Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Olbermann pressing on Hannity's waterboard offer

who's talking here?

JDB2 18
DrowningFish 1
smartypants 13
Fallon 6
randyjet 14
maverick 11
NoNameNoLastName 26
Mr Mark 1
David 1
Donkey Hodie 12
david 14
~sassy~ 1
ExLady In Blue 1
Perfection 3
traveller! 2
Meme2my5 1
Nightstorm 2
RiteWingKing 4
Shana 2
Agent of Change 1
Allimama 1
Hiro Protagonist 2
believer 10
voice of reason 1
Mark 3
goatlady 6
*momof5* 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

It's now obvious that Hannity is a coward. By DAVID BAUDER, AP Television Writer David Bauder, Ap Television Writer – Wed Apr 29, 6:36 am ET NEW YORK – The debate over torture is getting personal for two of cable TV's prime-time hosts. After Fox News Channel's Sean Hannity made a seemingly impromptu offer last week to undergo waterboarding as a benefit for charity, MSNBC's Keith Olbermann leapt at it. He offered $1,000 to the families of U.S. troops for every second Hannity withstood the technique. Olbermann repeated the offer on Monday's show and said in an interview Tuesday that he's heard no response. He said he'll continue to pursue it. "I don't think he has the courage to even respond to this — let alone do it," Olbermann said. Fox News Channel representatives did not respond to requests for comment. The two men are on opposite poles of a debate that has preoccupied the worlds of talk TV and radio. Hannity says waterboarding is a fair and necessary interrogation technique for suspected terrorists; Olbermann calls it torture, says it's ineffective and should not be done by Americans. Charles Grodin was challenging Hannity on the issue on Fox last week, and asked whether he would consent to be waterboarded. "Sure," Hannity said. "I'll do it for charity ... I'll do it for the troops' families." It wasn't exactly clear how serious the conversation was, since Grodin joked, "Are you busy on Sunday?" and Hannity laughed. "I'll let you do it," Hannity said. "I wouldn't do it," Grodin said. "I'll hand you a towel when you come out of the shower." Olbermann's offer was quick. Besides the $1,000 per second, Olbermann said he'd double it if Hannity acknowledges he feared for his life and admits that waterboarding is torture. "The idea of putting somebody in a position they have volunteered for, for charity, to respond to their own unsupportable claims, is in many ways priceless," Olbermann said. Olbermann, who hasn't missed any chance to criticize his ideological enemies at Fox, concedes TV competition plays a part in his offer. But he said it was sincere, because he believes Hannity has had a damaging role in the debate. "If you expose people to reality, even with someone who is denying reality, that can have a powerful and important impact," he said.  

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

Check out the video at this link: Journalist lasts only 6 seconds A journalist makes a bet that he can withstand 15 seconds of waterboarding, but lasts only 6 seconds. 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

I am wondering how many minutes the "detainees" have been subjected to of this method??! Hopefully alot 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Olbermann just wants/needs the publicity. He has only a handful of viewers and is hoping to ride on Hannity's coattails. What a loser Obermann is. He should go back to ESPN and do the sports again 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Hannity probably hasn't even heard of this challenge, it's like President Obama hadn't heard of the tea parties. 

david --- 17 years ago -

I bet hannity would last longer than olbermann would his old a$$ would probally pass out before the water touched him I say waterboard maddow and olberman at the same time there show is an hour of pub bashing without providing a source I'm so tired of hearing uhhh uhhhhh 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

his old a$$ would probally pass out before the water touched him So, you're saying that being waterboarded is not an easy thing to endure? That it might actually be torture? 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

They are terrorists, I don't care what they do to them. If I was captured by one of these scumbags I would be quite relieved if waterboarding was the worst treatment I received. Slim, why dont you go over to see the Taliban and tell them we want to play nice. Make sure you say goodbye to your head first. Of course they may not want to remove it from your arse before sawing it off with a dull machete. 

ExLady In Blue --- 17 years ago -

Slim, why dont you go over to see the Taliban and tell them we want to play nice. Make sure you say goodbye to your head first. Of course they may not want to remove it from your arse before sawing it off with a dull machete. FIGHT!!! (Good one, maverick). 

goatlady --- 17 years ago -

POPCORN TIME! 

david --- 17 years ago -

double post 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

I think I would rather be waterboarded than forced to watch Olberman's show. Tried to ONCE. Man what a wanna be. But I couldnt tell who he wanted to be, O'Reilly, Colbert or Stewart. The guy was all over the place. No wonder he has zero ratings. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Donkey nope don't believe its torture I have heard of a couple plots were foiled because of it the obama admin doesn't want to release the other why? Will it show all the intel that we received and saved america from attacks I believe so 

maverick --- 17 years ago -

No doubt IT WAS EFFECTIVE. FACTUAL - slim 

david --- 17 years ago -

I really can't say who's worse olberman or maddow it really must suck to bash a party for an hour knowing the other networks ratings are destroying yours kind of like going into a test knowing your going to fail why bother 

believer --- 17 years ago -

Why should Hannity accept Olbermann's measly $1,000 per second offer? What a cheapskate. Since it would be for charity, Olbermann should offer at least $10,000 per second. 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

Donkey nope don't believe its torture I'm not as rich as Olbermann, so I'll pay you just $1 per second if I can waterboard you. Are you up for it? But, if you can't take it for 30 seconds, you have to pay me $20. Sound fair? Well, I really don't care if you think it's torture or not. We are the USA. We are above that crap. We're supposed to be the good guys. If we torture the "bad guys" then that makes us the bad guys, too. Being right and good means taking the high road. Even with terrorists and other scum who hate us. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

*applause* for Donkey Hodie!! and David, I want to be there when you take on this bet! You are my favorite KUer :) 

JDB2 --- 17 years ago -

We're supposed to be the good guys. If we torture the "bad guys" then that makes us the bad guys, too. Being right and good means taking the high road. Even with terrorists and other scum who hate us. let's all be dead good guys...sounds like a terrific idea. 

Perfection --- 17 years ago -

Donkey Hodie, I will take you up on that, then you can donate the $30.00 to Angel Food Ministries so someone on KU who needs a hand can get some groceries. Just tell me when and where. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Donkey would you rather the united states have additional terrorist attacks killing innocent americans I think the kingwood kid said it best when talking about obama and rev hate (wright)the ends justifies the means And I don't think olbermann can afford 1000/sec with his ratings msnbc would write the check Ill even say this if olbermann Really writes the check out of his personal account ill personally donate 500 a second to hannitys charity if olbermann does waterboard ill match his 1000 a second (I get the tax credit for the donation though) 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

let's all be dead good guys...sounds like a terrific idea. False dichotomy. It's not, "Either we torture them or we all die!" That kind of thinking is just fear-mongering. There are more effective ways of getting information from a prisoner than torture. In fact, torture is notoriously a very bad way of getting information. The torture is done until the prisoner will admit to anything, just to get the torture to stop. So, we get "information" that the prisoner thinks we want to hear instead of the truth. Usually that information just reinforces the pre-conceived political notions of whoever is doing the torturing. It doesn't result in consistently accurate, usable intelligence. 

*momof5* --- 17 years ago -

So David, is that a no? 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

Donkey would you rather the united states have additional terrorist attacks killing innocent americans I don't want any Americans to be killed, innocent or otherwise. I don't want any other people killed, either. I just don't think torture is the most effective way to prevent terrorist attacks. And even if it was effective, it's still wrong, and if we as Americans want to claim any kind of moral high ground, we shouldn't do it. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Rainbow I've edited and added to my post that is my offer and its legitimate 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

After Fox News Channel's Sean Hannity made a seemingly impromptu offer last week to undergo waterboarding as a benefit for charity, MSNBC's Keith Olbermann leapt at it. He offered $1,000 to the families of U.S. troops for every second Hannity withstood the technique. So when is the waterboarding going to take place, or is Hannity chicken? Maybe someone else at Faux news will step up, but not Glen Beck. He would cry. 

JDB2 --- 17 years ago -

It's not, "Either we torture them or we all die!" it is a matter of opinion. 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

the ends justifies the means I don't believe in this philosophy. If you can't do the right thing as your means, you automatically forfeit the right end. The means ARE the end. 

smartypants --- 17 years ago -

the ends justifies the means What "ends"? Most authorities on the subject say you don't get quality information from using torture like waterboarding for interrogation. 

RiteWingKing --- 17 years ago -

let's all be dead good guys...sounds like a terrific idea. Live Free or Die!!!! 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Most authorities on the subject say you don't get quality information from using torture like waterboarding for interrogation Well, I don't think Bush wanted "real" information - just an admission that there was a link between Al Qaeda and Saddam. That's where torture becomes important - to get people to say what you want them to say. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Most authorities? That's like saying 9 out of 10 drs choose x product when behind the scenes there asked if this was the only product would you prescribe it then 9 out of 10 say yes. This is my ? If we were attacked again becuase there isn't any intel to stop the attack will the dems blame obama for not stopping the attack? 

JDB2 --- 17 years ago -

I don't think every bad guy gets waterboarded as soon as they get caught. They get opportunities to help before they get pressured. If they were simply telling us what we wanted to hear, we would certainly have had more events and we would not have been able to interupt some of the activities we have interupted. You guys just be disgusted and then be apologetic when we see a return stronger than you can imagine. btw, you might want to begin preparing some excuses too.... 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

Very interesting piece on NPR this morning about the subject - compare the torture techniques used by the CIA with the approach used by our military. Link to story. Once again, kudos to our military for doing the right thing. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

BTW, did I mention Hannity is a coward? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I remember during the Cold War that the US always said that the communists believed that the ends justified the means, and that is why they did such nasty things, and why we were better. I am glad to see that so many of you agree with the communists in this regard. I never knew there were so many cyrpto communinsts here in KU. It has also been revealed that the US military was VERY much opposed to torture. I guess that all of the armchair strategists think that they are better and smarter than the professionals too. It sort of explains why you would vote for Bush, who likewise thought that flying twice a month for two years made him a military expert. The other problem is that torture does not get good intel. You get so much crap that you spend a LOT of time chasing your tail, when you could get better intel doing the normal methods. Intel is VERY short lived. When you capture somebody or get some codes,etc.., the enemy has to assume that you will get everything out of a person or whatever you have. Thus all codes are changed, all ops involving that person are called off, plans are immediately changed, addresses are moved, persons are changed etc... So getting somebody to 'talk" is useless IF the other guys know you have the person. It is a little hard to disappear somebody like that and not have the bad guys notice. The very fact of catching a bad guy kills ANY operations that person could have know about. So saying that we foiled some attack because he talked is a fiction. Any operation that the person knew about would be called off any way. 

Donkey Hodie --- 17 years ago -

Very interesting piece on NPR this morning about the subject I heard that same article this morning, and was going to post it here, but you did it first. For those unwilling to go to a "commie pinko" website like NPR, or are too busy to listen to the interviews, I'll give a quick recap. NPR interviewed a military interrogator in Iraq, and he said their methods of just talking to the detainees, and not using and kind of physical force or stress gave them much better results. Information came quicker, and was more reliable. Using the "clean" method, they were able to get the location of Zarqawi, the guy who was head of the Taliban in Iraq in just two months, where the CIA had failed to get the same information using more aggressive techniques for more than three years. So, you tell me, is torture more effective? I don't think it is. And not even considering it's (in)effectiveness, torture is wrong. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Once again, kudos to our military for doing the right thing. I think that says it all. CIA never did get the bad guy WITH torture, and years of work. The US Army did its interogation and got results in TWO MONTHS! There is NO debate here. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

And Hanniy is douche bag. Screw him for not siding with our military. 

NoNameNoLastName --- 17 years ago -

And not even considering it's (in)effectiveness, torture is wrong. As I said, torture is only good to extract the information you want to hear, not necessarily the truth. That's probably what Bush wanted - to force people to admit a connection between Al Qaeda and Saddam that he knew never existed. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

politics


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground