Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

POLL: Which Life is More Valuable?

who's talking here?

Melanie 1
GCan 3
love4bdd 1
randyjet 2
planemom 2
R.E.B. 1
justforfun 7
Perfection 1
Lillabeth 5
MomTimesFive 14
OH SNAP! 3
PutOnYourBigGirlPanties 4
Wilstar77 4
*maryc 9
zombie slayer 1
sadiesmom 1
goatlady 6
*momof5* 3
JChandler 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

POLL: Which Life is More Valuable?

Just curious how people rationalize what makes a life valuable.

1. A baby at 5 months gestation that the mother does not want. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
2. A baby at 5 months gestation that the mother wants. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
3. A newborn baby. Vote
 
 0.0% (0)
4. A 3-year-old. Vote
 
 5.3% (2)
5. Only #2, 3 and 4. Vote
 
 5.3% (2)
6. All Vote
 
 89.5% (34)
MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

Just curious how people rationalize what makes a life valuable. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

I'm pro-choice but I voted for all because who are we to judge who's life has more value. The thing with abortion is that people don't think a fetus is a living human just yet. Does it have potential? Yes, but so do the discarded fertilized egg that don't take during in-vitro OR the trillion little soldiers that get flushed down the toilet from every male on the planet. 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

trillion little soldiers that get flushed down the toilet from every male on the planet. Reckless abandonment...IT SHOULD BE A CRIME!! 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

The thing with abortion is that people don't think a fetus is a living human just yet. This is another thing that I'm curious about. What constitutes a "living human"? The heart starts beating very early on, so in some people's eyes having a heartbeat does not constitute life (although a person without a heartbeat is declared "dead"). Does life begin when there is air in the lungs? Does life begin when there is awareness of one's self and one's surroundings? In that case, a newborn wouldn't be as "alive" as a baby who is a few months old. 

Melanie --- 17 years ago -

Just curious how people rationalize what makes a life valuable. They're ALL valuable. This thread makes no sense to me. 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Did you ever play the life boat game? Where you were told that persons X,Y and Z were in a life boat and you needed to choose who was kicked out? You also had to explain why. I never did like that game. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

To me life begins at conception. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

They're ALL valuable. This thread makes no sense to me. They are not all valuable to those who believe in abortion. That's what doesn't make sense to me. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

This poll doesn't make any sense to me. I was expecting it to be the mother vs. the fetus at various different stages. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

This poll doesn't make any sense to me. I was expecting it to be the mother vs. the fetus at various different stages. Why? I didn't say anything about the mother in the title. My question is what makes a life valuable. If it is valuable at any point in development, what makes abortion okay? 

R.E.B. --- 17 years ago -

At one time, I was number one on the list. Fortunately I was spared and adopted. Does it have potential? Yes, but so do the discarded fertilized egg that don't take during in-vitro OR the trillion little soldiers that get flushed down the toilet from every male on the planet. The fertilized egg contains unique DNA for a new human. This DNA is different from the parents, and from the incomplete DNA of sperm or unfertilized eggs. You can not compared them. Sperm does not have the DNA of a new person. The same is true of the unfertilized egg. But a fertilized egg not only contains the DNA for a new human, it builds that new human. This DNA is the blueprints for a new human. The mother just provides the building space and material. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

This is another thing that I'm curious about. What constitutes a "living human"? That's the million dollar question. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Why? I didn't say anything about the mother in the title. My question is what makes a life valuable. If it is valuable at any point in development, what makes abortion okay? Well, you've already started out the poll assuming that everyone believes a fertilized egg counts as a life from day 1. If everyone believed that, there really wouldn't be much room for discussion. 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

Each one is of equal value. In my world, life begins at conception. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

Sperm that doesn't reach an egg is not a human life. By itself, it cannot become anything. Nor can that egg. But an egg which has been fertilized and left alone, without intervention, will eventually become a human being except in the case of abortion or a spontaneous miscarriage. There's no other way to create life that doesn't involve uniting the sperm and egg. That's the difference. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Each one is of equal value. In my world, life begins at conception. That's what I said. They're all important. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

This begs a new question...... Whose life is more valuable A - A newborn B - A senior citizen Laugh not, as we enter in to a more socialized healthcare the decisions will be made on this since the resources will be limited. Who would benefit more? 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

REB, I've been in that number 1 position also, but was spared and adopted. I have thanked my biological mother for the choices she made and the responsibility she took for my life. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

They are not all valuable to those who believe in abortion. That's what doesn't make sense to me.  I think they are valuable and I believe in abortion. I just think it's up to the mother to decide for themselves. Example: A pregnant woman is shot by a robber. Fetus and mom die. He should get charged with double murder because even though the fetus was of abortion age, it is the mother's choice to abort it NOT the robbers. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

This begs a new question...... Whose life is more valuable A - A newborn B - A senior citizen Crap Chunky! I haven't wrapped my head completely around the last question yet! Are these fun old people or crabby, b!tchy ones? JK!!! 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

This begs a new question...... Whose life is more valuable A - A newborn B - A senior citizen Laugh not, as we enter in to a more socialized healthcare the decisions will be made on this since the resources will be limited. Who would benefit more? Good question and I know it's coming. What some don't realize is that one day they will be old and think differently. It isn't a nice thought, is it? 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

He should get charged with double murder because even though the fetus was of abortion age, it is the mother's choice to abort it NOT the robbers. He should be charged with murder for killing two human beings. If you say that a fetus isn't a human because it's not fully formed/developed...what about children with conditions such as cerebral palsy, spina bifida, etc? 

planemom --- 17 years ago -

Whose life is more valuable A - A newborn B - A senior citizen That was the point of the life boat game. We had to decide who was more valuable. Kind of like "Survivor" but with life or death repercussions. 

OH SNAP! --- 17 years ago -

Oh good grief. This is the last time I'm clicking on this thread. *sigh* 

*maryc --- 17 years ago -

"Whose life is more valuable A - A newborn B - A senior citizen " I don't know the answer to this question, but I'm sure it will be important with national health care, My grandson told me this weekend that if I died he would still love me, so I guess however it turns out, it will be okay :) I would consider my child or grandchild's life more important than mine. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

Well, you've already started out the poll assuming that everyone believes a fertilized egg counts as a life from day 1. I didn't make that assumption. I am honestly curious to know if a baby at 5 months gestation is more valuable if the mother wants it and not as valuable if the mother does not want it. I said nothing about a fertilized egg. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

it is the mother's choice to abort it NOT the robbers. So in your opinion, an unborn baby's life is valuable ONLY IF the MOTHER wants it. So your choice in the poll would be #5. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

I feel this topic going in circles. 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

Wil, so are you saying that if your wife didn't want your unborn baby that is inside her right now... She can abort it and you won't care cause it's HER body. HER choice? Sorry, buddy, but it takes TWO. I understand all too well about a dead-beat sperm donor. What about the men that would care for that child if given the chance? 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

I figure it's not our decision to make. It's a personal choice and while I may or may not agree with that choice, I don't think my beliefs should be pushed on someone else. People make their own choices and then have to live with the consequences. 

love4bdd --- 17 years ago -

Although I'm pro-choice.....one of my favorites.......  

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

I'm not saying I ever would have had an abortion, but if I had, I know it would weigh heavy on my heart forever..whatever the reason. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

I'm not even talking about beliefs, choice or judgment. I just honestly want to know what makes a life important-the fact that it is a life or the fact that the mother wants it. 

Wilstar77 --- 17 years ago -

Wil, so are you saying that if your wife didn't want your unborn baby that is inside her right now... She can abort it and you won't care cause it's HER body. HER choice? Hopefully she would respect me enough to take my opinion into consideration. At the end of the day it's her choice. I don't know what the law is for married people though. She's 8 months now and everything seems healthy so I guess she couldn't get an abortion now even if she wanted one. LOL. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

I'm not even talking about beliefs, choice or judgment. I just honestly want to know what makes a life important-the fact that it is a life or the fact that the mother wants it. The fact that it's a life and an important one at that. 

GCan --- 17 years ago -

How come women can have a choice to abort their babies...but this kid who didn't want to have chemo...is now being forced to do so? Seems like there's some selective reasoning. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

Also, why is the man so unimportant in the decision of whether or not his baby is born, but if the baby is born, then his role becomes important as far as paying for the child's care? 

Lillabeth --- 17 years ago -

Also, why is the man so unimportant in the decision of whether or not his baby is born, but if the baby is born, then his role becomes important as far as paying for the child's care? Yep. So sad and yet so true. 

justforfun --- 17 years ago -

Also, why is the man so unimportant in the decision of whether or not his baby is born, but if the baby is born, then his role becomes important as far as paying for the child's care? I have wondered about that. Why doesn't the man get a say in an abortion? He is expected to pay child support so why not give him a choice too. 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

Bigger question...why do these girls/women reproduce with men they don't want to raise a family with? Someone told me once to consider before you have sex with someone, if you are willing to take responsiblity for a child together. Birth control is not 100%. I didn't stop me from having sex but it was a valid point! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

polls


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground