Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Senior Democrat Says Obama’s Czars Unconstitutional

who's talking here?

marthas attic 1
freshhell 1
JerseyGirl 1
randyjet 7
david 1
rEVOLution 6
Perfection 4
26.2 1
Hiro Protagonist 1
anti-antichange 1
Ogre1 4
genxer 1
JohnLynch 1
james osterberg 1
MxMike. 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

marthas attic (Mod) --- 17 years ago -

Last week President Obama appointed yet another “czar” with massive government power, answering only to him. Even before this latest appointment, the top-ranking Democrat in the Senate wrote President Obama a letter saying that these czars are unconstitutional. President Obama’s “czar strategy” is an unprecedented power grab centralizing authority in the White House, outside congressional oversight and in violation of the Constitution. As of last week, Czar Kenneth Feinberg has the authority to set the pay scale for executives at any company receiving government money (and how many aren’t, these days?). Czar Feinberg has the power to say that someone’s pay is excessive, and to make companies cut that pay until the czar is pleased. Congress did not give Czar Feinberg this authority. For that matter, Congress has not authorized any of the czars that President Barack Obama has created. Over the past thirty years presidents have each had one or two czars for various issues, and once the number went as high as five. But now, by some counts President Obama has created sixteen czars, and there may be more on the way. Each of these has enormous government power, and answers only to the president. Ever since this practice of appointing czars began years ago, it has always been considered possible that they are all unconstitutional. But it never built to a critical mass to elicit a court fight. These czars were few and far between, and rarely did anything that seriously ruffled any feathers. But President Obama has taken this to an unprecedented level, to the point where these appointments are dangerous to our constitutional regime. This has become too much for the longest-serving senator in U.S. history to stomach. Democratic Senator Robert Byrd is the president pro tempore of the U.S. Senate. Even though Senate rules vest most powers in the Senate majority leader, the president pro tempore is a constitutional officer, and third in line to the U.S. presidency (after the vice president and the Speaker of the House). This office is held by a Democrat, who has been serving in the Senate since before Barack Obama was even born. Senator Byrd wrote a letter to President Obama in February, criticizing the president’s strategy of creating czars to manage important areas of national policy. Senator Byrd said that these appointments violate both the constitutional system of checks and balances and the constitutional separation of powers, and is a clear attempt to evade congressional oversight. (Didn’t this White House promise unprecedented transparency?) And Senator Byrd is exactly correct. The Constitution commands that government officers with significant authority (called “principal officers”) are nominated by the president but then are subject to a confirmation vote by the U.S. Senate. And principal officers include not only cabinet-level department heads, but go five levels deep in executive appointments, to include assistant secretaries and deputy undersecretaries. Inferior officers are appointed either by the president, cabinet-level officers, or the courts. But even then, the Constitution specifies that only Congress can authorize the making of such appointments. For these inferior officers, only Congress can create their offices, and also specify who appoints them. And such officers are still answerable to Congress. They are subject to subpoena to testify before Congress, and Congress holds the power of the purse by making annual appropriations for their division or program. White House officials, by contrast, cannot be compelled to appear before Congress and testify. They are alter-egos of the president himself, and as an agent of the Executive Office of the President they are entirely removed from Congress, and not answerable to Congress in any way. That was why during the Bush administration White House Chief of Staff Josh Bolten, Senior Advisor Karl Rove, and Counsel Harriet Miers could not be compelled to testify to Congress when President Bush invoked executive privilege (a battle they may well have won if they pressed their case all the way to the Supreme Court). Senior presidential aides advise the president alone, and the separation of powers forbids congressional interference in that relationship. But that’s the problem with these czars. The president can have any advisors he wants, people who privately advise him or meet with others on his behalf, but have little or no actual authority to exert government power on anyone. These czars, however, are directly dictating policy, impacting millions of lives in the way that few assistant secretaries or deputy undersecretaries do. The Founding Fathers specifically wrote the Constitution in a way to deny such absolute power to emanate from one person. That was why they required that no principal officers could exercise any power unless the U.S. Senate decided to confirm them. That was also why they specified that even for inferior officers only Congress could create their positions and could still require them to answer to Congress. The Founding Fathers were specifically blocking the type of centralized power that President Obama is currently exerting. Fortunately, there is a remedy. Any person on the receiving end of an order from any of these czars has standing to challenge their constitutionality in court. Any person whose pay is deemed excessive by Kenneth Feinberg, or affected by any other czar, could file a federal suit asserting that the order is an unconstitutional exercise of government power, and have a court both invalidate the order and hold that the position itself doesn’t legally exist. Then everyone could just ignore these czars, because they would simply be private citizens, without the authority to order any of us to tie our shoes.  

MxMike. --- 17 years ago -

Obama's presidency alone is unconstitutional. 

MxMike. --- 17 years ago -

The Founding Fathers were specifically blocking the type of centralized power that President Obama is currently exerting. Exactly. It's very sad. The America our founding fathers fought and died for is now dead. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

We love him and trust him implicitly. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Obama's presidency alone is unconstitutional. HELL, you think ANY part of the US government is unconstitutional. IT is NOT illegal for Obama to have these advisors since they have NO line authority over departments. They CAN advise the President to NOT allow the salary increases for execs. It is the President himself who does the act, not them. AS the chief executive of the USA and biggest stock holder of the companies, he sure CAN TELL them what to do. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I also love how the contracts and millions of dollars in bonuses are sacrosanct for execs, but the wages of the lower workers and their contracts are considered JUNK by you snobs! The workers who DID their jobs are supposed to NOT get paid their contract wages, but the salaries of the execs, who DID NOT DO THEIR JOBS is supposed to be paid. GIVE ME A BREAK! 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

If the company fails, everyone fails and all contracts are cut up. Including union contracts. If employees want to work there, they can, without being forced to join a union. How is it fair to be forced to join a union? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

How is it fair to be forced to join a union? How fair is it that I was forced to put up with EIGHT YEARS of BUSH? That is the way the majority voted though in one election. I had to live with it and the consequences too. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

How fair is it that I was forced to put up with EIGHT YEARS of BUSH? That is the way the majority voted though in one election. I randyjet that doesn't make sense. The employment contract is between a person and a company. The union doesn't employ them. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

You make no sense at all. The union is the bargaining agent for the employees covered under the contract. The executives often have their OWN AGENTS who bargain for them too! The union is VOTED into that position by the MAJORITY of the employees, and they can change that too at their will. If you don't like working under a union shop, then LEAVE! Find another JOB! If I found BUSH to be so BAD, I could have left the US too. As long as we have majority rule, you gets what the folks vote for in either case. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Czars are unconstitutional, bottom line. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Actually these types of positions in government have been unconstitutional since around the FDR administration and no one has done anything about it. A lot of what our government does is unconstitutional but like I've said before, that's why it's so convenient that America has such an amazing, Global entertainment industry to distract us from everything they do. Is it a coincidence? NO! We have the most sports entertainment shows globally as well. Why aren't Americans outraged that Sports "Stars" earn MILLIONS per year while the common tax payer watching these stars is barely scraping by? Americans just spent more than $50 Freakin' MILLION dollars to go see the movie BRUNO! This should have been a slap in the face to any tax paying, freedom loving American. We spend Hundreds of Billions of dollars every year on "Entertainment" and yet 80% of us are living pay check to pay check. How much sense does that make y'all? Yes other countries have them but not on the scale we do. France has been protesting their job losses and out of control government lately, Iceland actually was able get some of their corrupt government officials to step aside, not America. Nope! as long as we have our Plasma TV's and have the freedom to watch the shows that our entertainment industry have told us are popular then we are never going to complain about what "THEY" are doing. I can almost promise you that as long as they allow you the right to turn that TUBE on, the only uprising in this country will be by people that the government and media label as Crazy or right wing extremist. You folks can say what you want about people who are prepared with food, ammo, and shelter but you know what? I bet you anything those are the same ones that have zero if any focus on the entertainment industry or sports or any other stuff the TUBE is feeding them. And people call them crazy because they do not fit the mold that the media and entertainment industry tells us we should be. Today I turned on CNN, you know what they were talking about? There were literally in deep conversation about the time the Michael Jackson caught his hair on fire. I then tuned to Fox, you know what they were talking about? They were in deep debate over how this new health care plan is going to destroy what's left of our country. Not that any of the media really care about us but the it is interesting the differences right now. Czars are unconstitutional, anyone given the power by the government to oversee hundreds of billions of dollars of tax payers money without having to be elected nor can they be effected at all by the Tax paying citizen is unconstitutional. The government intervention into GM or Chrysler was unconstitutional. The government going against the wishes of the taxpayer and using their tax dollars to bail out banks, CEO's of private industry, and bailing out corporations that have been raping the taxpayers for decades is unconstitutional. Liberals, Republicans can say what ever the heck they want but the information in this video are fact. If this is the America you want to live in then keep doing what you're doing. If not, then educate yourself and in the next elections, do the right thing, not the popular thing. And yet we do nothing!  

genxer --- 17 years ago -

AS the chief executive of the USA and biggest stock holder of the companies, he sure CAN TELL them what to do. And you have no problem with this. If you don't you need to pull your head out of ...well you know.. you brain is suffocating and needs air 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

The President, the same one who is now asking for more taxpayers dollars for another failed attempt at a stimulus package is the ONLY person in America that these Czars answer to. That in itself is unconstitutional. I'm not saying that the Republicans have all the answers, they DON'T. But I will tell you that the Liberals in America today are being Brainwashed by their "Idolized" leaders into believing that what is happening right now is Just, is Constitutional, and is the right thing to do. Well it's not. It's leading America right down the road to full collapse and right into Communism. If this new cap and trade bill passes, along with the PASS Act, and the new health care reform bill. YOUR government will then have the full ability to tell you exactly what car to buy, what to set your thermostat in your home to,and which operations you can or cannot have. Those are not Right wing extremist opinions they are are FACTS identified in the legal hog wash of these bills that these people (if you want to call them that) are trying to pass into law in AMERICA. Yes, the right wingers are doing all they can to spin this there way and the left are doing the same thing but the one thing the Left can't argue is that the broad wording of these bills do allow for those types of unAmerican, unConsititutional, and immoral acts to be performed by government. NOONE in AMERICA should be able to tell you what to set your thermostat in your home to. But they are doing all they can to make sure that happens. Don't believe me? Just Google GE + Cap and Trade 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

Oh, get over it. 

JerseyGirl --- 17 years ago -

The USA is so going to hell with Obama in charge. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Oh, get over it. Sadly that's the attitude that go us into this mess. Too many people feel that way. People with that attitude will never see anything that the government does as wrong or unconstitutional. They will continue to praise, admire, and blindly follow their elected officials right back into modern day slavery. Some people consider me unpatriotic, or a tin foil hat wearin' right wind nut job but the truth is I'm just someone who is sick and tired of being taxed to death, forced to follow the rules of an unconstitutional government who is hell bent of making me conform to their rules like carrying a national ID card for my safety. Screw that. Every terrorist they blamed for 9/11 was confirmed to have received their passports from over seas. So now they want to do full body scans at the airport and force everyone to comply to their REAL ID national biometric ID cards? Y'all go right ahead but I want no part in it even though my tax dollars are paying for it. I feel sadness for those who have not been able to escape the programming that the TUBE has done to them. They honestly believe that as a nation that Obama should have all the tax payers dollars he needs to bail out the CEOs of corrupt corporations who have been raping Americans for decades, to have full control over your home, your car, and your health care. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

The USA is so going to hell with Obama in charge. Not if you listen to the liberals in this nation. They see nothing wrong with what's going on. People on here call me a tin foil hat wearer. But in reality it's them who have been brainwashed by this system into believing that as long as Brittany and Paris aren't wearin' underwear, and Monday night football comes on as scheduled, then everything is fine in our free Nation. Wake up folks, it's all a show to keep us focused on fun and not reality. What was the first thing the government gave the American Indians after they put them on their reservations? Alcohol and Disease. Think about it. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

the top-ranking Democrat in the Senate Vice President Joe Biden said this? After all, he would be the SENIOR democrat in the Senate. Yes, I know it's Byrd, but it's pretty sloppy writing to not name him early on. The problem here is are these Czars "public ministers" or are they "such inferior officers"? If they are determined to be ministers, then we have a Constitutional issue. On the other hand, if they are determined to be "Other inferior officers" then no issue exists. Truth is, the amount of money and power one holds isn't necessarily the determining factor either. Administrative Law Judges have power over billions of dollars and work for pretty much every agency in the country, and yet, they are considered employees and not appointees. So money is certainly not the deciding factor. Additionally, Sect 2, part II also says; "...Congress may by law vest the appointment of such inferior officers, as they think proper, in the President alone..." So if Congress doesn't have a problem with it, then there is no issue. And, while I'm no expert, the way I read this, the ONLY people who have standing to make a legal complaint is Congress. What are the odds of that? It's an interesting question, and it hinges on what a Czar REALLY, and LEGALLY is, minister, or an officer. No matter what the dictionary definition of a Czar is (we do adopt words to mean other things..I.E. Shuttle, Net, dog, etc.) Here's the thing though, ministers tend to be over agencies. Feinberg doesn't seem to be over any agency per-se. Only a policy. Dunno about the other fifteen. One thing they say here; "The Constitution commands that government officers with significant authority (called “principal officers”) are nominated by the president but then are subject to a confirmation vote by the U.S. Senate." Uh, where? Art.II Sect. 2 doesn't say anything of the sort and that is where this is addressed. In fact, numerous very powerful individuals (I.E. The White House Chief of Staff, many under-secretaries, etc.) are not appointed under the advice of the Senate. The fun part of this is that if he appoints this "Czar" as part of his staff, and not over any FORMED department in of the United States (I.E. Dept. of State, Dep. of Defense, Etc). Then he is considered an employee of the Executive branch and NOT COVERED by the Constitution. The BIG difference that determines that? Was the person appointed for a particular term or an indefinite term. If the term is particular, then they are covered by the constitution, but if they have no particular term, then they are employees. (I can't remember the case in which this was decided, but it was a Reagan era appointee (employee) of some sort...i"ll have to check my notes when I get a chance). This thing also says "For these inferior officers, only Congress can create their offices, and also specify who appoints them. "...uh..no. Art 2, Sect II says "but the Congress may by law vest the appointment of such inferior officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the courts of law, or in the heads of departments." It doesn't use the affirmative language "WILL" or "MUST" which is present throughout the rest of the Constitution. Therefore it is NOT an imperative clause. In other words, it does not prevent the other two branches from creating inferior offices. And if Congress has a problem with that inferior office, they have the right to legislate it out of existence without having to go to the courts. Dunno what Byrd's game is, but I don't buy the outraged constitutionalist stand from him. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Sadly that's the attitude that go us into this mess. actually, the attitude that got us into this mess was more along the lines of "We'll let the government take whatever rights they need to take so they can protect us from the evil Muslims." Apathy's been around forever. (I don't care about it..har har). But the desire, during the Bush administration, on the part of both Pubs and Dems to give the government a little leeway on how they abused our rights to ensure a little (temporary and falsely perceived) safety is the root of why we are where we are now. 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

actually, the attitude that got us into this mess was more along the lines of "We'll let the government take whatever rights they need to take so they can protect us from the evil Muslims." People willing to trade their freedom for temporary security deserve neither and will lose both. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

People willing to trade their freedom for temporary security deserve neither and will lose both. Benjamin Franklin - but was he talking to the French when he said it? 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

Benjamin Franklin - but was he talking to the French when he said it? LOL, I didn't quote him because there are literally 20 or 30 variations of that statement and it seems that no one really knows which one is correct. No matter who he said it to or how he said it I think the context is still true and fitting. If we give up our Freedoms and Liberties for temporary security we deserve neither and will lose both. It's happening today and it seems that it's happening more and more. The Patriot Act, FISA, Real I.D., PASS Act, are all attacks on our freedoms and liberty and were all created under the guise of protecting America from "terrorists." You know what gets me lately is that more planes have crashed due to safety failures and human error this year alone than any terrorists have brought down in history. Also, if there is an air martial or an armed, trained pilot on board aircraft, then why can't I take nail clippers on board with me? Anyway, that's off topic but either way, I'm not buying it. All of those laws I listed above are nothing more than attacks on Americans freedom and liberties, they are unconstitutional and were designed for nothing more than controlling the population and keeping them in fear. Heck, the Patriot act was actually drafted during the Clinton administration, they were just waiting for a reason to use it. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

And you have no problem with this. If you don't you need to pull your head out of ...well you know.. you brain is suffocating and needs air I have NO problem with the legitimate power that the President has and uses. You are in the WRONG PARTY if you object to even worse abuses. I have to remind you that it was the Democrats who were upset at the ILLEGAL power BUSH arrogated to himself by imprisoning American citizens without trial for indefinite periods. It was the Democrats who were upset at the ILLEGAL spying on ALL Americans in violation of the FISA statutes. I recall the Republican saying that they did NOT mind that at ALL! I also DO object to the idea that ALL of the conservative justices on the SCOTUS who think that the President has unlimited powers. It is the conservatives such as Bork who think that the SCOTUS can overturn amendments to the US Constitution. It is the Republicans who have put forward the idea as Nixon put it so well, "If the President does it, it is NOT ILLEGAL!" It is YOUR head which needs to come out of its comfortable hiding place. When you think that the President should obey the rule of law, then welcome to the Democratic Party. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Oh, and I left out the best part. The conservatives think that THERE IS NO RIGHT OF PRIVACY in the US Constitution. So please tell me just WHO is it that is for absolute power for the President? In all of our recent history, it is the Republican conservatives. You don't like it, GET OUT OF THE GOP! 

james osterberg --- 17 years ago -

Democratic Senator Robert Byrd This guy has only one thing on his mind(what's left of it), and that is BURNING COAL.Any wonder why he doesn't like Czars? Dunno what Byrd's game is, but I don't buy the outraged constitutionalist stand from him. It answers this,also. 

Hiro Protagonist --- 17 years ago -

Signing statements were a nice little add-on to executive power as well. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Signing statements were a nice little add-on to executive power as well. Congress has a remedy for that one. If it is bad enough, and the President refuses to do his job, they can impeach him. They should have done it for Andrew Johnson. I disagree with JFK that the guys who stopped Johnson from being impeached were good guys. 

anti-antichange --- 17 years ago -

where's that article from, martha? 

26.2 --- 17 years ago -

I was just going to ask the same question.. Would like source of article. 

david --- 17 years ago -

How fair is it that I was forced to put up with EIGHT YEARS of BUSH  

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

How fair is it that I was forced to put up with EIGHT YEARS of BUSH? Do you want some cheese with that whine? 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Do you want some cheese with that whine? MMMM.. got any Wenslydale? And I prefer beer to whine. And as to the source, there are numerous locations that have this story, just look for them. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground