Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Should Suicide Be Legal?

who's talking here?

MoveIt 1
*emily 2
Rachel 1
chunksNbones 1
EarlyBird 1
rEVOLution 1
fishlady 2
Unichic™ 1
Wilstar77 3
oneyedman 6
moltobella 1
NewNanna 1
t-1616 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Should Suicide Be Legal?

Fishlady posted a topic about the Health Care Bill and suicide counseling. I'm wondering what you guys think about Doctor Assisted Suicide? Should it be legal in terminal or close to terminal cases?

Yes, let the patient decide after counseling. Vote
 
 80.4% (37)
No, the patient should continue treatment. Vote
 
 19.6% (9)
Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

Fishlady posted a topic about the Health Care Bill and suicide counseling. I'm wondering what you guys think about Doctor Assisted Suicide? Should it be legal in terminal or close to terminal cases? 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

I knew someone suffering who from Cancer that was in the final stages. She suffered for a good while before she finally passed. Made me wonder what I would want in the same situation. 

MoveIt --- 17 years ago -

Assisted suicide? ...to many grey areas. Doing it yourself...can't arrest you once your gone. (Not that I condone it, but you can't walk in someone else's shoes.) 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

Fishlady posted a topic about the Health Care Bill and suicide counseling. I'm wondering what you guys think about Doctor Assisted Suicide? Should it be legal in terminal or close to terminal cases? Yes, I think it should be legal. As long as- A. The person gives full consent. They must be mentally competent to make the decision. B. The person suffers from a terminal illness that a outside doctor deems to be un-curable and causes them unnecessary suffering. C. It is done in a humane and non-painful way. C. It is strictly regulated. The Doctor must be be evaluated and given a special license. Quite frankly, if a person wants to end their life they should be given the right to do so. 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

I was talking about government end of life counseling, lol, not suicide counseling. I agree with move it, there are too many grey areas and if you want it done do it yourself, do not ask someone to do it for you where it will wiegh on their consience for the rest of their lives, that is selfish to me. If I was in that situation, because of religous beliefs I would wait and go when the lord saw fit to take me, but that is just me. 

fishlady --- 17 years ago -

Good question Wilstar....... 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

Good question Wilstar....... Agreed, it makes ya think. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

First: It is a sin Second: To allow it is to illustrate how far our society has progressed to Godlessness and lost our soul 

chunksNbones --- 17 years ago -

First: It is a sin Second: To allow it is to illustrate how far our society has progressed to Godlessness and lost our soul interesting. i wasn't aware we are all the same religion and believe the same thing... I think it should be legal...under the conditions listed above. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

I like t-1616's list. 

moltobella --- 17 years ago -

I was actually thinking about this the other day cause of someone needing to put one of their pets to sleep to keep them from suffering. If someone is suffering why shouldn't they be able to make this choice? (If you're taking the religious aspect out of it. My own personal choice....I would prefer to stay out of Hell. Ill take my suffering.) 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

i wasn't aware we are all the same religion and believe the same thing I didn't say we were... simmer down there ChunkyBoner PS. regardless of yor belief...it remains a sin 

Rachel --- 17 years ago -

I am no physician but have had several people I know in the end stages of cancer. They have had free reign to a morphine drip to control the pain. I wonder if there is enough in there to end ones life? I too will take my suffering... 

EarlyBird --- 17 years ago -

I've seen family suffer from pain of incurable diseases like cancer. I want to be able to determine how I go and when I go. Allow me that dignity. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

It should be a no brainer for any professed Christian. If you are a Christian and condone this sort of thing, you should ask yourself if you really believe in the eternal soul of Man. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

dignity Ahhh the modern fallacy rears it ugly head finally.... There is no dignity in killing yourself. There is supreme dignity in enduring your suffering. 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

Ahhh the modern fallacy rears it ugly head finally.... There is no dignity in killing yourself. There is supreme dignity in enduring your suffering. No, there is also no dignity in being confined to hospital and not being able to live your life as it was. There is plenty of dignity in being able to decide how you want to go and when you want to go if you know you aren't going to make it. I don't want to see my family suffer from my suffering. 

NewNanna --- 17 years ago -

No, there is also no dignity in being confined to hospital and not being able to live your life as it was. I agree entirely with you. Let me decide what is best. 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

I didn't say we were... simmer down there ChunkyBoner PS. regardless of yor belief...it remains a sin It may be a sin in your eyes, but not necessarily others. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

I believe that taking a life is a sin whether it is someone else's or your own. God's commandments are his whether we believe or not. I can say that I don't believe in air because I can't see it. But that doesn't mean it doesn't exist and isn't real. I have seen family members suffer and at the edge of death. Specifically my dad. He is not dead. He is still enduring. I am so glad that suicide was not an option for him. I know he thought about it. and I know that his pain was at times too much for him to bear. Thank goodness he was not selfish enough to end his life. What additional pain that would have caused his family. The short time we have here on this earth is a blessing from God and only He should be able to decide when we go. JMO. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

There is plenty of dignity in being able to decide how you want to go and when you want to go If this is a majority view in society, then I fear morality is lost, Christianity is dead and selfish desires have won over respect for life. You do not get to decide when and where you die if you wish to stay in the grace of God. You are certainly welcome to kill yourself, but this is far different that having the approval of society to do so. We already have abortion on demand. And demand they do, mostly for convenience. Once we start down this road, can we really deny the "right" to those diagnosed as depressed? or lonely? simply tired of living.... For their dignity should they not be given the choice of when and where they die? I weep that humanity has come to this. There is NO dignity in this... only shame. 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

Thank goodness he was not selfish enough to end his life. Why is it believed that committing suicide is selfish? If anything, most people commit suicide because they feel they are a burden on other people's lives. It is even more selfish to expect someone to continue to live their life if they feel that helpless. Also, JMO 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

It should be a no brainer for any professed Christian. If you are a Christian and condone this sort of thing, you should ask yourself if you really believe in the eternal soul of Man. I do agree with you there Oneyed but I also know that no man should tell another that he can or cannot die. In a free nation and having been given Free Will by God no government has the authority to tell you that you can't die. They certainly have no problems killing in the name of oil. Who are they to say that a person can't end their own life. I'm with you on what the bible says, I do believe it's wrong to commit suicide but I also know it's wrong for any government to tell you that you can't. 

*emily --- 17 years ago -

It IS selfishness that makes a person decide that it is ok to hurt the ones they love for the rest of their lives to shorten their own pain or suffering. 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

We already have abortion on demand. And demand they do, mostly for convenience. Baby's don't decide whether they are aborted or not! In this case, you make the decision. It is asinine to compare the two. You do not get to decide when and where you die if you wish to stay in the grace of God. Why would God send me to hell if I wanted to end my suffering? So if I am at the Pearly gates, and I say "Lord, I was enduring un-bearable suffering. I did this with the knowledge that I would be coming to you sooner. I am a good and decent person, who has done my best to do right in the mortal world." God will say "To bad, you are going to hell"? It seems like a harsh price to pay if you were a good person. 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

It IS selfishness that makes a person decide that it is ok to hurt the ones they love for the rest of their lives to shorten their own pain or suffering. If the person is enduring the pain that this thread is about, chances are they are not the same person they were before. Yes, in certain situations it can be selfish. The hypothetical person I am talking about is confined to a hospital bed and not living the life they were. At this point, it is a burden on the family to watch their loved one suffer so much. Well shoot, I have to get off the computer for now. 

oneyedman --- 17 years ago -

Why would God send me to hell if I wanted to end my suffering? If God was so concerned that we not endure suffering, I suspect he might have assured this world did not contain so much of it. In fact, it is in the suffering that we both affirm our humanity and purchase our everlasting life. 

Unichic™ --- 17 years ago -

OMG yes! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground