Kingwood Underground
the heart and soul of our Kingwood, Texas family
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Kingwood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
KU Live!

Here is it, Ogre1

who's talking here?

Fallon 1
AuthorMan 1
gumbeauxgirl 1
Ogre1 7
zombie slayer 9
burbchick 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites     » flag dangerous topic flag as a dangerous topic

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

Lisa is robbing a bank. Bart is driving down the road towards the bank. Two cop cars driving side by side are coming in his direction. Lisa shoots a cop and the cop is staggering in the street. In an effort to miss the two cop cars, Bart swerves and hits the cop, killing him. Bart then crashes into a building. At the top of the building, Homer is standing on a ledge about to jump. The impact of of the car forces Homer to fall, unfortunately he was rethinking the suicide at this point. A stray bullet from Lisa's gun hits homer in the head and kills him before his body smashes into the ground. Homers wife Marge comes out of the building to see Homer splattered into the pavement, she freaks out and pulls lout her own gun and starts shooting Homers dead body. Unfortunately a stray bullet from Marge's gun hits Bart in the head and kills Bart. Lisa walks up to the robbery and freaks out and runs but slips in the ran over cops blood. The fall causes her to break her back. Assume it is all true. Assume it is all logical. Identify who did something wrong. Why was it wrong? Is it a criminal offense or civil offense? I can not wait to hear your response, Ogre1. 

Fallon --- 17 years ago -

I have to say, Lisa is too young to drive or own a gun. yes that is my final answer. 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

Those are just the names used. It is not really the Simpsons, however, good answer! 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Oh Dear gods! It's a lousy law school finals essay question!!! You going to give me three hours to write an answer for this pig?(Seriously!) It actually sounds a LOT like a question we had on our tort law final that involved a "spiderman" climbing a building, falling and killing a bunch of people. Assume it is all logical. Now that's a mighty assumption! I've marked this, I'll hit it tomorrow after my job interview.. right now, I'm going to bed! 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

It's a lousy law school finals essay question!!! IT IS!!! lol. Ok. later! 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

IT IS!! Where in the name of Beelzebub's bunghole did you find this thing? 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

Where in the name of Beelzebub's bunghole did you find this thing? My professor :) 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

My professor :) Where at? 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

Where at? HEll! I cant tell you that, Zombie likes to be anonomyous! 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Hey! I just thought of something... I'm not helping you with your finals am I? :-P 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

. I'm not helping you with your finals am I No, not at all. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

Alright I'm outa here. Later guys. 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

Here you go Ogre1. 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

I’m not going to answer these in full sentences, that would be a HUGE post. So I’m not trying to answer these as I would a law school final. That would likely take six or seven pages. This will mostly be issue spotting. I will list all the crims/torts that I see. You can assume that lesser charges merge into the greater ones (I.E. Discharge of a firearm merges w/ Attempted Capital Murder of a Police Officer because one is necessary for the other, but I may list them anyway). The first thing I do with this type of law schoolesque question is tear it down to it's component parts; • Lisa is robbing a bank. o Aggravated (armed) Bank Robbery -Clearly criminal, punishable under both state and federal law. Felony, big time. (assuming she’s using the gun she shoots the cops with) o Brandishing (Again, assuming she’s using the gun she shoots the cops with) • Bart is driving down the road towards the bank. o Depends on why B is going to the bank.  If he is going there innocently, then no crime has been committed.  If he is an accomplice to Lisa, then he is as guilty of bank robbery as Lisa is in spite of him not being there. • In this case he will also be guilt of Felony Capital Murder. • Two cop cars driving side by side are coming in his direction. O.K. • Lisa shoots a cop and the cop is staggering in the street. o Attempted Capital Murder of a Police Officer. o Discharging a firearm in public o Reckless endangerment • In an effort to miss the two cop cars, Bart swerves and hits the cop, killing him. o NOW, is Bart responsible for the cop’s death? Assuming that Bart is an innocent bystander then no he is not criminally responsible as Lisa is the proximate cause of the officer being in the street in the first place. o Lisa now is subject to a felony murder charge because someone died during the commission of, or resulting from her criminal activity. And since this was a police officer, it’s felony capital murder. o You must apply the proportionality and distance tests. Basically, how much of the officer’s death is Lisa responsible for, and how distant (in time, range, events) from the crime do these events occur. Bart, even though he is not criminally responsible for the death of the officer can still be held liable in a civil court for wrongful death (Think O.J.’s murder trial followed by the civil trial. He was not guilty of the murder, but liable for the deaths… it’s a different standard) o Failure to control speed. o Failure to yield to emergency vehicles. • Bart then crashes into a building. o Trespass to property o Destruction of private property • At the top of the building, Homer is standing on a ledge about to jump. o Reckless endangerment o Trespassing? How did he get up there? • The impact of the car forces Homer to fall, unfortunately he was rethinking the suicide at this point. o The keyword here is rethinking. We have to determine if Homer had formed the intent to not commit suicide. This ties into the last bullet point as well. If Home was up on that ledge and had decided to not jump, then he’s just sightseeing and maybe trespassing. o However, if he had not formed the intent to not jump, then Homer is guilty of attempted suicide (Whether he jumps or not! In this case, it’s the intent of the individual, not the actual action). o The fact that Homer was knocked off the building is irrelevant to this argument. • A stray bullet from Lisa's gun hits homer in the head and kills him before his body smashes into the ground. o Felony Murder (BTW.. I should explain… Felony Murder is what happens when someone dies while one is in commission of a felony. The death has to be connected in some way to the murder. I.E the pizza guy who has a heart attack delivering to the SWAT team is not your responsibility. The old guy at the teller’s station who has the heart attack IS!!! Even more screwed up… if SWAT tries to take you out and shoots a hostage by mistake… That’s on you dude… Sucks being you doesn’t it! o Probably be talked down to Manslaughter depending on the DA. • Homers wife Marge comes out of the building to see Homer splattered into the pavement, she freaks out and pulls out her own gun and starts shooting Homers dead body. o Abuse of a corpse o Reckless endangerment o Discharging a firearm. o Illegal possession of a firearm? Maybe…but I’d need more info. o Being stupid…sadly, this isn’t a real charge. • Unfortunately a stray bullet from Marge's gun hits Bart in the head and kills Bart. o Ah, probably NOT felony murder unless one of the things I listed above is a felony. o BUT, it most certainly can be manslaughter (do you know the difference between murder and manslaughter? For there to be murder it must be intentional, purposeful, malicious, premeditated, and/or wanton… can the spraying of bullets be considered wanton? Maybe… dunno without more facts… otherwise this would be manslaughter). • Lisa walks up to the robbery (? what does this mean?) and freaks out and runs but slips in the ran over cops blood. The fall causes her to break her back. o Sucks being her. o Since she is the proximate cause of this three-ring circus she has no recourse. o She should have exercised due care in observing her surroundings. o A reasonable person would assume that the dead cops bloody is slick. O.K., this is half-@ssed. If this were a Law school exam I’d go back and fill it in. Probably take another three pages, maybe four. 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

You are awesome. I did not think of having to prove Homers state of mind, and that he had rethought the suicide. Probable not doable seeing as how he was on the ledge. Thanks for playing :) 

Ogre1 --- 17 years ago -

You'd likely have to have some sort of witness, or maybe a suicide note that was on his body that he was tearing up. There are a lot of things that require particular states of mind. And other things that you'd think would require a state of mind that don't, i.e., child molestation... if you pick up a 16 y.o. in a bar, with a cigarette in her mouth and a drink in her hand, dressed like she's 28 and you think she's 28 and she tells you she's 28, and has an id that says she's 28, and the bar tender and her friends all assure you that she's 28, you can still go to jail because she's 16 ... how's that for messed up. There is NO state of mind requirement for child molestation. Only the act. 

AuthorMan --- 17 years ago -

The cop driving on the wrong side of the road should be hung! lol 

gumbeauxgirl --- 17 years ago -

Are they driving on a two-way street or is Bart going the wrong way down a one way street? Or, are both the cops going the wrong way? 

zombie slayer --- 17 years ago -

It was a two way street. The police cars were in both lanes getting to the Bank robbery. 

burbchick --- 17 years ago -

The police cars were in both lanes getting to the Bank robbery. Off with their heads! lol 

page 1
topic is locked.

see more discussions about...


Online now:
hit counters

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Kingwood Underground