Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

TEXAS SHERIFF PARKER GOT 10 YEARS FOR WATERBOARDING

who's talking here?

Fallon 2
randyjet 17
Cicero 1
lemingrebel 2
david 1
rEVOLution 1
Meme2my5 10
PS 1
hopscotch 5
sadiesmom 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

For those who don't think that waterboarding is torture, I will refer you to the case of Sheriff Parker who in 1983 was prosecuted by Reagan's DoJ for waterboarding a number of prisoners to extract confessions from them At the time Reagan thought that it was torture as did the Texas jury and judge who gave the bad Sheriff TEN YEARS in prison for his crimes, and his three deputies got four years apiece for helping out. THAT is why the Obama administration needs to prosecute the DoJ officials who signed off on the waterboarding. What is good for the locals and lower orders of people is good for those who should know better. It also raises an interesting question on the court martials of the GIs in Iraq who were convicted for torturing at Abu Graib prison. At the very least they should have their convictions overturned if others are now going to be forgiven for doing the same thing. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

A sheriff waterboarding prisoners is whole lot different than waterboarding TERRORISTS. Nancy Pelosi knew all about it and didn't have a problem with it, you want to prosecute her and all the dems that knew it? I have NEVER thought any of our GIS should have been charged much less convicted fo doing the same thing. IT'S a freaking war, what do you want them to do..hand out coloring books and crayons. Whatever methods work or they want to try is ok with me. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

There's a huge difference. Sheriff Parker and his deputies were trying to force "confessions" out of prisoners for drug possession. The terrorists want to kill us. They despise our very existence, everything the Western World stands for. Pelosi has lied, lied and lied again. She knew and is trying to cover her butt. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

The 2 are unrelated, if you are a logical thinking human. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

IT'S a freaking war, what do you want them to do..hand out coloring books and crayons. Whatever methods work or they want to try is ok with me. The US Army and all the military don't agree with you. It is only those who have never been in the military who think that they follow NO rules in warfare. As for Pelosi not knowing about it, I have NO idea. I DO know that Sen. Feingold was on the Senate committee, and according to what I have read, he did NOT know either. Feingold is one person who I would believe since he has a LOT of ethics and courage. I am not so sure of Pelosi, but I will take the word of Feingold as being good as gold. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

In 1983, the Department of Justice prosecuted a Texas sheriff and three of his deputies for waterboarding prisoners to get them to confess to crimes. The deputies were sentenced to four years in prison and Parker pleaded guilty to extortion and federal civil rights violations and received a 10-year sentence. Parker admitted that he had operated a “marijuana trap” on U.S. Highway 59, arrested suspects, and, according to court documents, subjected “prisoners to a suffocating water torture ordeal in order to coerce confessions. source At the time Reagan thought that it was torture as did the Texas jury and judge who gave the bad Sheriff TEN YEARS Actually, the Sheriff pled guilty to extortion and civil rights violations and was then sentenced to 10 years. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

The fact is that all sides now agree that waterboarding is torture. The US DoJ says it was torture back then, so it still is NOW. THUS, Bush saying that the US does NOT torture is an OUTRIGHT LIE! I think that we can ALL agree on that one. Yes? 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

I wouldn.t take the word of any of those lying cheating crooks. Since I do have family in the military, I have to differ on them disagreeing with me. They believe it is a war that is being conducted on too many rules. If they would have thrown the hair dryer in while waterboarding, we wouldn't have had to worry about any of them complaining.JMO.Pelosi and her axis of evil fellow dems are about to be outed on what they knew.As for Sen Feingold I wouldn't put my bets on his word being as good as gold,seems like honest politician has become an oxymoron. 

david --- 17 years ago -

Well there's one way to know if pelosi knew release the minutes for the meetings I'm sure she knew exactly what was going on 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Well there's one way to know if pelosi knew release the minutes for the meetings For once I actually agree with you. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

If you had a family member in danger of being killed and had possession of a person you thought might have information to stop it, what lengths would you go to? 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

If you had a family member in danger of being killed and had possession of a person you thought might have information to stop it, what lengths would you go to? Waterboard with hot,scalding water comes to mind. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

we wouldn't have had to worry about any of them complaining. You forget that BUSH let hundreds of them go from Gitmo. I think that they all probably told others what happened to them. I also refer you to the case of the German citizen who the CIA got hold of. They shuttled him around their secrat prisons, tortured him and finally figured out that he was just an innocent tourist after having done all that to him. They insisted that he sign a document denying all that had happened to him. The German government was NOT happy about that at all. So the dirty little secret was secret ONLY to most Americans. THAT is what secrecy is all about. Like Nixon "secretly" bombing Cambodia, only a FOOL would believe it was a military secret that it was going on. The people on the receiving end sure knew who was dropping the bombs. 

lemingrebel --- 17 years ago -

Waterboarding is hardly torture. All you do gooders need to talk to POWs from WWII who where captured the the Japanese. They can tell you what torture is. When I was a kid, an old couple from Indonesia lived across the street and the babysat me. The old man was held captive by the Japanese and had his back broken, had bamboo slits forced under his fingernails and was kept in a hole for a few years. Heck, ask John McCain about torture. Waterboarding is for sissies that don't have the stomach for real torture. I'd waterboard a stranger to get winning lottery numbers out of them. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Waterboarding is for sissies I'd waterboard a stranger to get winning lottery numbers out of them LOL..Waterboarding is like skiing upside down, it could almost be considered vacationing. 

lemingrebel --- 17 years ago -

I've been dragged upside down from an innertube behind a speed boat. It sucked, but in no way would I call it torture. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

Compared to what they do to our soldiers and civilians, they have to be having a good laugh over what's being called torture. 

sadiesmom --- 17 years ago -

If you had a family member in danger of being killed and had possession of a person you thought might have information to stop it, what lengths would you go to? Waterboard with hot,scalding water comes to mind. Don't forget the hair dryer!! 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

lmao @ lemm, you are dang straight! I'd waterboard for the winning numbers too! Taking our guys and beheading them, that is torture. Take a few minutes and go read about what is actually happening right now in Africa. That people, is torture. Having to see the press push up even further in O's a** every day, that is torture. With spineless people in charge, our country is facing dangers like we have never faced. I am daily praying we do not get hit again. Because if we do, until the weak spineless Dems are out, we will be a target daily. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Taking our guys and beheading them, that is torture. Right it is.Sadiesmom is right I'm sure they are laughing their butts off at waterboarding being torture. Why even release this info other than to try to embarass the bush admin.Perhaps Holder should be looking up "Treason" for prosecution of Obama for releasing this.This is nothing more than a political move by Obama and his gang and in no way is it in the best interest of our country. 

Cicero --- 17 years ago -

Not this crap again. Waterboarding is torture. Doesn't matter WHO is doing it or who it's being done to. The FACT is, no reliable information can be extracted from someone being tortured. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

had possession of a person you thought might have information to stop it, what lengths would you go to? If you want to have hypothetical cases, then you have to be more specific and try and approximate reality. For example, let's say you pay a ransom, the victim is not released, but you followed the person who picked up the money. You know where that person is. THEN you might have an idea that the person you caught MIGHT have an idea of where the victim is. Of course, the kidnappers might be smart enough, to make sure the pick up guy would NOT know that intel. So HOW do you KNOW that the person has the intel? At what point do you stop asking and torturing? How many wild goose chases do you want to pursue when you get wrong answers. Will you put all of your eggs in this basket alone? Will you do other work that might actually wind up locating the victim? What the answers I Have seen so far indicate is that torture is used more as PUNISHMENT rather than intel purposes. I guess that those who advocate this kind of thing HATE our Constitution since it explicitly prohibits cruel and unusual punishments. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

By the way, the British were just as barbaric and vicious as the current Muslim extremists. It didn't help them out a bit. Look up what the punishment for treason was when the US was founded. It was drawing and quartering. Had our forebearers failed and fallen into British hands, that would have been their fate. Our response to such British barbarity was to PROHIBIT it in the USA. I am quite PROUD of that fact. Too bad some of you are NOT. 

hopscotch --- 17 years ago -

Ok Randy, heres my question for you. Would it be better if we ask an individual what he/she knows, when they say "nothing" , just shoot them in the face and move down the line until someone talks? Or is it better to keep the talks one on one to get as much info as you can? From all of the prisoners. Im not looking for a fight, its just a question. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

when the US was founded. It was drawing and quartering. Had our forebearers failed and fallen into British hands, that would have been their fate. Our response to such British barbarity was to PROHIBIT it in the USA. I am quite PROUD of that fact. Too bad some of you are NOT. How many years ago was that?? Times have changed. We live in a more dangerous, volitile time. We aren't torturing them, we are waterboarding them. It's all in perception. You percieve it to be torture others don't. These terrorists are barbaric. They can't be treated as you would other prisoners in a civilzed society. Terrorists are out to kill any and all Americans. They prefer to kill large numbers of us at one time. So waterboard away,like I said it's like vacationing. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Or is it better to keep the talks one on one to get as much info as you can? I can tell you what DOES work. The best interrogator of WWII, was a German who got the recently captured pilots and air crew in a nice hotel with a lot of security of course. He then brought them into his office for a conversation about their file that he had on each one of them. He asked them to correct his info on them and proceeded to tell them what college they went to, their frat, their wife, children etc.. Needless to say, they were rather astounded that he had that info, so they helped correct some of the mistakes that he made. He also gave a beer bash for all the POWs with ALL they could drink in a hall which had mikes all over the place. As you might imagine, he got a LOT more intel there too. The Army was so impressed with him that they hired him after the war to work for them. With a bit of imagination, you can work out your own methods for those who don't drink alcohol. My preference is Alice B Tolkas brownies, and keeping them from drinking or eating afterwards,UNLESS they tell you something useful. The FBI got good intel BEFORE they started torture too. Afterwards, they got crap and wasted time and resources. 

hopscotch --- 17 years ago -

Thats a very interesting story sir! I just try to put myself in that situation with one of my own. I doubt I could hold my composure in such an instance. When I see someone ridiculed i ask, "what would hopscotch do?". Thats my way of justifying the "means". 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

It's all in perception. You percieve it to be torture others don't. It is NOT perception,it is settled LAW and precedent that water boarding is torture. THAT is the FACT. The Inquisition also had limits since they were not allowed to spill blood. I don't think that any sane person would say now that the rack and other fun things they did wasn't torture. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

Maybe brownies and beer work sometimes. I don't think we should be baking and serving them anything, unless they're putting truth serum in it. Sometimes waterboarding works. I would rather go with that. Besides we don't know yet how much info we actually got from them because O's admin is being selective about what info they release. I'd rather have an admin. that takes terrorism serious than one that doesn't.JMO 

hopscotch --- 17 years ago -

It is NOT perception,it is settled LAW and precedent that water boarding is torture. THAT is the FACT. If one of my family members were injured or killed over some crazy sh!t, I could care less how the terrorist or the govt. felt! I think I could make a prisoner beg for waterboarding! And that is also why "Marshall Law" was invented! Because sometimes "Im sorry" just doesnt cut it! 

rEVOLution --- 17 years ago -

But this is America. Crime and punishment only depend upon who you are in society. Just like celebrities who brake the law and barely spend a day in court over it. 

PS --- 17 years ago -

Randyjet, that's about the sixth time you've used the 'Stalag 13, Colonel Clink' reference. Care to provide us with some references to your master interragator? Thx 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

I could care less how the terrorist or the govt. felt! I think I could make a prisoner beg for waterboarding! And that is also why "Marshall Law" was invented! Thank you for making my point. I said that those who were for torture were more about punishment than getting intel. If that is your goal, then I also have to remind you that the USA was founded on principles that FORBID cruel and unusual punishments for a very good reason. Our founders had direct personal experience of that with the British, and they made all those sacrifices and blood to make a BETTER country than the one they left. I am more impressed with them than you. Though I can certainly understand your feelings, which is why we have the STATE prosecute crooks. I felt that when that high school girl was found murdered at Conroe High that if I had been her brother, I would have been very happy to torture some people over that. Many years later, the person who they convicted was found innocent, and the two other janitors who they let go were the ones who I thought had done it. I would have tortured the WRONG people in that case. I would have gotten a confession of course, but it turned out to be somebody who had previously worked at the school and none of the suspects. THAT is why we don't torture. 

hopscotch --- 17 years ago -

I dont think that you and I will agree (completely) about this subject Randy! Im ok with that. Itrs just like a good game of chess, you really dont know whats gonna happen until it happens. If someone hurt one of mine, i would beat them silly, then offer and a$$ whoopin before the bullet! Im sure you would do the same. Lets just hope and pray that neither of us cross that bridge in our lives! Truce? 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

Randyjet, that's about the sixth time you've used the 'Stalag 13, Colonel Clink' reference. Care to provide us with some references to your master interragator? The book is Hanns Scharff, Master Interogator. The funny thing is that he came to the US after the war and was sponsored by his former prisoners. I guess he didn't waterboard them enough. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

i would beat them silly, then offer and a$$ whoopin before the bullet! That is IF you know WHO did it. As I have always said, if I know who did any harm to my wife, family or dogs, the least of their worries would be the cops. 

Meme2my5 --- 17 years ago -

That is IF you know WHO did it. As I have always said, if I know who did any harm to my wife, family or dogs, the least of their worries would be the cops. The people that are killed by the terrorists are someone's family, so they probably feel the same way as you regarding what they would want done to them. So if you saw these terrorists with your own eyes and you knew they did it w/o any doubt, then you are saying it would be ok to waterboard,etc. on that premise.So to that, shouldn't our military just do it when they capture them since they are in the battle, and have them confess what they know and save our military lives in the progress? That way they would have the right person no doubt, which is the part you have a problem with.Kinda like if you knew who did what to your wife,family or dogs. 

hopscotch --- 17 years ago -

That is IF you know WHO did it That is point right there sir!!! Wouldnt suspicion be enough to vent yourself? Especially if someone hurt one of your loved ones. Heaven forbid. Im talking about a "no holds barred" assault on something that you take personal. I have no idea how personal the military takes our lives and our freedoms! I guess I/We would have to be in that place and time. Do you see my point? I certainly understand yours! 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

.So to that, shouldn't our military just do it when they capture them since they are in the battle, and have them confess what they know and save our military lives in the progress? As I said, you are confusing PUNISHMENT with getting intel. You can have one or the other but NOT BOTH. For our security, intel takes priority over all other considerations. Also, if they are taken in battle, that makes them lawful combatants too. The fact is that the real veteran combatants have little or no use for torture. I can refer you to Col. Hackworth's book Steel My Soldiers Hearts. He told one dumb well connected Lt. who was torturing a VC suspect to stop it or Hackworth would shoot him on the spot. The Lt had enough sense to know Hackworth's reputation and stopped since it would have been his death if he had not. 

randyjet --- 17 years ago -

By the way, I went on the internet and saw a picture of Mr. Scharff with Gen. Doolittle and Gen. Curtis LeMay at a dinner honoring Scharff. He was also good friends with his former prisoners who all respected him. The reason that the Generals were so interested in him was that he was the best in the business and wanted to learn from him. I know of very few people who would consider Gen.Doolittle and LeMay pansies for NOT wanting to torture prisoners. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground