Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Public vs. Private School?

who's talking here?

stampin' gal 6
Sarah75 5
4nTX 3
Mygirl01 3
Aiemzee 1
ghostpost 1
3monkeysmomma 1
Diamom 2
dogsareagirlsbestfriend 2
Paige Paige 6
Wilstar77 1
PHSMOMOF2 1
crazymama87 1
♥kerry♥ 5
Shenanigans 2
Niki 2
theirsalways 2
bigla 1
*momof5* 5
YO♥Momma 4
t-1616 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Public vs. Private School?

(Not talking Preschool Schools) is your children in Public or Private school? WILL your child go to Public or Private School? And what made your choice. No MOney? Or could you do either and prefer one over the other and why?

Public Vote
 
 72.9% (43)
Private Vote
 
 27.1% (16)
YO♥Momma --- 17 years ago -

(Not talking Preschool Schools) is your children in Public or Private school? WILL your child go to Public or Private School? And what made your choice. No MOney? Or could you do either and prefer one over the other and why? 

theirsalways --- 17 years ago -

Mine attend public school. I grew up attending a private college-preparatory school. It was far too sheltered in my opinion and I want my children surrounded by much more diversity. Also, the parents had too much of a stronghold over the principal/instructors and what was taught. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

my kids have done both. If the school district is a good one, public school for sure! We lived in an area where they weren't so good, and the kids attended private school, I loved that school the teachers and staff were great! Living here, public school definitely. :) 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

My son is going to private school right now but once he's ready for 1st grade, BOOM, Public School it is. 

3monkeysmomma --- 17 years ago -

We have had lots of discussions on this and done a lot of research. As much as I would like a christian private school, we just weren't happy with the academics with any of the schools out here. My mom taught AP english at KHS for 25 years and her experience with private kids coming into the public system here was that they were almost always academically behind. I can't remember where we pulled all of our information, but that is one of the main reasons we ended up public. Of course, with the economy the way it is and kiddo #2 going into kinder, we probably couldn't affort private now anyway! Private school folks - I'm sure that there are exceptions - just giving the results of MY research. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

public. we can afford private if we wanted, but have no desire. our schools in kingwood are top notch. that is why we moved here. 

ghostpost --- 17 years ago -

public. we can afford private if we wanted, but have no desire. our schools in kingwood are top notch. that is why we moved here. Same here. My kids went to private Preschools in the community and then public K-12 in Kingwood. I would put their education up against the best private schools any day. They both sailed through the universities they attended because they were so well prepared by the public schools here. 

Shenanigans --- 17 years ago -

we will do our best to keep our kids in private school through elementary grades. personal choice based on wanting to have a strong say in what they hear at school and what they are taught. we also like the smallness of private school. 

Diamom --- 17 years ago -

personal choice based on wanting to have a strong say in what they hear at school and what they are taught. we also like the smallness of private school. ditto 

dogsareagirlsbestfriend --- 17 years ago -

My kids have gone to public school for years, but with my youngest the public school system failed him miserably. They pigeonholed him because of the TAKS testing and made him feel like he was stupid. I put him in private school and he got a teacher who actually loves teaching. By the way, she had to tutor him after school to get him caught up to the kids in his class. The public school stopped teaching in order to teach to the TAKS. He was happier than I have ever seen him and he will definitely go there until middle school. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I have worked in both private and public schools in the area. If you are strictly comparing education, then I would say it depends on where your children are attending school. The schools in Kingwood by and large are excellent. I have worked in some schools outside of Kingwood that I don't think offer the same quality of education...certainly not all, but individual schools. If the decision is based on religious reasons or class size..then of course, private school may be preferable to some families. Some of the private schools I have worked in had higher standards than others..some had more stringent requirements to qualify teachers as well. So, basically it boils down to personal choice and of course financial means. I personally choose for my kids to attend the schools here in KW because I know first hand that the education is first rate. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

My dd has been in private her entire school life so far, she is going to 2nd grade this year. We did a math class at discovery college a couple of weeks ago, and when I questioned them on how very easy the lessons were and informed them that my dd did not learn anything she had not been taught in K (at her school)and she has just finished 1st grade, they asked to see her math book from her private school. So the next day I brought the book in and the teacher told me the lessons in her first grade math book were closer to a 3rd grade level not 1st and she then informed me that my 7 year old soon to be 2nd grader was way ahead of the Humble ISD Math curriculm K-3th. So for us, private school is giving her the advantages and the head start that I wanted her to have. 

dogsareagirlsbestfriend --- 17 years ago -

By the way, I have also worked in Humble ISD for 5 years. That is why I was so disappointed in the way things were handled with my son. I realize a lot of the way a school runs is due to the principal. I moved to Kingwood 11 years agoo because of the schools. I have definitely seen things change in the last 5 years. And for the record, my son is just an average kid, those are sometimes the ones who fall through the cracks in a larger school. 

theirsalways --- 17 years ago -

So for us, private school is giving her the advantages and the head start that I wanted her to have. I agree that my college-preparatory school probably gave me a stronger foundation in elementary school. It was in middle-school and high-school that it fell apart. I couldn't immediately reference books that college professors assumed I had already read in English classes during high school because they were deemed inappropriate for my private school, and both the science and social science curriculum were seriously lacking! 

bigla --- 17 years ago -

money... 

4nTX --- 17 years ago -

We researched both public and private schools. While the public schools offer a fine academic education, I didn't see my oldest child fitting in in the public school(she is the sweetest thing, quiet and sensitive - I really felt she would get crushed by the other kids). I have worked in public schools and have seen what goes on behind the scenes and really felt that my children would get more individual attention and emotional support from a private school education - instead of just being a #. And yes I do know there are wonderful teachers out there in all environments. I also felt that a smaller class size was a benefit. I always felt my children wouldn't get exposed to as much in a private school as in a public school, it's there, I know, but we don't think it would happen as much in a private school. As far as academics; I'm hoping it will be all right. My girls are ahead in academics so I will see if it is challenging. I will challenge them more at home if needed just like I have in the past. I would rather they were in a safe, structured, nourishing environment. So, if your child does not fit the "cookie cutter" mold, public school may not be an option. Fortunately, there are some different options out there. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

So, if your child does not fit the "cookie cutter" mold, public school may not be an option. Interesting point of view. I always saw private school as the "cookie cutter" mold, with the uniforms and strict rules of conduct, if it's a religious school, you'd have the same religious views expressed there. The thing that scares me about private schools, would be their accredidation. You definitely want to do your research when choosing a private school. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

The thing that scares me about private schools, would be their accredidation. You definitely want to do your research when choosing a private school. yes, you do. to teach in a private school, you DO NOT need a teaching degree. as a matter of fact, 95% or more don't even REQUIRE a college degree to teach there. unless the individual school REQUIRES it, and even if they do, the governing body for private schools doesn't require it. so, a school can SAY they require it and then the next year decide they want to change that and no one can stop them (and i doubt they would inform the parents of the change). i've seen it happen......i used to teach at a private school. usually, religious schools have even looser standards than private schools on teacher accredidation, but not always. be sure to check out the teachers credentials. i just have an issue with someone teaching my kid that didn't even graduate from college. 

4nTX --- 17 years ago -

All the teachers at the school my children will be attending have college degrees or above. And by "cookie cutter" I meant if your child didn't fit in or act like other kids their age - mine being extremely shy and quiet. And uniforms aren't a bad thing, makes everyone equal and it makes mornings a lot easier. I like rules of conduct. I like that a private school can ask a child leave if they don't follow the rules. Bullying not even an issue. 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

I like that a private school can ask a child leave if they don't follow the rules. absolutely, that is a great benefit. but, being a private school, they are a business. the people that write the checks hold the power. that gives parents some power, which can be good AND bad. Bullying not even an issue. probably not true. if the bullies parents have lots of money, the school won't risk losing it most times. remember, it is a BUSINESS as well as a school. I'm not saying it is that way at the private school you use, 4ntx, but it ABSOLUTELY can be that way, and more often than you think. i taught in a private school......i've seen quite a bit on that side, lol. but the private school i taught at was probably the best in the country, so you take the good with the bad! :) 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

One of the private schools I subbed in (in this area) is very well respected. They offered me a job even though I was not yet certified. As I got to know other teachers there, I found out that the ones I met were not certified to teach in Texas and that was one of the reasons that they were working there, they were not able to work in the public schools here and didn't want to get certified here for one reason or another. As with a lot, if not most, private schools pay was less than in Public schools so attracting teachers can be a challenge, although I met some very good teachers while there. As far as choosing private schools because your child will be exposed to less social problems, I find that to be a misconception. Just like anywhere else there is a mix of kids and a mix of issues. There are kids attending that had problems in the public schools and that is why they are attending the private school...both academic and social problems and sometimes those problems don't just go *poof*. One concern I had was because it was a "private" school, the parents were viewed as customers. We were encouraged to gloss over some problems and inflate some abilities. That was just my own experience, so it is not meant to condemn a private school education, but I do believe people should not necessarily equate it as superior. It is a personal choice each family needs to make on their own, but their eyes wide open. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

I always felt my children wouldn't get exposed to as much in a private school as in a public school, it's there, I know, but we don't think it would happen as much in a private school. lol....growing up, my cousins went to private catholic schools, in VERY rural NE U.S.....we went to public...turns out my cousins were the ones into hard core drugs and one ended up in rehab right out of HS....his Mom (a teacher in the school) had NO idea...my cousins would say it was "so easy" because in the smaller school, you knew exactly where/who to go to and for what ever you wanted....he knew it was easily accessible...the parents were/are active members of the church (there every Wed & Sun) and their small community...they tried College, but never went on (even though their parents offered to pay)....in my family, we weren't perfect, by ANY means, but we didn't go AS far as they did....we also all got at least one degree... just depends on the kid...my Aunt (and the whole family) all thought her kids were the "best" in the family and most of the family looked in envy at their family and how close and "perfect" they were.... 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

My kids went to a private school when they were little and they loved it! I loved it too, the uniforms DEFINITELY make it easier in the mornings! I love the public schools here. My kids are really thriving, and the schools were the main reason we moved to Kingwood. It's so awesome to hear all of the success stories from this area, kids that have gone on from KHS to great colleges and great careers! 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

That was just my own experience, so it is not meant to condemn a private school education, but I do believe people should not necessarily equate it as superior. It is a personal choice each family needs to make on their own, but their eyes wide open. this is so true, and very well said. if we still lived in new orleans, my kids would be attending the private school i taught at. it was a great school.....but, it did hold its own set of problems. ALL schools do. you just need to look at each one and decide what is right for your own kids. as for class ratio size, is that really an issue for some in public schools? my kid is in public and hasn't had more than 17 in his class yet any year. that seems like a pretty good size to me. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

religious schools have even looser standards than private schools on teacher accredidation Not the one my child attends. All of her teachers are state certified teachers and as far as accreditdation, if your school follows the same standards that the state sets, then you should be able to find a fully accredited school, like the 5 years old to enter K, if your private school doesn't follow that then your child can be held back if they ever enter public school. My child is learning more than her peer's that attend public school (and I have compairing what she learns vs her friends because she will go to public school eventually) and she is being taught by state certified teachers with a curiculm supported by the state and her school is fully accredited. 

Mygirl01 --- 17 years ago -

my cousins would say it was "so easy" because in the smaller school, you knew exactly where/who to go to and for what ever you wanted....he knew it was easily accessible I went to Kingwood High School and it is full of Drugs and everyone "knew" where you could get ANYTHING you wanted and who to get it from. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

I went to Kingwood High School and it is full of Drugs and everyone "knew" where you could get ANYTHING you wanted and who to get it from. no doubt, i didn't once say (or even imply) that you couldn't ;)...of course they're everywhere...duh ;)....i'm just sayin, a private school does not exclude you from any of it ;) 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

Not the one my child attends. All of her teachers are state certified teachers and as far as accreditdation that is awesome, but is the exception to the rule, not the norm. if your school follows the same standards that the state sets, very true.....IF they choose to follow it. it is a choice. in the public system, they have to follow the standards. i'm not saying all private schools are bad......i'm saying people need to choose carefully and be informed. 

4nTX --- 17 years ago -

I don't think private school is superior, I think it is another option. Something each family needs to decide on their own for their own reasons. And I think there can be examples of this happening there and that happening here everywhere. We're talking elementary school here and I'm not thinking about drugs at this point (although????) but I would like my Kindergartener and Second Grader to go without hearing about sex etc. this year. This is a personal choice that families make. I wouldn't even think to think that my child is superior or look "down" on someone because they go to public school. That is not what our choice is about. Our choice was the best for our family. You are welcome to your own choice. 

Niki --- 17 years ago -

I am going to be teaching next year when my dd starts K. I plan on sending her to public with me. My thoughts are why would it be OK for me to teach your kids at public school but not let my own child attend there?? 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

my cousins would say it was "so easy" because in the smaller school, you knew exactly where/who to go to and for what ever you wanted....he knew it was easily accessible I went to Kingwood High School and it is full of Drugs and everyone "knew" where you could get ANYTHING you wanted and who to get it from.  that's all schools...there will be access to drugs WHEREVER your kids attend. The more expensive the neighborhood, the better quality of drugs. I'm sure the kids at KHS have Rx drugs all over the place! This is why it's important to know your kids, know their friends, and stay involved in their lives! 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

My thoughts are why would it be OK for me to teach your kids at public school but not let my own child attend there??  you'd be surprised at how many teachers feel differently! Where we lived in RI, the ENTIRE SCHOOL BOARD for the public school, had their kids in private school...it was very telling and sad. 

Niki --- 17 years ago -

it was very telling and sad That is very sad. Kind of hypocritical (sp??) if you ask me! 

stampin' gal --- 17 years ago -

I would like my Kindergartener and Second Grader to go without hearing about sex etc. this year. This is a personal choice that families make. absolutely right! and it isn't up to anyone to judge your choice......i wasn't trying to do that, just offer my own opinions on it from another side (the teachers side of private schools). and, i have a 3rd grader next year in public school and he hasn't heard any talk about 'sex' from school......yet. i'm sure it will happen, but not yet! :) 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

just offer my own opinions on it from another side i felt thought that was all anyone was doing, not "damning" anyone's choice, but offering their opinions and experiences on both sides....unless i missed something (which happens often ;p).... 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

I went to Kingwood High School and it is full of Drugs and everyone "knew" where you could get ANYTHING you wanted and who to get it from. ..and don't think that private schools have immunity from this either. I know this first hand. Keep in mind that once kids are in high school they all associate with each other anyway..public school, private school..they are at the same parties on the weekends. As far as hearing about sex...but I would like my Kindergartener and Second Grader to go without hearing about sex etc. this year. The public schools won't be talking about sex in the classroom in Kindergarten or second grade either. Now, as far as the playground..it isn't any different than what they may hear in the neighborhood. We had an adorable little girl at the private school I worked in "giving birth" using a doll in the play center. She was pretty knowledgeable, having just witnessed a home birth of a sibling. But we had to quickly redirect her, because some children were appalled and getting a little more education that day than their parents intended. It happens everywhere,lol. 

♥kerry♥ --- 17 years ago -

absolutely right! and it isn't up to anyone to judge your choice......i wasn't trying to do that, just offer my own opinions on it from another side (the teachers side of private schools). Absolutely. I was just addressing the topic as raised by the OP..why or why not. It is never a "one size fits all" when it comes to parental choices for their children. The fact that people are so carefully weighing for works best for their children means that they are taking their parental responsibilities seriously. All children should be so lucky to have parents that do that...regardless of the decisions made. 

Sarah75 --- 17 years ago -

LOL Kerry!!!!! that was a funny story! i agree, my cousins (yes, the private schoolers), were able to school us on the sex ed....(and boy was my mom surprised whenever i expressed my new "vocabulary" to her...which i was quite proud of, but her not so much i guess ;p...my Aunt got "the talk" later that night....LOL ;)) 

t-1616 --- 17 years ago -

I have always been puzzled by parents who say they chose private schools because they want to shelter their kids from the bad things that go on in public schools. I fully understand their argument, but I think it is a bit misguided. The thing is, life is full of bullies, jerks, idiots, and the like. You can shelter your kids during their grade school years, but sooner or latter they will be thrust-ed into the real world. IMO, Life is full of bad things and bad people and the sooner they learn to deal with it the better. Just because these kids are exposed to certain undesirable things they won't necessarily become bad people. Also, who says they won't experience the same things in a private school? But, to each his own I guess. 

Aiemzee --- 17 years ago -

I taught in public high schools and depending on what district my daughter is in when she's school age- I don't know yet (we plan to move out of state in the next year.) I see both sides of the issue and I only attended public schools (i come from a family of public school teachers.) However, I don't see anything wrong with people putting their kids in private schools if they can afford it- especially if it caters to their religion (christian, catholic, whatever.) If we can afford it, and its a better situation for my daughter, then it may end up being where my daughter goes. Issues like being too sheltered take a back seat to safety, curriculum, and competence of administrators imo. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground