Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Is Waterboarding Torture?

who's talking here?

freshhell 2
randyjet 1
steinhoister 1
NoNameNoLastName 2
rEVOLution 1
MomTimesFive 2
RiteWingKing 5
POTUS 2
genxer 1
cushybum 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

RiteWingKing --- 17 years ago -

After thinking about this the question arises: Has the United States of America ever prosecuted a case of waterboarding as torture. If we have done this then it would be hypocrisy to call waterboarding an enhanced interrogation technique and not torture. In the United States, waterboarding has long been considered illegal or a violation of military rules of conduct. The earliest known case of a prosecution for waterboarding occurred in 1901 when an Army major was sentenced to 10 years in prison for waterboarding a Filipino guerrilla insurgent during the Philippine-American War. In 1926 the Mississippi Supreme Court overturned the conviction of a black man accused of murder because his confession had been obtained by waterboarding. Following World War II American prosecutors convicted several Japanese soldiers for waterboarding Allied prisoners of war. The soldiers were tried as part of the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, also known as the Tokyo War Crimes Trials. During the Vietnam War, a U.S. soldier who participated in the waterboarding of a North Vietnamese prisoner of war was court-martialed in 1968. As recently as 1983, a Texas sheriff was sentenced to ten years in prison for waterboarding suspects in an attempt to coerce confessions. In 1994 the United States ratified the Convention Against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (CAT). When this international treaty was ratified, its provisions became U.S. law. The convention defined torture as “any act by which severe pain or suffering, whether physical or mental, is intentionally inflicted on a person.” Also in 1946 the U.S. Congress adopted the Torture Statute, which provides criminal liability for a U.S. national who tortures a person outside of the United States. A foreign national apprehended in the United States for torturing someone outside of the United States could also face criminal liability under the Torture Statute. The U.S. War Crimes Act of 1996 provides life imprisonment or the death penalty for a U.S. national or any member of the U.S. armed forces who is convicted of torturing someone to death. Anyone charged with a grave breach of the Geneva Conventions, which forbids torture, could also be tried in the United States under the War Crimes Act.  

RiteWingKing --- 17 years ago -

After World War II, we convicted several Japanese soldiers for waterboarding American and Allied prisoners of war. At the trial of his captors, then-Lt. Chase J. Nielsen, one of the 1942 Army Air Forces officers who flew in the Doolittle Raid and was captured by the Japanese, testified: "I was given several types of torture. . . . I was given what they call the water cure." He was asked what he felt when the Japanese soldiers poured the water. "Well, I felt more or less like I was drowning," he replied, "just gasping between life and death." Nielsen's experience was not unique. Nor was the prosecution of his captors. After Japan surrendered, the United States organized and participated in the International Military Tribunal for the Far East, generally called the Tokyo War Crimes Trials. Leading members of Japan's military and government elite were charged, among their many other crimes, with torturing Allied military personnel and civilians. The principal proof upon which their torture convictions were based was conduct that we would now call waterboarding. Source 

cushybum --- 17 years ago -

depends on who's being waterboarded 

RiteWingKing --- 17 years ago -

depends on who's being waterboarded Show me where our laws make this distinction. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

If it was truly torture, rather than just a very unpleasant experience, I wouldn't think anyone would go through it more than once before they would talk. 

RiteWingKing --- 17 years ago -

If it was truly torture, rather than just a very unpleasant experience, I wouldn't think anyone would go through it more than once before they would talk. Then why has the United States prosecuted others for waterboarding? That is the question. We are just a bunch of hypocrites. Maybe its just because they had slanted eyes. 

cushybum --- 17 years ago -

Show me where our laws make this distinction seriously? LMFAO! 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

We are just a bunch of hypocrites. That's the answer to MANY a question. Regarding water boarding everyone who that I have seen who have tried it lasted only seconds and said immediately, yes, that was torture. But then again we are talking about TV and radio personalities, not hardened terrorist. Regardless. My take on it is, try these people for what ever crime they were arrested or let them go. But when you let them go, track them. We have the technology to do it so why not do it. You can torture some one and they will tell you what ever it is you want to hear. I don't see it as an effective route. Some might say "well it's kept us safe ever since 9/11, must be working." Well that would depend on if you think terrorist really hijacked planes and flew them into buildings. There is a lot of evidence that proves that theory is not plausible. And many people begging for an actual investigation. The latest news on the 9/11 front is that there have been abundant amounts of explosives found in dust samples taken from Manhattan but they are still investigating who made the explosives and where they might have been placed. 

genxer --- 17 years ago -

See here's the problem with this. There is waterboarding and then there is pouring water on someones face while they are laying on a board, something that we do to our own army and navy as part of training. They were stupid to call it the same thing because its not. But frankly you have to decide is this a war or a criminal justice problem. The right sees it as a war where the death of our own citizens are not acceptable. The left views this as a law enforcement exercise and al-queda is no different than MS13. For the record, chopping someones heads off is torture. Having people be so afraid of fire that the jumped out of the WTC to the cement below, that's torture. Hanging burning bodies off a bridge is torture. Dismembering someone is torture. 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

something that we do to our own army and navy as part of training. training for what? To withstand torture! Duh! 

freshhell --- 17 years ago -

Go through it yourself before you pass judgement. 

MomTimesFive --- 17 years ago -

Go through it yourself before you pass judgement. I probably wouldn't. I would probably give the information that was being asked of me. The prisoner has all the control over whether they go through it or not. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

The prisoner has all the control over whether they go through it or not. THAT is silly. A POW has NO control over much of anything. We actually got most all the useful intel from those guys BEFORE we tortured them. It was only AFTER Cheney and others wanted MORE intel about Hussein being in collaboration with Al Qeada, that they started torturing them. Of course, they got the "confessions" and intel that they wanted. When do you stop torturing? How can you "know" you have gotten all the intel that is available? You have to keep on torturing. The Soviet Union used such methods to get "confessions" and guess what? They had even MORE "criminals" to catch and torture. It is a never ending cycle which simply feeds on itself and produces what Stalin wanted, which was a terrorized population. Torture produces confessions that will simply feed the machine of terror by implicating MORE people who are in fact innocent. 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

Again, the American public is made to debate a small issue so that the larger one goes unnoticed. Gotta love how the media and government is making the entire torture issue about waterboarding, while ignoring the rape and physical abuse that goes on. 

steinhoister --- 17 years ago -

The prisoner has all the control over whether they go through it or not. How can you be so sure? 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

I would probably give the information that was being asked of me. No - you would give whatever they wanted to hear. Big difference. 

POTUS --- 17 years ago -

No - you would give whatever they wanted to hear. Big difference. Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, the so-called "9/11 Mastermind", was waterboarded hundreds of times and eventually confessed to blowing up buildings that HADN'T EVEN BEEN BUILT until after he was imprisoned in Guantanamo. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

waterboarded hundreds of times And if needs to be done hundreds of time - I'm sorry, it doesn't work. Bottom line, people were waterboarded to confess to a non-existing connection between Saddam and Al-Qaeda, so the war could be justified. 

RiteWingKing --- 17 years ago -

But frankly you have to decide is this a war or a criminal justice problem. The right sees it as a war where the death of our own citizens are not acceptable. Lets say the right is correct and this is a war. I agree with this is many ways. Waterboarding is still a crime. This was prosecuted at Tokyo War Crimes Trials. What makes me sick is we allowed this to happen. Our laws were trampled on. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground