Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Supreme Court Rules in Favor of Firefighters

who's talking here?

whatchamacallit 3
GCan 1
smartypants 17
randyjet 12
planemom 6
Going off air 1
Mabbers 1
Cicero 1
~sassy~ 28
ExLady In Blue 30
rEVOLution 4
Perfection 1
Shana 1
Phileen 3
iheartboxers 1
JohnLynch 6
james osterberg 8
*momof5* 4
Jambilly 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Discrimination  

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

I meant to post this but got so frustrated cause KU was dragging. Houston fire department is having the same problem. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

Great! Hope this ruling keeps this from happening elsewhere! 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

VIDICATION, BABY!!! This happened on the sergeant's promotional test on the police department that I served on (happened around the time I got on). It took YEARS to fight it, but the officer's passed over for promotion, based on race issues, were granted the promotions due them, including back dating their promotion and pay. Boo Ya! A test is a test; either you have the smarts or you don't, and race has nothing to do with it. 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

In New Haven, Nancy Ricci, whose son, Frank, was the lead plaintiff on the lawsuit, carried a large cake decorated with red, white and blue frosting into the law office where the firefighters were celebrating their victory. The ruling is "a sign that individual achievement should not take a back seat to race or ethnicity," said Karen Torre, the firefighters' attorney. "I think the import of the decision is that cities cannot bow to politics and pressure and lobbying by special interest groups or act to achieve racial quotas." At a press conference on the steps of city hall in New Haven, firefighter Frank Ricci said the ruling showed that "if you work hard, you can succeed in America." 

whatchamacallit --- 17 years ago -

A test is a test; either you have the smarts or you don YES!!! 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

At a press conference on the steps of city hall in New Haven, firefighter Frank Ricci said the ruling showed that "if you work hard, you can succeed in America." I have chills all over right now.....Good for those Fire Fighters. I hope this is a step towards doing away with affirmative action altogether. Promotions based on personal ability always, never race, which is reverse discrimination. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Looks like Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor might be looking to hold onto her current job. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Looks like Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor might be looking to hold onto her current job. Dare I dream? 

Mabbers --- 17 years ago -

Victory. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

The firefighter ruling could alter employment practices nationwide and make it harder to prove discrimination when there is no evidence it was intentional. New Haven was wrong to scrap a promotion exam because no African-Americans and only two Hispanic firefighters were likely to be made lieutenants or captains based on the results, the court said Monday in a 5-4 decision. The city said that it had acted to avoid a lawsuit from minorities. Why would there have been a law suit from minorities????? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Why would there have been a law suit from minorities????? Because tests that give a racial preference result are illegal under US law. For example, one question would be was your grandfather a full US citizen? If it is NO then, the person who says that gets disqualified. This was used in many "literacy" tests to keep blacks from voting. The same is true for other kinds of tests. I personally had to intervene in a case at the oil refinery where I worked. A black guy was going into the crafts, which had been a white preserve for years. Some people gave him racial crap and harassed him, he complained about it. From that point on he failed all his tests. I gave a deposition in his support and pointed out that it was rather unlikely that he would fail those exams since he had been a crew chief on a large USAF aircraft and had extensive maintenance experience. He had done all that well for over four years in the USAF, and in order to be even accepted into that program, he had to test at the top percentile of recruits. They thought that I made some good points,and he was re-admitted to the training program and passed. Things like THAT are the reason for lawsuits. In this case, I think that I would side with the majority of the SC. Doing otherwise is counterproductive in getting the best talent, and if there is no racial intent, then the test should be kept. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Looks like Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor might be looking to hold onto her current job. She will still be confirmed and will not have any problem since she applied current law at the time. 

~sassy~ --- 17 years ago -

Because tests that give a racial preference result are illegal under US law. For example, one question would be was your grandfather 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

It'll be interesting to see what impact this case has future discrimination laws. The SC used the Civil Rights act to interpret this case. In the future, cases could be made under the Equal Protection Clause. I see the laws regarding what is discrimination changing. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

I am sort of happy with this outcome. I didn't agree with Sotomayor's decision, but then I'm not a judge who is informed about precedent. The city declined to validate the test after it was given, a step that could have identified flaws or determined that there were no serious problems with it. In addition, city officials could not say what was wrong with the test, other than the racially skewed results. Why the heck not? Lastly, basing a promotion on test results ALONE seems incredibly stupid! I doubt that the ability to perform under stressful and dangerous conditions can be measured by a written test. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Lastly, basing a promotion on test results ALONE seems incredibly stupid! I doubt that the ability to perform under stressful and dangerous conditions can be measured by a written test. Um, I hate to bust your balls, oh, who am I kidding, I love to bust your balls, but you really don't know what you're talking about. Read on. JUNE 29, 2009, 6:17 P.M. ET Details Of New Haven, Conn., Firefighting Exam WASHINGTON (Dow Jones)--New Haven, Conn.'s white firefighters and city officials couldn't agree on what constitutes a fair promotional exam in briefs leading up to Monday's U.S. Supreme Court ruling on employment discrimination. The white firefighters involved in the Ricci v. Stefano case, which involved New Haven's decision to discard the tests, said the promotion exam was fair and neutral. The city argued it had been unintentionally designed to put minority firefighters at a disadvantage. In 2003, New Haven hired professional testing firm Industrial/Organizational Solutions, Inc. to develop its promotional exams for both captains and lieutenants. Applicants needed to be well-versed on a wide range of topics including fire science, building and high-rise construction and collapse, advanced rescue techniques and how to respond in the case of fires and other catastrophes. The exam was composed of two sections. The first was a written exam of 100 multiple-choice questions focused on technical job knowledge that counted for 60% of the total score. According to the brief filed by Ricci and other petitioners, the exams were written below a 10th-grade reading level. Next came an oral exam, weighted 40%, in which panels of three experts evaluated how well firefighters could assess a situation and direct others in an emergency. In its critique of the test, the city noted that the test contained questions that were irrelevant to New Haven. This included whether to approach an emergency from uptown or downtown - a distinction not meaningful in New Haven, city officials said. The city also argued that placing more emphasis on memorized knowledge put the minority candidates at a disadvantage. If the oral exam had counted for 70% of the total, three black firefighters would have been contenders for promotions, attorneys for the city noted. But the white firefighters, led by Frank Ricci, said the tests were not skewed. Firefighters who completed a questionnaire following the exam overall said it was "fair and job-related," they noted. The tests were developed based on professional textbooks, in collaboration with New Haven Fire Department's top two officers. Three months before the test, the city gave firefighters a syllabus of the topics that would be covered to help them study. On Monday, Justice Anthony Kennedy, writing the Supreme Court's 5-4 conservative majority opinion, said New Haven violated Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964, which prohibits employment discrimination. - By Kristina Peterson, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-862-6619; kristina.peterson@dowjones.com 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Oh, and here's the source, for your reading pleasure. READ IT AND WEEP!!! 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Lastly, basing a promotion on test results ALONE seems incredibly stupid! I doubt that the ability to perform under stressful and dangerous conditions can be measured by a written test. I agree with you on that. Again, at the refinery we had a test required to make Stillman. One of the older white guys was not a very sharp tack, but he could pass the test. The supervisor who knew the guy well refused to promote him to stillman. The union filed a grievance on his behalf, and he was promoted after many years of trying. In real emergencies he performed very badly, and even came close to killing me during one. I was promoted rather quickly with no trouble as were many black guys as well. The promotion was based soley on the judgement of the supervisor as the final factor. The bad thing about this is the subjective nature of such a system, and it is open to abuse. So there is a fine line between what is good and what is simply politics. It requires good faith on all parties concerned to get a fair solution. There is no one size fits all cases. This was one in which I would disagree with the liberal members. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Randy, as clearly stated in my post above, this was a written and an oral test! What did you want the testing firm to do, go out and start a fire, give the call to all of the men taking the test and see who put out the fire the fastest, in the safest way possible with all persons safely rescued from the burning home? 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

The bad thing about this is the subjective nature of such a system, and it is open to abuse. I agree. Everything in this world that has to do with a person's perspective is subjective. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

basing a promotion on test results ALONE seems incredibly stupid! I don't see where your post addressed my point, ex lady. How people perform during an emergency can be very different from how they perform under the controlled conditions of test taking, written or oral. You can have all the training and knowledge in the world and freeze or panic when the real deal hits. Especially when a job involves life saving, unpredictability, and making snap judgements, proven experience of being able to perform under pressure is important, and may be just as important as knowledge that can be measured by an oral or written exam. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

What did you want the testing firm to do, go out and start a fire, give the call to all of the men taking the test and see who put out the fire the fastest No, but if a firefighter is being promoted to Captain, wouldn't there be yearly evaluations of his performance? Wouldn't his supervisor be able to give input as to how he performed in dangerous situations? Wouldn't other coworkers? That information could be relevant when deciding who is the best candidate for the job. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

basing a promotion on test results ALONE seems incredibly stupid! I don't see where your post addressed my point, ex lady. How people perform during an emergency can be very different from how they perform under the controlled conditions of test taking, written or oral. You can have all the training and knowledge in the world and freeze or panic when the real deal hits. Especially when a job involves life saving, unpredictability, and making snap judgements, proven experience of being able to perform under pressure is important, and may be just as important as knowledge that can be measured by an oral or written exam. Okay, I addressed it to Randy, but I will say the same thing to you: Randy, as clearly stated in my post above, this was a written and an oral test! What did you want the testing firm to do, go out and start a fire, give the call to all of the men taking the test and see who put out the fire the fastest, in the safest way possible with all persons safely rescued from the burning home? Furthermore, when you are dealing with captains and lieutenants, those jobs deal with more paperwork than anything, so yes, a written exam should hold more weight in those instances. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Randy, as clearly stated in my post above, this was a written and an oral test! I see that you have a hard time taking YES for an answer. So far I have seen NO dissent from the SC majority opinion. I and smartypants agree with you and the decision. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

No, but if a firefighter is being promoted to Captain, wouldn't there be yearly evaluations of his performance? Wouldn't his supervisor be able to give input as to how he performed in dangerous situations? Wouldn't other coworkers? So then you're going back to what Randy said about it being based on other people's opinions, prejudices. You do realize that even if police officers or firefighters are evaluated on a yearly basis, they all make the same base salary based on years of service, right? With your logic, their pay would be based on their performance as well, which can lead you to a very slippery slope. Normally, when someone screws up and they are reprimanded, this goes in their file, and if they're that big of a screw up they're not eligible to take the test, either. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

when you are dealing with captains and lieutenants, those jobs deal with more paperwork than anything Really? Here is example of want ad for a Fire Captain: City of Foster City Estero Municipal Improvement District Job Specification Fire Captain DEFINITION: Plans and supervises the activities of firefighting personnel in preparation for and performance of response duties to fire, rescue and medical emergencies; directs subordinate personnel to ensure that Fire Department Procedures Manual and City Rules and Regulations are adhered to; participates in training, prevention, and company inspection procedures. DISTINGUISHING CHARACTERISTICS, FEATURES, REQUIREMENTS: This position is distinguished by the supervisory role in responding with company personnel, equipment, and apparatus to fire and medical emergencies. Requires periodic assignment to the function of shift platoon commander. SUPERVISION EXERCISED AND RECEIVED: Supervises firefighting personnel. Receives direct supervision from the department's Operations Chief, as well as indirect supervision from other Chief Officers. IMPORTANT AND ESSENTIAL DUTIES: Responds with personnel, equipment, and apparatus to fire, rescue, emergency medical and hazardous materials incidents; maintains discipline, supervises, and evaluates the performance of firefighting personnel and makes recommendations for disciplinary action within department and city policies, rules and guidelines, inspects, tests, and assures readiness of equipment and apparatus. As an emergency medical technician (EMT-D), provides emergency medical services as required and performs light to heavy rescue functions at emergencies; performs fire prevention activities, company level inspections as assigned and participates in public education for members and groups in the community. When performing Paramedic duties: respond to medical emergency calls; evaluate conditions of patient(s); take and monitor vital signs; communicate with Base Hospital and Emergency Medical Dispatcher; select and implement a course of medical action based on patient medical conditions; establish intravenous medications as required; interview patients and witnesses; observe evidence at the scene; coordinate with transport personnel; work closely with Fire Emergency Medical Technicians at the scene; complete reports, and ensure that all equipment and supplies are available in working order; may train other personnel or civilians in CPR techniques and EMT skills; prepare thorough after action alarm reports as well as in depth technical staff reports that support the mission of the department; create and foster effective working relationships in the department among all ranks and with other city departments and employees. OTHER JOB-RELATED DUTIES: Makes recommendations on department practices, policies and procedures. Attends meetings, conferences and training sessions to keep current on technical standards and supervisory expertise. Attendance includes both on and off duty time, in compliance with current FLSA requirements. JOB-RELATED QUALIFICATIONS: Knowledge, Skills and Abilities: Knowledge of: principles of supervision, time and project management; techniques and equipment used in modern firefighting, protection of life and property, and fire prevention; building construction related to fire control and fire investigation, emergency medical services and rescue practices. Ability to: understand, interpret and act in accordance with department rules, policies and standard operating procedures and demonstrate skill in applying these toward specific situations; direct fire personnel and companies at fire scenes, hazardous materials incidents and medical and rescue situations. EDUCATION AND TRAINING GUIDELINES: Any combination equivalent to experience and education that could likely provide the required knowledge, skills and abilities would be qualifying. A typical way would be: Education: Graduation from high school or equivalent; possession of 30 units in Fire Science with at least six (6) units in supervisory management; an Associate Degree in Fire Science, or State certification as a Fire Officer, or the ability to obtain such prior to the completion of probation. Experience: Four (4) years of full-time, paid experience as a firefighter. SPECIAL REQUIREMENTS: Normal hearing and vision, or correctable to a normal level: possess physical strength, endurance, agility; produce extreme effort and energy for periods of time in highly stressful situations, apply knowledge of the streets, water mains and building complexes within the city, utilizing this information when in command of emergency situations; provide appropriate instruction to line personnel in both classroom and field applications of the principles of fire control and emergency medical services; remain accountable for the safety and welfare of others while working as a team leader to abate an emergency. LICENSES, CERTIFICATES, REGISTRATION: Licenses: Possession of a valid Class B, or Firefighter Restricted California Drivers License. Valid certificate to practice as an Emergency Medical Technician (EMT) in the State of California. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

I and smartypants agree with you and the decision. Then why this comment? How people perform during an emergency can be very different from how they perform under the controlled conditions of test taking, written or oral. You can have all the training and knowledge in the world and freeze or panic when the real deal hits. Especially when a job involves life saving, unpredictability, and making snap judgements, proven experience of being able to perform under pressure is important, and may be just as important as knowledge that can be measured by an oral or written exam. No, but if a firefighter is being promoted to Captain, wouldn't there be yearly evaluations of his performance? Wouldn't his supervisor be able to give input as to how he performed in dangerous situations? Wouldn't other coworkers? That information could be relevant when deciding who is the best candidate for the job.  

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

With your logic, their pay would be based on their performance as well, which can lead you to a very slippery slope. Not necessarily. The promotion would merit a pay raise though, and to qualify for the promotion, the individual should have a track record of successful performance. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

I know way too many firemen, and while they do respond to fires and do perform duties, they are the same duties they have been doing their entire career, along with the added responsibilities of doing paperwork, planning, scheduling, training, supervising, and a plethora of other things. **Edited to say, it's not like they are introduced to firefighting at the captain's and lieutenant's promotional testing. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Then why this comment? I said I was sorta happy. My objection was, and still is, that in this particular case, the promotion seems to rest solely on the results of written and oral tests. That is what I don't agree with as I would like the test results AND practical job experience be considered. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

I said I was sorta happy. My objection was, and still is, that in this particular case, the promotion seems to rest solely on the results of written and oral tests. That is what I don't agree with as I would like the test results AND practical job experience to be considered. Well then they better throw out every promotional test ever given, because, normally, all promotional tests for fire and police work are based on written and oral testing. Heck, I even had to take an oral boards to be hired for the police department and I knew absolutely nothing about "real police work" at that time. I guess the fact that I aced it meant that it was skewed, right? 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

Randyjet gave a very good example of someone who was able to pass the test but did not perform well when a dangerous situation occurred. My feeling is, people like that would be weeded out if the ability to perform in a high pressure, dangerous situation was a requirement. When there are fires and medical emergencies, having higher standards can mean the difference between life and death for someone. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

I can see you have never served in any type of profession that requires this type of decision making. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

they better throw out every promotional test ever given, because, normally, all promotional tests for fire and police work are based on written and oral testing Try to read my posts...I'm not saying throw out the test. In fact, I disagreed with Sotomayor's opinion that the test results should be thrown out. I'm saying the test results PLUS proven ability to perform under pressure should be considered when making the decision who to promote. 

JohnLynch --- 17 years ago -

That is what I don't agree with as I would like the test results AND practical job experience to be considered. I would think that if their job experience was poor, then they would no longer have that job and wouldn't be taking the test. Therefore, it seems that job performance is considered. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

I'm saying the test results PLUS proven ability to perform under pressure should be considered when making the decision who to promote. Since you cannot create true, accurate "under pressure" situations to prove this point, then are you saying only those that have performed heroic acts should be allowed to be promoted? In the military, are only those with a Purple Heart, or other commendation, allowed to be promoted to lieutenant and above? Based on your scenario, then 0 should have never been allowed to run for the presidency, because he has never been tested to the degree of those that served before him. He was inexperienced, and only "book smart". 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

How people perform during an emergency can be very different from how they perform under the controlled conditions of test taking, written or oral. The reason for that comment is that it is TRUE! Thus an even more subjective standard is applied in that case. All I am doing is discussing the different parameters and reasons for promotion. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

I'm saying those who have performed well would be known to their supervisors, coworkers, and community. The same for those who didn't perform well. Does every fire fighter or policeman perform with the same degree of competance in a dangerous or life threatening situation? Probably not, and that should be taken in consideration. Purple Hearts are given to those wounded or killed. You can be stupid and get a purple heart. That's probably not PC to say, but it's true. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Nighty, night, libs. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground