePrincess! 4
Cubcake218 1
Ogre2 1
Zombie Slayer! 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

GCan --- 17 years ago -

This parenting style was discussed on the radio this morning. I had to call in and give my two cents worth. (The caller before me practiced Consensual Living and gave the example of her son stealing from them. They did not punish...only talked. And then because their son obviously had a "need", they increased his allowance because they felt it would stop him from stealing. Thoughts? 

Superwitch --- 17 years ago -

Ummmmmmmmmmmmmmm..dont think so!!! He would be so grounded the only thing he could do is breathe! 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

And then because their son obviously had a "need", they increased his allowance because they felt it would stop him from stealing. Not knowing the age of the child this may not sound right. First, there would have been a whooping for stealing. Then, allowance would have disappeared. After a while, allowance would have been returned. No way would I raise it. If the child is old enough and didn't like the amount of allowance he was given he could get himself a job. I don't have any idea what consensual living is. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

And people wonder why their children have no boundaries, morals and no ambition?!?! I'm afraid mine would get a punishment he would never forget, for stealing ANYTHING! 

Deltadawn --- 17 years ago -

Sounds like someone needs new parenting classes. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

The kid in the example above was 13 years old. She had two other children ages 6 and 8. If they come home late, they get talked to. If they hit another kid on the playground, they get talked to, etc. According to the caller, parents should love their children all the time and unconditionally and she asserts that if you punish a child, then you do not love them. When I called the radio station, I told them that her assertion is WRONG. I love my kids enough to make sure that they can live in the real world. I don't think a boss will take too kindly to an employee who steals. Can you imagine that boss giving the employee/thief a raise? 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

Sounds like the parents need a butt beating! 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

And she further stated that by living in this manner, kids are less likely to do wrong. If that's the case, why is her son stealing from them? If I was the son, I'd steal again so I can get another increase. 

!PiratePrincess! --- 17 years ago -

Ummm WOW! So if I was to go with that if my child steals a car he must just "need" one? I'm all for new ideas of way to teach my child but that just seems a little off. Why would you teach your child that? When he gets older he can steal from his company and when he gets caught they will just give him a raise. Yep, great life lesson! 

Ogre2 --- 17 years ago -

Do you really want to know my thoughts? Here it is, my mother practiced this with her two younger sons before there was a name for it. Rick's rap sheet has 13 charges on it, including one felony possession of cocaine. Rick has had two (TWO) children with girls under the age of 15 and has been charged with (though acquitted of) rape of a relative. Rick's most recent stay in Harris County was because he hit his brother Kevin across the back of the skull with a heavy glass ashtray. Over $5.00. He got a whole six months for that... I can't wait till he kills someone. Kevin's rap sheet has 15 charges on it, and one felony breaking and entering of a rail car. Kevin also was charged with (and acquitted of) rape of a relative. His history includes two stints in the H.C. Boot camp, and four years in TDCJ for stealing a car. Kevin is a dopehead. They both live with momma to this day (Ricks 39, Kevin's 37). Whereas, I grew up mostly with my father and he beat us when we screwed up. My rap sheet has ZERO charges on it, I'm a former military police officer, I also served in the U.S. Navy and am now a law student. My sister is married with six kids, she owns a house, numerous cars. Her rap sheet isn't perfect, but she hung out with stoners in high school. She has a charge for being a runaway and that's it. My brother is an Engineer for UP rail road. He's married, has kids and a house. Kenny also got into a little trouble in high school and has a couple of MIP's (Minor in Possession). But beyond that he's pretty clean. Yeah, Consensual living, it works so well. 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

Sounds like someone needs new parenting classes Are you kidding me? This is what is so wrong with the world today, parenting classes my A@@ if you dont know how to take care of kids then do not have them. First off you are the adult, you dont reason with kids, you tell them what to do. Bottom line, they dont listen you punish them. Time out and thinking you are their friend nonsense... What ever happened to old fashioned values and RESPECT??? 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

she asserts that if you punish a child, then you do not love them. That is backwards. You discipline a child because you love them. How would you like to have these kids in your class rooom? 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

That's ridiculous. When life rears its ugly head, it doesn't "talk" to us. Those parents are NOT preparing those children for life and all its unpredictable nuances. Life isn't easy. It's not fair. And it's not "gentle." It doesn't sit down and talk to us. It doesn't put us in a corner for five minutes. And it doesn't wait for apologies. 

Deltadawn --- 17 years ago -

SE - It is too late, they already have the kids, that is why I said they need classes. You have to discipline your children, that is part of being a parent. It is part of how you love them, by teaching them right from wrong and consequences. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

How would you like to have these kids in your class rooom? That's a very valid point. Can you imagine have a classrom full of children that have been raised to have no boundaries, no restrictions. I wholly understand and support a child having a healthy self-esteem but not at the risk of going to an extreme. 

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Yeah she is warped.....smoked a lil too much pot. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Consensual Living 

outermaga --- 17 years ago -

Sometimes a kid needs a spanking! Obviously all the talks through out his 13 years didn't do him a whole lot of good. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Yeah she is warped.....smoked a lil too much pot. Exactly what I was thinking! 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Wow, what a bizarre philosophy. Here's what wikipedia has to say about it. Here's Consensual Living's website...just in case anyone is interested. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

sorry GCan, didn't see you'd posted it first! LOL! 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

"CL rejects the use of parental coercion and views coercive acts as psychologically harmful to the child." Well THAT must explain why we're all screwed up. It's our parents fault. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

sorry GCan, didn't see you'd posted it first! LOL! No problem. I had a brunette moment when I posted the first comment. I thought I had added the link. I imagined it apparently! 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Wow Ogre, that's quite the story about your brothers! How does your mom feel now about her choice of "Consensual Living"? 

txdaddy --- 17 years ago -

if you dont know how to take care of kids then do not have them. seriously? i mean, i never had kids until i did. so, does anyone KNOW how to do it *until* you have them. the idea (philosophy sounds too educated for this) is horrible. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

does anyone KNOW how to do it *until* you have them. I was second mom to 5 siblings. I did know. 

outermaga --- 17 years ago -

seriously? i mean, i never had kids until i did. so, does anyone KNOW how to do it *until* you have them. I have to agree with you there! Unless you are a Nanny or something of that nature. :-) 

Rhea --- 17 years ago -

I make sure my kids suffer consequences when they do something wrong. Some of them are natural consequences that I step back and allow to happen and some are consequences created by me. There is no learning without consequences. Now when the heat of the moment is over I do sit down and explain to them why what happened could have been prevented. I also stress that just because you do what's right good things don't always come from that. You need to be content in life with knowing you did what was right for your own benefit. At the end of the day, God knows you did what was right. Consensual living is a form of neglect in my opinion. You have to prepare your children everyday for how the world really works. It's not fair and it's tough out there. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

"CL rejects the use of parental coercion and views coercive acts as psychologically harmful to the child." I've already agreed to pay for the therapy. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

One of the issues I have is that outside of their family unit, there world isn't a consensual world. They are doing a major disservice to their offspring but suggesting/teaching that all their choices (whether good or bad) or okay as long as they are happy. There are consequences in the world for everything. 

!PiratePrincess! --- 17 years ago -

Maybe you don't know how to raise kids until you have them, I can relate to that. But a lot of parenting is, or should be, common sense. Common sense tells me not to buy my son candy after he stole some. For some reason society has gotten to 'soft' on kids. I was raised by a man with a very firm hand, had my share of spankings. I think now a lot of parents are scared to use discipline. What they need to be scared of is what they are letting into the world. I'm not saying spanking is right or wrong but I was afraid of getting one so I acted right, most of the time. Now days kids seem to have no fear, that is freakin scary!! 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

does anyone KNOW how to do it *until* you have them. I was second mom to 5 siblings. I did know.  My oldest is like this. She's very nurturing by nature and genuinely loves kids. I'm sure they drive her nuts sometimes, since she's the oldest, but I think having so many younger siblings is an EXCELLENT form of birth control! LOL! 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I think now a lot of parents are scared to use discipline. What they need to be scared of is what they are letting into the world. I think MOST parents discipline their children, but with the fear of CPS constantly waved around, there's a fine line between what some would consider discipline and someone else would consider abuse. So, to avoid this whole scenario, parents take a hands off approach and use time out and bribery instead. I was a babysitter and a nanny for years before I had my own kids, and I saw this pattern over and over again. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

but I think having so many younger siblings is an EXCELLENT form of birth control! LOL! Worked for me! Never understood my peers who thought having a baby would be cool. I had babies all around me and at that age, it wasn't cool! 

PHSMOMOF2 --- 17 years ago -

Now days kids seem to have no fear, that is freakin scary!! So very true, they think they are untouchable. Look we all raise our kids different. I have friends who think I have raised my boys waaay to strict, while thier kids run a muck. They have no control of their own. But I love my friends, They dont get how we do it or have done it. When they ask I just tell them, they dont listen so I dont bother to tell them anymore. So let them pull thier own hair out all stressed while they get their blood pressure high. One of my friends daughters give her back talk all the time, hell she wont have no teeth if she spoke to me that way. Which she doesnt because she respects me, but to her mom.. its a whole different story. 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Oldest ds has a friend who was raised this way. The "talking" way. Lmao. It's hard for me to even type. Anywho, y'all should hear the way he speaks to his parents. Both ds AND I have mentioned this to him, but he's literally beyond reproach. I feel so so bad for them because the respect is completely void. He expects the world and refuses to do anything deserving OF it. It's a miserable existence for all. And it's really something when all his friends notice this and discuss it behind his back. But everyone knows it will never change. I mean this kid's personality has been bronzed and he wears it with pride. Very very sad situation. 

!PiratePrincess! --- 17 years ago -

I have a niece(12) and a nephew(10) that I watch a lot. At home they do NOTHING! Their parents expect nothing. While they are hear they have chores. Dishes, making their beds, cleaning up toys, yard work, whatever. Their mom did not understand how I got so much out of them. It was easy. If you want to have computer time you earn it. If you want to have tv you earn it. If you want to play outside you earn it. Nothing in life is free and they should not think that. The first few days I have them is always an adjustment for them but by day 2 or 3 they know what is expected of them. No slave labor but you earn rewards. And yes I think tv is a reward;) 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Here's what wikipedia has to say about it. Now THAT is truly scary! It is an absurd idea that kids can have reasoning at young ages. To treat them as adults is not even pyschologically sound. Who ever came up with this idiocy? 

Cubcake218 --- 17 years ago -

I'm the parent to my chihuahua only at the moment but have had the pleasure of being brought up in a household where the "rod" was never spared therefore never spoiling me. I was in third grade when I learned the F-bomb and was promptly slapped across the face the instant I used it in anger towards my mother. I didn't know what it meant until the 4th grade. Take this to the 10th grade and I told my Dad off because he was getting after my sister for wearing make-up. He threw a glass of water at me, drenching my favorite shirt at the time. I let my lip loose at him with all kinds of expletives. He went to his room, grabbed a golf club and hit me with it. To this day, there is a bump where he hit me. That was abuse. There is a fine-line between discipline and abuse. From the time I was 15 years old, I understood that respect deserved respect. My Dad disrespected me and my space so many times that eventually I stopped respecting him. To this day, our relationship is tarnished and volatile. My Mom took the time out to talk to me after disciplining me and our relationship now is closer than ever. She spanked me more than my Dad did. A lot of kids get away with disrespect and deceit with their own parents. I know a kid in two homes due to divorce where the kid is such a brat and demands things from all of his caretakers. The only one that disciplines him is his step-Mom and he shows her the most respect. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

I feel so so bad for them because the respect is completely void. you reap what you sow. I have no pity for parents who do this to their children. Now society, I pity, when these little monsters are unleashed. I have a niece who was born immediately after my brother and sister in law had a still born daughter. She's the only girl, with 3 brothers. She's been allowed to be hyper-emotional and no one has ever treated her diarrhea of the mouth. She's going to be 18 in November. She was being rude to me the other day, I told her not to speak to me until she learned how to control her tongue. Her response was...."I'm Sally (not her real name), I don't have to control anything" I said, The world doesn't give two craps who you are, and if you don't think you have to control anything don't cry when you fail miserably. About 20 minutes after that conversation, I overheard a conversation between her and her mother, she called her mother an idiot, trash, and actually said.....if you really loved me, you'd stop being so disgusting. So after my head did the 360 a few times, and I picked my jaw up off the floor, I asked my niece what her problem was. She said my kids will talk to me the same way some day, it's what kids do now. hmmm, not mine. They know I'm not afraid to go to jail for "abusing" them. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground