Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: How do you tell your child.....

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 1
la guerita 7
planemom 2
Sandyr9111 1
funmom 1
Joybell 1
Clown Vomit 2
curlygirl 13
AFWife 1
ghostpost 12
chunksNbones 1
~sassy~ 1
Perfection 5
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 15
ladybughomeschool 1
Melissa 1
oneyedman 1
mommie21g1b 14
james osterberg 2
*momof5* 12

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: How do you tell your child.....

That no matter how hard they work that no matter that they are in the top 5% of their class that they cannot get in to the University of Texas - even though UT has a top 10% admission criteria - simply because they are white. What do you do? There is a recent court case about this very subject with two girls who met the 10% criteria but were denied admission because they are white and UT accepted non-white students outside the 10%.

Explain to them that its ok that they not go to the school they always wanted to go to and worked hard to gain admission to because it is their responsibility to give up their spot to someone who is of a different race and didn't meet the top 10% criteria Vote
 
 7.0% (3)
Fight for your childs right to go to the school that they meet the criteria for regardless of racial profiling and discrimination Vote
 
 93.0% (40)
Perfection --- 17 years ago -

That no matter how hard they work that no matter that they are in the top 5% of their class that they cannot get in to the University of Texas - even though UT has a top 10% admission criteria - simply because they are white. What do you do? There is a recent court case about this very subject with two girls who met the 10% criteria but were denied admission because they are white and UT accepted non-white students outside the 10%.  

Sandyr9111 --- 17 years ago -

Its just racism @ its finest if u ask me. 

Joybell --- 17 years ago -

But wait...I thought you could only be a racist if you were white. Ooops, my bad! 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Steve --- 2 min ago - quote - flag comment Affirmitive action is WAY out dated. There was a time in the beginning when I think it id some good and forced some paradigm changes in the workplace. I think it is now time to end it gracefully Agreed. I think we have passed the point of affirmative action and have moved to racial discrimination. 

Melissa --- 17 years ago -

I would fight for it. There is no harm in fighting what you have worked so dang hard for. Tell them you need to adjust your application and mark another race...lol I hate that things are the way they are, but if you lay back and don't fight for what you want, things will never change. There are ALWAYS exceptions to the rules! Best of luck to your child! 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

You would think that the use of affirmative action directives would be insulting to minorities. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

But they're women. Don't they qualify as a minority? What if they said they wanted to major in engineering or pre-med? Those are both male dominated areas that need to hire women. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

But wait! Isn't this simply leveling the playing field? I mean, after all, it's the white man's greed and the white man's racism that put blacks (and others) so far behind. It's the right thing to do. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

What about the option where you explain to them that being White means that they are racist and if they don't feel racist, they need to get in touch with their inner racist and once they do, they need to be consumed by guilt. Once this is done, they will be happy to give up their opportuity for an education to a lesser qualified person of color so as to relieve some of that terrible guilt they have for being racist simply because of the color of their skin. 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

I don't know. I'm not white. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

Chunky, can you refer me to the story you are citing? I tried to google it but didn't see it. The 10% policy has supporters other than those of minorities. It is popular in rural areas where the students historically didn't perform as well on SATs as well. The strong suburban school districts have a disadvantage where they have students outperforming students all over the state in regard to all the admissions criteria, but because of the strong academic competition at these schools, a straight A student with a high SAT may be in the 20th percentile of their graduating class. It has presented other problems for UT. Having to accept a flat 10% may have created the diversity it intended, but it is overpopulating the university with freshman every year. It also leaves very few slots for extremely talented out of state or international students. Another issue, for both A&M and UT, the 10% rule doesn't allow any preference toward certain majors..and the result has been that certain math and science majors are decreasing in student populations. I am guessing that intent of what CH is referring to (Not sure without reading it) was to continue to attract a diverse population as required by law, but to put a cap on the increasing student population that the 10% rule has inevitably resulted in. The university is between a rock and a hard place, so to speak. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

Chunky, can you refer me to the story you are citing? Maybe it's this one? 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

Thanks, Panties. That is probably the one she is referring to. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

There are many, many strong students at KHS that will not be in the top 10% either. It is frustrating for students to work hard in a competitive environment and to be turned away. I understand the premise behind affirmative action and support equal opportunity, but I think it goes too far sometimes. I know people that have put their kids in less challenging high schools to give them a better chance at being in the top 10%. I also have heard of kids taking a less rigorous course load for the same reason. Both my sons attended UT and were not in the top 10% of their class at KHS. They both graduated from college in 4 years and did very well so they were obviously qualified to attend. They attended Jr. college for 1 semester and then were immediately accepted..apparently the 10% rule doesn't apply to transfer students. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

ghostpost --- 13 min ago - quote - flag comment Chunky, can you refer me to the story you are citing? I tried to google it but didn't see it. ghostpost, I heard it on KTRK 740 this morning on my drive in, they were interviewing the attorney and a rep from LULAC about the case and it going to the 5th circuit now. Perhaps they have the link 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

When I looked at the case of the students mentioned in the article I did not see anything saying they ranked in the top 5%. The case I looked at said the student from Sugarland was in the top 12% and missed the 10% criteria. Where is the 5% class rank coming from? 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

When I looked at the case of the students mentioned in the article I did not see anything saying they ranked in the top 5%. The case I looked at said the student from Sugarland was in the top 12% and missed the 10% criteria. Where is the 5% class rank coming from? My theoretical poll based on the premise behind this case. How would you explain this to your child? Would you accept it or would you fight it? 

funmom --- 17 years ago -

i am going to say this and hopefully wont make anyone mad but when my son was starting pre- k i chose NOT to mark him as white.. he is half white and half native american and i chose to mark him as native american just for this reason.. i wanted him to be proud of his heritage and i was selfish to think maybe being a minority he could get into college with no problems.. so far the race card has not been used for college yet.. he is still at a 2 yr school so i guess when he applies to UT and A&M we will see if it does anything for him. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

My theoretical poll based on the premise behind this case. Chunky, I think your poll and post is misleading. The case is not based on your premise. From what I can infer they would have been admitted if they had been in the top 10%. They sued because after the 10% numbers were reached by UT, they contend that the university used racial criteria to review admissions appeals and both young woman were still denied admissions, while they contend minority students that also did not meet the 10% guideline were admitted on appeal. The case they are making is that the 10% rule has satisfied the goal of insuring diversity and any further admissions beyond the 10% should be racially neutral when considering admissions criteria. In that regard, I would agree with their case and am sorry their suit was not upheld if they were more qualified than the other students admitted upon appeal. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

My theoretical poll based on the premise behind this case. which would be fine except the premise of the case doesn't exist if the girl wasn't even in the top 10% let alone the top 5%! 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

My theoretical poll based on the premise behind this case. How would you explain this to your child? Would you accept it or would you fight it? I am not sure what you are asking since it is not a real situation. I support the real premise from which the two woman raised their suit. They were both talented and deserving students from what I read. Like I said, I support diversity from a racial and economic opportunity standpoint. The 10% rule does that, even though I have issues with it. I guess I am not going to wonder about what I would do in a make believe scenario, there are plenty of real life situations to challenge parents these days, lol. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

There is also the unknown (at least to me, I didn't see any info) facts regarding the qualifications of the minority students that were accepted on appeal. Without the whole picture, it is hard to make an intelligent response. 

la guerita --- 17 years ago -

How do I tell my child that there are people that will never see things the way they really are, only some made up scenario in their head? 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

I thought the same thing ghostpost...not enough details on any of the students involved in this lawsuit/scenario. 

PutOnYourBigGirlPanties --- 17 years ago -

How do I tell my child that there are people that will never see things the way they really are, only some made up scenario in their head? too funny! 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

Like I said earlier, my kids didn't meet the top 10% criteria either. They also didn't get accepted on appeal..we are not minority, economically disadvantaged, both parents are college graduates, two parent household, no hardships..yada, yada, yada..in other words, we met no preferential guidelines for reconsideration. This is what I told them: "Where there is a will, there is a way." lol...it worked. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

This is what I told them: "Where there is a will, there is a way." lol...it worked.  absolutely! I was told that the Jr. College in Austin shares the same dorms with UT, so, why couldn't your child attend a JC for a bit then transfer? That's exactly what your kids did ghostpost and if mine want to go there, they will do the same if they aren't immediately accepted. There are many good colleges out there, I wouldn't limit my children to one or two possibilities. 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

Tell them to get a job. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

I was told that the Jr. College in Austin shares the same dorms with UT, so, why couldn't your child attend a JC for a bit then transfer? There are private dorms in Austin that accept both UT students and Austin Community College students (at least that was the case when my sons were in Austin) and many apartment facilities that are basically college only with roommate programs, private rooms with locks and a central living area, so essentially a dorm situation. My sons attended Austin Community College for one semester and lived in Austin. They were both admitted to UT for the spring semester. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

I think the top 10% rule is crap. Sorry someone in the top quarter at KHS more than likely has a greater chance of earning a degree than someone in the top 10% of an inner city school. That is just the reality. I saw firsthand how those who were granted admission never finished and were given grants to go to school. What a waste of resources. Grants should go to the tope students. I would tell my child he/she doesn't want to go to a racist school and help him/her find a better school. 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

The ACLU would be glad to take the case. (did that just turn the thread red)? 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

. Grants should go to the tope students. Taking money from big socialist government? Wash you mouth with soap. 

la guerita --- 17 years ago -

Sorry someone in the top quarter at KHS more than likely has a greater chance of earning a degree than someone in the top 10% of an inner city school. Really? There are plenty on here that complain about their dead beat sons who are graduated from high school and don't do anything. They want to keep mooching off of their parents' money. If I were to stereotype, like you are doing, I would say inner city children would be more appreciative of an opportunity that they had to work for instead of screwing up something that someone at KHS felt they were entitled to. I would much rather my children experience inner city schools than to ever step foot in KHS. I normally stay quiet, but I can't believe the fact that people somehow believe their children deserve more or can assume that a child will not do well in life because they didn't go to khs...ha ha ha ha 

Clown Vomit --- 17 years ago -

Grants should go to the tope students I take it you weren't one. 

la guerita --- 17 years ago -

Grants should go to the tope students I take it you weren't one. lol 

AFWife --- 17 years ago -

My dd had trouble getting into A&M due to our military move during the Summer of her going into 11th grade. She graduated with honors & had her heart set on A&M & was wait-listed. The person who she had to go see regarding this grew up a military brat so she was a big help. She was fortunate to get her spot. 

curlygirl --- 17 years ago -

am going to say this and hopefully wont make anyone mad but when my son was starting pre- k i chose NOT to mark him as white.. he is half white and half native american and i chose to mark him as native american just for this reason Me too, funmom. My husband is African, so that means is skin is dark or he is black as some would refer to him. I am light skinned or white as some would refer to me. Put the two of us together and you get African American, which is what my childern are listed with the district. Here is the kicker, my oldest is as fair skinned as me, yet according to the district, she is black. That is how I registered her. She is of African decent but her skin is white not black like is listed on the form. I was advised by the elementary registrar years ago to do this. And I don't care if it makes anyone mad. It's our right. And yours too. And as for the poll...don't put all your eggs in one basket. And I would rather my childern earn their acceptance to college based on merit, which I am sure they will. 

mommie21g1b --- 17 years ago -

I did the same thing. Both of my children look white, like me, but on paper they are minorities. I gave them their father's race. I was actually told at the hospital by the person in charge of birth certificates that the mother's race was what what supposed to be chosen as the child's race (I had never heard this before), but I was like He!! NO. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

Holy hell!!! Mommie21g1b, you have the audacity to bi*tch about Affirmative Action and yet make sure your kids are going to benefit from it?!?! You have GOT to be f'ing kidding me! WOW!!! What a hypocrite you are!!! 

ladybughomeschool --- 17 years ago -

Well, I do not know anything that will help but there is a solution. When I went to college i did not have any problems being accepted , I just did not get scholarships. My Dad very wisely offered me a deal. He said that if I went to North Harris for 2 years then he would foot the bill for that plus 2 more year anywhere in Texas. My degree from Texas A & M does not say anywhere that I did not do my first two years there. it saved my dad a lot of money. Transfers do not have to meet the same criteria. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground